From a Welfare State to a Working State: analytical annex
Published 17 November 2026
Analytical annex to the From a Welfare State to a Working State report
November 2026
Please see Accessibility statement for www.gov.uk for information on what to do if you need the information in this publication provided in a different format.
For media enquiries contact the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) Press Office.
Crown copyright 2026.
You may re-use this information (not including logos) free of charge in any format or
medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence. To view this licence, visit the Open Government Licence page on the National Archives website or write to:
Information Policy Team
The National Archives
Kew
London
TW9 4DU
Or email psi@nationalarchives.gov.uk.
Purpose of the statistics
This annex accompanies the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. It provides details of previously unpublished analysis referenced in the report and additional analysis that contextualises the themes of the report.
Analysis to inform the From a Welfare State to a Working State report has been led and coordinated by an independent team of government and external analysts. In undertaking this work, the analytical team has sought to adhere to established government analytical good practice, including the principles set out in the Code of Practice for Statistics and transparency around methodologies, assumptions, data sources and limitations. This annex is intended to support understanding of the evidence and analytical approaches used by the review and to provide greater transparency on how findings and estimates have been derived.
The analysis produced to inform the From a Welfare State to a Working State report, including the material contained in this annex, should not be regarded as official government analysis or as representing agreed government policy. Further work would be required by relevant government departments to refine and assure any estimates of costs, impacts or deliverability as policy development progresses. Publication of this analysis should not be interpreted as government endorsement of the costs, impacts or policy package considered by the review.
Section 1 provides information and methodology on the gross costs of the recommended policy package. This includes information and methodology on: gross costs of the ‘local system reform’ policy area; gross costs of the ‘Opportunity and Support Guarantees’ policy area; gross costs of the ‘health’ policy area; gross costs of the ‘education’ policy area; gross costs of the ‘Youth hiring incentives’ policy area; and Annually Managed Expenditure (AME) saving from the ‘welfare savings’ policy area.
Section 2 provides information and methodology on the not in education, employment, or training (NEET) impacts of the recommended policy package.
Section 3 provides information and methodology on the fiscal offsets of the recommended policy package.
Section 4 provides information and methodology on the impact of youth participation on Gross Domestic Product (GDP).
Section 5 provides information and methodology on the further education expansion target.
Section 6 provides information and methodology on young people supported through early intervention and preventative mental health and neurodevelopmental support.
Section 7 provides information and methodology on the net incomes of young people.
Section 8 provides information and methodology on the relative poverty impacts after housing costs of the recommended policy package.
Section 9 provides information and methodology on employment support and welfare spend.
Section 10 provides information and methodology on increase in apprenticeship starts and achievements.
Section 11 provides information and methodology on improved use of Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) workforce capacity.
Section 12 provides information and methodology on the number of young people that fall out of work due to ill health.
Section 13 provides information and methodology on workforce requirements for the proposed mental health model.
Section 14 provides information and methodology on estimated savings from attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and autism assessment reform.
Section 15 provides information and methodology on Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) workforce.
Section 16 provides information and methodology on historical spend on employment support schemes.
Section 17 provides information and methodology on General Population Polling Young People and Work Final Report.
Section 18 provides information and methodology on quantitative survey of NEET and non-NEET young people aged 16 to 24.
Section 19 provides information and methodology on ‘Test and Learn’ Research.
1. Gross costs of the recommended policy package
Figure 1 in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report presents the total estimated annual gross costs in 2036/37 of the recommended policies by policy area. Note this is presented in 2026/27 prices. Table 1 in this annex presents these gross costs, the fiscal offsets are covered in section 2.
Table 1: Annual gross costs per policy area for the year 2036/37, real-terms 2026/27 prices, £m
| Policy area | 2036/37 gross annual cost (£m) |
|---|---|
| Local system reform | <£100 |
| Opportunity and Support Guarantees | £1,900 |
| Health | £700 |
| Education | £2,100 |
| Youth hiring incentives | £1,100 |
| Welfare savings | -£3,600 |
Costs have been built up from key individual policies. The following sections set out which policies have been covered and how costs for those policies have been estimated. For all policies costs are in 2026/27 prices. The gross cost estimates are based on suggested policy design or considerations of possible policy scenarios for modelling purposes. Any policy design is subject to further development and decisions. Where possible evidence is taken from comparable activity to indicate the likely scale of resources required.
The geographical coverage of the costs vary, in part depending on the devolved responsibilities of the departments involved. The geographical coverage is specified in each section below.
The report is an independent review of the increase in the number of young people who are not in education, employment or training (NEET), focused on examining the evidence and making recommendations. As such, it does not generate Barnett consequentials or trigger the Barnett Formula. Any subsequent government decisions would be considered in the usual way and in line with established funding arrangements.
Gross costs of the ‘local system reform’ policy area
The 2036/37 gross cost figure for the ‘local system reform’ policy area is estimated to be less than £100m in 2026/27 prices. This estimate is the sum of estimated gross costs for the following policies:
- improvement of current data infrastructure
- digital systems for running of the Youth Opportunity Service (YOS)
- funding for assurance and improvement support
- new local capacity and capability funding
- funding to a What Works Centre
Please refer to the From a Welfare State to a Working State report for more detailed information about these policy recommendations. The costs associated with these policies are for England only.
These estimates would be notably affected by material changes to the implementation timetable, geographical delivery model, number of lead local areas or responsibilities of the organisations included.
Data infrastructure and digital systems
The estimated costs associated with data infrastructure and digital systems contribute to the cumulative gross cost of the local system reform policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
Data and evidence
The main evidence used in the costing: Impetus’ costing estimate for their recommendation to build a comprehensive 16 to 24 NEET identification and tracking system.[footnote 1]
Methodology
The Impetus steady-state costs were assumed for 2036/37, with an uplift applied to account for the policy elements Impetus had not considered in their recommendation.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The key assumptions are captured by the overarching policy design-related caveats.
Funding for assurance and improvement support
The estimated costs associated with funding for assurance and improvement support contribute to the cumulative gross cost of the local system reform policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
Data and evidence
The main evidence used in the costing:
- Ofsted annual report and accounts[footnote 2]
- Health and Care Act 2022: Impact Assessments for Adult Social Care Provisions[footnote 3]
Methodology
Two estimates of the costs for this policy were completed for quality assurance purposes. Firstly, the Ofsted annual report and accounts was used to understand Ofsted’s current spend on local authority children’s services as a comparable cost for the recommended new assurance and improvement activity.
Secondly, the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) documentation above provided an estimated cost of activity through using the estimated cost of a Department for Education (DfE) Children’s Services Commissioner Review and applying this cost to the estimated level of activity across the assumed 40 lead local areas.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimate assumes that any local activity of the function is introduced across England rather than through a phased geographical rollout. It also assumes that the function interacts with 40 lead local areas.
Local capacity and capability funding
The estimated costs associated with new local capacity and capability funding contribute to the cumulative gross cost of the local system reform policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
Data and evidence
The main evidence used in the costing:
- Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) staffing and pay information (internal)
- DfE monthly workforce management information[footnote 4]
- Scottish Government Education and Skills budgets 2021 to 2024[footnote 5]
- Welsh Government education department staffing information[footnote 6]
Methodology
An estimate was calculated for the cost of DWP Full-Time Equivalent (FTE) demand for activity comparable to the activity that would be devolved to local areas as part of the Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) recommendations, for example, analysis of NEETs data and local policy decisions.
The proportion of this cost expected to fall to local areas was estimated using a comparator based on published staffing levels in the education departments of the Welsh and Scottish Governments relative to the equivalent education and skills functions in England. An average of these proportions was used as a proxy for the level of resource required to deliver comparable activity outside central government.
This proportion was then applied to the cost of DWP FTE demand for comparable YOS activity, which was multiplied by the assumed 40 lead local areas.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimate assumes that any local activity of the function is introduced across England rather than through a phased geographical rollout. It also assumes that the function has activity across 40 lead local areas.
Funding to a What Works Centre
The estimated costs associated with additional funding to a What Works Centre contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the local system reform policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
Data and evidence
This costing used the budget guidance for setting up a What Works Centre from the What Works Network and Evaluation Taskforce.[footnote 7]
Methodology
The costing used the suggested level of activity that would be needed by the What Works Centre to select a suggested annual budget from the What Works Network budget guidance.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
If the scope of the work required by the What Works Centre changes the funding amount will need to change to meet the new level of activity.
Gross costs of the ‘Opportunity and Support Guarantees’ policy area
The 2036/37 gross cost figure for the ‘Opportunity and Support Guarantees’ policy area is estimated to be £1,900m in 2026/27 prices. This estimate is the sum of estimated gross costs for the support provided through the guarantees. Costs are modelled on the assumption of the support being available across Great Britain.
Some policy recommendations that form part of the wider employment support package are captured in other policy areas, such as health and education.
Please refer to the From a Welfare State to a Working State report for more detailed information about these policies. recommendations.
Youth Opportunity Service
This analysis produced the estimated gross cost for the ‘Opportunity and Support Guarantees’ policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
The Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) has been modelled as:
-
providing support to additional groups beyond the existing Universal Credit (UC) “Intensive Work Search” group, for example those on Personal Independence Payments (PIP), who have Limited Capability for Work Related Activity (LCWRA), or in No Work-Related Requirements (NWRR) for other reasons, and young people that are NEET and not claiming benefits (‘hidden NEETs’)
-
additional interventions required to meet the increase in volumes, for example more Sector-Based Work Academy Programs (SWAPs), work experience, bootcamps, a new civic service programme, a new flexjobs scheme and increased Access to Work expenditure
-
a new Health and Disability Fund
Data and evidence
The data used in the costing includes the following:
- Internal estimates of unit costs for existing programmes that are either the same or similar to measures in the YOS:
- Work Experience
- SWAPs
- Skills Bootcamp
- Jobs Guarantee
- Liverpool Trailblazer
- Cambridge and Peterborough Trailblazer
- Shaw Trust
- Pathways to Work Confident Futures
- Peer Mentoring
- Access to Work Plus
- existing and historical volunteering and work experience programmes, including France’s Service Civique and Germany’s BFD
- analysis showing how quickly 18 to 24 year olds in IWS and NWRR leave these conditionality groups from December 2022 to December 2025 (internal analysis)
- Spring Summer 2026 forecast of IWS inflows for 16 to 24 year olds for 2030/31 (internal analysis)
- data on past inflows to No Work Requirements and IWS for 16 to 24 year olds in 2025/26 (internal analysis)
- internally estimated volumes of PIP and LCWRA claimants eligible for the YOS post modelled welfare reform
- NEET forecast (internal analysis)
- Consumer Prices Index (CPI) R2 SB26 inflation forecast
- DWP Winter Workload 25 staff salaries for 2026/27 (internal estimates)
- DWP Winter Workload 25 work coach productive minutes for 2026/27 (internal estimates)
Evidence on hidden NEETs is used to inform the policy design and assumptions for costing the support offer for hidden NEETs:
- Young people and work: interim report analytical annex[footnote 8]
- Office for National Statistics (ONS) dataset on characteristics of young people who are NEET[footnote 9]
- Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) report on NEETs not claiming benefits[footnote 10]
- Youth Futures Foundation NEET Trends Analysis (2025 Q4)[footnote 11]
- unpublished internal DWP analysis on hidden NEETs based on ONS Labour Force Survey and Universal Credit administrative data (experimental statistics)
Methodology
Separate estimates were developed for the cost of each measure in the YOS and combined to produce the overall figure.
