Skip to main content
HMRC internal manual

Enquiry Manual

EM3232 - Discovery: making a discovery - whether there is a discovery: making an assessment - qualifying conditions - careless or deliberate behaviour

Qualifying conditions

If the taxpayer has submitted a return, a discovery assessment will be valid if the conditions in either s29(4) TMA 70 / Para 43, Sch 18 FA98 or s29(5) TMA 1970 / Para 44 Sch 18 FA98 are met.  If the taxpayer has not submitted a return before the assessment is made, neither of these conditions needs to be met.

Only one of the conditions has to be met for an assessment to be valid.  Both conditions are objective tests that depend on the facts rather than the view of the officer. Although an officer does not need to decide one of the conditions is met before making an assessment, they should normally consider at this stage whether either of the conditions might apply. See also EM3252 on explanatory letters.

In cases of dispute, whether a condition is met or not is an issue to be decided by way of an appeal. Although there is no legal requirement for an officer to consider their application before making an assessment and no requirement for HMRC to show whether any condition applies at the time a discovery assessment is made.  During any appeal HMRC will need to demonstrate that the relevant condition applies, and the burden for demonstrating this will rest with HMRC.

The guidance on the timing of the relevant tests also applies to the s36 TMA70 / Para 46 Sch 18 FA98 time limit conditions.

Careless or deliberate behaviour – s29(4), TMA70 and Para 43, Sch18, FA 1998

For guidance on careless and deliberate behaviour, please see HMRC guidance at CH53400 and CH53700.

Acting on behalf of

When applying the assessing conditions (s29(3) / Para 42(1)) or the ETL conditions the behaviour of persons acting on behalf of that person are also often relevant.

The Upper Tribunal in HMRC v John Hicks ([2020] UKUT 0012) approved the First-tier Tribunal’s definition of a person acting on behalf in The Trustees of the Bessie Taube v HMRC ([2010] UKFTT 473) as

“…a person who takes steps that the taxpayer himself could take, or would otherwise be responsible for taking. Such steps will commonly include steps involving third parties, but will not necessarily do so. Examples would in our view include completing a return, filing a return, entering into correspondence with HMRC, providing documents and information to HMRC and seeking external advice as to the legal and tax position of the taxpayer. The person must represent, and not merely provide advice to, the taxpayer”.

The meaning of ‘on behalf of’ is narrower than ‘for the benefit of’ or ‘in the interest of’.

If the person acting on behalf of a taxpayer is a tax advisor, when determining the behaviour of that person the minimum standard is that of a reasonably competent tax advisor.

Please contact the Specialist Technical Team, see EM21000, if you have any litigation cases where ‘acting on behalf of’ forms part of the case.

Causation

For each error in an assessment where HMRC rely on careless or deliberate behaviour, HMRC must show that the taxpayer’s behaviour caused the loss of tax. What is needed to show the taxpayer’s behaviour caused the loss of tax will depend on the facts and circumstances of each case. Caseworkers should make reasonable endeavours to gather all relevant facts relating to both behaviour and causation.

If there is an appeal, HMRC must be able to make at least a prima facie case that on the balance of probabilities the behaviour caused the specific loss. What this involves will vary by case. HMRC is not required to prove a detailed counterfactual or speculate on what might have happened if the taxpayer had acted differently, but HMRC should at least be able to state what the taxpayer should have done differently and how this could have prevented the loss of tax.

Once HMRC establishes a prima facie case, the taxpayer may rebut it by showing on the balance of probabilities that the behaviour did not cause the loss. The taxpayer needs to show the behaviour did not cause the loss, not merely that the behaviour might not have. For example, in cases where the behaviour is the result of no or inadequate advice, it is for the taxpayer to show that this lack of adequate advice was not the cause of the loss of tax.

Please contact the Specialist Technical Team, see EM21000 if you have any litigation cases where causation is an issue in the case.