Part 4: Impact assessments
Published 12 November 2026
Applies to England
Equality impact assessment
As Ofqual is a public body, we must comply with the public sector equality duty in section 149(1) of the Equality Act 2010. In developing these proposals, we have considered the likely impact on persons who share particular protected characteristics.
The proposals for Subject Level Conditions (SLCs) are based on the Department for Education’s (DfE’s) proposed subject content. DfE is responsible for setting subject content for V Levels, and for considering whether the proposed content could have an impact on students with particular characteristics. Ofqual is responsible for assessment of the subject content and has a role in advising on the potential implications for assessment arising from proposed content. For Ofqual to adopt DfE’s subject content into its regulatory framework, it must be satisfied that any equality impacts have been sufficiently identified and mitigated. We consider whether the proposed content will allow us to regulate for effective assessments to be developed, and we base our proposals for assessment of each subject on the subject content, and in the context of the V Levels rules that have already been set.
This assessment considers the potential equality impacts – positive and negative – arising from our proposed Subject Level Conditions, both for students who share particular protected characteristics and for those who may be affected due to other factors such as socio-economic background. We welcome views on the impacts identified, suggestions for mitigation, and any additional impacts not identified.
Subject content and assessment objectives
We propose to require awarding organisations to develop assessments that cover the nationally set subject content as specified by DfE. Subject content is a matter for DfE, and DfE will conduct its own equality impact assessment on its draft content. As our subject-level proposals reflect DfE’s policy intention, we consider that they will have no identifiable equality impact.
We also propose to set subject-specific assessment objectives and associated guidance for each V Level subject, the wording of which is set out within this consultation. This will help to ensure that assessments developed by awarding organisations against nationally set subject content are designed in a comparable way and support the setting and maintenance of standards. Overall, this should have a positive impact on all students, as it will support consistency across awarding organisations.
Assessment methods
We propose that the new qualifications will include a balance of assessment methods. By specifying a balance of assessment methods, students will not be wholly assessed by either Assessment by Examination (AbE) marked by the awarding organisation or by Non-exam Assessments (NEA) marked by the centre or the awarding organisation. This will have a positive impact on all students as they will have the opportunity to demonstrate what they know, understand and can do in more than one type of assessment.
Our regulations will ensure consistency across awarding organisations so that V Levels in the same subject will have the same proportion of Assessment by Examination and Non-exam Assessment. This will ensure that they have a consistent experience of assessment regardless which awarding organisation’s qualification they take within a subject.
It is important to note that Assessment by Examination does not have to be in the form of a written test or written examination and awarding organisations may develop other forms of assessment that meet our requirements. Regardless of assessment method, disabled students will be entitled to reasonable adjustments, as they would be with any regulated qualifications.
Terminal assessment
We propose to put in place a terminal assessment requirement, whereby a proportion of the overall assessment for the qualification must be taken in the final series of the 2-year course. This must take the form of Assessment by Examination, set and marked by the awarding organisation. The proportion for each subject is set out within this consultation. This means that a significant proportion of assessment will take place at the end of the course. While this could increase exam anxiety for some students, it will support standard setting in the overall qualification. Effective standard setting will increase fairness for all students as grading will be more consistent across awarding organisations.
The impact of requiring terminal assessment is mitigated as it allows more time for teaching and learning, helping to ensure students are well prepared for the assessment, while also reducing the amount of assessment throughout the course. As a proportion of the assessment is likely to take place in the first year of study, and a compensatory approach to marking will be used, students’ overall grades will not be entirely reliant on their performance at the end of the qualification.
Assessment availability
Ofqual’s Qualification Level Conditions (QLCs) for V Levels require that the new qualifications have a modular assessment structure, with assessments available at appropriate points throughout the programme of study. Modular assessment approaches can support learner motivation and engagement, and mastery learning. There is some evidence that modular assessment designs can support some groups of learners to maintain a consistent level of engagement and performance where this might otherwise be more variable.[footnote 1]
The opportunity to retake assessments in modular qualifications can be viewed negatively as leading to grade inflation or more positively as allowing students, particularly those who are disadvantaged, to attain more highly than they otherwise could.
We have not proposed restricting opportunities to retake assessments, although the availability of assessments will naturally limit the number of opportunities to retake assessments. We think this is proportionate as it will allow some opportunity to retake assessments but will prevent students from repeatedly retaking assessments, which would have an impact on time available for teaching and learning. Overall, we think this approach would have a positive impact.
On-screen assessment
In relation to on-screen assessment, the anticipated equality impacts were set out in more detail in the equality impact assessment for the consultation Regulating on-screen assessment published in December 2025.
The guiding principles consulted on in December have informed our approach to the use of on-screen assessment in Assessment by Examination in V Levels. They set out expectations for fairness and accessibility, including that on‑screen assessment should maintain, and wherever possible enhance, accessibility for students with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND). In practice, the accessibility impacts of on‑screen assessment may vary depending on individual needs and assessment design, and our proposals therefore seek to support accessibility, including for those students with SEND who may benefit from an on‑screen mode of assessment.