For most measures, the unit cost assumption is multiplied by the volume assumption to calculate the total cost. For the health and disability fund, this has been illustratively modelled as a set portion of yearly savings from reforms to PIP recommended in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
Unit costs from existing programmes that are the same or similar to the measures in the YOS are used. Unit costs are adjusted using the CPI R2 SB26 inflation forecast.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
Alongside NEET young people claiming benefits, the YOS will also seek to engage ‘hidden’ NEET young people not currently claiming benefits. There is significant uncertainty in the number of hidden NEET young people who would take-up the support offer. The costings assume 46% of NEET young people are not claiming benefits (based on analysis conducted for the interim report[footnote 12]) but only a proportion of these will take up the support offer.
There is uncertainty in the volumes of young people taking up the support offer and starting different employment measures, for example, how many young people would reach 12 months and be able to start the Jobs Guarantee. The volumes are based on scenarios that have been tested with sensitivity analysis. The figures provided are the central estimates of costs. Each measure has a separate assumption on volumes.
There is uncertainty on volumes of PIP/LCWRA claimants engaging in the YOS.
There is uncertainty in the actual Access to Work implications from supporting more young people with disabilities and health conditions.
Gross costs of the ‘health’ policy area
The 2036/37 gross cost figure for the ‘health’ policy area is estimated to be £700m in 2026/27 prices. This estimate is the sum of estimated gross costs for the following policies:
- mental health package which includes the expansion of Individual Placement and Support for Young People (IPS-Y), the expansion of Early Support Hubs, additional high-intensity support within Mental Health Support Teams and Early Support Hubs and a national digital mental health offer (“Digital Front Door”)
- Vocational Rehabilitation Service
- fit note reform
- wider structural reform through additional capacity and capability funding to integrated care boards (ICBs)
Please refer to the From a Welfare State to a Working State report for more detailed information about these policy recommendations. The costs associated with these policies are for England only as health responsibilities outside England are devolved policy.
Mental health package
The mental health related policies contribute to the cumulative gross cost of the health policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
The set of mental health interventions intended to improve access to support for children and young people, include:
- expansion of Individual Placement and Support for Young People (IPS-Y)
- expansion of Early Support Hubs
- additional high-intensity support within Mental Health Support Teams and Early Support Hubs
- a national digital mental health offer (“Digital Front Door”)
The cost estimates of the mental health package include costs associated with workforce, training, implementation, digital infrastructure, licensing, programme management, operational, capital and evaluation costs where applicable.
Data and evidence
The costs for the mental health package draw on a combination of existing service data, published evidence, operational benchmarks and expert advice from organisations involved in delivering comparable mental health services.
Key evidence includes:
- costing information, workforce assumptions and delivery guidance provided by individual placement and support (IPS) Grow for Individual Placement and Support services
- costing and operational evidence provided by the Children and Young People’s Mental Health Coalition, including evidence from existing Early Support Hubs on staffing, setup costs, ongoing operating costs and caseloads
- existing business cases, market engagement and operational evidence relating to digital mental health services and digital therapeutic products
- NHS workforce structures, pay scales and service delivery assumptions used to estimate staffing requirements and associated costs
Where detailed delivery models are not yet finalised, the analysis uses evidence from existing services and comparable programmes to estimate the likely scale of resource requirements.
Methodology
For each recommended mental health intervention, the analysis identified the expected scale of provision and estimated the workforce, infrastructure and operational resources required to deliver the service. Staffing requirements were derived using service-specific assumptions regarding team structures, caseloads and workforce capacity. Salary costs were combined with additional employer costs and other operating costs to estimate total delivery costs.
Additional costs relating to implementation, training, programme management, digital infrastructure, software licensing and evaluation were included where these were expected to form part of the delivery model.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimates are indicative and were developed to support policy development.
The principal sources of uncertainty relate to:
- the final design and specification of individual interventions
- the scale, sequencing and pace of implementation
- workforce requirements, including staffing structures, productivity assumptions and pay costs
- future levels of service demand
- implementation, mobilisation and training requirements
- procurement arrangements and supplier pricing, particularly for digital services and digital therapeutic products
- future local delivery arrangements and governance structures
- evaluation requirements and associated delivery costs
The modelling assumes that the interventions included within the package are implemented as specified in the policy design available at the time the analysis was undertaken. Material changes to delivery models, rollout assumptions or service specifications would be expected to affect the estimated costs.
The estimates also assume that individual interventions are costed separately and that there is no overlap in the costing of service activity across the package.
Vocational Rehabilitation Service (VRS)
The Vocational Rehabilitation Service (VRS) contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the health package presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
The VRS has been costed as a service to support young people with a range of physical health conditions and impairments, including neurodivergence and musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions. While the service is not designed to provide direct support for mental health conditions, some participants may have co-occurring mental health conditions alongside other health conditions and will therefore receive support through the VRS for those wider health-related barriers. As such, the VRS is intended to complement, rather than duplicate, the other proposals within the wider mental health support offer.
Data and evidence
The main evidence used in the costing:
- percentage of NEETs that are economically inactive with a health condition[footnote 13]
- DWP’s forecast of annual inflows of 18 to 24 year olds to PIP and LCWRA in England (internal analysis)
- percentage of 18 to 24 year old WorkWell participants that cite mental health as their primary health barrier to work (internal analysis)
- percentage of people managing a mental health condition that have a comorbidity with a physical health condition[footnote 14]
- National Cost Collection for the NHS to establish a unit cost for the VRS[footnote 15]
- Office for Budget Responsibility’s (OBR) long-term economic determinants[footnote 16]
Methodology
Take-up estimates for the VRS were calculated using forecasts of health-related benefit caseloads and assumptions about the proportion of eligible young people who would engage with the service. Given the uncertainty associated with future participation rates, take-up has been informed by evidence from comparable programmes and benchmarked against realistic levels of engagement among the eligible population. As a result, estimated delivery volumes are substantially lower than the total number of potentially eligible individuals.
To avoid double counting participants already in the Mental Health pathway, a proportion of participants is removed from the costing. The proportion excluded is based on the share of 18 to 24 year olds participating in WorkWell who identify a mental health condition as their primary barrier to employment. However, some of this cohort will have physical health condition as a comorbidity and thus require VRS support, so not all are removed.
An average unit cost per participant was estimated. This considered varying costs by primary health condition and intensity of support received and accounted for referral and overhead costs. This average unit cost was then applied to the assumed take-up volumes.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The analysis relies on a range of assumptions regarding take-up, participant characteristics, delivery models and workforce capacity. Key uncertainties include policy design, future demand for the service, interactions with other support pathways, and the proportion of participants requiring more intensive support. Delivery costs are particularly sensitive to local implementation decisions and the availability of suitably qualified staff.
The final costs of the VRS will depend on detailed policy design, the scale of take-up and policy decisions regarding the Youth Opportunity Service, and wider welfare reform.
Fit note reform
The expansion of fit note reforms to all young people contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the health policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
Definitions
Fit note - a fit note (Statement of Fitness for Work) is a form issued by a healthcare professional following an assessment of a person’s health and fitness for work, providing advice on whether they are not fit for work or may be fit for work with appropriate workplace adjustments.
Data and evidence
The main evidence used in the costing:
- number of fit note episodes[footnote 17]
- number of fit notes in an episode[footnote 18]
- number of fit notes for those in work (internal analysis)
- number of fit notes for young people (internal analysis of WorkWell programme and age distribution of working population[footnote 19]
- cost of triaging a participant[footnote 20]
- costs of administrative tasks[footnote 21]
- cost of clinical oversight (assumed to be a general practitioner (GP))[footnote 22]
- cost of the multidisciplinary team (community occupational therapists[footnote 23] and social prescribers[footnote 24])
Methodology
As no age-specific fit note data are available, a best estimate of fit note episodes for young people aged 18 to 24 was developed using a range of assumptions and proxy-evidence. These were applied to published fit note statistics to approximate the number of fit note episodes among in-work young people that would be eligible for reform.
As the proposed service differs from the existing fit note system, assumptions were applied to published fit note episode data to better reflect uncertainty in the policy design, as design and delivery, in terms of the number of appointments and level of clinical input, will be devolved to local areas.
Costs associated with delivering the service are based on a range of activities required to complete the process end-to-end, their associated costs and how long on average it takes to do them.
Costs were estimated by modelling the activities required to deliver the service across a sickness absence episode and applying assumptions about service delivery, resource requirements and engagement patterns. Unit costs were then applied to estimate the overall cost of delivery under different workforce mix scenarios.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The key analytical assumptions and uncertainties are as follows:
- number of fit notes for young people: unavailability of specific data of fit notes by age group means that the expected number of participants is highly uncertain
- delivery model: as delivery will be devolved to local areas, there is uncertainty around both the cost per fit note appointment and the number of appointments required per fit note episode. While the volume of fit note episodes is assumed to be fixed, higher costs per episode, whether driven by increased appointment volumes or a more clinically-intensive workforce model, would increase overall proposal costs, all else being equal.
- workforce: assumption that there is a workforce available to deliver the fit note reforms
Wider structural reform through additional capacity and capability funding to ICBs
The gross costs associated with wider structural reforms to make participation an outcome for the NHS contribute to the cumulative gross cost of the health policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
These costings relate to additional capacity funding to ICBs for commissioning, data, workforce, partnership and evaluation capability to support ICBs to scale up their capacity and avoid a situation where local leaders are asked to improve outcomes but cannot reshape the services or resources that influence them.
Data and evidence
The costings proposed are based on comparisons with existing programmes to benchmark likely resource needs associated with making participation an outcome at integrated care board (ICB) level. Illustrative modelling has also been used to show how the funding might be used to recruit to roles at ICB level.
Benchmarks used to estimate funding required per ICB are:
- data from the Health and Growth Accelerators on what spending they have allocated to relevant capacity building work including programme support, data and reporting, test and learn development, information governance and evaluation, and leadership and management support. This data has been sourced from within the NHS England (NHSE) Health and Growth Accelerator Programme (internal analysis)
- the WorkWell programme leadership allocation. This data has been sourced from with WorkWell programme run by the Joint Work and Health Directorate (jointly by DHSC and DWP) (internal analysis)
- DWP’s proposal of similar capacity/capability funding for Mayoral Strategic Authorities (MSAs) for NEETs (internal analysis)
Data for illustrative modelling of ICB recruitment is based on 2026/27 Agenda for Change salaries[footnote 25], with an allowance for employer on-costs.
Methodology
The funding figure has been proposed on the basis that:
- it is below the upper end of what the Health and Growth Accelerators have spent on enabling expenditure
- it is materially above WorkWell’s leadership allocation, which funded approximately one role to deliver a programme rather than system transformation and was reported by ICBs as insufficient
- it is comparable to the proposed costing of similar capacity/capability funding for MSAs
- illustrative modelling demonstrates the proposed funding is sufficient to fund a senior strategic commissioning function spanning leadership, commissioning, transformation, partnerships, analytics and specialist expertise
Key assumptions and uncertainty
Given the funding figure has been based on benchmarking from existing sites, there is an inherent risk this figure could over or underestimate the required funding needed. There is likely to be variation in the level of capacity and capability building needed across different systems, and the level of resource needed in benchmark sites may not match what is needed elsewhere.
