Skip to main content
Research and analysis

Work aspirations and support needs of young NEET health and disability customers: qualitative research

Published 17 November 2026

DWP research report no. 1151

A report of research carried out by the National Centre for Social Research on behalf of the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP).

Views expressed in this report are not necessarily those of the Department for Work and Pensions or any other government department.

Crown copyright 2026. 

You may re-use this information (not including logos) free of charge in any format or medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence. To view this licence, visit the Open Government Licence on the National Archives website.

or write to:

Information Policy Team
The National Archives
Kew
London
TW9 4DU

Or email psi@nationalarchives.gov.uk.

This document/publication is also available on our website  

If you would like to know more about DWP research, email socialresearch@dwp.gov.uk

First published October 2026.

ISBN 978-1-80786-054-7

Acknowledgements

The research team would like to thank all participants for sharing their time and experiences with us. We would like to thank Sonia Shirvington and her team of telephone interviewers for making the many phone calls that were required to recruit participants for this research. Christopher Farrell and Eliska Holland contributed to conducting the interviews. We would also like to thank Princess Akin-Olugbade, Andrew Stocks and Laura Parkhouse at DWP for their ongoing support.

Author details

This report was produced by the Policy Research Centre at the National Centre for Social Research (NatCen). The authors were Abigail Rennick, Sarah Sharrock and Bernard Steen.

Executive summary

Background

This study explores the experiences, aspirations and support needs of young people aged 18 to 24 who are not in education, employment or training (NEET) and are in receipt of health and disability-related benefits. It builds on a previous Department for Work and Pensions study, Work Aspirations and Support Needs of Health and Disability Customers (DWP, 2025).

Rates of young people who are NEET and in receipt of health and disability benefits have increased in recent years, creating a growing challenge for the labour market and the welfare system (see Young people not in education, employment or training (ONS, 2026)). While previous research has explored the experiences of health and disability benefit customers more broadly, less is known about the pathways through which disabled young people become and remain NEET, and their hopes and aspirations for the future.

This research provides a detailed understanding of young people’s experiences of education, training and work, their journey into NEET status, and the barriers they face in moving closer to participation. It also explores the types of support that could help them make progress towards education, training and work, as well as their broader life aspirations.

Methodology

This study is based on in-depth qualitative interviews with 40 young people or their appointees (typically, family members who manage a young person’s benefits on their behalf). All young people were aged between 18 and 24 and were NEET at the time of interview. They were also in receipt of at least one health and disability benefit, including:

  • Personal Independence Payment (PIP)
  • New Style Employment and Support Allowance (NS ESA)
  • the health component of Universal Credit (UC)

Most (33/40) were in receipt of PIP and UC; a full breakdown is in Appendix A.

Due to the nature of the sample that was used to recruit participants for this study, the achieved sample does have some biases: there are no young people aged 18 to 19; it does not include young people who became NEET, or started claiming benefits, relatively recently; and it includes a high proportion of participants who had multiple or complex health needs. This means the study mainly represents the views and experiences of young NEETs who have quite high barriers to education, employment or training.

Interviews were conducted online or by telephone between January and April 2026. Adaptations were made to support accessibility where needed. Data collected during interviews were analysed using the Framework approach to identify patterns across participants’ experiences, in line with the study research questions. As a qualitative study, the findings illustrate the range and diversity of views and experiences rather than their prevalence.

We use the term ‘customer’ when referring to the wider health and disability benefit population, or when distinguishing between the customer and the appointee (for example, in quote labels). Otherwise, we use the term ‘participant’, to reflect that findings are drawn from qualitative interviews with a specific group of individuals rather than being fully representative of the wider customer population.

Key findings

Participants described broad life aspirations that shaped their views on work, education and training

They emphasised wanting purpose, social connection, independence, stability, and financial security. These aspirations manifested in various forms, including a stabilisation of health conditions, an increased sense of belonging in their community, the ability to support themselves and their family, and for those furthest from work, achieving a sense of wellbeing and safety.

Many wanted to work, study, or train and had clear aspirations, grounded in their broader life goals

Some participants made decisions about educational and vocational courses aligned with their career ambitions. Often, participants aspired to work in vocational roles as opposed to those that required university degrees. This was shaped by their own experiences: for example, wanting to work in health, care or support roles following their own contact with services. Others preferred roles they had prior experience in, which felt achievable given their existing skills. Their motivations reflected their broader goals, including a desire for independence, routine, social contact, and purpose; while income mattered, it was rarely the only driver.

“I really want to work. It gives me some active goal and purpose, instead of it just being the same thing over and over.”
(Customer, 23, multiple conditions, UC)

Some young people were actively seeking to engage in education or employment

This took various forms: for example, by searching for an education course or job role that suited them or engaging in volunteering as a way of building up relevant skills and confidence before applying for a role. Some did this independently, while others did so with the support of friends, family or their Work Coach.

But work was not an immediate or realistic option for everyone

Some were focused on stabilising their health or securing appropriate support before engaging in their search for employment. For those with complex health conditions, aspirations were centred more on safety, quality of life and engaging in supported activity. For others, work was not something they were prioritising or interested in at this stage of their life.

Participants’ routes into NEET status reflected a build-up of challenges across multiple areas of their lives

No single factor explained NEET status. Rather, young people faced difficulties across the full range of systems they interacted with, including education, health services, the labour market and the benefits system. For some, peers or family also influenced their pathway, either supporting attempts to engage or reinforcing disengagement.

Difficulties often began at school, including bullying, problems engaging in lessons, and health needs being misread as bad behaviour or lack of motivation

This led to poor attendance and a difficulty coping in mainstream settings. In some cases, this was compounded by the lack of a useful diagnosis from health services. Where schools identified support needs early and put effective adjustments in place, young people were better equipped to attend and participate in school. Where they did not, participants typically left school with lower confidence, disrupted learning and little sense of what came next.

“I was always labelled as disruptive… I was like, ‘No, I’m just struggling’.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC)

Experiences in further education were shaped by access and capacity

Some participants entered further education or specialist provision, but pathways were often disjointed, with movement between courses, providers, or periods of withdrawal. Participants’ ability to access a course was limited by the availability of suitable provision, prior academic attainment, ability to travel to locations that were further away, and affordability. Where participants did enrol, their ability to participate was influenced by their health-related capacity, as well as the quality of reasonable adjustments provided. Similar to experiences at school, participants tended to withdraw when courses did not accommodate needs or their health worsened.

“I actually had to stop [attending college] because of my own mental health and other health [conditions]. I have the intellect but not the health capacity to do what my brain is capable of.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC)

Gaps in support were evident at numerous key moments of transition

Limited preparation for adult life at school left many feeling unprepared. Some received little support to progress into further education, training, and employment. Where support did exist, it often did not consider health needs or prioritise jobs that could realistically be sustained. Support gaps were particularly stark at the transition from child to adult health services. Young people lost input from medical professionals with whom they had built trusting relationships, and even lost access to effective treatments, with no replacement available. In some cases, this failure contributed to them becoming NEET as their health deteriorated.

“She’s been under the adult mental health services since she turned 18. [… and is] turning 23 soon. […] There’s never been anyone available.”
(Appointee of: 22, mental health, PIP and UC)

Labour market barriers made it harder for young people to access work

Appropriate jobs, particularly entry-level roles that could accommodate fluctuating health conditions, were limited. Apprenticeship opportunities were also not widely available, and where young people did access them, they did not always provide a direct route into a job afterwards.

When young people did enter work, experiences of reasonable adjustments were variable

Some participants tried to find roles that suited their capacity, rather than receiving formal adjustments, which, when provided, were not always sustained over time. Some chose not to disclose their condition to employers or colleagues, either due to a limited self-understanding of their needs or a desire to manage independently. Where health conditions may not have been disclosed, some participants’ coping strategies were misunderstood by colleagues, leading to incorrect assumptions about their behaviour.

Some participants entered work that was not suitable for their needs

Roles did not always align with their health conditions, capacity or preferred ways of working. For example, roles with long hours or high levels of social interaction were difficult for some to sustain. This led to challenges remaining in work.

“He was there less than a month before […] he had […] another mental breakdown [His boss] emailed and said ‘This isn’t going to work. He just can’t cope with the pace. It’s too much pressure on him and he’s just not going to manage’”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC)

Confidence and readiness to engage were shaped by systems, not just by individual motivation

Repeated experiences of being misunderstood, bullied or overwhelmed in education or work had lasting effects, and arose when health needs were not recognised or were ineffectively supported. Some avoided classrooms or workplaces because they associated them with distress or failure. Others feared ending up in the same position again and disengaged completely. As such, rebuilding confidence was identified as a key support need and, for many, an important pre-condition for participation.

While many participants faced barriers, there were examples of more positive experiences

These were typically characterised by early identification of health and support needs, supportive relationships with staff throughout education provisions, access to specialist educational provision which enabled shared peer environments, and support from family, professionals or wider networks. Where these factors combined, participants were better able to engage in education or training and move closer to work.

Case study

Emma is 23 and has mental health, neurodevelopmental and physical health conditions. She is in receipt of UC Limited Capability for Work and Work Related Activity (LCWRA). She is currently volunteering at a flower shop with a clear goal of being taken on as a paid employee. Her Work Coach helped her secure the placement by supporting her with her curriculum vitae (CV) and cover letter. Since starting to volunteer, the florist has provided Emma with necessary adjustments, including a stool to support with her fatigue, flexible breaks, and extra time to learn new tasks. Receiving benefits has also enabled Emma to cover living expenses, such as food, and taught her how to manage her finances, in preparation for her longer-term goal of living independently.

The benefits system both supported and discouraged movement into education and work

It provided an essential safety net and, for some, enabled them to volunteer, study or look for work without immediate financial pressure. Some felt that if they had accessed benefits earlier, they might have stayed in education for longer rather than trying to move into work, which would have been better for them long-term. At the same time, uncertainty about how benefits would be affected by entering education or work could deter participation. Participants described fear of losing income, confusion about what would happen if a job did not work out, and anxiety about whether support would be resumed. Finally, some participants noted that moving into work would leave them little, if at all, better off financially, reducing their incentive to engage.

“It’s almost like he’s frightened that [his benefits are] going to be snatched away from him if he shows any indication of wanting to find a job.”
(Appointee of: 22, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC)

Appointees focused more on achieving goals like improved wellbeing, health stability, and quality of life, rather than employment

They were often cautious about employment, viewing it as unrealistic or only feasible under very specific circumstances. Their views reflected the severity of health condition and impairments their young people experienced.

