Analysing change across all indicators
Updated 17 November 2026
Applies to England
Key messages
- The England Biodiversity Indicators bring together a wide range of measures to track the state of nature and how it is changing over time. They include indicators of pressures on biodiversity, the condition of species or habitats and society’s response to biodiversity’s decline.
- There are some indicators which show a positive picture for biodiversity, for instance, the area of habitats exposed to damaging levels of acidity from air pollution has fallen over both the short and long term.
- However, many indicators show a deterioration or are not changing.
- Although one measure shows that one aspect of the many pressures on biodiversity is reducing across England (damaging levels of acidity from air pollution), the UK Biodiversity Indicators show there are other pressures which are still posing a threat to biodiversity (such as pressure from invasive species).
- The quality of biodiversity (the condition and quantity of habitats and species) in general is in decline over the long term, and much of it is still declining over the short term too. In general, habitat indicators have fared better than species indicators.
- The England Biodiversity Indicators includes only three indicators which relate to aspects of society’s response to nature’s decline. Expenditure on biodiversity and volunteer time in conservation have both increased over time. This indicates that society has been increasing efforts to combat nature’s decline.
- It is known that ecological lags mean that species and habitats will take time to respond to conservation efforts.
The England Biodiversity Indicators bring together a wide range of measures to track the state of nature and how it is changing over time. They cover wildlife species, habitats and ecosystems, the pressures they face, the actions being taken to conserve and restore them, and the benefits that nature provides to society.
There are 35 individual measures that make up 17 indicators. Of those 35 measures, some are unsuitable for a formal assessment of change (for instance they may have insufficient data or are in development). In 2026, 22 are suitable for assessment.
Over the long term, of the 35 measures:
- 7 measures (20%) show an improvement
- 4 measures (11%) show little or no overall change
- 11 measures (31%) show a deterioration
There are insufficient data to make long-term assessments for 3 measures (9%), and 10 measures (29%) are not assessed.
Over the short term, of the 35 measures:
- 4 measures (11%) show an improvement
- 6 measures (17%) show little or no overall change
- 12 measures (34%) show a deterioration
There are insufficient data to make short-term assessments for 3 measures (9%), and 10 measures (29%) are not assessed.
Figure 1 shows how an assessment of how an indicator is changing over time depends on the time frame being considered. For instance, some indicators have shown improvement since the beginning of their time series but improvement has stalled and they have not changed more recently (the dark blue indicators on the left, moving to be teal on the right).
Figure 1: A summary of long-term and short-term indicator assessments, 2026
Notes about Figure 1
- Figure 1 shows how the analysis of whether an indicator has changed varies depending on the time frame assessed. Left hand bars represent the long term change, while right hand bars represent the short term change. The relationships between long term and short term results are highlighted in the shaded flows.
- Some indicators don’t have enough data to perform a long term (10 years or more of data) or a short term (5 years of data) analysis of change, and so are categorised as “insufficient data”. Others might still be in development or be otherwise inappropriate for an analysis of change and are classed as “not assessed”.
- Due to rounding, percentages may not sum to 100%
Analysis of change using a Natural Capital Framework
Natural capital is defined as the elements of the environment which provide valuable goods and services to people such as clean air, clean water, food, and recreation. A natural capital approach accounts for all the different ways the environment benefits society and so can inform better decision making. A natural capital framework sets out the need to:
- reduce pressures on natural capital (for example, pollution or plant disease)
- improve the state of natural assets (including air, water, land and seas)
- increase the benefits that we get from those assets
- respond to declines in biodiversity through societal change (for instance, through increased spending on conservation or reduced habitat destruction)
The Biodiversity Indicators can be considered as either a measure of (a) the quantity or quality (i.e. state) of natural capital assets, (b) pressures on natural capital assets, (c) the benefits associated with natural capital assets, or (d) society’s response to biodiversity loss (Figure 2). This classification is not always straightforward since the condition of one natural capital asset (for example, water quality) may place a pressure on another (for example, wildlife habitat).
Figure 2: Diagram showing the Pressure, State, Benefit and Response categories used in the Biodiversity Indicators, and theoretical interactions between those.