The estimate assumes that implementation begins in 2027/28 and that the new arrangements are introduced nationally rather than through a phased geographical rollout. It also assumes that:
- all areas take on the relevant additional responsibilities from implementation
- the functions and responsibilities of the organisations remain consistent with the policy design used for the costing
Gross costs of the ‘education’ policy area
The 2036/37 gross cost figure for the ‘education’ policy area is estimated to be £2,100m in 2026/27 prices. This estimate is the sum of estimated gross costs for the following policies:
- work experience package
- participation and work-readiness premium for 16 to 19 year olds
- Expanded Pupil Premium Plus
- Care Leaver Transition Allowance
- 16 to 17 year old NEET re-engagement
- further education participation expansion for 18 to 24 year olds
- further education in-year growth and mid-year enrolment funding
- pre-apprenticeships
- supported internships
Please refer to the From a Welfare State to a Working State report for more detailed information about these policy recommendations. The costs associated with these policies are for England only as education responsibilities outside England are devolved policy.
Work experience package
The work experience programme contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the education policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. The costs for the programme are associated with expanding access to structured work-experience opportunities for young people in England. Funding would be required to generate, coordinate and support additional placements.
Data and evidence
The analysis draws on evidence from work-experience programmes, employer engagement initiatives and existing delivery models. Operational assumptions relating to placement, coordination and administration informed the costing approach.
Methodology
The contribution to package costs was estimated by projecting the number of placements to be delivered and applying assumptions regarding delivery, coordination and programme administration costs.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimate depends on assumptions regarding employer participation, placement volumes, programme design and future delivery arrangements. Different delivery models could result in materially different costs.
Participation and work readiness premium for 16 to 19 year olds
The participation and work readiness premium contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the education policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. The costs for the policy are associated with additional funding for disadvantaged learners aged 16 to 19 to support participation, retention and progression in education and training.
Data and evidence
The analysis draws on unpublished administrative learner data, projected learner numbers and evidence relating to disadvantage within post-16 education. Existing funding mechanisms were used to benchmark the scale of resources required.
Methodology
Costs were estimated by identifying the projected eligible learner population and applying the proposed premium funding rate.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
Key uncertainties relate to learner participation, eligibility, future population projections and funding rates. Material changes to policy design or implementation arrangements would affect the overall cost estimate.
Expanded Pupil Premium Plus
The Expanded Pupil Premium Plus policy contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the education policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. The costs associated with this policy relate to extending additional educational support funding for care-experienced young people, helping them to remain engaged in education and training and supporting their progression into employment.
Data and evidence
The estimate uses unpublished administrative data on learner characteristics, together with ONS’ population projections[footnote 26] to estimate the beneficiary population over time. Existing pupil premium funding arrangements informed the costing assumptions.
Methodology
The contribution to package costs was estimated by applying the proposed funding entitlement to projected number of eligible learners.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimate is sensitive to learner numbers, learner characteristics and rate of the Premium. Changes to eligibility criteria or future funding settlements would affect the estimated cost.
Care Leaver Transition Allowance
The gross costs associated with the Care Leaver Transition Allowance contribute to the cumulative gross cost of the education policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. The costs for the programme are associated with providing financial support for eligible care leavers to help incentivise them to enter education, employment or training.
Data and evidence
The costing draws on information relating to the care leaver population[footnote 27], expected eligibility rates and assumptions regarding payment values and duration. Administrative data and policy assumptions were used to estimate likely expenditure.
Methodology
Costs were estimated by applying the proposed payment arrangements to projected numbers of eligible care leavers.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimate is sensitive to assumptions regarding eligibility, take-up, the size of the care leaver population and the duration of support. Future policy design decisions could alter the projected costs.
16 to 17 year old NEET re-engagement
The 16 to 17 year old NEET re-engagement policy contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the education policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. The costs for the policy reflect the funding required to support additional learner participation in further education, alongside associated delivery costs and implementation assumptions.
Data and evidence
The costing draws on published data relating to NEET status,[footnote 28] together with existing further education funding arrangements and published evidence on the educational and labour market pathways of young people who had previously been NEET.[footnote 29]
Methodology
The gross costs were estimated by modelling the number of additional learners expected to participate and applying relevant funding rates and delivery assumptions.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimate is sensitive to assumptions regarding learner demand, participation rates, implementation timing and the level of support required. Uncertainty also arises from future funding rates, provider behaviour and the final specification of the policy. Costs would change if delivery assumptions, eligibility criteria or rollout arrangements were amended.
Further education participation expansion for 18 to 24 year olds
The expansion of further education (FE) to accommodate an extra 150,000 18 to 24 year olds participating a year contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the education policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
The participants will be young adults in England only, reflecting devolved responsibilities for education services.
The expansion target of 150,000 additional learners is expected to be reached in 2036/37.
Data and evidence
The target of 150,000 learners in FE was informed by an ambition to substantially reduce the vocational education gap between the UK and comparator European countries Denmark, Germany and the Netherlands. This is further described in section 5 of this annex.
Assumptions about proportions of full-time and part-time study, classroom capacity per student and the cost of full-time learner places are informed by current FE provision for young adults.
Methodology
The required full-time learner places were estimated by applying estimates of full- and part-time study to the target volumes of additional learners. The estimated gross costs were calculated by multiplying the target yearly volumes of full-time learner places by the unit cost of the places. Modelling ensures no overlaps in the costs of this and supporting policies that will help more young adults to participate in further education.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimates are indicative and were developed to support policy development.
The principal sources of uncertainty relate to:
- the final design and specification of supporting education interventions
- the scale, sequencing and pace of further education expansion
Material changes to delivery models, rollout assumptions or service specifications would be expected to affect the estimated costs.
Further education in-year growth and mid-year enrolment funding
The further education in-year growth and mid-year enrolment funding policy contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the education policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. The costs for the programme are associated with increasing funding available to support in-year growth in 16 to 19 education (including up to age 24 for those with high needs), alongside providing timely, proportionate funding for additional eligible learners who enrol after the November reference date.
Data and evidence
The analysis draws on further education funding information and evidence regarding learner demand and participation patterns. Existing growth funding arrangements informed assumptions regarding likely levels of additional provision.
Methodology
The costing was developed by estimating the volume of additional learner places and in-year starts expected to be supported through increased growth funding, applying relevant funding assumptions.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimate is sensitive to assumptions regarding learner demand, provider uptake of growth funding, future funding rates and implementation arrangements. Changes to any of these assumptions would affect the estimated contribution to the overall education package cost.
Pre-apprenticeships
The pre-apprenticeships programme contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the education policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. The costs for the programme are associated with providing pre-apprenticeships programmes for young people, including employability support, work experience and occupation-relevant training.
Data and evidence
Evidence from previous provision was used to inform assumptions regarding participant numbers, delivery models and programme costs.
Methodology
Costs were estimated by modelling anticipated participant volumes and applying assumptions regarding unit costs of pre-apprenticeships.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimate is sensitive to assumptions regarding demand, provider capacity, programme specification and delivery arrangements. Changes to the final programme design would affect the projected costs.
Supported internships
The supported internships policy contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the education policy area presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. The costs for the policy reflect funding additional supported internship places and associated support arrangements.
Data and evidence
The costing draws on information from current delivery models to estimate the unit costs of supported internships.
Methodology
The gross costs were estimated by projecting the planned expansion in supported internship provision and applying unit costs assumptions.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimated gross costs depend on assumptions regarding participation volumes, provider capacity, and programme design. Future decisions regarding delivery arrangements and levels of support could materially affect costs.
Gross costs of the ‘youth hiring incentives’ policy area
The 2036/37 gross cost figure for the ‘youth hiring incentives’ policy area is estimated to be £1,100m in 2026/27 prices. This is the estimated gross cost of the expansion of the Youth Jobs Grant and apprenticeships recommendations.
Please refer to the From a Welfare State to a Working State report for more detailed information about these policy recommendations.
Expansion of the Youth Jobs Grant
The gross costs comprise the costs of expanding the Youth Jobs Grants by up to an additional 40,000 opportunities per year to a total of around 60,000. The grants will be available to young people not in employment, education or training aged up to 24 years old and in Great Britain.
Impacts and costs peak at 40,000 additional incentives per year and are scaled over the period of the review.
Grant costs differ based on participant and employer type. Employers who take on any young person who has been NEET for 6 months should receive a £3,000 payment. An extra premium payment of £2,000 should go to employers taking on somebody facing substantially greater barriers, such as care leavers or disabled young people. In addition, a further small business premium of £2,000 should be available to businesses with fewer than 50 employees.
Data and evidence
The target for the number of grants delivered per year was informed by:
- ONS vacancies data[footnote 30]
- Employer survey evidence from Employer views on hiring young people survey done as part of the Young people and work: interim report[footnote 31]
Assumptions about the prevalences of different top-ups to the basic hiring incentives were informed by publications including:
- Young people and work: interim report analytical annex[footnote 32]
- ONS dataset on characteristics of young people who are NEET[footnote 33]
- ONS employment data[footnote 34]
- Department for Business and Trade business population data[footnote 35]
Methodology
The ONS vacancies data and employers survey evidence was used to approximate the take-up increase compared with current delivery that may be achieved by significantly improving employer awareness and reducing administrative burden.
The evidence on priority groups and employers informed estimates of the prevalence of the different top-ups to the basic hiring incentive. This was used to calculate an estimated weighted average grant cost.
The estimated gross costs were calculated by multiplying the target yearly volumes by the estimated weighted average grant costs, such as the unit cost.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The final costs of any expansion to the Youth Jobs Grant will depend on detailed policy design, the scale of grant take-up and the proportion of employee participants from priority groups and participating employers that are small businesses.
Apprenticeships
The apprenticeships policy contributes to the cumulative gross cost of the ‘youth hiring incentives’ presented in chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. The costs associated with this policy are for England only as apprenticeships outside England are devolved policy.
Data and evidence
The main evidence used in the analysis:
- apprenticeships forecasts for starts and spend (internal analysis)
- Covid incentive evaluation (internal analysis)
- apprenticeships official statistics[footnote 36]
- historical spend data for apprenticeships (internal analysis)
Methodology
The figures presented for apprenticeships cover estimated starts and spend in 2036/37. The investments comprise of several policy measures. The financial and starts impacts for these measures draw on estimates of unit costs. Additionality estimates as well as historical starts data (including official statistics) and historical spend data are then used to inform assumptions around starts volumes impacts which, when coupled with estimated unit costs, create the forecasts for aiming to hit 270,000 16 to 24 starts annually and the corresponding spend.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
Forecasting apprenticeships costs and starts has a high degree of uncertainty. The programme is demand-led, meaning estimating starts and costs is challenging. While data and evidence available for these proposed measures has been utilised, there is a lot of uncertainty around potential employer behaviour in response to these measures which can have a significant impact on how actual starts and costs materialise.
AME saving from the ‘welfare savings’ policy area
The 2036/37 figure for the ‘welfare savings’ policy area is estimated to be -£3,600m in 2026/27 prices. The cumulative welfare savings from 2029/30 to 2036/37 are estimated to be -£13,700m. The estimates cover impacts on PIP and UC expenditure across the UK. The figure represents the estimated savings relative to the baseline forecasts.
This is the result of the estimated welfare spending impact of the health and disability welfare reform scenarios and forecast additional spend resulting from recommended changes to the work allowance and rate of Youth Allowance proposed for young people, starting in 2029/30. Annual savings are modelled starting in this year, with cumulative savings representing the sum of annual savings from 2029/30 up to 2036/37 all in 2026/27 price terms. It is likely savings continue to build beyond this point as successive cohorts of young people benefit from the reforms and move into work, alongside ongoing savings from those who remain in employment.
