Skip to main content
HMRC internal manual

Enquiry Manual

EM3258 - Discovery: issuing discovery assessments: notification to taxpayer

Where an officer makes and notifies an assessment, it is best practice to issue an explanation letter at the same time; see ARTG2190. EM3238 outlines the difference between the assessment and the notification of assessment. The explanation letter is usually separate from both, though the explanation letter can also meet the requirements for valid notification of the assessment.

Explanation letter

In the explanation letter the officer should:

  • state that the officer has made a discovery for each issue being assessed
  • explain what discovery or discoveries the officer thinks they have made and why they think the information they have at least points in the direction of a loss of tax
  • if the officer is making an assessment which relies on an assessing condition or making an assessment which relies on an extended time limit condition, the explanation letter should also include an explanation of why the officer considers that they can rely on a condition for each issue an assessment is made in respect of
  • if there are important areas of factual or legal uncertainty the officer considers exist, it is best practice to outline these
  • tell the taxpayer about their right to appeal against the assessment and their right to ask for a review of HMRC’s decision, and their right to apply for postponement of the tax charged by the assessment

Officers should avoid describing an assessment as ‘protective’ as doing so will give the impression that it does not meet the basic conditions for a discovery assessment and invite unwarranted challenges via the appeals process

The rules for extended time limits are at CH53100 for assessments made after 31 March 2010, if HMRC are considering or intend to charge penalties, the officer should also include a copy of factsheet CC/FS9 if they have not previously sent one and explain in the letter that CC/FS9 tells the person about their rights when HMRC are considering penalties.