Participants identified a range of support needs to help them move closer to education, training and employment, spanning health, social care, and employment support

These include:

  • co-ordinated, sustained support at the transition from child to adult services, as provision often ended abruptly leaving young people with limited help
  • structured emotional support to rebuild confidence after negative experiences in education or employment, including support from family members, peer connection opportunities, and signposting to relevant organisations by Jobcentre Plus (JCP)
  • mental and physical health support to stabilise health conditions and make participation in education, employment or training feel feasible
  • social care support (for those with goals focused on quality of life rather than work) which included access to funded activities across the week and respite for family carers
  • hands-on, tailored, one-to-one check ins to identify and access opportunities, including help with CVs, applications, and interview preparation, delivered by JCP to all who wanted it (including those who are less likely to receive employment-focused support, such as the Limited Capability for Work Related Activity group on the UC Health Journey), and more tailored than current provision, which was described as too generic
  • clear, personalised advice from JCP on how participation would affect benefits, alongside reassurance that they could be reinstated if needed
  • access to free or subsidised vocational skills development, delivered in flexible, tailored formats to meet a wider range of learning needs
  • reasonable adjustments at work: particularly flexibility in working patterns; reduced physical demands; and structured training and ongoing supervision to carry out tasks effectively

Conclusions

This study has highlighted 4 key facts about the experiences of young NEETs claiming health and disability benefits.

1. There was rarely a single point at which young people disengaged from school, training or employment. Rather, their current situation was a result of challenges building up gradually over a long period of time. This highlights the importance of early identification and intervention, and repeated engagement and support throughout school and the transition to adulthood.

2. Young people experienced challenges across the full range of services and systems they interacted with, including school, further education, health services, workplaces, and the benefits system. Negative experiences in one area of young people’s lives tended to spill over, causing difficulties in other areas. For example, a lack of early diagnosis and treatment could lead to difficulties engaging at school, which could lead to lower educational attainment, which could lead to difficulties accessing further education, exacerbated by difficulties transitioning to adult health services. This highlights the importance of taking a holistic view of the whole ecosystem of services that young people interact with.

3. A key consequence of this accumulation of challenges across different areas of their lives was that young people often had extremely low confidence and self-esteem. In some cases, they had become increasingly isolated and fearful of re-engaging in education, employment or training. Young people often felt that the first step to re-engaging was to rebuild this missing confidence.

4. Participation in education, training and employment was not for everyone. For some young people, particularly those with the most complex health conditions, participation in work was not viewed as feasible. The appointees of these young people described how their focus is instead on maintaining wellbeing, quality of life, and stabilising their health where possible.

Glossary

Term Description
Appointee An appointee is somebody who has been granted the right to deal with the benefits of someone who cannot manage their own affairs because they’re mentally incapable or severely disabled.
Jobcentre Plus Jobcentre Plus is a brand under which the DWP offers working-age support services, such as employment advisory services.
Personal Independence Payment A tax-free, non-means-tested benefit that contributes towards the extra costs of long-term ill health or a disability for working-age people (16 to the day before State Pension age when first claiming) who need help with mobility and/or daily living costs. It replaced Disability Living Allowance (DLA) for working age people and is available to those both in and out of work. 
Universal Credit A payment to help with living costs for people on low income or out of work. UC has replaced, for most customers, six means-tested benefits and tax credits: Child Tax Credit; Housing Benefit; Income Support; income-based Jobseeker’s Allowance (JSA); income-related Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) and Working Tax Credit. Some customers who receive Universal Credit are on the ‘Health Journey’ and may receive additional payments because of work-limiting health conditions or impairments.
Work Coach Front-line DWP staff based in jobcentres who support customers into work by challenging, motivating, providing personalised advice and using knowledge of local labour markets.

Abbreviations

Abbreviation Meaning
ADHD Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
DLA Disability Living Allowance
DWP Department for Work and Pensions
EHCP Education, Health and Care Plan
ESA Employment and Support Allowance
GCSE General Certificate of Secondary Education
JCP Jobcentre Plus
LCW Limited Capability for Work
LCWRA Limited Capability for Work and Work Related Activity
NEET Not in education, employment or training
PIP Personal Independence Payment
PRU Pupil Referral Unit
PTSD Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
SEND Special Educational Needs and Disabilities
UC Universal Credit
WCA Work Capability Assessment

1. Introduction

Background and context to the research

This study is an extension of DWP’s Work Aspirations and Support Needs of Health and Disability Customers study. While the original study included health and disability benefit customers of all ages and employment statuses, this study focuses specifically on health and disability customers aged 18 to 24 who are not in education, employment, or training (NEET).

A sharp rise in young people claiming health and disability benefits, coupled with an increase in the rates of those who are NEET, highlights a growing challenge for the UK labour market and welfare system. Between January and March 2026, 13.5% of young people in the UK were NEET, equating to 1,012,000 individuals (see Young people not in education, employment or training, (ONS, 2026).

Those with disabilities are among the most at risk of being NEET (Youth Futures Foundation, 2023). The original Work Aspirations study, however, found that younger benefit customers were more likely than older groups to feel able to work under the right conditions [footnote 1]. Identifying tailored policy solutions to support this population to move closer to work is a growing priority for DWP.

The National Centre for Social Research (NatCen) was commissioned by DWP to carry out this research.

Research aims

This report explores the experiences, aspirations, barriers, and support needs of young health and disability benefit customers who are NEET, based on in-depth interviews with young people or their appointees. Its research questions expand on those addressed by the previous Work Aspirations study, with a more specific focus on the experiences of this young population. It examines:

  • young people’s benefit, education, training and work histories
  • factors influencing their NEET status, including impacts of their health conditions and impairments, and the extent to which experiences of education prepared them for future participation
  • their aspirations and motivations in relation to education, training and work
  • support they would need to move closer to education, training or employment

The full list of detailed research questions is provided in Appendix A.

Methodology

To explore participants’ views and experiences in detail, we carried out in-depth qualitative interviews with young people aged 18 to 24 who were NEET or their appointees. All were in receipt of at least one health and disability benefit, such as the health component of Universal Credit (UC), New Style Employment and Support Allowance (NS ESA), or Personal Independence Payment (PIP). NatCen’s Research Ethics Committee granted ethical approval for this research in January 2026.

Sampling and recruitment

The research used a purposive sampling approach to achieve range and diversity across key characteristics including age, primary health condition, benefit group, and appointee status. Our sample frame was drawn from a larger sample provided by DWP for Work Aspirations (DWP, 2025) in summer 2024. From this larger sample, we drew a subsample of 1,515 young people who, at the time the larger sample was drawn, were claiming health and disability-related benefits and aged 18 to 24. Around 10% of these individuals took part in the original Work Aspirations survey and consented to future contact about qualitative research. The remainder had not previously been contacted by NatCen.

Recruitment was led by NatCen’s Telephone Unit, supported by the research team. Recruitment was more challenging than anticipated. Over 1,150 customers were contacted to achieve the final sample, with difficulties arising from out-of-date contact details, customers who were no longer NEET, and a proportion of customers opting out of participation. As a result, 40 interviews were conducted, rather than the original target of 50. Secondary sample quotas were treated flexibly, and the achieved sample included a diverse spread across key characteristics. We also had no participants aged 18 to 19, reflecting the fact that the sample frame was drawn in summer 2024, around 18 months before fieldwork began. Full details are provided in Appendix A.

Data collection

Fieldwork took place between January and April 2026. Participants were offered a choice of interview mode, including face-to-face; however, all chose to take part online or by telephone. To ensure inclusive and accessible participation, special arrangements were discussed with participants. These included sharing a list of interview topics in advance, using live closed captioning, completing the interview in more than one sitting or attending with someone, for example. Of the 40 interviews conducted, 24 involved an appointee, either interviewed alone or alongside the person they supported. In 20 of these cases, the interview was conducted with the appointee only. (This is only slightly higher than the proportion of health and disability benefit customers aged 18 to 25 who have an appointee.)

All participants received a £40 e-voucher as thanks for their contribution.

To ensure consistency of coverage across interviews, they were structured using a topic guide which set out the key themes and subthemes to be covered. Researchers used the guide flexibly, responding to the natural flow of discussion and terminology used by participants. A summary version of the guide is included at Appendix B.

Analysis

With participants’ consent, interviews were digitally audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim to support detailed thematic analysis. We used NatCen’s case- and theme-based Framework approach (Ritchie et al., 2013) to manage and analyse the data systematically, examining the full range of views and experiences across the dataset and seeking to identify similarities and differences between participant subgroups.

Anonymised verbatim quotations are used to highlight key themes and findings where appropriate throughout this report. Care has been taken to protect participants’ confidentiality. Quotations are labelled according to 3 sampling characteristics (age, primary health condition and benefit(s)). This information should be interpreted as indicative only, as some participants had multiple/additional conditions that are not reflected. In addition, benefit details in labels are based on information held when the sample was drawn in 2024. Although expected to remain broadly stable for most participants, some participants’ benefit circumstances or conditionality may have changed by the time interviews were conducted. We have included footnotes to indicate where information collected during recruitment suggests a change in benefit circumstances.

Case studies included throughout this report have been pseudonymised to protect participants’ anonymity and are included to illustrate key themes from the qualitative interviews.

Throughout this report, we use the term customer when referring to the wider population of health and disability benefit customers, or when distinguishing between the customer and an appointee (for example, in quote labels). Otherwise, we use the term participant, reflecting that findings are drawn from interviews with individuals who took part in this qualitative research study, rather than being fully representative of the wider customer population.

Limitations of the research

While this study was robust in its design and conduct, it is important to acknowledge limitations that may affect its findings.

Due to the time gap between DWP originally drawing the larger sample (summer 2024) and the fieldwork for this follow-up study (January to April 2026), the sample of participants who we interviewed is biased towards those who have been NEET and claiming benefits for a longer time. This means:

  • the study does not include young people aged 18 to 19
  • the study does not include young people who only recently became NEET or started claiming health and disability benefits
  • compared to the wider population of young health and disability benefit customers, a slightly higher proportion of the achieved sample had appointees who managed their benefits on their behalf (interviews were either conducted with the young person or the appointee). Appointees provide important insight into the circumstances of the person they supported, particularly of those with more severe health needs. However, their perspectives may differ from those of the young person themselves

This risk of bias towards longer-term benefit participants was identified at the outset of the study. Given the unique policy challenge of supporting the longer-term NEET into work, it was decided that this bias was acceptable.

In addition, the sample size was relatively small and participation was opt-in, which may have introduced bias into the views and experiences captured. Although the achieved sample included a good spread across key characteristics, some perspectives may not have been represented. The very large number who were contacted to achieve 40 interviews suggests this is likely to be the case, and those who declined to participate or who could not be contacted may differ from those who took part.

There is also a risk of bias relating to ability to engage. Despite making accommodations to support participation, and interviewing appointees, some with the most severe health needs may not have been able to take part. Their views may be underrepresented.