Please refer to the From a Welfare State to a Working State report for more detailed information about these recommendations.
Data and evidence
The estimates for health and disability expenditure are based on forecasts of flows into health and disability benefits. The age distribution of forecast claimants is derived from recent administrative data and held constant over the projection period using age-specific proportions. The modelling draws on observed claimants flow patterns and caseload forecasts to estimate the impact of the health and disability welfare reform scenario.
The cost estimates for the Youth Allowance for young people living independently and work allowance are modelled using the DWP Policy Simulation Model (PSM), which is based on the Family Resources Survey (FRS), forecasts of the Universal Credit caseload and OBR economic assumptions and population projections. Administrative data is also used for further refinement of the analysis.
Methodology
The estimates for health and disability expenditure were produced by forecasting future flows into relevant benefit cohorts and applying the policy changes to affected claimant groups. Existing claimants’ stocks were projected forward over time using assumptions on inflows, outflows and ageing in line with observed historical data. Policy impacts were estimated for those who will be both existing and future claimants. Resulting changes in expenditure then model behavioural and take-up assumptions listed in the section below to produce annual change to welfare spending impacts. Estimates were projected across the modelling period from 2029/30 to 2036/37 and compared against the baseline forecast to derive the final savings figures.
Modelling for the Youth Allowance and work allowance changes uses the forecasts for the UC caseload up to 2030/31 and its compositional changes affecting UC entitlement such as earnings growth and demographic changes which are then applied to the FRS data. Costs and impacts of the work allowance and Youth Allowance changes are then estimated by comparing benefit entitlement under current and proposed rules, holding other circumstances unchanged, and applying the results to forecast caseloads. Administrative data provides a more robust basis for identifying young people on UC who are living independently and is therefore used to refine the Youth Allowance costing. No behavioural or employment assumptions were estimated for the Youth Allowance or the work allowance changes and any interaction with employment impacts from the other reforms is not accounted for.
Given Youth Allowance and work allowance forecasts are only available up to 2030/31, the assumption is made that costs are flat in 2026/27 prices until 2036/37.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The health and disability benefit scenario modelled uses illustrative assumptions to place PIP inflows aged 18 to 24 in the following groups:
- those who will be awarded Severe and Complex Needs Insurance, at a rate higher than current highest PIP and LCWRA awards
- those who will be awarded the Additional Cost Allowance
- those who will be no longer be eligible for this type of benefit
An additional employment impact of 9% is assumed in line with other welfare costings when estimating the behavioural employment impact for UC health claimants. This is based on an assumption used in previous departmental modelling of the employment rate for the LCWRA group increasing to narrow the gap between that rate and the LCW employment rate.
A proportion of those who receive PIP do not receive UC, therefore a UC Standard Allowance take-up rate is assumed among those who will in the future not receive PIP. It is assumed that a proportion of hidden NEETs may take this up due to their engagement with the Youth Opportunity Service. All recipients are assumed to receive the under-25 Standard Allowance rate were they to newly claim UC.
Modelling on the Youth Allowance and work allowance changes projects forward incomes of households on UC using survey data from the FRS linked to administrative data. The model uses the benefit caseload and economic assumptions forecasts which are subject to change. An assumption is made that costs for the youth and work allowance are flat in 2026/27 prices until 2036/37 in the absence of forecasts beyond 2030/31.
For estimating the costs for the Youth Allowance, there is no direct information on whether young people on UC live with their parents but the receipt of a housing element has been used as a proxy for living independently.
The figures do not capture any upstream impacts arising from education or health policies that may affect volumes and outcomes under this reform.
These figures are considered indicative and are intended to provide an estimate of the broad scale and direction of impacts rather than a precise forecast of future savings. They are subject to policy development and uncertainty.
2. NEET impacts of the recommended policy package
This section explains the analytical approach to the NEET rate and volume impacts of the recommended policy package as presented in chapters 1, 6 and 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. The modelling shows that in 2036 the reforms and policies that are proposed in this report will lead to:
- a NEET rate of around 6.8%
- around 400,000 more 16 to 24 year olds in work
- around 500,000 more 16 to 24 year olds in employment and education
NEET headcount reductions are rounded to the nearest 100,000.
Reductions in the headline NEET rates and volumes for 16 to 24 year olds are built up from the individual key policies included in the costs in section 1 above. A system transformation effect is modelled to reflect the participation, integration, earlier intervention and improved transitions across the system. All impacts are compared to a baseline forecast of NEETs.
Data and evidence
The baseline forecast was derived from a central, seasonally-adjusted NEET projection scenario from Youth Futures Foundation (YFF) SARIMAX modelling using Labour Force Survey data from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) and Office for Budget Responsibility economic projections.[footnote 37] This was supplemented by ONS mid-year population projections[footnote 38] to inform an adjustment for temporary growth in the youth population. DWP and DfE internal analysis informed further adjustments to the baseline for the impacts of some employment programmes and education changes already in train or announced but not captured in the underlying data.
Impacts of individual key policies are informed firstly by volumes and geographical coverage of interventions as described in section 1 above and, where possible, by evaluations of previous similar health, education, employment and infrastructure programmes and initiatives. In particular, evaluation evidence informed proportions of NEETs entering education and/or employment. It was not always possible to draw on appropriate evaluation evidence. For example, only employment impacts could be estimated for health, participation, welfare and employment interventions due to a lack of evaluation evidence to inform education and training impacts for these areas. Both education and employment impacts were estimated for education proposals.
The estimated system transformation effect is informed by internal analysis of past NEET trends using annual estimates from the Labour Force Survey of young people aged 16 to 24 who are NEET[footnote 39] and ONS characteristics of NEETS (derived from Census 2021 NHS hospital episode statistics, HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) Pay As You Earn (PAYE) data, and birth and death registrations).[footnote 40]
Methodology
The methodology used to derive the YFF NEET projection scenarios is described in A persistent challenge: NEET projections for the UK to 2036 under alternative economic scenarios - Youth Futures Foundation. The projections are conditional on the economic assumptions in each scenario and assume no major change in the policy environment. Youth population was tested as a candidate explanatory variable but was not retained in YFF’s final model specification, so projected NEET volumes do not respond directly to expected increases in the size of the youth population, other than to the extent that past demographic trends are reflected in the historical NEET series. To account for expected temporary youth population growth, an adjustment has been applied which assumes that additional 16 to 24 year olds enter the cohort with a higher average probability of being NEET, reflecting increased competition for jobs.
Estimated impacts of employment programmes and education changes already in train or announced, but not captured in the underlying data, were also applied as an adjustment to the baseline.
The impacts of policy recommendations take into account during-intervention and/or sustained post-intervention education and/or employment impacts over time. Post-intervention employment and/or education impacts are gradually reduced to consider participants aging out of the 16 to 24 cohort. Impacts are summed into a point in time reduction to the stock of NEETs in each year.
As far as possible, impacts were modelled to avoid overlaps between policies, but to account for residual overlaps, 2 approaches were taken:
- Conservative impact assumptions have been used where appropriate
- An overlap reduction is applied that increases gradually from 5% to 10% over time
The increasing profile of the overlap adjustment accounts for the impacts of policies overlapping to an increasing extent over time as some individuals are exposed to multiple interventions.
The system transformation impacts were estimated using backcasting and cohort-flow modelling with a target NEET rate. Analysis of past NEET rates informed a proportion of historic change that is due to higher inactivity in addition to labour market change. The approach considers NEET risk factors leading to inactivity and performance under past conditions to estimate the impact of improved cross-government initiatives for stronger post-16 transitions and improved participation trajectories across childhood and adolescence. The impact of digital transformation was modelled by considering the uplift in NEET identification, improvement in digital access to employment support and digital matching to jobs, courses and apprenticeships.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
As the policy recommendations proposed are complex and, in many cases, a significant departure from the current approach, the past can be used as a source but there is not always a direct link to previous interventions, and therefore high-quality evidence on which to assess their likely impact. Some reforms may not deliver as expected and need further development and refinement.
3. Fiscal offsets of the recommended policy package
This section explains the analytical approach to the fiscal offsets of the recommended policy package as presented in figure 1 of chapter 8 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. The fiscal offset is estimated to be £2,400m in 2036/37, in 2026/27 prices.
As young people stop being NEET and move into employment, this will generate income in the form of tax, National Insurance and indirect tax as they increase their spending. If they were claiming benefits, their claims may reduce or stop resulting in savings for the State. Both of these will offset spending on the policy recommendations being funded to support these young people into education or employment. The net cost value is the sum of the gross costs, direct welfare savings from proposed reforms and fiscal offsets.
Data and evidence
Estimates of benefits savings and tax and National Insurance income from increasing employment derived from internal DWP analysis using scenarios of individual characteristics and employment behaviour.
An estimate of the proportion of NEETs who are ‘hidden’ (not claiming benefits) is taken from the interim report.[footnote 41] The assumption of the proportion of NEETs who are hidden was lowered for:
- young people with health conditions
- some education interventions aimed at young people who are likely to have been NEET for longer and therefore more likely to be claiming benefits
Estimates of young people who are no longer NEET as a result of our interventions are derived as described in section 2 above.
Methodology
Internal DWP analysis, using the department’s established cost benefit analysis framework, is used to model tax and benefit saving scenarios, based on assumptions about hours worked and wages for those moving into work as well as benefits claimed. NEET volume reductions due to employment were multiplied by different scenarios depending on the policy intervention and the characteristics of young people participating in them.
The model splits offsets into:
- savings from reduced spending on benefits, which is applied to the portion of young people moving into employment and assumed to be on benefit. Claimants claiming only PIP, but no other benefit, are treated as non-benefit cases in the fiscal offset calculation
- increased tax revenue, which is applied to all NEET young people moving into employment
No benefit savings were assumed from moves into education or training. No benefit savings from the welfare reforms are included in the fiscal offset figure, though the fiscal offset figure does include increased tax revenue resulting from the increased employment caused by welfare changes.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The underlying analysis to generate the fiscal offset scenarios relies on assumptions on age, average hours worked, average wages earned and benefits claimed. The offsets are also sensitive to the assumed proportions of hidden NEETs. All of these assumptions are subject to uncertainty.
4. Impact of youth participation on GDP
This analysis is included in chapter 1 and 4 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
If implemented in full, the recommended reforms could increase GDP by over 0.4% per year by 2036/37.
Data and evidence
This analysis draws on:
- average weekly earning statistics from the Office for National Statistics (October 2026)[footnote 42]
- Economic and fiscal outlook – March 2026 from the Office for Budget Responsibility[footnote 43]
Methodology
The analysis uses a rule-of-thumb approach to estimate the impact of increased youth employment on GDP. It first calculates the percentage increase in total employment which is then adjusted to reflect the lower expected earnings, hours and productivity of additional workers relative to the economy-wide average, using lower and upper weekly earnings assumptions and a two-thirds productivity adjustment.
The resulting GDP effect is then scaled to an estimated increase of 440,000 young people in employment. This produces an estimated increase in GDP of 0.4%, rounded to 1 decimal point.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimate is illustrative rather than a full macroeconomic forecast. It assumes that earnings provide a reasonable proxy for hours worked and productivity, applies a fixed two-thirds adjustment to reflect there might not be the required adjustment in the capital stock in the short-term, and scales the GDP effect proportionately to the number of additional young people entering employment. It therefore does not explicitly model displacement, labour market composition, wider fiscal effects or interactions with other economic variables.