Lags are present in several of the flows between pressures, state, benefits and responses. Species and habitats can be slow to respond to improving conditions, such as reduced pollution or targeted conservation actions; these delayed responses are often referred to as ecological or conservation time lags (Kuussaari et al., 2009; Watts et al., 2020). Even when species and habitats begin to recover, there may be a further delay before improvements are sufficient to affect the benefits and ecosystem services that people receive from biodiversity (Watts et al., 2020). Society can be slow to respond to a decline in nature (Hocherman, Trop & Ghermandi, 2025), and society’s efforts to reduce pressures or improve the state of nature can be slow to have an impact (e.g. Murphy et al., 2014).
Figure 3 summarises the results for all measures across these categories.
Figure 3: Long-term and short-term change indicator assessments arranged by Natural Capital Framework Status category, all 35 measures, 2026
Notes about Figure 3
- Based on 35 measures, which make up 17 indicators.
- Some indicators don’t have enough data to perform a long term (10 years or more of data) or a short term (5 years of data) assessment of change, and so are categorised as “insufficient data”. Others might still be in development or be otherwise inappropriate for an assessment of change and are classed as “not assessed”.
Tables 1 to 4 at the bottom of this page show the assessment results of all the measures when separated into “pressure”, “state”, “benefit” and “response” categories of the Natural Capital Framework.
Analysis of change in pressures on natural capital assets
The England Biodiversity Indicators include 2 indicators made up of 3 measures which relate to the pressures on biodiversity. Of these, 2 measures have sufficient data for an analysis of change in either the long or short term (see Table 1 for full results).
Pressures are the human actions or environmental change which harms biodiversity, such as pollution or habitat destruction.
Over the long term, 1 measure is improving, none are deteriorating and 1 remains stable. In the short term, 1 is improving and 1 is stable. These indicators measure two different aspects of pressure from air pollution.
Analysis of change in quantity or quality (state) of natural capital assets
The England Biodiversity Indicators include 12 indicators made up of 29 measures which relate to the quantity or quality of biodiversity. Of these, 18 measures have sufficient data for an assessment of change in either the long or short term (see Tables 2 and 3 for full results).
Most of the England Biodiversity Indicators reflect change in the quantity or quality of species or habitats, which can be thought of as natural capital assets.
In general, habitat indicators have fared better than species indicators, over the long term, more habitat measures have improved (2) or remained stable (1) than deteriorated (0). In contrast, also over the long term, many more species measures have deteriorated (11) than remained stable (2) or improved (2).
The indicator of the extent of protected areas at sea has improved in the long term, and has continued to do so in the short term. This is the only state indicator to show continued improvement over the long and short term.
There are some signs of positive change across the indicators of the quantity or quality of biodiversity. Of those 11 species indicator measures which have been deteriorating in the long term, 1 has stabilised in the short term, suggesting a possible halting of the historical declines for this indicator. This indicator reflects change in the abundance of farmland specialist butterflies.
There are also some less positive trends in the indicators this year. Of those 2 habitat and 2 species indicator measures which have been improving over the long term, 3 have shown no change over the short term, suggesting that historical improvements in the assets these indicators measure might have slowed down or stalled more recently. These indicators reflect changes in populations of wintering waterbirds and bats, and extent of protected areas on land.
Of those 11 species indicator measures which have been deteriorating over the long term, 10 are also deteriorating over the short term, suggesting that we are yet to halt the declines in the species these indicators measure. These indicators mainly reflect change in several different breakdowns of bird and butterfly abundance, as well as species more widely through the all-species and priority species abundance indicators.
Analysis of change in the benefits associated with natural capital assets
The England Biodiversity Indicators currently do not include any indicators which relate to the benefits associated with natural capital assets. This is a known gap in the England Biodiversity Indicators suite which the production team are working to fill.
Benefits are the ways in which biodiversity supports people, such as clean air or water, or food production.
Analysis of change in society’s response to biodiversity loss
The England Biodiversity Indicators include 3 indicators made up of 3 measures which relate to society’s response to nature’s decline. Of these, 2 have sufficient data for an assessment of change in either the long or short term (see Table 4 for full results).
Responses are the choices and actions society takes to improve biodiversity, and these apply to both individuals and organisations. This can include restoring habitats, farming in an environmentally sensitive way or volunteering for a conservation charity.
