Skip to main content
HMRC internal manual

Enquiry Manual

EM3233 - Discovery: making a discovery - whether there is a discovery: information made available condition

Information made available condition

The information made available condition can be relied on where the hypothetical officer could not have been reasonably expected to be aware of the s29(1)/Para 41(1) situation at the point in time the enquiry period ceased. The enquiry period includes both the enquiry window and the period between the issuing of a valid opening and closure notice. The purpose of the condition is to test the adequacy of the disclosure and offers protection from a discovery assessment to taxpayers who make honest, complete and timely disclosure. As the condition tests the hypothetical officer’s awareness at a point in time, the circumstances which should be considered are those that existed at the end of the enquiry period.

Hypothetical officer

The HMRC officer in the test is not the actual officer but a hypothetical officer. It is usually unhelpful to consider the views and actions of actual officers when applying the test.

There is no single hypothetical officer; the knowledge and experience will vary depending on the point at issue. The hypothetical officer is one of general competence, knowledge or skill which includes a reasonable knowledge and understanding of the law, and a level of knowledge and understanding that would be reasonably expected in an officer considering the information provided by the taxpayer.

Information made available

The hypothetical officer’s awareness derives only from the information ‘made available’ to them. Information is made available to the hypothetical officer only if it falls within one of the specific categories in legislation. This information is often different to the actual information which the real officers used to make decisions. It is therefore best practice to start consideration of the test by compiling a complete list of information made available. HMRC should be able to list the extent of the information made available to the hypothetical officer. If case teams have difficulty in doing so, please contact the Specialist Technical Team via the TAA1 form, see EM21000.

Information ‘made available’ in respect of any year of assessment (or accounting period for CTSA) is defined as information that is

A. contained in a relevant return or any accounts, statements or documents accompanying a relevant return.

B. contained in any relevant claim or accompanying accounts, statements or documents.

C. contained in any documents, accounts or particulars supplied in connection with an enquiry into any relevant returns or claims by the taxpayer or persons acting on their behalf.

D. information whose existence, and the relevance of which to the situation discovered, could be reasonably expected to be inferred from information within items (a) to (c) above, or information the existence and relevance of which to the situation discovered is notified in writing to HMRC by the taxpayer or persons acting on their behalf.

‘Relevant’ returns and claims are the taxpayer’s returns and claims for the year of assessment and each of the two immediately preceding years of assessment (or accounting periods for CTSA).

To be ‘made available’, information must be provided by the end of the enquiry period. Information provided before the enquiry period begins can be ‘made available’ if it falls within one of the categories above.

Individual pieces of information do not by themselves have to make the hypothetical aware of the loss of tax to be ‘made available’ for the purposes of s29(5). For example, the return for a relevant year is ‘made available’ even if it says nothing about the loss of tax discovered.

Please contact Specialist Technical Team via the TAA1 form, see EM21000, if you have any litigation cases where ‘acting on behalf of’ forms part of the case. 

Meaning of aware

For HMRC to be unable to rely on the test, the hypothetical officer must be aware of an actual insufficiency. The awareness threshold is not one of conclusion, but nor is the awareness threshold the discovery threshold. It is not enough that the information made available would have made them aware of something less than this, for example that they should ask more questions. The operational question of whether HMRC should have opened an enquiry plays no part in this test. Whether a disclosure is adequate or not will depend on the circumstances of the case. The greater the level of legal or factual complexity the issue involves, the greater the level of factual and legal disclosure that will be required to have allowed the hypothetical officer to be sufficiently aware.

Relationship with behaviour condition

Where a taxpayer has submitted a return for a year, only one of the assessing conditions needs to be met for an assessment to be valid. If a view is reached that the information made available was sufficient to reasonably allow the hypothetical officer to be aware of the loss of tax it is sensible to carefully consider whether the taxpayer, who also had that information, carelessly or deliberately brought about the loss of tax.