Skip to main content
HMRC internal manual

Enquiry Manual

EM3259 - Discovery: issuing discovery assessments: onus of proof for ETL assessments

Situations where officers may validly make extended time limit assessments (ETL) include those where the loss of tax was brought about carelessly or deliberately by the taxpayer or a person acting on their behalf.

Please see EM3232 for HMRC guidance on acting on behalf of and causation, which are relevant to the behaviour-based time limit conditions.

The initial burden on HMRC in demonstrating that an assessment is valid is to establish a prima facie case that a relevant condition is met. Once that is done, the assessment is presumed to be valid. The burden then shifts to the taxpayer to demonstrate that the relevant behaviour did not occur or that the behaviour did not bring about the loss of tax. This does not mean that case owners should cease fact finding when they consider they have sufficient evidence to make a case. Case owners should always seek to gather all relevant facts so that the most accurate decision can be made on whether the condition is met.