As a qualitative study, the findings illustrate the range and diversity of views and experiences among participants. Inferences about prevalence are not supported by qualitative approaches and cannot be drawn from these data.

Outline of the report

This report brings together the views of participants who took part in interviews.

  • Chapter 2 describes participants’ day‑to‑day lives and contexts, including their health, finances and social circumstances
  • Chapter 3 explores participants’ experiences of school, including the support they received to inform next steps and their levels of preparedness for life beyond school
  • Chapter 4 examines participants’ experiences of further and higher education, including decision-making, access, and factors shaping engagement
  • Chapter 5 presents participants’ experiences of training and employment, including pathways into work and reasons for disengagement
  • Chapter 6 describes participants’ current activities in relation to education, training and work, their aspirations, and longer-term ambitions
  • Chapter 7 outlines key barriers and support participants need to move closer to education, training and/or employment

2. Participants’ daily lives and contexts

This chapter provides an overview of participants’ daily lives and circumstances at the time of interview. Participants were, in general, in one of 3 main living situations:

  • living with family, usually parents and sometimes siblings – they typically had health conditions with varying levels of complexity and severity and often received ongoing support from family members
  • living in formal supported accommodation with varying levels of on-site support – this included participants with neurodevelopmental conditions, learning disabilities, or severe physical health conditions
  • living independently in privately rented or social housing, either alone, with a partner, their children, or in shared accommodation with people they did not know well – those living independently had mental health or physical health conditions which did not require the same level of support that would necessitate a supported setting

 2.1 Impact of health conditions on daily living

Participants’ health conditions fell into 4 broad categories:

  • neurodevelopmental/cognitive conditions (such as autism, ADHD, and learning disabilities)
  • mental health conditions (including anxiety, depression, PTSD and personality disorders)
  • long-term conditions (including visual impairment, hearing impairment, epilepsy, cerebral palsy, diabetes, genetic syndromes, chronic fatigue and chronic pain)
  • multiple conditions (participants with a combination of the above)

Co-occurrence of multiple conditions was common. Symptoms ranged from physical effects such as pain, fatigue and mobility difficulties to emotional effects including stress, anxiety and fear. All of these had practical consequences for participants’ ability to carry out day-to-day tasks.

Persistent pain severely restricted daily activity for some participants. They described being unable to engage in everyday activities and needing to rest for long periods.

“I’m in a lot of pain every day, and my body can’t function, which means I can’t really engage with things. […] I can get paralysis as well if I don’t rest.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Fatigue was a common and debilitating symptom across a range of physical and mental health conditions. Participants described exhaustion linked to conditions such as chronic fatigue syndrome and fibromyalgia, the ongoing demands of managing conditions like diabetes that require constant monitoring, and the cognitive effort involved in masking neurodevelopmental conditions in social settings. This reduced their capacity to complete daily tasks.

Mobility difficulties further restricted independence for some participants with physical health conditions. These participants described needing mobility aids and struggling with everyday household tasks.

“I have to use a wheelchair at the moment to walk around […]. I can’t really do many household tasks or […] even showering.”
(Customer, 22, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Emotional impacts also shaped participants’ daily lives. These included chronic stress, anxiety and fear, either directly linked to their condition, or arising from navigating daily life with complex health needs.

“[Because of my anxiety] I feel sick pretty much everything I do outside the house. [I] feel like I can’t do anything because I feel sick.”
(Customer, 21, mental health, PIP and UC LCW)

Functional impacts and levels of independence

Together, the physical, cognitive and emotional effects of participants’ health conditions translated into functional impacts on their daily lives. Difficulties carrying out day-to-day tasks were a direct consequence of their conditions, including the executive function difficulties associated with ADHD and autism; chronic fatigue; mental health issues such as depression; or physical health conditions that made physical tasks challenging.

“He doesn’t bathe unless I remind him he hasn’t for weeks. He doesn’t eat. He will only eat if I say to him, ‘It’s time to eat’.” (Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP) [footnote 2]

Participants described a spectrum of independence, ranging from those who were almost entirely dependent on others for most aspects of daily life, to those who could function more independently within familiar environments but struggled as soon as circumstances changed.

At the more severe end of this spectrum, some participants were unable to manage their conditions effectively, describing worsening health and increasing difficulty in day-to-day functioning. These participants said they either had no health support in place, or that the support they were able to access was not condition-specific, and as such, did not fully meet their needs. For example, some participants with autism and pathological demand avoidance (a persistent and marked resistance to demands and instructions) described standard support approaches as counterproductive, as they replicated the demand-based structures their condition made unmanageable. Others described care arrangements where staff lacked knowledge of their specific condition, such as chronic fatigue syndrome, meaning support was available but not effective in practice.

Other participants with physical health conditions or neurodevelopmental conditions described being able to manage by using their own strategies. This included practical approaches such as written lists to manage memory difficulties or following a strict routine to reduce anxiety. These strategies enabled some level of independence, particularly where symptoms were fluctuating.

In contrast, some participants were able to manage their conditions effectively with appropriate support. This included medication, as well as support from family members, carers, and day centre staff. For these participants, consistent and tailored support from people who knew them well enabled them to maintain routines, manage symptoms, and sustain a greater level of independence.

2.2 Day-to-day activities

Participants with severe and highly limiting health conditions (including, for example, genetic syndromes or chronic fatigue) described very restricted day-to-day activity. Much of their time was spent resting or in bed, rarely leaving the house. Some required support from carers to complete daily tasks such as personal care.

“I’ve got numerous health problems, which means that I am bedbound […] I’m in a lot of pain every day, and my body can’t function, which means I can’t really engage with things.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Another group of participants spent their day engaged in a very limited range of activities – examples were online gaming and reading. We heard this from participants with neurodevelopmental disorders, learning disabilities, and mental health issues.

By contrast, other participants engaged in a broader range of activities but required supervision or support due to lifelong physical conditions or cognitive impairments. This support was provided through day centres or council-funded activities, such as exercise groups and crafts, as well as at home with families.

Other participants engaged in activities independently. These included personal care and domestic tasks alongside health appointments, hobbies and voluntary work. While they were able to engage independently, they still experienced limitations to their functioning, including physical pain affecting mobility and mental health issues affecting their mood.

“I am a volunteer at a flower shop […] which would include me helping making the flower arrangements and bouquets […otherwise,] I will usually either be drawing, doing character design, taking care of the animals. I like to write.”
(Customer, 23, multiple conditions, UC LCWRA)

For participants who said their health condition fluctuated, the range of activities they could undertake varied from day to day, depending on how they felt.

“His interaction and engagement with any activity on a day-to-day, to an hour-to-hour basis can be dependent on his mood and whether he’s up to it or not.”
(Appointee of: 22, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Caring responsibilities also shaped participants’ daily activities. Some with children structured their day around childcare, such as caring for babies, attending toddler groups and preparing children for school. How independently they managed these tasks depended on the nature and severity of their health conditions, and some relied on family support to meet their children’s needs fully.

2.3 Financial circumstances

Participants’ financial circumstances generally fit into one of 3 groups:

  • one group relied on claiming benefits as their only source of income, including PIP, UC and child benefit
  • others said their family provided occasional financial support, such as ad hoc borrowing when money ran short
  • others said their family provided a financial safety net by regularly supplementing their income from benefits – either financially, or through in-kind support such as accommodation in the family home

Participants who received Disability Living Allowance (DLA) as children said they transitioned to receiving PIP around age 16. Those who had not received DLA as children typically applied for benefits as an adult following worsening health, changes in living circumstances, or on the advice of professionals they were already in contact with. This included their college tutors or the Jobcentre Plus (JCP).

Some participants described their broader financial circumstances as manageable, particularly where housing costs were covered or reduced. This included those living with parents; those receiving additional financial support from family; or some living in formal supported accommodation where rent and living costs were met through local authority funding. This left benefit income available for their day-to-day spending. As a result, some in supported accommodation described having low outgoings or sufficient disposable income which enabled them to save.

But not all participants were financially stable. Other participants in formal supported accommodation whose costs were not fully externally funded, who were renting independently, or who had higher health-related needs said that making ends meet each month could be difficult. Benefits became essential for paying rent and purchasing disability-specific equipment, but not always sufficient to meet their needs fully.

“Things are tight. […] Without me in his life, […] he would really struggle to make ends meet. I contribute. I top up to make sure he doesn’t go without.”
(Appointee of: 22, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

For some participants with physical health and/or neurodevelopmental conditions, disability-related costs were a key driver of financial pressure. Benefits did not always cover the additional costs associated with disability, including specialist equipment, personal care items, up-to-date technology, and adapted vehicles. As a result, they described relying on family support or in some cases on a one-off basis, going into arrears with rent to cover these expenses.

2.4 Social contexts

Participants’ social circumstances were shaped both by their personal preferences and by the impact of their health conditions. Some had relatively limited social networks and relied almost entirely on family for social contact. For some, taking part in the research interview was the only social interaction they had experienced in a long time. There were 2 reasons for this: either participants were disinterested in pursuing friendships and preferred to focus on their hobbies and interests instead; or their health condition limited their physical and/or mental capacity to devote energy to social contact, particularly outside the home.

Others described having a small number of close, trusted relationships, including childhood friends, family, partners, carers and online friends. They maintained these through in-person and online contact, depending on their health. Some said friends with similar health conditions offered mutual understanding, though relationships were easier to sustain more generally when others understood that their health could fluctuate.

Participants reflected on how their circumstances compared with those of their peers and family members, including people in and out of work and education. Among those whose friends and family were in employment, participants described feeling left behind, expressing feelings of embarrassment or disappointment about being out of work and receiving disability benefits.

Others indicated that their circumstances and health issues made comparison with potential role models feel less relevant, however. This was the case where participants felt that standard ideas of working and a good life were not fully achievable for them due to their disabilities.

“[He] has all these positive role models, but I think he feels like [working and having a nice life is] not achievable for him, because of his disabilities, because of the way his brain works.”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP) [footnote 3]

In some instances, appointees spoke about people in the young person’s social circle, including their family members, romantic partners and friends, who were in similar circumstances. Some appointees speculated that knowing other people who were NEET helped to normalise the young person’s situation and potentially reduced their motivation to seek work. Some appointees also felt they perceived a negative shift in the young person’s attitude towards working following interactions with these peers, describing them as moving from being open to work to no longer expressing this.

“The majority of [his friends] are either claiming disability benefit or unemployment benefit. […] I think it makes him feel comfortable that he’s not the only one […] like it’s okay to not have a job.”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP) [footnote 3].

