EM3231 - Discovery: making a discovery - whether there is a discovery: what is a discovery
A discovery is made when an officer comes to a view, regarding a person for a year of assessment or an accounting period, that:
- an amount which ought to have been assessed to tax has not been assessed,
- an assessment to tax is or has become insufficient,
- relief has been given which is or has become excessive
There do not need to be any new facts or information for a discovery to be made. All that is required is that the officer reaches a view that a loss of tax exists. This includes a situation where the officer comes to a new view or changes their opinion. It is possible for different officers to discover the same issue.
A discovery must be made by an individual officer. A discovery cannot be made by ‘HMRC’ or by a ‘team’ within HMRC. On appeal, HMRC will need to be able to demonstrate than an officer made a valid discovery prior to an assessment being made regardless of the taxpayer’s grounds of appeal, though it is not always necessary to name the officer who made the discovery. To demonstrate a valid discovery HMRC will need to show the subjective and objective tests were met for each taxpayer, for each year.
Subjective test
The officer must believe that the information available to him points in the direction of there being an insufficiency of tax. The discovery must be something more than suspicion of an insufficiency of tax, but it need not go so far as a conclusion that an insufficiency of tax is more probable than not.
Objective test
The officer must act honestly and reasonably in coming to their subjective belief. This means that their view must be one that a reasonable officer could form. Reasonable officers can come to different views, so the fact an officer may be wrong or someone may think they are wrong does not necessarily mean the objective test is not met.
Audit trail
For each assessment HMRC must be able to demonstrate that the subjective and objective test was met before the assessment was made. It is therefore important that officers record their views on the tax position at the time of the assessment and their reasons for those views.