Both indicators which relate to society’s response to nature show an improving trend, which indicates that society has been increasing efforts to combat nature’s decline. These indicators relate to measures of expenditure on biodiversity and volunteer time in conservation.
Assessment methods
Each indicator is composed of one or more measures which will show trends over time. Many indicators have only a single measure, but some have more than one measure. Each measure is analysed separately and assigned to one of four categories.The four categories are:
- Improving
- Little or no overall change
- Deteriorating
- Insufficient or no comparable data
These categories communicate how the measures are changing over time. They do not show whether the measure has reached any published or implied targets, or indeed whether the status is ‘good’ or ‘bad’, although where targets have been set, these are identified in the indicator commentary.
A result of ‘Improving’ or ‘Deteriorating’ is assigned only when there is sufficient confidence that the change is statistically significant and not simply a product of random fluctuations. When there is insufficient confidence the ‘Little or no overall change’ result is selected.
The change categories are determined by identifying the period over which the change is to be assessed and comparing the value of the measure in the base or start year with the value in the end year. Where possible, the assessment has been made by evaluating trends using statistical analysis techniques. The assessment may be made by Defra statisticians in collaboration with the data providers, or undertaken by the data providers themselves.
For some indicators, it is not possible to formally determine statistical significance and in such cases the assessment has been made by comparing the difference between the value of the measure at the beginning of the time period and the value in the most recent year against a ‘rule of thumb’ threshold. Where the data allow it, a 3-year average is used to calculate the starting value; this reduces the likelihood of any unusual years unduly influencing the assessment. Usually, the starting value is calculated from an average of the first three years of data for the long term assessment, or the three years centred around the beginning of the short term time period for the short term assessment. The standard threshold used is 3%, unless noted otherwise.
Where an indicator value has changed by less than the threshold of 3%, the ‘Little or no overall change’ result is used. The choice of 3% as the threshold is arbitrary but is used across other government indicators and is deemed to be a suitable proxy for meaningful change. The use of this approach is kept under review.
Where there is insufficient data to analyse change, for example, when the time series is too short, or where there is no data available to compare, this is indicated by the ‘Insufficient data’ category. It is inappropriate to analyse change for some indicators, for those that are undergoing methodological development, such as Official Statistics in Development, where results are likely to change from year to year due to those developments. For others evolving data collection methods make comparisons over time inappropriate. These indicators are not assessed.
The change results only reflect the overall change in the measure from the starting value to latest year and do not reflect fluctuations during the intervening years.
Where sufficient data are available, 2 time periods have been used:
- Long term – an analysis of change since the earliest date for which data are available, although if the time series is less than 10 years a long-term analysis is not made.
- Short term – an analysis of change over the most recent 5 years. In some indicators which are particularly variable 10 years of data are used (for instance, the indicators of change in abundance of butterfly species).
For both long-term and short-term analyses of change, the time periods over which the analysis is undertaken are stated in the relevant table and/or accompanying notes.
Where the data allow, some indicators also have a third marker showing the direction of change in the latest year. This period is too short to make any meaningful analysis of change. However, when the change exceeds a 1% threshold, the direction is given simply as an acknowledgement of very recent trends and as a possible early indication of emerging trends. This is not done for indicators which are too variable from year to year or where it might otherwise be deemed statistically inappropriate.