2.5 Summary

Health conditions shaped participants’ day-to-day functioning

The severity, combination and fluctuation of conditions determined what participants could do each day, which ranged from being housebound to engaging in a range of activities. For some, it meant that participation in education, training or work was unrealistic.

Wider support networks shaped participant experiences

Where participants described having supportive relationships, including family, peers, and their wider network, this enabled greater overall stability. It enabled them to maintain routines, manage symptoms, and sustain a greater level of independence.

Financial circumstances were tied to support networks, rather than receipt of benefits on its own

While some participants relied on benefits as their primary source of income, those who received financial support from their family were more likely to describe their situation as manageable. Those who struggled were often the ones without family support.

These were the starting point for participants’ pathways into education, training and employment

Differences in health conditions, support received and financial circumstances shaped how participants experienced later stages and their journey to NEET status.

3. Experiences of school

This chapter examines participants’ experiences of secondary school. It focuses on the different types of school that participants attended and the factors that shaped their experiences and outcomes.

Participants attended different types of educational settings, including mainstream schools, special schools, home education, one-to-one tuition, and alternative provision such as pupil referral units (PRUs), which are designed to support students who struggle in mainstream schools due to medical, behavioural, or social challenges. Some participants had transitioned between different educational settings to better meet their education or health needs, or following experiences of bullying.

3.1 Ability to engage in school due to health

Physical health conditions limited some participants’ ability to attend and participate consistently in school because of health-related absence. Participants described missing school because of symptomatic episodes, medical treatment, and periods of recovery. For some, periods of absence were short, whereas for others the cumulative effect was substantial, leading to missed learning and lower attainment. Some linked their subsequent health deterioration directly to the physical toll of persisting at school despite undiagnosed and untreated physical conditions.

“Even though I got good grades in the end, the impact of all that pushing through my health has resulted in me being bedbound because I’ve gone through so much stress. My body’s actually shut down now.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

However, physical health conditions were not always a barrier to participation. Participants with symptoms which were more stable, or whose schools had support in place that worked for them, described largely positive attendance and social connection with peers. They did not feel their health condition had limited their ability to take part in school life.

Participants with mental health conditions tended to withdraw from school gradually over time as their attendance fell. Some described attendance worsening progressively, linked to anxiety or depression that they felt schools did not recognise or address. This led to patchy attendance for some and complete withdrawal from education for others.

“[My attendance] gradually got worse, really. I think in junior school and first school […] it was fine. Nothing unusual. Maybe like Year 7, Year 8 it was a bit dodgy, Year 9 it wasn’t great, and then Year 10 it was like pretty poor, really. I’d have just like the odd days off, like 2 days here, maybe a week here, stuff like that, which at the time, I didn’t realise what it was, but obviously, looking back on it now, it was the anxiety.”
(Customer, 21, mental health, PIP and UC)

For participants with neurodevelopmental conditions, the impacts were broader, affecting not just attendance but the ability to participate in the school environment at all. Sensory overload, difficulty managing noise, changes in staff, and classroom environments where others were not following rules created persistent distress. For some, this manifested in behaviour that was interpreted as disruptive.

3.2 Identification of health needs and reasonable adjustments

Participants described better educational outcomes when schools recognised their health needs and put appropriate adjustments in place. Needs were identified either through formal diagnosis, staff observation, or parental advocacy. Support included one-to-one assistance, flexible use of classroom space, adapted materials, and exam adjustments. Many of these were guided by Education, Health and Care Plans (EHCPs) providing a structured framework for support. Participants described this support as helping them stay involved with learning and build confidence.

“I think the reason he did so well in school was because there was always support in place. There was always people that were like, ‘Well, you might have got it wrong this time, but here’s how we can correct that, and this is what we need to do’.”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP) [footnote 4]

Support from individual members of staff was often central to positive experiences. Participants and appointees described teachers, teaching assistants and pastoral staff who understood their needs as having a transformative effect on participation and wellbeing. Some participants credited these relationships as enabling them to complete their GCSEs.

For participants with more complex needs, special schools were often better able than mainstream schools to reduce their barriers to taking part in school. Participants with complex genetic conditions, severe learning disabilities, or multiple physical and neurodevelopmental conditions generally described positive experiences in special schools. Smaller class sizes, specialist staff and an individually tailored curriculum enabled participants to take part in learning that had not been possible in mainstream settings.

“[At her special school] you only had about five to six children with specialist needs, and [there were] more people to help with her, as well. [She] blossomed.”
(Appointee of: 24, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC pre-WCA)

However, when health needs were not recognised or supported during school years, this created barriers to motivation at school. Across all types of health condition, the absence of a diagnosis made life at school harder. For example, participants with undiagnosed neurodevelopmental conditions described being labelled as naughty, disruptive or lazy. Behaviours linked to sensory sensitivity or difficulty concentrating were at times punished rather than supported, contributing to feelings of frustration, feeling misunderstood, and in some cases, anger or disruptive behaviour.

“I was always labelled as disruptive [at school] but I just couldn’t actually concentrate. […] my mental health was just really bad through school and then everyone just dismissed it […] and just put me down as disruptive. I was like, ‘No, I’m just struggling’.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, UC LCWRA) [footnote 5]

Without a diagnosis, participants struggled to explain or advocate for their needs, and schools were less able to provide appropriate support. This resulted in health-related disengagement, particularly when related to behaviour or attendance, being misread as a behavioural or motivational failure.

“[He] was diagnosed with a learning disability, autism and ADHD, but he was very late diagnosed, because when he was at school, they just put him down to be a naughty boy.”
(Appointee of: 20, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Even when conditions were diagnosed, inconsistent or impractical support did not remove the barriers it was intended to address. Participants with physical and mental health conditions described adjustments that their school put in place but were difficult to use in practice. This discouraged them from asking for help and disadvantaged them academically. The quality and implementation of EHCPs varied, with some schools following them closely and others applying them inconsistently or not at all. This led to variation in support received and affected the extent to which participants could engage in learning.

Case study

John is 22 and has a long-term health condition. He is in receipt of UC LCWRA and PIP. After losing most of his sight as a teenager, he became increasingly socially isolated. He saw a decline in his mental health related to adjusting to sight loss and currently spends most of his time in his bedroom. John has encountered barriers to participation at multiple stages of education. At school, adjustments were not fully effective: textbooks were enlarged, but the page numbers didn’t match those used in class, making lessons difficult to follow.

“So, if they’re saying, ‘Turn to page 20’, it wouldn’t be page 20 on his A3 printout. That was really difficult. He struggled a lot, and he was afraid to ask for help if they hadn’t printed out stuff for him. He didn’t want to seem like he was a bother, and that massively affected him.”
(Appointee of: 22, long-term condition, PIP and UC LCWRA)

When he moved to a mainstream college, he was offered adjustments to help him navigate the building, but this was not provided. He was left unable to navigate around independently, leaving him unable to get to the toilet. He soon withdrew and became NEET.

John’s appointee said he would have benefited from specialist visual impairment support, noting that the only support offered at college was a magnifying glass. They also felt that signposting to specialist, condition-specific education courses by DWP would have been beneficial before agreeing his benefits; instead, the family identified courses specifically for those with visual impairment themselves, several years later.

In some cases, funding constraints led to existing support being withdrawn over time. Participants described losing one-to-one support, specialist activities or therapeutic input while at school. This contributed to increased emotional distress, worsening behaviour, including increased absconding, and acting out towards staff.

Where barriers persisted, some participants transitioned to alternative settings. This included transfers to home education, special schools, or PRUs. Home education was sometimes viewed as more engaging than school, as learning could be structured around health needs and practical life skills rather than academic content which was deemed as not appropriate for them.

3.3 Appropriateness of academic challenge in special schools

Participants with severe or complex learning needs generally felt that the curriculum in special schools was matched to their abilities. For these young people and their families, schools prioritised engagement, development and preparation for daily life rather than academic attainment. Appointees described their children attending happily, developing communication skills and being well looked after. Some valued specialist teaching approaches suited to their child’s way of learning.

“She then started going full time to this special needs school, which she loved because they break it down into tiny steps, which suits her sort of learning.”
(Appointee of: 22, long-term condition, PIP and UC LCWRA)

However, challenging classroom environments in some special schools limited opportunities for learning. Where pupils with a wide range of needs were grouped together, appointees said teaching time could be diverted towards behaviour management. Some described teachers as having limited capacity to manage these environments while also providing meaningful learning.

Participants whose physical or neurodevelopmental conditions did not limit academic capability described learning that felt repetitive or did not push them academically. Some said that more challenging content was absent or had been removed from the curriculum due to funding, which reduced their motivation to continue with education.

“It was really boring. […] In a special education school, you don’t really learn a lot of things, you just learn life skills.”
(Customer, 21, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC LCWRA) [footnote 6].

3.4 Experiences with peers and bullying

Participants in mainstream education settings reported instances of social isolation and bullying. Health conditions affected their ability to connect with peers, particularly where physical health differences were visible, or where participants had atypical communication styles associated with neurodevelopmental conditions. Bullying was reported across all health condition groups, suggesting that vulnerability was not condition-specific but instead related to the level of understanding from peers within the educational setting.

For some, bullying reduced attendance and learning time, contributing to lower attainment and poorer mental health. For others, it led to transitions into alternative provision. Some viewed this positively, as being in an environment where they had more in common with their peers fostered a sense of belonging. In contrast, others found it difficult to adjust to a new school routine. This was particularly the case for those who had been out of education for a prolonged period due to bullying.

Shared peer experiences and specialist support played a protective role against bullying. Participants and appointees said that spending time with peers with similar experiences, being in environments where difference was normalised, and having teachers with understanding of health conditions reduced the social isolation participants had experienced in mainstream settings. This was spoken about in relation to special schools and PRUs.

“Everybody [at the PRU] had a problem. So [she] wasn’t the only one with a problem. […] Nobody really picked on people for their little quirks. It was just understood.”
(Appointee of: 20, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

3.5 Support and expectations for post‑school transition

Some participants who attended mainstream and special schools described receiving information about post‑school options, including careers fairs, one‑to‑one advice, and signposting to college or sixth‑form open days. Schools sometimes offered work experience, while special schools more often focused on specialist further education routes. However, the availability and quality of support differed considerably between settings.

Participants who attended special schools spoke about receiving support but explained that this was not always comprehensive. Some appointees described schools providing guidance on application processes, deadlines, and visits to specialist further education providers. Others felt schools had limited awareness of provision beyond their own setting. In these cases, families said they had to identify options themselves and lacked clear information about funding, eligibility and timelines.

Participants who attended mainstream schools often described transition support as generic rather than tailored. While support was available, it was not always adapted to participants’ health needs, interests or capacity. For example, work experience placements were sometimes unsuitable, and participants said they received little guidance on how different roles might relate to their circumstances.