5. Further education expansion target
This analysis is included in chapter 4 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
Over the next decade, post-18 further-education participation should expand substantially, with an extra 150,000 18 to 24 year olds participating a year to significantly reduce the gap with comparator countries.
Data and evidence
This assessment is informed by the following evidence on vocational participation in the UK, Netherlands, Denmark and Germany:
- Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) vocational participation data, ages 18 to 21[footnote 44]
- OECD vocational participation data, ages 22 to 24[footnote 45]
- Office for National Statistics population projections[footnote 46]
Methodology
Vocational participation data was compared between the UK and the Netherlands, Denmark and Germany to arrive at percentage-point participation gaps for 18 to 21 year olds and 22 to 24 year olds respectively. Vocational participation for ages 22 to 24 years was informed by vocational enrolment rates for 20 to 24 year olds in the absence of data for the specific age group.
Applying these percentage-point gaps to the projected England population of 18 to 24 year olds gives an estimate of the vocational participation gap. This was used to set the scale of ambition for expanding further education, while simultaneously expanding under-25 apprenticeship starts from 172,000 in 2024/25 up to 270,000 by 2036/37 and introducing 25,000 pre-apprenticeships.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The 18 to 21 year old vocational participation comparison between countries is directly evidenced, but the 22 to 24 year old estimate is a proxy. The calculation also applies UK-level participation rates to England’s projected population.
6. Young people supported through early intervention and preventative mental health and neurodevelopmental support
This analysis is included in chapter 1 and 5 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
Earlier intervention and preventative services could support up to an estimated 930,000 young people over 5 years, with many more accessing advice and support through digital channels. This is a highly indicative upper estimate of the cumulative number of young people being supported over the first 5 years of the recommended mental health package.
Data and evidence
The data and evidence used for this analysis came from a range of sources including evidence from stakeholders and clinical experts, published guidance from NHSE and analysis of the Mental Health Services Data Set.
Methodology
Estimates are developed by estimating the caseloads per practitioner or per service, which are then applied to a further rollout of that service. A 2% increase in caseload per annum is modelled in the upper bound estimate to account for anticipated productivity improvements.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
These are highly indicative estimates, based on a number of simplifying modelling assumptions which may not reflect actual delivery of new services. Additionally, for some policy proposals, a single service model does not exist and services are specified by local commissioners. The national estimates are based on one illustrative model being expanded.
7. Net incomes of young people
This analysis is included in chapter 1 and 6 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
This section explains the analytical approach to the estimation of the rise in net incomes of young people resulting from the impacts of the recommended policy package. The estimated rise in net incomes is estimated to be over £2 billion.
Data and evidence
The calculation of this figure is dependent on gross costs, impacts and fiscal offsets modelled by this review, outlined in sections 1, 2 and 3 above. It also uses internal DWP analysis to calculate the net earnings to individuals moving into work, based on different scenarios of hours worked and wages earnt.
Methodology
The analysis takes the modelled impacts of the NEET rate impact of the recommended policy package, to derive a scenario of numbers of NEET young people moving into work as a result of the policy package.
An average net earning resulting from moves into work is taken, using DWP analysis and assuming a mixture of moves into full-time work and into part-time work. The modelled welfare savings and fiscal offsets are deducted from this figure to derive a net change in incomes.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The analysis is subject to the same assumptions and uncertainties underlying the welfare Annually Managed Expenditure (AME) savings (section 1), NEET impacts (section 2) and fiscal offsets (section 3).
Additionally, an assumption is made as to the average hours worked and wage earned by those moving into work as a result of the policy package. These assumptions represent an illustrative scenario and are subject to uncertainty.
8. Relative poverty impacts after housing costs of the recommended policy package
This analysis is included in chapter 1 and 6 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. It is estimated that there will be 50,000 fewer individuals in relative low income after housing costs (relative poverty) as a result of the modelled measures recommended in the report once fully rolled out.
This analysis provides an estimate of the combined impact on poverty levels for individuals based on the following measures from the report:
- health and disability benefits for people under 25 claiming UC LCWRA and/or PIP
- the estimated employment effects from the wider package of support. This includes sustained employment effects beyond age 24
- introducing a Health and Disability Fund to support young disabled people and young people with health conditions
- implementing a Youth Allowance for young people with a higher rate for those under 25 living independently
- introducing a Work Allowance in Universal Credit set at a level to allow for part-time work for all those under 25
Data and evidence
The Department for Work and Pensions’ Policy Simulation Model (PSM) is used to model the impact of policies on individuals and low income poverty levels. The PSM is a static microsimulation model based on a snapshot of the UK population from the Family Resources Survey (FRS), currently for the financial years 2022/23, 2023/24 and 2024/25. It uses caseload forecasts alongside benefit rules to simulate results such as poverty levels for each year, currently up to and including 2030/31.
Because the PSM is a static model, it does not account for behavioural effects arising from policy changes, including changes in labour market participation in response to altered work incentives or increased take-up among existing eligible non-claimants. However, it can be used to estimate the poverty impacts of employment transitions by modelling the movement of individuals into and out of work under specified assumptions.
To model the impact of policies, the PSM compares new policies to a baseline scenario, which assumes existing benefit rules, forecasted caseloads, and estimates the impact of the policy change on poverty rates and incomes in the year in question. This analysis uses a model consistent with the OBR’s economic and caseload forecasts in March 2026 as these were the latest available at the time of modelling.
As the poverty impacts presented are independent of the underlying trends in poverty they are not an estimate of the total change in poverty over time. Instead, they show the difference between our expectations of the number of people in poverty in a given year with and without the measures listed above.
This analysis uses equivalised incomes after housing costs (AHC). Equivalised incomes are calculated at the household level. This means that individuals not directly affected by the policy can lose or gain as a result of being in the same household as someone who is impacted.
Estimates are rounded to the nearest 50,000 individuals.
Poverty analysis is presented for relative low income after housing costs.
Further information on the methodology behind the low income measures can be found at How low income is measured in households below average income statistics and at Households Below Average Income: Background Information and Methodology report FYE 2025.
Methodology
The PSM has been used to model the following elements of the report package:
-
Health and Disability Benefit Reform – Claimants are assumed either to be awarded a Severe and Complex Needs Insurance (at a rate higher than current highest PIP and LCWRA awards), awarded the Additional Cost Allowance, or to be no longer be eligible for this type of benefit
-
Employment Effects – It is assumed that 440,000 additional young people are in work. Of this increase in employment, it is assumed there are a mixture of moves into full-time and part-time work
-
Health and Disability Fund – The Health and Disability Fund is illustratively modelled as a set portion of yearly savings from reforms to PIP recommended in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report. It is assumed support provided is targeted to those who receive no Additional Costs Allowance or Severe and Complex Needs Insurance
-
Youth Allowance – The modelling assumes the Youth Allowance is paid at the rate of the current UC Standard Allowance for claimants aged under 25 unless they live independently, in which case it is increased to the rate currently paid to those aged 25 and over, proxied by receipt of the UC Housing Element
-
UC Work Allowance – The UC Work Allowance is extended to all claimants aged under 25 and is set at a level to allow for part-time work
These policy changes and employment effects have been modelled as a package, with the resulting estimates reflecting the combined impact of all measures on poverty.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
There are inherent uncertainties in modelling poverty impacts. As noted above, estimates have therefore been rounded to the nearest 50,000 individuals.
Several of the measures modelled rely on assumptions that could affect the estimated poverty impacts if alternative assumptions were applied. In particular:
- the Health and Disability Benefit reforms assumptions around how many will receive the Severe and Complex Needs Insurance, receive the Additional Cost Allowance, or will no longer be eligible for this type of benefit
- the employment effects assume an additional 440,000 young people in work with those moves into employment being a mixture of part-time and full-time work
- whilst the employment effects have been modelled any impact on extra earnings over the life course as a result has not been accounted for
- the Health and Disability Fund assumes support provided is targeted to those who receive no Additional Costs Allowance or Severe and Complex Needs Insurance
The estimated poverty impacts are intended to represent a steady-state position. However, the PSM only produces estimates to 2030/31, reflecting the latest available benefit caseload projections and OBR economic forecasts. While the employment assumptions are intended to represent the steady state, the benefit caseloads do not. As a result, the estimated poverty impacts may differ if future caseloads diverge from those assumed in the model.
The estimates do not capture the full effects of the overall package and are limited to the measures and employment effects modelled.
9. Employment support and welfare spend
This analysis is included in chapter 1 and 8 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
- in 2024/25, for every £1 that DWP spent on employment support for young people, around £25 was spent on welfare support for young people
- if expenditure on current DWP employment support is maintained at levels equivalent to those currently funded through the Youth Guarantee and the additional support recommended by the review, including the Youth Opportunity Service (YOS), is implemented then by 2036/37, for every £1 spent on employment support for young people, around £2 would be spent on welfare support for young people
These headline ratios are derived from the underlying estimates:
- in 2024/25, expenditure on DWP employment support for young people is estimated to be 3.7% of welfare expenditure on this group, equivalent to approximately £1 spent on employment support for every £25 spent on welfare after rounding
- in 2036/37, expenditure on DWP employment support for young people is estimated to be 43.3% of welfare expenditure on this group, equivalent to approximately £1 spent on employment support for every £2 spent on welfare
Data and evidence
The main evidence used in the analysis:
- internal DWP estimates of Jobcentre Plus expenditure in the financial year ending (FYE) 2025, excluding estates, digital and other corporate costs
- internal estimates of DWP employment programme expenditure in 2024/25 and 2036/37
- benefit caseload figures by age[footnote 47]
- benefit expenditure forecasts[footnote 48]
- Office for National Statistics population estimates[footnote 49]
- forecasts of the number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET), produced for the From a Welfare State to a Working State report
- forecasts of Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and Disability Living Allowance (DLA) caseloads for 16 to 24 year olds in 2036/37, produced for the Young people and work: interim report[footnote 50]
- modelling undertaken for the From a Welfare State to a Working State report to estimate the cost of the recommended employment support package in 2036/37
Methodology
For financial year ending 2025 estimates
Employment support expenditure comprises:
- expenditure on DWP-funded employment programmes in 2024/25. For programmes available to all age groups, expenditure for 16 to 24 year olds was estimated using the proportion of participants in that age group. Where participant age data were unavailable, estimates were based on the age profile of benefit claimants within the eligible population
- Jobcentre Plus expenditure on young people, estimated by allocating 10% of the nominal £1.4 billion Jobcentre Plus budget in 2024/25 (excluding estates, digital and other corporate costs)
- welfare expenditure for 16 to 24 year olds in 2024/25, comprising outturn spending on Universal Credit (UC), Employment and Support Allowance (ESA), Jobseeker’s Allowance (JSA), Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and Disability Living Allowance (DLA)
For 2036/37 estimates
Employment support expenditure comprises:
- estimated expenditure on DWP-funded employment programmes in 2028/29, including programmes captured in the 2024/25 estimate and programmes introduced subsequently, such as the Youth Guarantee and additional support recommended by the review, including the Youth Opportunity Service (YOS). For programmes available to all age groups, expenditure for 16 to 24 year olds was estimated using the expected proportion of participants in this age group. Programme expenditure is assumed to remain constant in nominal terms between 2028/29 and 2036/37
- Jobcentre Plus expenditure on young people, estimated by uprating the 2024/25 figure in line with projected population growth to 2036/37
Welfare expenditure for 16 to 24 year olds comprises:
- forecasts of PIP and DLA expenditure produced for the review
- expenditure on UC, ESA and JSA for young people in 2024/25, uprated in line with projected growth in combined UC and ESA expenditure to 2036/37
- estimated welfare savings of £3.6 billion in 2036/37, as set out in the gross costs of the recommended policy package section, were deducted from total welfare expenditure
- for both 2024/25 and 2036/37, employment support expenditure was divided by welfare expenditure to produce a percentage, which was then converted into a ratio
Key assumptions and uncertainty
- estimates of DWP expenditure on young people assume that spending is proportional to the share of participants or caseload accounted for by 16 to 24 year olds. In practice, expenditure may vary across age groups because of differences in take-up, support needs and the intensity of provision
- future spending allocations are uncertain. Funding levels in 2036/37 will be determined through future spending reviews and may differ materially from the assumptions used in this analysis
- programme expenditure in 2036/37 assumes that spending on employment support remains constant in nominal terms from 2028/29 onwards. Actual expenditure may increase or decrease over time
- new employment support programmes recommended by the review would be delivered by DWP, despite similar interventions historically being delivered by DHSC or DfE
- forecasts of welfare expenditure are subject to uncertainty and depend on future economic conditions, labour market outcomes and policy decisions
10. Increase in apprenticeship starts and achievements
This analysis is included in chapter 4 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
The apprenticeship achievement rate should rise from around 65% today to 80%. On current cohort assumptions, that would mean increasing annual under-25 starts from around 172,000 in 2024/25 to around 270,000 by 2036/37, with around 215,000 young people achieving an apprenticeship each year.