Assessment results tables
Table 1. Analysis of change in pressures on natural capital assets
| Indicator | Measure | Long term period | Long term | Short term period | Short term |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pressure from air pollution | Air pollution: area affected by acidity | 2003 to 2023 | Improving | 2018 to 2023 | Improving |
| Pressure from air pollution | Air pollution: area affected by nutrient nitrogen deposition | 2003 to 2023 | Little or no overall change | 2018 to 2023 | Little or no overall change |
| Spring index | Timing of biological events: Spring Index | Not assessed | Not assessed |
Table 2. Analysis of change in quantity or quality (state) of natural capital assets - species
| Indicator | Measure | Long term period | Long term | Short term period | Short term |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abundance of wild birds | All breeding birds | 1970 to 2025 | Deteriorating | 2020 to 2025 | Deteriorating |
| Abundance of wild birds | Breeding farmland birds | 1970 to 2025 | Deteriorating | 2020 to 2025 | Deteriorating |
| Abundance of wild birds | Breeding woodland birds | 1970 to 2025 | Deteriorating | 2020 to 2025 | Deteriorating |
| Abundance of wild birds | Breeding water and wetland birds | 1975 to 2025 | Deteriorating | 2020 to 2025 | Deteriorating |
| Abundance of wild birds | Breeding seabirds | 1986 to 2025 | Little or no overall change | 2020 to 2025 | Deteriorating |
| Abundance of wild birds | Wintering waterbirds | 1975/76 to 2024/25 | Improving | 2020/21 to 2024/25 | Little or no overall change |
| Abundance of wild birds | Breeding upland birds | 1994 to 2025 | Deteriorating | 2020 to 2025 | Deteriorating |
| Abundance of butterflies | All-species of butterfly | 1976 to 2025 | Deteriorating | 2015 to 2025 | Deteriorating |
| Abundance of butterflies | Habitat specialist butterflies | 1976 to 2025 | Deteriorating | 2015 to 2025 | Deteriorating |
| Abundance of butterflies | Generalist butterflies | 1976 to 2025 | Little or no overall change | 2015 to 2025 | Little or no overall change |
| Abundance of butterflies | Farmland specialist butterflies | 1990 to 2025 | Deteriorating | 2015 to 2025 | Little or no overall change |
| Abundance of butterflies | Woodland specialist butterflies | 1990 to 2025 | Deteriorating | 2015 to 2025 | Deteriorating |
| Abundance of bats | Bat populations | 1999 to 2024 | Improving | 2019 to 2024 | Little or no overall change |
| Abundance of plants | Arable field margins | Not assessed | Not assessed | ||
| Abundance of plants | Bog and wet heath | Not assessed | Not assessed | ||
| Abundance of plants | Broadleaved woodland and hedges | Not assessed | Not assessed | ||
| Abundance of plants | Lowland grassland | Not assessed | Not assessed | ||
| Abundance of all-species | Relative abundance of all-species | 1970 to 2024 | Deteriorating | 2019 to 2024 | Deteriorating |
| Distribution of all-species | Distribution of all-species | Not assessed | Not assessed | ||
| Distribution of priority species | Distribution of priority species | Not assessed | Not assessed | ||
| Abundance of priority species | Relative abundance of priority species | 1970 to 2024 | Deteriorating | 2019 to 2024 | Deteriorating |
Table 3. Analysis of change in quantity or quality (state) of natural capital assets - habitats
| Indicator | Measure | Long term period | Long term | Short term period | Short term |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Area of land in agri-environment schemes | Area of land in biodiversity-positive agri-environment schemes | Not assessed | Not assessed | ||
| Area and condition of priority habitats | Extent of priority habitats | Not assessed | Not assessed | ||
| Area and condition of priority habitats | Condition of priority habitats | 2015 to 2026 | Insufficient data | 2021 to 2026 | Insufficient data |
| Area and condition of protected areas | Extent of protected areas on land | 2005 to 2025 | Improving | 2020 to 2025 | Little or no overall change |
| Area and condition of protected areas | Extent of protected areas at sea | 2005 to 2025 | Improving | 2020 to 2025 | Improving |
| Area and condition of protected areas | Condition of Sites of Special Scientific Interest | 2016 to 2026 | Insufficient data | 2021 to 2026 | Insufficient data |
| Area and condition of protected areas | Percentage of marine protected sites in effective management | 2025 | Insufficient data | 2025 | Insufficient data |
| Local sites under positive conservation management | Percentage of local sites under positive conservation management | 2008/9 to 2024/25 | Little or no overall change | 2019/20 to 2024/25 | Deteriorating |
Table 4. Analysis of change in the response to nature’s decline
| Indicator | Measure | Long term period | Long term | Short term period | Short term |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Expenditure on biodiversity | Public sector expenditure on biodiversity | 2000/2001 to 2024/2025 | Improving | 2019/2020 to 2024/2025 | Improving |
| Volunteer time in conservation | Conservation volunteering | 2000 to 2024 | Improving | 2019 to 2024 | Improving |
| Habitat creation and restoration | Habitat creation and restoration | Not assessed | Not assessed |