“My school was known for putting you in nurseries, and I can’t handle kids [because they’re] just very loud, abrupt [and…] germs, I’m scared of germs. So they were like, ‘Okay, fine, we’ll put you in a hotel.’ The hotel could only keep me for three days and then I was put into [a] bank for a week, but I wasn’t legally able to touch anything because I was 15, so […] I just sat there.”
(Customer, 23, multiple conditions, UC LCWRA)

Participants also reported that they received limited information about options other than college and university, such as apprenticeships or direct routes into work. They felt schools emphasised progression to college or sixth form, and subsequently university. These participants reflected that further education had been difficult for them and that moving straight into work could have been more manageable.

“I feel like apprenticeships should have been looked more at […] back in 2016, 2017 when I was leaving school it was very much the norm […] to go to college, get three A Levels, go to university, get a degree, then go into work. That was always what was pushed.”
(Customer, 24, mental health condition, PIP and UC LCWRA)

A lack of tailored support contributed to many participants feeling unprepared for adult life when they left school. Participants across health condition groups described a curriculum that felt disconnected from adult responsibilities. Some questioned the prioritisation of academic content over practical skills, such as managing money. Others said disrupted attendance, due to health conditions or bullying, further limited their preparedness for life after school.

“He’s really passionate about, ‘We can do maths at school, but why don’t we apply that to getting a mortgage? Why have I got to learn algebra, which I’m never going to use?’.”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP) [footnote 7]

“I obviously didn’t finish schooling, so maybe this would have changed in the last year-and-a-half or something, but I think schooling in general is pretty bare bones. There’s nothing about, ‘Oh, how do you open a bank account? How do you find a first job? […] I think it’s literally just education and that’s it […]. It doesn’t really prepare you for life.”
(Customer, 21, mental health, PIP and UC LCW)

Expectations upon leaving school differed by type of provision and level of need. Participants who attended mainstream schools and had mental health or neurodevelopmental conditions often left without a clear sense of what came next. Some followed peers into college by default, without considering whether it was the right option for them, while others felt too distressed by their school experiences to plan for the future. This included instances of bullying or support promised by the school not being delivered. In contrast, participants who attended special schools (or their appointees) often believed from a young age that their options were limited, with specialist further education seen as the only realistic next step.

“He needed a bit of time to just heal himself from the whole school experience.”
(Appointee of: 22, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC LCWRA)

For participants with complex health conditions, families described having little agency over post‑school decisions. Appointees said they were often waiting to be told by the local authority about what provision would be allocated, rather than being the primary decision-maker. Provisions included local authority-funded day centre programmes, special further education colleges, or supported living arrangements. These families felt excluded from decisions and uncertain about what the transition would involve.

3.6 Why some participants did not progress beyond school

In general, 3 factors explain why some participants did not go on to further education, training or work.

The first was the direct impact of health conditions. For some, health had deteriorated during or immediately after school to the point where any structured activity was not possible. This included periods of being bedbound, admission to mental health units, or acute health crises around the point they left school. For others, conditions had not been adequately supported during school years as a result of health-related absence and inadequate support when they were attending, leaving them behind their peers in terms of qualifications and confidence. Participants with complex health conditions (or their appointees) were confident that further education or employment was not a realistic option, and their transition from school or post-16 education was directly into care or supported living.

The second factor was limited information about available pathways. This was most evident for those who had stopped attending school before transition support was offered and left without clear next steps. It also affected families navigating specialist provision, who described having to identify options themselves, rather than being guided at the point of transition.

Even when information was available, participants described limited viable routes. Participants with neurodevelopmental or mental health conditions said that college and sixth-form settings were not adapted to their needs, replicating difficulties they had experienced in mainstream school. While specialist provision existed, families often did not know about it, had difficulty accessing it due to local authority funding constraints, or found it was unavailable locally. Participants with physical health conditions or learning disabilities who required specialist further education described limited places and long waiting times.

3.7 Summary

Health conditions affected attendance and ability to participate at school

For some participants, periods of absence were short, while for others, the knock-on effect was substantial and equated to missed learning and lower attainment. Some linked participation at school directly to periods of health deterioration.

Recognition of health needs improved outcomes, while lack of recognition led to disengagement

Early identification, effective adjustments, and supportive staff enabled participation. Where conditions were undiagnosed or misunderstood, participants could be labelled as disruptive or unmotivated. This contributed to frustration, anger and feelings of being misunderstood.

Peer relationships shaped experiences at school

Supportive friendships enabled attendance and participation. However, experiences of bullying and social isolation were common. They contributed to reduced attendance, poor mental health, and at times movement into alternative provision. Others left education completely.

Support for post-school transition was inconsistent and not tailored to the individual

Some described limited guidance on next steps and viable options. Participants were left feeling unprepared for adult life and unclear about the available pathways beyond school. Some entered further education without clear direction or because their peers had, while others could not access suitable provision, leading to later disengagement.

These factors contributed directly to pathways into becoming NEET

Health challenges, unmet support needs, negative experiences with peers, and gaps in transition support impacted on attendance, attainment and mental health, and interacted with each other to shape participants’ routes out of education.

4. Experiences of further and higher education

This chapter explores participants’ experiences of further and higher education. It focuses on how they decided whether and where to take part, and the factors that affected whether they could access and continue in education. Experiences of higher education were limited within the sample, so the discussion focuses primarily on further education. Participants who did not take part in any further or higher education are not covered here; their reasons for non-engagement are discussed in Section 3.6.

4.1 Journeys into further and higher education

Participants who entered further education did so across a range of settings and provision types. Many followed non-linear pathways, moving between courses or providers, withdrawing and re-engaging at different points. This related to struggling with the course because of their health needs, not enjoying the course they had enrolled in, or promised support not being provided.

Those from mainstream schools typically progressed to mainstream colleges, sixth forms or special colleges. Others undertook non-accredited skills courses (such as digital marketing, computer programming, and sewing), or employability courses aimed at preparing them for work. Some then progressed to university.

Participants who had attended special schools or alternative education provision moved into special colleges, mainstream colleges with dedicated SEND provision, or one-to-one education accessed via their EHCP.

4.2 Decision-making around further and higher education

Participants decided whether and where to attend further education based on their work aspirations, alongside advice and support from schools, other professionals, and family or friends. Participants who aspired to work tended to choose educational or vocational courses aligned with their ambitions. In contrast, those without clear plans sometimes entered further education without a strong sense of purpose, following a path guided by others rather than their own interests. At times, this led to participants withdrawing from their course, though health conditions were typically also a factor.

The role of schools in providing transition support is discussed in Chapter 3. This section focuses on support from other professionals and informal networks.

Other professional support

Support from professionals outside of schools helped some participants identify suitable further education options. Some reported that JCP Work Coaches guided them towards specific courses in line with their career aspirations, whereas others who had EHCPs in place noted how they had input from the council to help identify provisions that would suit their health condition. This support increased awareness of opportunities, which participants without such support said they lacked.

Informal support from family and friends

Family and friends played an influential role in shaping decisions on further education. Some provided helpful advice to help them select a course they would enjoy and benefit from studying. Similarly, friends also offered advice, signposting them to courses they were doing themselves.

However, some participants described their family as steering them towards further education courses that did not align with their interests. Participants said this negatively affected their motivation and led some to later reconsider their choices and move course.

“My mum had a very big influence in my first year at college. […] I’ve had different family members try and […] convince me to do other things, whereas, instead of sticking to my guns and going, ‘No, this is what I want to do.’ […] it’s landed me in a few situations where […] I just cannot be arsed […]. As soon as that [feeling] kicks in, then it’s game over for me.”
(Customer, 24, mental health, PIP and UC LCW)

4.3 Accessing further and higher education

Participants could not always enrol on their preferred further education pathways. In some cases, suitable provision was simply not available or accessible. In other cases, participants’ prior educational attainment limited their options, and for others, financial insecurity was a barrier. Among those facing financial insecurity, some opted to enrol on an apprenticeship instead. This is discussed in Chapter 5.

Availability and accessibility of settings and courses

Whether suitable courses were available and accessible determined whether participants could enrol in further education. Appointees described struggling to find suitable settings for young people whose needs did not fit existing offers. This was most evident for some young people with neurodevelopmental conditions. These participants did not require physical support, but needed more structure, smaller groups, or tailored teaching approaches than in mainstream settings. At the same time, their needs were not considered severe enough for special colleges, which focused on students requiring significant support. In some instances, this left participants without a suitable option.

Where courses were available, practical factors then affected participants’ ability to attend. For example, how far participants lived from a further education provider shaped whether they could attend, with those living outside towns or cities having fewer nearby options or facing long travel times to get there.

“[The issue is] just finding [courses] that’s available. I don’t live in the middle of London or anything, so there’s not a lot of stuff going on.”
(Customer, 21, mental health, PIP and UC LCW)

In contrast, the provision of funded travel supported participants with complex health conditions to get to and from their specialist setting. Where funding for travel was withdrawn, this could prevent access to further education.

“If you cancel all the special needs transport, nobody is ever going to get anywhere. Those children are not going to get their rightful access to education.”
(Appointee of: 22, long-term condition, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Eligibility constraints within specialist provision also created additional barriers. Some participants with complex health needs were unable to continue in specialist settings once they reached a certain age or had completed a fixed number of years, despite still benefiting from and wanting to continue with education that was tailored to their needs.

“It’s a bit treading water because she was at […] the special needs college here, but they’ll only have them for three or four years max. […] The new one she’s just started at […] they keep plonking her in front of the telly [… and] it doesn’t push her.”
(Appointee of: 22, long-term condition, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Prior attainment

Participants’ previous academic attainment affected their confidence around further education. Those who had achieved lower grades often then doubted their academic ability and felt less confident about managing the demands of further education. While it didn’t deter participants from applying, it did make applying or starting courses feel more difficult.

“I think at first, I did want to [go to university], and then my GCSE results [weren’t] as I expected. I expected to do better than I did, and it put me off going into further education, in a way, because […] I thought, ‘If I’ve tried my best and it’s not happened, then it’s going to be the same in college and university’.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Some participants managed to access sixth form despite their prior academic results meaning they did not meet formal academic entry requirements. This occurred where schools had considered their individual circumstances, particularly where they were already familiar with participants from school.

Funding and financial support

Financial circumstances also shaped decisions about entering further education. For some participants, receiving disability benefits enabled access by covering travel costs that would otherwise have made it impossible to attend. They also helped to pay for course materials.

“If I did not have the [disability benefits] that I did, then I don’t think I would have got as far […] I can buy things, like taxis, to get to my courses.”
(Customer, 23, multiple conditions, UC LCWRA)

In contrast, financial insecurity meant some participants prioritised paid work over further education when they left school. Although not unique to this group, participants reported that this was particularly the case when they had fixed outgoings to pay, such as housing costs. Some reflected that, had they accessed PIP earlier, they might have been able to stay in education.