This section explains the analysis estimating the number of under-25 apprenticeship starts and completions needed each year to reach the suggested increase in achievement rate.
Definitions
Apprenticeship starts – individuals beginning apprenticeship training.
Apprenticeship achievements – individuals passing their end point assessment and achieving their apprenticeship.
Data and evidence
The main evidence used in the analysis:
- historical data on apprenticeship starts and achievements derived from the individualised learner record (ILR)
- future years impacts are estimates from modelling (internal analysis)
Methodology
Future starts are forecast using historical trends in starts and assumptions informed by the experience of previous policy interventions. Assumptions about the achievement rate are then applied to calculate the volume of achievers.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
These figures are highly uncertain because the apprenticeship programme is demand-led, meaning it is challenging to forecast impacts of policies.
11. Improved use of CAMHS workforce capacity
This analysis is included in chapter 1 and 5 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
Alongside specialist service reform, by moving to such a more preventative model, where diagnosis doesn’t gatekeep and support is made available sooner, it could release up to one quarter of existing CAMHS workforce capacity, enabling faster access to high-intensity support for children and young people with moderate to severe needs.
Data and evidence
This analysis draws on 2025/26 Mental Health Services Data Set (MHSDS) activity data, evidence on the prevalence and severity of mental health need among children and young people, and engagement with stakeholders and clinical experts.
Methodology
Estimates are developed through modelling that compared current numbers of children and young people accessing CAMHS with estimates of the population requiring specialist support under the proposed service model for ages 0 to 17. This was used to estimate the potential capacity that could be released as earlier intervention services expand and specialist services are increasingly focused on those with higher levels of need.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
This only includes NHS-funded mental health support so may exclude non-NHS funded private or Voluntary, Community, and Social Enterprise (VCSE) support and is subject to the quality of the underlying data.
The estimate is highly indicative and is sensitive to assumptions about the level of need requiring specialist care, the extent to which pathways can be streamlined, and the effectiveness, impacts and coverage of earlier intervention services. In practice, released capacity may also be used to improve access, quality and intensity of specialist care.
12. The number of young people that fall out of work due to ill health
This analysis is included in chapter 5 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
It is estimated that around 20,000 young people fall out of work due to ill health each year.
Definitions
Unemployed - people aged 16 years and over without a job, who have been actively seeking work in the past 4 weeks and are available to start work in the next 2.
Economically inactive - people aged 16 years and over without a job who have not sought work in the last 4 weeks and/or are not available to start work in the next 2 weeks.
Explanation
This analysis presents the number of young people (aged 16 to 24) in the UK not in employment, education or training, who report leaving work for health reasons in the last year based on data from 2013/14 to 2024/25.
Data and evidence
This analysis is based on data from the Annual Population Survey from 2013/14 to 2024/25. It uses a combination of a number of Labour Force Survey (LFS) variables described in detail below.
Methodology
This analysis is based on data from the Annual Population Survey from 2013/14 to 2024/25.
It uses a combination of a number of Labour Force Survey (LFS) variables to create a single ‘left work for health reasons’ variable:
- those who reported giving up work for health reasons
- those who reported resigning, but later reported it was mainly due to health reasons
- those who reported giving up work for family or personal reasons, but later reported it was mainly due to health reasons
This is then combined with LFS variables for NEET status and when the respondent left their last job. Respondents aged 16 to 24 in each financial year who are unemployed or economically inactive, and not in employment or training, and left work within the last 12 months are included.
An average is then produced across the financial years from 2013/14 to 2024/25 to produce the final ‘around 20,000’ estimate.
More information on the LFS variables can be found in the Labour Force Survey – user guidance - Office for National Statistics.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
Whilst respondents gave ill-health as the main reason for leaving work, it is not known under what circumstances they fell out of work. For example, whether this followed a period of sickness absence or receiving a ‘not fit for work’ note.
Due to small sample sizes, proportions have been calculated over an 11 year period (2013/14 to 2024/25).
APS data has not been reweighted to the latest UK population estimates.
More information on the Annual Population Survey (APS) including strengths and limitations, methods, data uses and users can be found at: Annual population survey (APS) quality and methodology information (QMI) - Office for National Statistics
This estimate is subject to potential limitations inherent in all surveys. More information can be found in the General limitations of survey-based statistics section published in The employment of disabled people: background information and methodology
Quality and methodology information for the Annual Population Survey. Includes strengths and limitations, methods, and data uses and users.
13. Workforce requirements for the proposed mental health model
This analysis is included in chapter 5 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
It is estimated that the reformed mental health model will require an estimated 4,500 staff. This is an estimate of the number of workforce required across Early Support Hubs, Mental Health Support Teams/Early Support Hubs High Intensity Therapeutics and Individual Placement and Support-Youth.
Data and evidence
The data and evidence used for this analysis came from a range of sources including evidence from stakeholders and clinical experts, policy design and published guidance from NHSE.
Methodology
This estimates additional workforce required to achieve national coverage of MHSTs HIT policies and Early Support Hubs (ESHs), scaling team level workforce requirements to national rollout.
Workforce estimates for IPS-Y came from published guidance from NHSE and stakeholder feedback. Early Support Hub (ESH) workforce estimates came from stakeholder engagement and MHST/ESH HIT came from clinical feedback. All workforce estimates were subject to policy design decisions. This was the applied to rollout of the services to estimate the total number of workforce required.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
These are highly indicative estimates, and based on a number of simplifying modelling assumptions which may not reflect actual delivery of new services. Additionally, for some policy proposals, a single service model does not exist and services are specified by local commissioners. The national estimates are based on one illustrative model being expanded.
14. Estimated savings from ADHD and autism assessment reform
This analysis is included in chapter 5 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
This analysis provides a highly indicative estimate of the potential reduction in assessment costs for autism and ADHD if the cost of NHS-funded assessments delivered by independent sector providers were brought closer to estimated NHS delivery costs through the introduction of a tariff-based approach. These costs are theoretical and should not be interpreted as an exact cost saving that could be generated in practice.
Data and evidence
This estimate was developed using a combination of published administrative data, Freedom of Information (FOI) data, published guidance and academic evidence.
Independent sector assessment costs were estimated using information published through NHS FOI requests on spending for neurodevelopmental assessments commissioned from independent providers. The primary source was FOI data published through the Neurodiversity Directory’s compilation of Integrated Care Board (ICB) responses on spending for ADHD and autism assessments.
Estimated NHS assessment costs were informed by evidence on staff involved and their time taken on assessments drawn from academic literature, publicly available FOI responses and National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidance relating to autism and ADHD assessment processes.
Workforce costs were estimated using NHS pay scales and an estimated allowance for additional employer costs.
The volume of individuals awaiting assessment was estimated using NHS waiting list data. Autism estimates were informed by open suspected autism referrals recorded in the Mental Health Services Data Set (MHSDS). ADHD estimates were informed by open referrals potentially relating to ADHD recorded in the MHSDS and Community Services Data Set (CSDS) sit rep. To create an annual assessment, the figures used were based on people who had been waiting up to a year.
Methodology
The estimate was produced by comparing indicative assessment costs for NHS-funded autism and ADHD assessments delivered by independent sector providers with estimated costs of equivalent assessments delivered directly by the NHS.
An estimated unit cost saving was calculated as the difference between these 2 costs. This estimated saving per assessment was then applied to the volume of people who had been awaiting assessment for up to a year to produce an illustrative estimate of the potential annual savings associated with bringing independent sector assessment costs closer to estimated NHS provision costs.
For autism, the calculation used the number of patients with an open suspected autism referral. For ADHD, the calculation used the number of patients with open referrals that may relate to ADHD.
The resulting figure represents an indicative annual gross saving.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
This analysis should be interpreted as indicative only.
The independent sector cost estimates are based on data from a single integrated care board for one year only and may not reflect costs, commissioning arrangements or contractual terms elsewhere in England. If provider costs differ across the country and over time, the estimated savings could be higher or lower.
The NHS cost estimates are based primarily on assumptions about workforce inputs and assessment duration. Actual assessment pathways vary across services, locations and individuals, meaning that NHS costs may differ from those estimated.
The independent sector estimates are based on total expenditure paid to providers, while the NHS estimates are principally based on workforce costs. Provider expenditure is likely to include a wider range of costs, such as administration and overheads, which may not be fully reflected in the NHS estimates.
The annual savings estimate assumes that the estimated reduction in the unit cost of assessments could be applied across current waiting list volumes. The estimate therefore depends on the accuracy of referral and waiting list data and on assumptions about the volume of future assessment activity.
The analysis assumes that a tariff could successfully reduce assessment costs to the levels estimated. Actual savings would depend on final policy design, provider responses, procurement arrangements, operational implementation and the pace of transition to any new pricing model.
In some places estimates reflect costs within child or adult services which have been used as a proxy to estimate cost across all services. If costs differ between these services the estimated savings could be higher or lower.
15. Youth Opportunity Service workforce
This analysis is included in chapter 7 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
This analysis provides an estimate of the Full-Time Equivalent (FTE) staff resource that currently delivers DWP youth-facing functions. In the report this is presented as an estimate for the number of people currently delivering services that could be brought together in the Youth Opportunity Service. This estimate uses current youth-focused employment support activity delivered through the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP). Only estimates of Jobcentre Plus (JCP) FTE have been used due to data availability, so have not included staff delivering youth facing support in other DWP commissioned or locally commissioned services.
The results represent estimated annual FTE demand across financial years 2026/27 to 2030/31 and are rounded to the nearest 500 FTE. Using this approach, youth FTE demand is estimated to range between approximately 4,500 and 5,500 FTE across the forecast period. The estimates presented in the report combines this with the FTE demand for Decision Making (DM) and Dispute Resolution Service (DRS) activities. The estimate of DM and DRS demand indicates that inclusion of these functions could increase the estimate by up to a further 500 FTE.