The availability of on‑screen assessment as a reasonable adjustment will not be restricted where it is necessary and appropriate to meet the specific accessibility needs of disabled students.
Question 18
Are there any other potential equality impacts (positive or negative) on students who share a particular protected characteristic or are from a lower socio-economic background arising from our proposals, either individually or in combination? Where possible, please separate your answer by protected characteristic.
Question 19
Are there any additional steps that Ofqual could take to mitigate any potential negative impacts resulting from the proposals, either individually or in combination, on students who share a particular protected characteristic or are from a lower socioeconomic background?
Regulatory impact assessment
Introduction
Ofqual has a duty under the Apprenticeship, Skills, Children and Learning Act 2009 to avoid introducing or maintaining unnecessary regulatory burden. We have considered the potential costs and benefits associated with the proposals set out in this consultation.
This consultation relates to Subject Level Conditions (SLCs), requirements and guidance proposed for tranche 2 V Level subjects due to be first taught from September 2028.
The introduction of V Levels and the content to be taught within them are matters for the Department for Education (DfE). Our proposals relate only to the regulatory arrangements that will apply to qualifications developed against that content. The impacts assessed below therefore focus on the consequences of Ofqual’s proposed regulatory requirements rather than on DfE’s broader policy decisions.
The baseline assumes that awarding organisations developing tranche 2 V Levels are regulated through Ofqual’s General Conditions of Recognition and Qualification Level Conditions (QLCs) for V Levels.
Impacts on awarding organisations
Benefits
The proposed SLCs provide awarding organisations with greater clarity regarding regulatory expectations when developing qualifications.
By specifying common SLCs, requirements and guidance, Ofqual is seeking to secure consistency and comparability across qualifications offered by different awarding organisations within a subject. This may also support more efficient qualification design and regulatory review processes by providing clarity on Ofqual’s requirements.
Costs
Awarding organisations will incur familiarisation costs in reviewing the proposed SLCs, requirements and guidance and considering the implications for qualification design and delivery. These costs are expected to be one-off and relatively limited, as the V Level QLCs have already been published and the proposed approach for the SLCs closely aligns with that adopted for tranche 1 V Level subjects.
Awarding organisations developing qualifications in the relevant subjects may incur qualification development costs associated with:
- designing assessments that comply with specified assessment objectives and weightings
- meeting prescribed assessment method balances
- meeting terminal assessment requirements
- preparing evidence to demonstrate compliance as part of accreditation.
The proposals may also reduce flexibility in qualification design relative to a position without subject-level requirements. This could restrict the ability of awarding organisations to choose different approaches to qualification design that could have been more cost effective to design and deliver.
Overall, we anticipate the costs to awarding organisations will be minor to moderate in magnitude and largely one-off, arising primarily during qualification development, accreditation and implementation.
Impacts on learners, centres and users of qualifications
Benefits
The proposals should help ensure greater consistency in assessment arrangements across awarding organisations offering qualifications in the same subject.
By specifying common assessment objectives and assessment requirements within individual subjects, the proposals should support comparability of assessment and help ensure that qualification outcomes are interpreted consistently by learners, centres, employers and higher education providers. The proposed SLCs, requirements and guidance are also expected to support more consistent and robust qualification development across awarding organisations by setting clear expectations regarding assessment design and approaches to standard setting. This should provide greater assurance that accredited qualifications meet an appropriate and consistent standard of quality. In turn, this may increase confidence amongst learners, centres, employers and higher education providers that qualification outcomes provide a reliable indication of knowledge, understanding and skills.
The proposed requirements relating to assessment design and terminal assessment may contribute to the reliability and consistency of qualification outcomes over time. This should support public confidence that grades awarded in the same subject represent comparable levels of attainment regardless of awarding organisation. This, as above, may increase confidence amongst learners, centres, employers and higher education providers on what the qualification demonstrates. Greater confidence in qualification outcomes may, in turn, strengthen the currency and value of V Levels as qualifications that can be relied upon to inform progression and recruitment decisions.
More consistent qualification outcomes may provide clearer signals of learners’ knowledge, understanding and skills, supporting progression to further study, higher technical education, apprenticeships and employment. Conversely, employers and higher education providers benefit from the use of V Levels as a reliable representation of a learner’s skills and knowledge.
Overall, we anticipate the benefits to learners, centres and users of qualifications will be moderate in magnitude and ongoing, reflecting improved comparability, reliability and confidence in qualification outcomes over time.
Costs
Centres may incur limited familiarisation costs when planning delivery and assessment arrangements for the new qualifications.
The proposed requirements may reduce flexibility for centres by requiring more consistent assessment arrangements across awarding organisations, which could limit alternative approaches to course delivery and assessment scheduling.