“I probably would have liked to go uni and do, like, architecture, design skyscrapers and stuff, or just something within construction. […Accessing PIP earlier] would have helped me a lot. It would have definitely helped me a lot. My whole kind of journey in my life would have […] been a lot different.”
(Customer, 24, long-term condition, PIP)

4.4 Participation in further and higher education

Participation in further education was shaped by participants’ ability to take part, their experiences with peers, and the availability of support and accommodations. When these were lacking, participants typically had to leave education, contributing to them becoming NEET.

Capacity to participate and remain in further and higher education

Physical capacity

Participants with physical health conditions described limitations that meant they could not complete tasks required on their further education course. Some were unable to carry out practical elements, particularly activities that required sustained physical effort, dexterity or coordination, and needed support from others to complete them. Additionally, participants with chronic fatigue described being unable to sustain full days of attendance, even when they were interested and motivated.

“I actually had to stop [attending college] because of my own mental health and other health […]. I have the intellect but not the health capacity to do what my brain is capable of.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Cognitive and processing capacity

Cognitive and processing difficulties, including those associated with learning disabilities, memory loss and ADHD, affected participants’ ability to engage with course content. Some struggled to retain course material, despite interest and effort with the course. For participants with autism, challenges sometimes arose from how information was communicated to them. Where instructions from teachers were understood literally and deemed to be too intense of an ask, participants withdrew from their course.

“He was doing mechanics at college and […] they said to him, ‘Each car has got a different engine and you’ve got to learn each different engine.’ But he took it as […] you’ve got to learn that engine and you’ve got to learn that engine and that engine so they’re all different. He said, ‘Mum, I’m not going to be able to learn them all.’ He packed it in.”
(Appointee of: 21, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Independence

The transition to further education, particularly university, exposed difficulties with living independently that had not always been apparent at school. When placed into a new environment without support, some were unable to manage daily living tasks, which in some instances progressed into an inability to care for themselves.

“His [university] bedroom was an absolute mess. He couldn’t even get in the bed, and there was just stuff piled everywhere. He hadn’t eaten properly. By the fourth week, I contacted the housing accommodation officer and said, ‘You need to check on him, there’s something not right.’ And yes, we ended up having to go and get him and bring him home, and he just had a full-blown breakdown. Went to the GP and the GP said, ‘Yes, this isn’t okay.’ We had to take him out of university.”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment) [footnote 8].

Health deterioration and withdrawal

For some participants, the demands of further education exceeded their physical, cognitive, or emotional capacity, particularly where courses did not adequately accommodate their needs. Participants described struggling to keep up with attendance, coursework or social demands, and some said their health worsened as a result. This was most evident among participants with mental health and neurodevelopmental conditions, who described further education as overwhelming and stressful. In some cases, participation made existing conditions worse, leading to periods of crisis and extended recovery, which had not always been achieved by the time of interview.

This pattern was also reflected among the few participants who enrolled in university, none of whom completed their course. All attributed their withdrawal to health-related reasons rather than academic difficulty.

Experiences with peers

Social experiences in further education shaped participation, mirroring the patterns described in Chapter 3.

In specialist further education settings, social experiences were generally more positive than in mainstream provision. Being among peers with similar conditions reduced isolation and increased feelings of belonging. Positive relationships with teachers also contributed to these experiences.

In mainstream further education, social challenges were more common, particularly for those who had experienced isolation or bullying at school and had limited recent experience of peer interaction. For participants who had been home-schooled following bullying, returning to college brought the additional difficulty of relearning social norms with little preparation.

Some appointees mitigated these challenges by providing practical support, such as encouraging family members or friends to attend courses alongside participants. This was viewed as a way to increase confidence and enable attendance. However, this was not possible for everyone, and some noted leaving further education to escape the social interaction element, either going on to an apprenticeship or becoming NEET.

Availability of support and accommodations

Participants were more able to stay in further education when high-quality support and accommodations were available. Where appropriate support was in place, for example, where special colleges offered highly supported placement opportunities, participants with complex conditions remained in education for longer. Where it was absent or inadequate, participants tended to drop out.

Case study

Jane is a 24-year-old PIP customer who has cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairments, which were diagnosed when she was young. She received consistent support throughout her time in mainstream education, including access to a specialist resource base in primary school, 1:1 teaching assistant support in secondary school, and an EHCP, which worked for her. She went on to attend college, where she disclosed her condition and teaching staff put in place adjustments, such as written instructions displayed around the building as memory prompts. Jane described feeling genuinely supported throughout her education journey. Her long-term goal was to work once her child was older and she could find a role that worked around them and her health needs.

Disability awareness among teaching and support staff

Where staff had disability-specific knowledge, participants and their appointees described responsive relationships and a sense of being understood. In contrast, when settings used general teaching staff with only occasional specialist input, or none at all, the quality of support fell below what participants and appointees had expected and was not sufficient to meet complex needs. In special schools, this related particularly to knowledge of SEND.

Reasonable adjustments

Where reasonable adjustments were in place and effective, participants were better able to attend and stay in education. Adjustments included smaller classes, options to work independently, specialist equipment, rest breaks, exam adjustments and one-to-one support workers. In cases where adjustments had been promised but not delivered, participants struggled to cope and, in some cases, had to leave, contributing to them becoming NEET.

“[Because of his visual impairment] he was supposed to have a buddy, and they never paired him up with anyone. […] He couldn’t find his way around the college, to the point he wasn’t going to toilet all day because he didn’t know where it was. They didn’t obviously want to put in the level of support that he needed […] so he decided not to go, and that’s when he started this whole Universal Credit journey.”
(Appointee of: 22, long-term condition, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Flexible and personalised learning arrangements

Some participants said remote and online learning made attendance easier when going in-person felt too difficult. This was most common for those with conditions such as social anxiety, irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), ADHD and agoraphobia. Being able to learn online allowed them to work at their own pace, avoid travel-related anxiety associated with commuting to a setting, and manage their health without the pressure of fixed attendance.

Some participants needed highly personalised educational approaches. For example, participants with pathological demand avoidance (a characteristic experienced by some people with autism in which they have a persistent and marked resistance to demands and instructions) said they struggled to follow standard teaching approaches, regardless of the subject or setting. They were more able to take part when they could choose what to work on and when, rather than being set tasks by a teacher. This type of approach was only available through specialist community college provision. When this ended due to age limits, there were no similar options available.

Transition support

Transitions within further education were identified as points where engagement was more at risk, particularly for participants with mental health conditions. Key transition points included the move from remote to in-person learning during the COVID-19 pandemic, the shift from structured school environments to flexible university settings, or the loss of familiar teachers. During these, if support for the change was not available or ineffective, anxiety increased and led some participants to withdraw from the course.

“Everywhere was locked down […] I didn’t know anybody on that course whatsoever. Then the second year […] I went in, finally found my classroom, sat down to a complete group of strangers, and then [was] just expected to do group work like nothing ever happened. […] I just couldn’t do it. I’d end up just staying silent and then it just looked like I was being ignorant and not contributing […] because of my social anxiety […] that ultimately led to me not going to classes and eventually I ended up dropping out.”
(Customer, 24, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA) [footnote 9]

4.5 Why some participants did not progress beyond further or higher education

In general, 4 factors explain why some participants did not go on to participate in training or work.

The first was the direct impact of health conditions. Like experiences at school, for some, health deteriorated during or as a direct result of attempting to participate in further education. This was most evident among participants with mental health and neurodevelopmental conditions, some of whom described their time in further education as overwhelming and stressful. Despite an interest in the course content and motivation to study, this led to an eventual withdrawal from education.

The second related to gaps in support. This included reasonable adjustments being ineffective or not being provided, staff not having disability-specific knowledge that may have enabled them to support participants, or inadequate support provided at key transition stages, such as the shift from in person to remote learning. The result of this meant that participants felt unable to continue in further education and withdrew.

Some participants felt that completing further education courses had not brought them closer to their goal of securing work. In some cases, promised elements such as employer visits or work experience placements did not materialise, reducing the perceived value of courses as an avenue to employment. Even where participants expected the skills gained as part of their further education course to improve their job prospects, some continued to face the same health-related barriers. As a result, a gap remained between course completion and work readiness, contributing to a return to NEET status.

Finally, some participants in specialist further education said they exhausted the provision available to them. This was particularly the case where reaching a specific age or being at a college for a set number of years meant that provision had to end. For some, namely those with more complex health conditions, this marked the end of engagement with education, with no transition planning or next step in place.

“That 19 to 25 SEND strategy is an afterthought because they’re still trying to sort out what happens early years on all the way up to the end of secondary education and sixth form education and trying to get provision right in there. It’s a gap.”
(Appointee of: 22, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

4.6 Summary

Difficulty getting into further and higher education was influenced by the availability of accessible courses, prior academic attainment and affordability

Participants could not always enrol on preferred courses due to limited provision that was suitable for their health needs, travel constraints, or financial pressures. Some did not meet entry requirements, reflecting difficulties experienced while at school.  

For those who did enrol in further education, some experienced difficulties being able to sustain participation:

  • health conditions shaped their ability to continue, with physical, mental health and cognitive challenges affecting both attendance and engagement – where course demands were higher than they could manage, participants’ health worsened and they struggled to remain in education
  • support, adjustments and learning environments also influenced whether participants could remain – where provision was tailored, staff understood participants’ health needs, and appropriate adjustments were in place, participants were better able to attend and stay enrolled. Where support was absent or ineffective, withdrawal was common
  • reflecting difficulties at school, social experiences shaped engagement. In specialist settings, being around peers with similar conditions increased feelings of belonging – in contrast, social challenges in mainstream provision were evident, and some left completely to avoid social interaction

Difficulties were also encountered when progressing from further and higher education into work:

  • gaps remained between completion of further education and gaining a job. Reasons included promised elements of courses not materialising, like work experience opportunities or employer visits, reducing the perceived value of courses and skills gained
  • even where participants said they did gain skills, ongoing health-related barriers prevented some from entering work

As a result, further education represented another point where future participation in education, training or work could falter

Challenges carried over from school interacted with new barriers, limiting progression and contributing to becoming NEET.

5. Experiences of training and employment

Please note, this chapter contains mention of suicide or self-harm which some readers may find distressing.

This chapter explores participants’ experiences of formal vocational training and paid employment. It focuses on their decision-making and motivation to engage with training and/or employment, facilitators to accessing opportunities, and participants’ reasons for disengagement. It is important to bear in mind that these data are drawn from a small number of interviews, which varied in terms of topic coverage and level of detail. The views and experiences discussed are not exhaustive or generalisable to the wider population. Participants who had not engaged in any formal training or employment, which is most participants in this study, are not covered in this chapter; barriers to their participation are discussed in Chapter 7.