The figures cover Great Britain and represent estimated resource demand rather than funded staffing levels. FTE demand should therefore be interpreted as an indicative estimate of resource requirements rather than a forecast of future headcount.
Data and evidence
The analysis was completed using existing DWP demand modelling and workforce planning products produced during the Spring 2026 planning cycle. These products are used within DWP to support operational planning and resource allocation. They combine customer demand forecasts, operational assumptions and workforce planning methodologies to estimate future staffing requirements and are developed for internal purposes.
Methodology
The estimate was produced by identifying employment activities within the Spring 2026 demand forecasts directly attributable to youth. Associated management resource was then included through the application of existing organisational spans of control used within DWP workforce planning methodologies.
The estimate is based on current Jobcentre (JC) FTE demand only. Service Centre activities that may support youth, such as benefit administration and related processing activities, have not been included in the estimate.
Not all services that support youth are delivered through dedicated youth activity. A range of wider operational functions, including decision making, dispute resolution, service delivery support, employer engagement and disability employment support, support both youth and non-youth customers. To estimate the youth-related share of these activities, the proportion of total Work Coach demand attributable to youth-focused activity was calculated and applied to operational activities where a direct youth split was not available. This included National Careers Service (NCS) activity, where estimated NCS staffing was apportioned using the published demographic profile of NCS customers, with the share of customers aged 18 to 24 used as a proxy for youth-related resource requirements.
Key assumptions and uncertainty
The estimate is subject to the following assumptions and uncertainties:
-
demand forecasts: the estimates are based on Spring 2026 demand forecasts and associated planning assumptions. Future changes in labour market conditions, customer volumes, policy or operational assumptions will change estimated resource requirements
-
allocation of wider operational demand: a proportion of the estimate is derived through proportional allocation rather than direct measurement. Where dedicated youth demand lines are unavailable within the forecasting products, the analysis assumes that the share of resource attributable to youth broadly reflects the share of youth demand within other activities that can be directly attributed to supporting youth. This provides a proxy for estimating youth-related resource requirements, however actual resource requirements may differ from those derived using this approach
-
coverage of operational activity: the estimate is based on Jobcentre activities included within demand modelling products. Some services that support youth may be delivered through Service Centre functions, including benefit administration and related processing activities. These activities have not been included within the estimate
-
forecast interpretation: the figures should be interpreted as indicative estimates rather than precise forecasts of future staffing requirements. They represent estimated operational demand expressed as Full-Time Equivalent resource requirements and should not be interpreted as funded headcount or commitments to future workforce requirements. The estimates are intended to support strategic planning and discussion and to provide an evidence-based proxy for the scale of resource currently associated with youth-focused employment support
16. Historical spend on employment support schemes
This analysis is included in chapter 1 and 8 in the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
Expenditure on the Youth Guarantee is equivalent to around 17% of spending on the Youth Training Scheme (YTS) and 46% of spending on the New Deal for Young People (NDYP).
Data and evidence
This main evidence used for this analysis includes evidence and information from:
- Youth Training Scheme[footnote 51]
- The New Deal for Young People[footnote 52]
- Youth Guarantee[footnote 53]
Methodology
Expenditure on the Youth Training Scheme (YTS), published in 1981, estimated that the scheme would cost around £1 billion per year when introduced in 1983.
Expenditure on the New Deal for Young People (NDYP), published in 2002, estimated total programme costs of £3.15 billion over 5 years, equivalent to approximately £630 million per year in 1998 prices.
In the Autumn Budget 2025[footnote 54] the government announced funding of £820 million for the Youth Guarantee over the spending review period (the 3 years from 2026/27 to 2028/29). This was additional spend and did not include existing support for young people as part of the previous Youth Offer. In March 2026, the government announced an additional £1 billion of funding in employment and skills support over the spending review period.[footnote 55] Total expenditure was therefore estimated at £1.82 billion, equivalent to around £600 million per year.
Expenditure for the first 2 programmes was then converted into 2026 prices using the Bank of England inflation calculator.[footnote 56] This produced annual estimates of £3.5 billion for the YTS and £1.3 billion for the NDYP, rounded to the nearest £100 million.
Key assumptions and caveats
The programmes operated in different economic contexts: the YTS, NDYP and Youth Guarantee were introduced at different points in the economic cycle and labour market, meaning levels of youth unemployment, vacancies, economic inactivity and employer demand were not directly comparable.
Programme objectives differ: while all 3 programmes sought to improve labour market outcomes for young people, they varied in their primary aims, target groups and delivery models. Expenditure comparisons do not account for differences in policy design or intended outcomes.
Coverage and eligibility vary: the scale of each programme differed, including the age groups covered, eligibility criteria and the number of participants expected to receive support. Differences in expenditure may therefore reflect differences in programme scope rather than levels of investment per participant.
Inflation adjustments are indicative: historical expenditure has been converted to 2026 prices using the Bank of England inflation calculator. While this allows broad comparisons of spending power, it does not capture changes in the relative costs of programme delivery, wages, training provision or contracted services.
Differences in programme duration affect comparisons: expenditure figures are reported on both a total and annualised basis where possible. However, programme lengths and spending profiles varied, meaning annual averages may not reflect actual year-to-year spending patterns.
Administrative and delivery costs may be treated differently across programmes: published expenditure estimates may not include the same categories of spending, limiting the extent to which costs are directly comparable.
17. General population polling: young people and work final report
Methodology
The research was conducted by Ipsos on behalf of the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP). It explored the general population’s attitudes towards possible approaches to addressing the recent rise in the number of young people who are not in education, employment or training.
The research was based on an online survey of 2,180 UK adults aged 16 to 75, conducted between 31 July and 5 August 2026.
A full research report will be published in November 2026.
The sample was representative of UK adults aged 16 to 75. The data was weighted to the known profile of the UK adult population by:
- age
- gender
- region
- work status
- social grade
- education
Key assumptions and caveats
Results are presented as percentages. Where respondents could select more than one response, percentages may not sum to 100%.
Subgroup findings are reported where differences are statistically significant. All significance testing was undertaken at the 95% confidence level. Findings based on smaller subgroups should be interpreted with caution.
Findings
Findings from the survey can be found in chapter 2 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
In polling commissioned for the review, 50% of UK adults said young people today have fewer opportunities than previous generations. Only 23% said they have more.
Among 16 to 24 year olds, 48% pointed to fewer opportunities for part-time work or early work experience, while only 18% blamed a lack of motivation.
18. Quantitative survey of NEET and non-NEET young people aged 16 to 24
Methodology
The research was conducted by Verian on behalf of the Department for Work and Pensions. Findings are based on 1,877 online interviews with young people who were NEET and 996 online interviews with young people who were not NEET. Interviews included young people aged 16 to 24 across England and Wales.
Fieldwork was carried out between July and August 2026.
A full research report will be published in November 2026.
Findings
Findings from the survey can be found in chapters 1, 2, 4 and 6 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
Nearly 3,000 young people took part in the review’s online survey, two-thirds of whom are NEET.
Our quantitative survey found that one third of NEET respondents said they had never been in paid employment, compared with one fifth of young people in education, employment or training. Another 24% had moved in and out of paid work, compared with 18% of their peers who are not NEET. Only 14% of NEETs said they had mostly been in paid employment since leaving compulsory education. Among non-NEET respondents the figure was 46%. Yet 57% of NEET respondents had been in education at some point during the previous 2 years and 47% had been in paid work.
73% of NEET respondents said they wanted to move into employment, education or training: 42% wanted a full-time job, 16% a part-time job and 16% education or training. Among those with a preferred next step, 77% were looking for jobs, courses or opportunities and 45% were already applying or making enquiries. Only 4% said they were doing nothing to move towards what they wanted.
Most strikingly, 52% of the NEET young people that were surveyed wanted to move into paid work, education or training as soon as possible. A further 25% wanted to do so but felt their present circumstances made it too difficult. Of those who wanted to move forward, 61% said they could start now if the right opportunity became available. Another 13% thought they could start within a few months with practical help. 13% said they would need more intensive support first. 6% did not feel able to take part at the moment. That is not one cohort. It is a wide range of need hidden inside one label.
Among those NEET young people who wanted to work, lack of experience was the single biggest obstacle, cited by 53%. A further 31% said they lacked the right skills for the jobs they wanted. For young people wanting education or training, not having the required qualifications was cited by 37% and cost by 33%. Health or disability was cited by 29% and lack of information about opportunities by 27%. The problem is not simply whether a young person wants to move. It is what is standing between them and the next step.
48% of NEET respondents reported a long-term health condition, compared with 25% of non-NEET respondents. 37% said their NEET status was related to a physical or mental health condition or disability. Among NEET respondents with a long-term condition, 79% said it was one of the reasons they were currently outside work, education or training.
The issue is not simply how many young people report a health condition. It is how much that condition affects what they can do. Among NEET respondents with a long-term condition, 54% said it reduced their ability to carry out day-to-day activities a lot, compared with 22% of non-NEET respondents with a condition. Across the whole sample, around 2 in 5 NEET respondents had a long-term health condition that affected day-to-day activities, compared with around 1 in 5 of their non-NEET peers. Among the small group who did not expect to move into work, education or training now or in the future, health was by far the most common reason, cited by 73%.
Lack of work experience was the most commonly reported barrier to entering work. 39% of NEET respondents had undertaken work experience during secondary school, compared with 56% of non-NEET respondents. Even where they had done it, they were less likely to say it had helped them move towards work, education or training: 45% compared with 59%.
Just 35% of NEET respondents said school had helped them gain the qualifications they needed for the future, compared with 62% of non-NEET respondents. 29% said it had helped them develop the skills they needed, compared with 48%. Only 16% said school had prepared them to be successful at work, 14% that it had prepared them for adult life and 11% that it had helped them get a job. Among their non-NEET peers, the equivalent figures were 30%, 22% and 22%. The difference runs from attainment through to whether a young person feels ready for what comes next.
NEET respondents were less likely than their peers to say they had received help towards work, education or training from family, education providers and friends. Separately, only 4% said they could rely on a teacher or tutor when they needed support or help, compared with 21% of non-NEET respondents.
Asked what might have stopped them becoming NEET, young people did not describe exotic interventions. 39% chose more local jobs or training opportunities. 36% chose help finding work experience or placements. 31% chose more support at school or college, including mental health, SEND or pastoral support.
What strikes me is how ordinary those answers are. A job nearby. A placement. Better help at school. Someone who notices that things are beginning to go wrong. 18% of NEET respondents reported leaving school, college or training early and 21% leaving or losing a job.
Our online survey is equally clear about what young people say is missing now. 52% wanted help finding suitable jobs, courses or training. 37% wanted help building skills or experience. 28% wanted support that took account of their circumstances, including health conditions or caring responsibilities.
Only 42% of NEET respondents said they had received support from family or carers to move towards work or learning, compared with 56% of non-NEET respondents. For education providers the figures were 22% and 42%; for friends and peers, 24% and 33%.
By contrast, 28% of NEET respondents reported support from Jobcentre Plus or a work coach, compared with 8% of non-NEET respondents. 14% said they had received no support at all.
Asked who they regarded as most credible in finding solutions, 45% of NEET respondents chose young people with lived experience. Employers and business leaders came next at 19%, educators and training providers at 16% and charities and youth organisations at 11%.
Care-experienced young people are more likely to report financial problems and relationship or family breakdown, and to feel their current circumstances make moving into work education or training difficult.
