EM3252 - Discovery: issuing discovery assessments: making versus notifying
‘Making an assessment’ vs ‘Issuing a notice’
There is a distinction between a discovery, an assessment, and the notification of an assessment.
An assessment is made when an officer reaches the decision to make the assessment for a period, has calculated the amount due, and makes a record of the assessment or authorises a record of the assessment to be made with the intention that the record be a permanent record of the assessment. That officer can then complete the administrative tasks required to issue the notice of assessment to the taxpayer.
S113(1B) TMA 1970 allows the assessing officer to pass on the responsibilities of completing the administrative tasks to another officer. S2(4) CRCA 2005 permits other officers to complete an assessing procedure started by another. This means that the process of notification does not have to be carried out by the same officer who made the assessment or the discovery.
The assessing time limits operate by reference to the assessment itself, not the notice of assessment. Therefore, the notice of assessment does not need to be issued within the relevant time limit though it should be wherever possible to avoid disputes. It should be issued shortly after making an assessment, but this can be after the time limit to make an assessment has expired.
In situations where there is an error in the assessment or notification of assessment, s114 TMA70 should be considered.
For guidance on how to issue a discovery assessment, see SAM20061.
Best practice – explanatory letter
When an officer makes and notifies a discovery assessment it is best practice to accompany it with a letter explaining what discovery was made, when, and why. It should also explain which conditions have been met in order to validate the assessment.
For further guidance about explanation letters see EM3258.
Whilst not compulsory, providing this information can help taxpayers understand why the assessment has been made, and aid the reduction of potentially unnecessary disputes and assist HMRC in defending any appeals against the assessment.