5.1 Training journeys

Participants discussed 2 types of vocational training: short placements that were part of college courses they attended (discussed in Chapter 4), and formal apprenticeships. A small proportion of participants undertook apprenticeships, doing so as an alternative to sixth form/college, either directly after school, or after first attempting to attend college.

A key reason for engaging in apprenticeships rather than further education was financial: participants did not have access to other sources of income or financial support (from family or benefits, for example), meaning they felt unable to attend further education. Another reason was the accessibility and suitability of the delivery of the course: some apprenticeships could be completed largely online, which was preferred by participants who had found that standard classroom settings and interaction with peers triggered their anxiety.

“I went to try […] college, but I wasn’t able to attend […] it was really daunting and I was like always hiding in the toilets and I couldn’t fathom it, at all. So I ended up doing an NVQ [National Vocational Qualification] through an apprenticeship […] a lot of the work I was doing from home, and […] the assessor came to me. So, I never […] had to be around other people my age.”
(Customer, 23, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Participants did not detail how they found out about or accessed these apprenticeships, although some reported that their decision was influenced by peers who were doing the same thing.

Experiences and outcomes of training

Participants’ financial circumstances sometimes dictated whether they were able to complete training. Struggling to cover their living expenses and knowing they might be able to access better-paid employment led some to leave part-way through. They said that receiving benefits earlier may have enabled them to complete their training.

“If I was taking PIP at the time, I probably would have completed my apprenticeship, but I had to go to [… work] that paid me a lot more.”
(Customer, 24, long-term condition, PIP)

Completing the training was not itself a direct route into work. One participant noted they were not guaranteed a paid role with their placement employer upon completion of the course, and said they had to wait for confirmation of their qualification before they were eligible to apply for roles elsewhere.

“I looked for work for about eight months […] after my apprenticeship finished. […] They didn’t want to pay me as full-time staff, so as soon as my apprenticeship finished, I had to leave. […] I was left with nothing, because I couldn’t get the job [I wanted…] until I’d already had my qualification, which didn’t come through […] for about two months […] I had to wait for the certificate and everything to be marked.”
(Customer, 23, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

5.2 Experiences of employment

Participants who had some previous experience of paid employment had worked across a wide range of sectors, roles, and working arrangements, including ad hoc, temporary and longer-term positions. All had worked in 2 or more roles. Some had followed a linear pathway, progressing from school into vocational training and then into work. Others followed more non-linear pathways, combining work and education at the same time, returning to education after periods of employment, or making multiple attempts to work across different sectors, with each spell ending because of health issues.

Participants’ prior work experience included:

  • health and social care (for example, in support worker and hospital healthcare assistant roles)
  • manual labour (in warehouses or construction roles)
  • retail and customer services (including roles in shops, banks, or on helplines)
  • hospitality (including working in cafes)
  • office administration

Accessing employment

Participants talked about 3 ways in which they had accessed employment: finding work directly through their contacts, including family and friends; applying for advertised roles; and progressing directly from a college placement into a paid role offered by the same employer.

Some participants found that accessing opportunities through their networks allowed them to circumvent application processes which felt onerous.

“I was […] at an advantage because I didn’t have to sit an interview […] sitting in interviews is okay once you’re there, but it’s motivating yourself to actually do it [that I struggle with]. The thought of having an interview absolutely terrifies me, and I’d only ever had one interview before that, and it lasted about ten minutes! So, I didn’t really have any experience.”
(Customer, 20, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Where they did complete formal applications, however, some participants said that tailored individual support to help familiarise and prepare them was instrumental to their success. Examples included help to draft CVs, cover letters, and applications, as well as interview practice sessions. Participants most commonly accessed this support through college, noting that it exceeded what they had been able to find through JCP or other professional services. Alongside this, participants said that gaining qualifications they had not completed at school (such as English and Maths) helped them move into work. These too were typically accessed through college provision.

“It sounds silly, [but] being young [I didn’t really understand] how to […] make a CV […] I didn’t really know much about IT. Because of the bullying, my parents didn’t […] give me a phone, for social media […] so I didn’t really know how to use a lot of tech […] It was [my college] that helped me apply for the new job […] They helped me write things and prepare, they prepared me for an interview […] they did practises where there’d be like four of them trying to interview me, just to prepare me for it.”
(Customer, 23, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Some family members also provided extensive support at the application stage. For some whose neurodevelopmental and mental health conditions affected their focus and communication, appointees described, for example, supervising completion of the application form; accompanying them to the interview; and liaising directly with the prospective employer to discuss their support needs. This was important to overcome barriers to entry that related to the individuals’ health-related challenges around concentration, anxiety, and interpretation of social cues.

“I helped him get the job: I had been emailing with the boss, and between me and [my son], we [did] the interview. [Otherwise…] we’d get to the interview stage and it would fall apart, because of communication problems and all of his anxieties.”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP) [footnote 10].

What young people wanted from work

Young people described wanting work that balanced practical needs with personal wellbeing and a sense of fulfilment. Preferences were shaped by the need to earn money, the importance of roles feeling manageable alongside their health, opportunities for appropriate level of social interaction, and a desire to find work that felt meaningful.

Some were motivated primarily by a need to support themselves financially. Others sought work that aligned with their longer-term career aspirations and desire to engage in roles they found meaningful and intellectually stimulating. This contributed to a sense of purpose and fulfilment.

Others said a key priority was work that would be manageable in terms of their health condition and other commitments. Some participants started off in ad hoc or part-time roles, limiting the hours they worked to manage their energy and capacity. Some struggled to strike the balance between earning and managing health impacts, however. Attempts to increase their working hours over time were not always manageable with their health. Some participants had a clear idea of the kind of work they wanted to do or gained insight in previous roles about types of work that were to be avoided as they were more likely to worsen their mental or physical health.

“I couldn’t have something that was too mundane because of my ADHD […] I worked at [a supermarket] at one point on cashier, and I was so bored it made me depressed, which can happen with ADHD.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Levels of interaction and contact with colleagues or customers were also important. Some found that a high degree of autonomy and independence was their preferred way of working for them, as they were better able to manage effects on their energy/fatigue and social anxiety when they could work largely alone. Other participants discussed a desire to interact with colleagues and/or a need for consistent support.

Reasonable adjustments at work

Few participants spoke in detail about adjustments to facilitate their work in paid positions. More commonly, they discussed finding roles they anticipated would suit their skills and capacity – including, for example, part-time or flexible work arrangements, work they could do from home, or employment that offered higher or lower levels of contact with colleagues or customers.

It was not always clear whether or to what extent participants disclosed health conditions and/or specific support needs to employers. Some described instances where they were reprimanded by colleagues who had misinterpreted their coping strategies as evidence of distraction or work avoidance, for example, suggesting that these issues had not been openly discussed.

“I was always going to the toilet, so they’d accuse me of being on my phone, but unbeknownst [to them, I was going there because] I was just really shaky […] I lost quite a lot of sleep because I was quite anxious […about going] into work […] that was something that happened practically every night. So, I was […] prescribed sleeping tablets […] to try and help make sure I was okay to go to work.”
(Customer, 23, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Other participants had discussed their health condition or disability with their employers and felt they had been clear about tasks they felt unable to do, but felt pressured nonetheless. Even when adjustments had been in place, these were not always maintained. Participants described, for example, increased workload following company growth and personnel changes, and reduced accommodation of adjustments to their role.

“The company was growing […] which meant I was busier [and…] they didn’t understand the things that I couldn’t do […] I [had] said from the start that I hate doing phone calls, and I can’t [do work involving the phone…] it just became sort of like a, ‘Well, you’ve got to do it, because we need the income to be coming in.’ […] Because they never struggled to do it and […] can just pick up the phone and call anyone, […] they couldn’t understand why someone else would struggle with that […] I did tell them. I did say, ‘I’m struggling’, and they said, ‘It’s a priority, though’.”
(Customer, 20, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Finally, some participants were clear that they had not disclosed their condition or asked for adjustments, driven by both a limited understanding of their own needs and a desire to overcome any challenges independently. Reliance on self-identification and disclosure may therefore result in key opportunities for intervention being missed.

“I wasn’t very open [about my health or support needs], because I just thought I could get over it and conquer it and be a man, sort of thing […] Now, obviously, I understand that in that sort of job [I would need support and] I’ll make sure I [have] got things in place, [… but it’s] probably only since last year that I [have understood,] like, ‘Oh, I was born with disabilities […] this is why a lot of these things affected me’. [… It] took me a while to understand what all these people are helping me for, and I used to be against these people, just because I didn’t know how to ask or […] receive help.”
(Customer, 24, long-term conditions, PIP)

5.3 Reasons for leaving work

Some participants or their employers came to a realisation that employment they had taken on was not suitable for them due to their particular health conditions and disabilities – including cognitive, physical, and mental health conditions. Particularly where participants had limited support to help manage their symptoms, their conditions had a marked effect on their ability to engage effectively in work.

Cognitive capacity

Among those with cognitive or neurodevelopmental health conditions and disabilities, some participants struggled to meet typical workplace expectations due to difficulties around understanding rules and social dynamics as well as with taking on unfamiliar tasks independently.

Without step-by-step guidance and individual support, participants struggled to acclimatise to the workplace and made frequent mistakes. This led to negative experiences with colleagues who were unhappy about picking up additional work, causing additional strain on participants’ confidence and wellbeing, all of which fed into worsening mental health.

“If you’re the one person that isn’t […] seen to be pulling your weight, which is how [he] came across, I think everybody was just a bit fed up of it, and he could feel that. So he came home every day feeling deflated and not quite knowing why […] or what he’d done wrong.”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment) [footnote 11]

Physical capacity

Some participants with physical health conditions described limitations that affected their ability to work. Communication barriers were an issue for those with physical disabilities such as hearing impairments, which participants said led to missed instructions and errors. In retrospect, they felt that they couldn’t perform certain roles safely, suggesting misalignment between the nature of their work, their skills, and level of support or adjustments they had been able to access.

“It was dangerous […] using power tools, I [could] have hurt others around me [… because] I couldn’t hear people around me […] not hearing people, not following instructions properly [… I would] be […] told to do something, and then I’d just completely mess it up because I heard it wrong.”
(Customer, 24, long-term conditions, PIP)

Those with conditions involving fatigue reported experiences of debilitating exhaustion resulting from exertion involved in both in-person and remote work, which made consistent engagement impossible.