For many young people, community service should be an important stepping stone to paid work but only 6% of NEET young people regularly undertake volunteering or unpaid work.
More than 7 in 10 young people who are NEET want a job or training.
19. ‘Test and Learn’ research
Methodology
These findings have been produced by Verian through a series of ‘Test and Learn’ research projects which were designed to gather rapid insight and initial feedback from young people on potential policy solutions. Research was carried out between July and August 2026.
The research was made up of 3 strands covering: apprenticeships, work experience and transition points.
A full research report will be published in November 2026.
Apprenticeships
This project explored the barriers and enablers to take up of apprenticeships, from the perspective of young people and employers.
Researchers held 4 online focus groups with young people (each lasting 90 minutes), speaking to 18 participants in total. Researchers also conducted 6 online one-to-one interviews (each lasting 60 minutes) with employers.
Work experience
This project explored whether a guidance session from a professional coach would help young people to better reflect on what they learned from their work experience placement.
Two in-person workshops lasting 3.5 hours were carried out with 23 young people aged 15 or 16 who had recently completed a work experience placement as part of their schooling. The workshops consisted of the following activities:
- pre-intervention activities: a short survey covering the outcomes above; a written submission asking them to ‘describe what you learned from doing your work experience placement (for example, any skills gained)’; and a group discussion to find out more about any support they had received from their schools around work experience.
- Intervention: A 60-minute guidance session from a professional development coach, covering reflection activities, skills employers are looking for, and the Situation, Task, Action, Result (STAR) method of communication
- post-intervention activities: a repeat of the short survey asking them about the outcomes above; a repeat of the written submission asking them to ‘describe what you learned from doing your work experience placement (for example, any skills gained)’; and one-to-one interviews to explore their experiences of the guidance session and to what extent it impacted the outcomes of interest
Transition Points
A total of 12 qualitative interviews were conducted with young people who were either classed as NEET or at risk of becoming NEET. The in-depth interviews lasted up to 90 minutes and took place online via Zoom. The interviews focused on young people’s experiences of leaving education and any support that was available to them. Interviews also contained projective exercises, which involved asking young people to imagine how different types of support, provided either at the transition point or currently, could have supported them back into education, employment or training.
Participants ranged from age 16 to 24. Those aged 16 to 17 were recruited based on key risk factors associated with becoming NEET, such as being identified as having Special Educational Needs (SEN), low educational attainment or persistent absence from school/college. Those aged 18 to 24 were recruited on the basis of not being in education, employment or training. Those aged 21 to 24 needed to have been not in education, employment or training for at least 6 months.
Key assumptions and caveats
The 3 projects followed a ‘test and learn’ approach and were exploratory rather than full-scale evaluations. The methodologies were designed to provide rapid, indicative insights into participants’ experiences and views, rather than to assess impact or provide comprehensive findings. Given the relatively small sample sizes, the findings should be interpreted with caution and should not be treated as representative of wider populations. No longitudinal follow-up was conducted to establish whether any reported changes continued beyond the research period.
Findings
Findings from the research can be found in chapters 2, 3 and 4 of the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
One said, with bleak humour: “It’s exciting when I get a rejection because it’s like oh my gosh, they actually emailed me back.”
Another young person in our qualitative research said they had received rejections months after applying for jobs they had forgotten about. Silence on that scale gives a young person nothing to learn from. It also begins to change what they expect from the next application.
In our research, young people described being NEET as demoralising and isolating. Friends had moved away for university or work while they were left at home, sometimes with little contact beyond immediate family and few ways to make new connections.
Among the 23 young people aged 15 and 16 that were interviewed, who had recently completed a placement, personal networks played a major role in finding one. Many placements came through parents or friends of parents. Young people without those connections had fewer choices. Some did work experience in primary schools simply because that was the only opportunity available. Support afterwards was often slight. Several young people said there had been little reflection on what they had learned or how to use it.
Others said they were treated “like a kid” or given easy and boring tasks that bore little resemblance to the job. Most reported little help from school afterwards beyond practical guidance. One young person said: “The school did tell you that you could learn valuable skills beforehand but there was no reflection otherwise.”
One young person told the review that school had offered one or two presentations on apprenticeships but the main focus was UCAS: “not everyone wants to go to university”. Our apprenticeship research tells a similar story. In research conducted for this Report, young people and employers both saw apprenticeships as a valuable route into work, particularly in a difficult labour market.
Conversely, one apprentice described watching friends finish university and struggle to find work while, as they put it, “I’ve kind of got in early”.
One young person had moved around 170 miles for an apprenticeship because the opportunities they wanted were concentrated in bigger cities. Others worried that apprentice pay would not cover the cost of living or relocation.
Our research heard from graduates who had done what the system asked of them, gained qualifications and still could not secure a suitable first job.
One said: “Once you leave, [the school] just cut off all connections with you.”
“If you have zero links, you cannot get a job in this day and age.”
“They did one or two presentations on apprenticeships or things like that, but their main focus was UCAS and I don’t think that’s fair, like not everyone wants to go to university”
A placement can happen but not necessarily leave the young person feeling more capable or more connected to work.
20. Voluntary Statement of Compliance with the Code of Practice for Statistics
The Code of Practice for Statistics (the Code) is built around 3 main concepts, or pillars:
- trustworthiness – is about having confidence in the people and organisations that publish statistics
- quality – is about using data and methods that produce statistics
- value – is about publishing statistics that support society’s needs
Trustworthiness
HM Government analysts work to a professional competency framework and Civil Service core values of integrity, honesty, objectivity, and impartiality. The analysis in this release has been scrutinised and quality assured in line with the Aqua Book and received sign off by a Senior Civil Service analyst.
Quality
Quality assurance has taken place in line with the standards usually applied to HM Government analysis. The analysis included in this publication uses a range of data sources. Details of the limitations of the analysis, including the data sources used, are detailed within each section.
Value
Publishing this annex ensures that the public have access to the analysis that supports and complements the From a Welfare State to a Working State report.
-
Baloch, A., (2026), ‘Closing the Youth Jobs Gap’, Impetus ↩
-
Ofsted, (2026), ‘Office for Standards in Education, Children’s Services and Skills: Annual Report and Accounts 2025–26’ ↩
-
Department of Health & Social Care, (2023), ‘Health and Care Act 2022 Impact assessments for adult social care provision’ ↩
-
Department for Education, (2026), ‘DfE monthly workforce management information: June 2026’ ↩
-
Scottish Government, (2024), ‘Education and Skills budgets 2021-2024: FOI release’ ↩
-
Jones, Sir D. (2016), ‘Written Assembly Question 71635’, Welsh Government ↩
-
What Works Network, (2022), ‘Considerations around Setting up a What Works Centre’ ↩
-
Office for National Statistics, (2026), Characteristics of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) who did not receive benefits, England ↩
-
Michael, Jed and Xu, Xiaowei, (2026), ‘Off the radar: who are NEETs not claiming benefits?’, Institute for Fiscal Studies ↩
-
Coxton, A. and others, (2026), ‘NEET Trends Analysis (2025 Q4): Characteristics of long-term and short-term NEET groups’, Youth Futures Foundations ↩
-
ONS, (2026), ‘Sociodemographic, health, and employment characteristics of young people who are NEET, England’ ↩
-
NHS England, Long term conditions and medically unexplained symptoms, Accessed 12 November 2026 ↩
-
NHS England (2025), ‘National Cost Collection for the NHS’, Accessed 12 November 2026 ↩
-
Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), (2026), ‘Economic and Fiscal Outlook – March 2026’ ↩
-
NHS England, (July 2026), ‘Fit Notes Issued by GP Practice’ ↩
-
NHS England, (July 2026), ‘Fit Notes Issued by GP Practice’ ↩
-
Office for National Statistics, (2026), ‘A01: Summary of labour market statistics’ ↩
-
Jones, K and others (2026). Unit Costs of Health and Social Care 2025, Centre for health economics ↩
-
Jones, K and others (2026). Unit Costs of Health and Social Care 2025, Centre for health economics ↩
-
Jones, K and others (2026). Unit Costs of Health and Social Care 2025, Centre for health economics ↩
-
Jones, K and others (2026), Unit Costs of Health and Social Care 2025, Centre for health economics ↩
-
NHS, ‘Social prescribing link worker’, Accessed 12 November 2026 ↩
-
NHS Employers (2026), ‘Pay scales for 2026/27’ ↩
-
Office for National Statistics, (2026), ‘Population projections’ ↩
-
Department for Education, (2026), ‘Care leavers (now 17-21 years)’ from ‘Children looked after in England including adoptions‘, Created 20 October 2026 ↩
-
Department for Education, (2026), ‘Participation in education, training and employment age 16 to 21’ ↩
-
Department for Education, (2026), ‘Post-16 education: pathways and outcomes for disadvantaged learners’ ↩
-
Office for National Statistics, (2026), ‘Earnings and employment from Pay As You Earn Real Time Information, UK’ ↩
-
Department for Work and Pensions, (2026), ‘Employer views on hiring young people survey report’ ↩
-
Department for Work and Pensions, (2026), ‘Young people and work: interim report analytical annex’ ↩
-
Office for National Statistics, (2026), Characteristics of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) who did not receive benefits, England ↩
-
Office for National Statistics, (2025), ‘Employment in the UK’ ↩
-
Department for Business and Trade, (2025), ‘Business population estimates for the UK and regions 2025: statistical release’ ↩
-
Department for Education and Department for Work and Pensions, (2026), ‘Apprenticeships’ ↩
-
Coxon, A. and Bhasin, A., (2026), ‘A persistent challenge: NEET projections for the UK to 2036 under alternative economic scenarios’, Youth Futures Foundation ↩
-
Office for National Statistics (ONS),’Population projections’ ↩
-
Department for Education, (2026), ‘Help and related information - NEET age 16 to 24 - Explore education statistics - GOV.UK’ ↩
-
Office for National Statistics, (2026), ‘Characteristics of young people not in education, employment, or training (NEET), England: March 2021’ ↩
-
‘Young people and work: interim report’, (2026) ↩
-
Office for National Statistics (2026), ‘EARN01: Average weekly earnings - Office for National Statistics’, (October 2026) ↩
-
Office for Budget Responsibility (2026), ‘Economic and fiscal outlook – March 2026 - Office for Budget Responsibility’ ↩
-
Resolution Foundation, (2026), ‘Lost in transition’, Figure 21 and accompanying analysis ↩
-
OECD, (2023), ‘OECD (2023), Education at a Glance 2023, Table B1.2’ ↩
-
Office for National Statistics, (2026), ‘Office for National Statistics (2026), 2024-based National Population Projections, principal projection for England’ ↩
-
Department for Work and Pensions, ‘Stat-Xplore - Log in’ ↩
-
Department for Work and Pensions, (2026), ‘Benefit expenditure and caseload tables - GOV.UK’ ↩
-
Office for National Statistics, (2025), ‘Population estimates for England and Wales - Office for National Statistics’ ↩
-
Department of Employment, (1981), ‘A New Training Initiative - A programme for action (1981)’ ↩
-
Comptroller and Auditor General, (2002), ‘The New Deal for Young People’ ↩
-
House of Commons Library, (2026), ‘Youth Guarantee - House of Commons Library’ ↩
-
HM Treasury, (2025), ‘Budget 2025’ ↩
-
Department for Work and Pensions (2026), ‘Major employment drive to help unlock 200,000 new jobs and apprenticeships for next generation’ ↩
-
Bank of England, ‘Inflation calculator’ ↩