There may also be transition costs associated with the introduction of new qualifications and assessment arrangements. These costs are expected to arise primarily from the wider qualification reforms and introduction of V Levels, rather than from the specific regulatory proposals consulted on here. However, certain aspects of the proposed assessment arrangements, such as requirements relating to assessment methods and terminal assessment, could result in limited additional costs for centres relating to timetabling, staffing, logistics or uploading of learner evidence.
Overall, we anticipate the costs to learners and centres will be low in magnitude and primarily transitional, associated with familiarisation and adaptation to new assessment arrangements.
Impact of on-screen assessment
In our consultation Regulating on-screen assessment for GCSEs, AS and A levels, we set out our view of the impacts on awarding organisations, centres and students. We intend to apply the same guiding principles for the use of on-screen assessment in V Levels.
Our approach to regulating on-screen assessment is intended to manage risks to standards, fairness and public confidence and ensure secure and reliable delivery, whilst allowing awarding organisations to use on-screen assessment where appropriate and where risks can be effectively mitigated.
Allowing on-screen assessment in Assessment by Examination may provide awarding organisations with greater flexibility in assessment delivery. In some cases, this could reduce delivery costs where on-screen assessment is less costly than paper-based assessment and allow fixed technological costs to be spread across a larger number of assessments. This may help to reduce unit costs and mitigate fee increases compared to a baseline where additional restrictions on on-screen assessment are imposed. If Ofqual was to decide that offering a choice of on-screen assessment and paper-based assessments did not require different specifications or substantially different assessment materials, then awarding organisations may not incur additional development costs.
Potential negative impacts for awarding organisations include the costs of developing and maintaining on-screen assessment systems, managing risks associated with technical failures or cyber incidents. The extent of these impacts is likely to vary depending on how widely on-screen assessment is adopted and the arrangements put in place to manage delivery risks.
While we recognise that the evidence on the benefits of on-screen assessment is limited, allowing on-screen assessment in Assessment by Examination could have positive impacts for learners and centres. They may benefit from greater flexibility in assessment delivery and, where appropriate, from assessments that reflect the digital environments in which learning and work increasingly take place. On-screen assessment may also provide benefits for some learners where digital delivery supports accessibility, familiarisation, or the effective use of assistive technologies.
Centres offering on-screen assessment may face costs associated with providing suitable devices, staff training, student familiarisation, testing systems and processes, and with establishing arrangements to support secure delivery. Impacts may be greater for centres with more limited digital infrastructure or less experience of delivering assessments on screen. Learners may also face challenges where familiarity with digital assessment environments varies between centres. However, our proposals are intended to support a consistent, secure and reliable assessment experience and to maintain public confidence in qualification outcomes.
Growth duty
In developing these proposals, we have considered the desirability of promoting economic growth.
The proposals seek to support reliable and comparable qualification outcomes across awarding organisations. Greater consistency in qualification design and assessment should help ensure that qualifications provide trusted signals of learners’ knowledge, understanding and skills.
V Levels may also support innovation in qualification design and assessment delivery if, where appropriate, awarding organisations make use of on-screen assessment within a clear regulatory framework. This approach could facilitate the adoption of assessment methods that reflect the digital environments in which learners increasingly study and work, while maintaining confidence in standards, fairness and reliability.
Over time, increased confidence in qualification outcomes may support progression into further study, apprenticeships and employment by helping users of qualifications understand what successful achievement represents. The proposals are therefore expected to support the effective operation of the qualifications system while imposing only limited additional burden beyond that required to achieve Ofqual’s regulatory objectives.
Question 20
Are there any impacts of these proposals (individually or combined) that we have not identified? Please outline any additional costs or benefits that you foresee.
Question 21
For all identified impacts (including any additional ones identified), what do you expect their scale to be? This could include the activities required, the level of resource commitment, financial outlay, or the nature and value of any benefits.
Question 22
Do you have any suggestions for reducing or mitigating the costs associated with these proposals?
Innovation
Ofqual has a statutory duty to have regard to the desirability of facilitating innovation in relation to regulated qualifications.
The priority given to consistency and comparability for V Levels means that the proposals may place some constraints on innovation by requiring compliance with Department for Education (DfE) set subject content, common assessment objectives, specifying the same proportion of assessment methods across awarding organisations and terminal assessment requirements. These requirements may limit the extent to which awarding organisations can adopt markedly different approaches to qualification and assessment design within a subject, but this is line with Ofqual’s policy intention to ensure consistency and comparability.
However, awarding organisations will have some flexibility in qualification design, coverage of the subject content and design of assessment instruments as these are not prescribed within the regulatory framework. We therefore consider that the proposals strike an appropriate balance between supporting innovation and securing consistency, comparability and standards.
Question 23
Do you have any comments on the impact of the proposals on innovation by awarding organisations?
-
Baird et al. (2019), Examination Reform: Impact of Linear and Modular Examinations at GCSE, Ofqual. ↩