“I worked in [a supermarket for] three months […] 16 hours, 4 hours a day! I thought, ‘Yes, easy. Easy peasy. That’ll be fine’, [… but] I’m surprised I lasted three months, to be honest. I was just […] bedbound the days I wasn’t in work. It was basically bed to work and then that was it.”
(Customer, 22, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Mental health

Deterioration in mental health was a common reason for having left work. Some participants were already struggling with poor mental health, and the additional pressure of employment served as a tipping point at which this became unmanageable, particularly for those with limited access to support.

“I didn’t work there for too long […] my head just went funny one day and […] I just couldn’t face anyone. I just said, ‘I can’t do it’, then I left. I think I was struggling with self-harm and […] I was quite suicidal and whatnot, so it was just my [mental health]. I just couldn’t actually work. It was just awful.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, UC LCWRA) [footnote 12].

For some, impacts on their mental health were directly linked with their efforts to engage with work, particularly where roles were unsuitable for them, workloads increased and support or reasonable adjustments were not provided. Some chose to move away from work before this escalated to a crisis point, but others attempted to continue until it was no longer viable.

“He was there less than a month before […] he had […] another mental breakdown […His boss] emailed and said ‘This isn’t going to work. He just can’t cope with the pace. It’s too much pressure on him and he’s just not going to manage’.”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP) [footnote 13].

“The amount that they were asking me to do just became ridiculous. […] I got to the point where I took a week off sick and that was that. […] I just decided I couldn’t go back […] I was very low! I was anxious all the time, and […] I thought, ‘It’s not worth me sacrificing my mental health for a job’.”
(Customer, 20, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Inadequate workplace support

Participants with mental health and neurodevelopmental conditions in particular described situations where their employer did not accept or understand the adjustments they needed. Examples included employers not accommodating flexible working or time off during periods of ill health, or being reprimanded for symptoms of their conditions, such as memory loss. In these cases, the lack of support and sense of being misunderstood were detrimental to their wellbeing, and in some instances contributed to them leaving work.

Purpose, fulfilment and motivation

Participants wanted work to feel meaningful, and a lack of job satisfaction was a key reason some left roles.

Some participants felt their work was insufficiently varied or challenging to sustain their interest over time. Others indicated that roles did not align with their values – for example, working as a salesperson trying to upsell in the context of the cost-of-living crisis felt increasingly uncomfortable. In these cases, participants left with the expectation that they could find work better aligned with their longer-term goals. They had either been unable to do so, or this had been superseded by a more urgent need to prioritise their health and wellbeing.

“Health-wise, I couldn’t cope, but I also knew that if I had the health, [the job] wasn’t challenging enough. Because of what I’ve gone through, I’d like to help others emotionally […] but [that role] didn’t offer that.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

5.4 Summary


As seen throughout participants’ journeys, health conditions shaped whether they could access, participate and continue in work

Physical health, mental health and cognitive challenges affected their attendance, performance, and ability to sustain employment, particularly where job demands exceeded capacity.

Work was not always aligned with participants’ health needs

Some entered roles that were unsuitable from the beginning, including jobs which required sustained physical effort, high levels of social interaction, or fast-paced environments. Where these were unmanageable, some participants left employment.

Access to reasonable adjustments was influenced by whether health conditions were disclosed and how employers responded

Some relied on focusing their job search on selecting roles they perceived to be manageable, rather than looking more widely and seeking formal adjustments. In other instances, health conditions were not always disclosed and, where they were, employers did not consistently recognise or respond appropriately, reducing access to support.

Sustaining employment was therefore often difficult

Roles ended due to the interaction of health deterioration, unmet support needs, and job demands that did not align with their health-related capacity.

Again, supportive relationships and tailored support enabled more positive experiences

Support from family, friends and professionals to find jobs, complete applications and attend interviews helped some individuals access work. Flexible and/or tailored workplace approaches that accommodated health needs enabled them to remain.

6. Current activities and future aspirations

This chapter focuses on what participants were doing at the time of interview to try to access education, training and/or work. It explores how they viewed the purpose of work, what a good life looked like to them, and their aspirations for the future. Barriers to engaging in work, training and education and participants’ support needs are covered in Chapter 7.

Some participants with more stable or managed health conditions were actively attempting to engage by seeking employment, applying for courses, or volunteering to build skills. Others expressed clear aspirations for the future but were not yet able to pursue them, due to health conditions, caring responsibilities or the need for appropriate support to be in place first. A final group were not attempting to engage and, in most cases, did not view participation in education, training or work as feasible, either in the short term or at all.

Actively engaging in education, training or work

These participants were either looking for roles and courses independently, with family, or with support from their Work Coach. Some spoke about this process positively and were motivated to find a job or education course that suited them. Others were dejected and felt that there were not many available work opportunities that would suit their health conditions.

Participants seeking both educational courses and employment had an awareness of how they would need to fit around their health conditions. They described being selective about the course and roles they pursued based on the tasks involved, working environment and hours required.

“I’ve basically come to the conclusion that face-to-face university is just not for me [so] I’ve had a look into the Open University. […] They’re going to put me on the next cohort […], to study […] physics. […] With it all being online and distance-learning, I do feel like I’ve got a better shot.”
(Customer, 24, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA) [footnote 14]

Some with health conditions that were more stable were volunteering as a way of building confidence and skills relevant to the roles they hoped to move into.

“I’m absolutely loving [volunteering at the florist]. It’s a little bit physically demanding, but I am really enjoying it. […] I’m building my confidence. I’ve began answering the phone and actually sorting out orders slowly, and greeting customers when they come in.”
(Customer, 23, multiple conditions, UC LCWRA)

Benefits also interacted with their thinking around work in positive ways. One view was that having a stable income through benefits allowed them to focus on skills-building, volunteering, or job searching, without the immediate pressure of needing to generate income. This enabled them to find employment opportunities which were more sustainable long-term, rather than having to prioritise shorter-term immediate income. Others said the desire to stop claiming benefits and earn independently motivated them to seek work. This was either because they expected to be better off financially in employment; valued the independence and sense of self-reliance associated with earning their own income; or wished to avoid repeated benefit applications, which they described as an onerous process.

“I don’t want to be on some form of financial support. It’s really the last resort for me at the minute. […] It’s kind of something I keep to myself. It is a bit embarrassing. […] I wouldn’t kick up a fuss if [DWP] said, ‘You’re earning now. We’re going to cut your [Universal] Credit.’ […] If anything, I’d be grateful for that, because then I could tell people that I’m earning my own money.”
(Customer, 21, mental health, PIP and UC LCW)

Aspiring to engage with education, employment, or training, but not yet in a position to do so

Participants were either unable to pursue education, employment or training because of their health, or because of wider circumstances. The first group of participants shared 2 characteristics: a sense of what they wanted to do for work, and a health condition that needed to improve before they could pursue it. For those with mental health conditions, this was needing their health condition to stabilise. For participants with physical health or neurodevelopmental conditions, it was the need for appropriate support systems to be in place, such as access to healthcare professionals, social care support, and suitable medication.

“The ultimate goal for her is to work in mental health […] that’s not in the near future […] because […] she’s unable at the moment to manage her own mental health. Obviously, she can’t help others […] before she can help herself.”
(Appointee of: 22, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

“I wanted to try getting […] back into construction, but […] I’m just trying to make sure everything’s in place, for example, […] all my diagnoses, […] my social worker being in place, […] All [of] these workers [weren’t] really in place when I was younger. I’m just trying to get them all in place so I can make the best version of myself.”
(Customer, 24, long-term condition, PIP)

The other group of participants could not engage due to their wider circumstances. This was a result of other priorities that were more pressing. Examples included caring responsibilities which meant that education or work was not possible alongside the demands of childcare.

“I know we’re a long way off that at the moment, but finding something that works […] around childcare and if I am one day able to get her into a nursery or a preschool, then finding work that accommodates that as well. […] The dream is still [to] work.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP) [footnote 15]

Not currently engaging in employment and not anticipating doing so

Another group of participants reported not currently attempting to engage in education, training or work, and did not see this as a realistic future option. For participants with a severe and permanent health condition, participation in education, training or work was not feasible. This included participants with learning disabilities, uncontrolled epilepsy, or complex conditions requiring full time care.

“There is not any type of education he can do because of his health condition. […] I don’t think he can work because if he cannot go anywhere by himself, he can’t do anything. He uses one hand and the other is completely not working, and he has a learning difficulty. I don’t see any type of work he can do.”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Some appointees described young people engaging in structured activities that were not intended as a route to paid employment. These included day services, social care placements, and supported volunteering, and were viewed as an appropriate level of activity given their health needs. For these participants, the primary aspiration was consistent attendance and enjoyment of activities, rather than progression towards further education, training or employment.

6.2 Aspirations about future education, training and employment

Reflections on the purpose of work

Participants described the purpose of work in broadly consistent ways. They emphasised work as providing a sense of purpose and direction, contrasting it with experiences of inactivity or feeling “stuck” when not in employment. Work was also associated with structure and routine, helping to provide a sense of forward movement and progression.

“I really want to work. It gives me some active goal and purpose, instead of it just being the same thing over and over.”
(Customer, 23, multiple conditions, UC LCWRA)

Participants also thought that work would enable social connection. They viewed it as a way of reducing isolation by getting out of the house and meeting people. While income also mattered, participants rarely described it as the only motivator and was often not the primary one. For some, income was framed as a way to achieve independence or save money, rather than the main feature of what made work worthwhile.

“I suppose the biggest incentive for me honestly is social stuff, […] getting out of the house […], physical fitness […], the pay. Obviously, everyone wants money, but the pay wouldn’t be the worst thing in the world. I could be on pretty poor pay and I’d accept [the job].”
(Customer, 21, mental health, PIP and UC LCW)

However, work did not feature in everyone’s aspirations. Some appointees said the young people they supported had not considered employment. This was not always because of a specific barrier, but because it was not something they were interested in or prioritising at this stage of their lives.

“I don’t think he’s got any interest [in work, education or training…]. Until he changes and perhaps matures a bit […] I don’t think he’d say a lot [about what purpose works serves].”
(Appointee of: 20, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

What a ‘good life’ looks like

When describing what a ‘good life’ looked like, participants’ responses echoed similar themes. They emphasised wanting purpose, social connection, independence, stability and financial security, alongside goals that felt personally meaningful.

For some participants, a good life was described primarily in terms of happiness and relationships. For participants with mental health conditions, this was commonly described in terms of health stabilisation. For participants with neurodevelopmental conditions or learning disabilities, it was often expressed through social connection and belonging.

“Everyone thinks of success as like [a] really good job, really nice house, really nice car, stuff like that. I don’t really care about that […]. I suppose just being happy with the state that you’re in. […] I just want to be like a normal person, really! I think the best thing I can do for life is feel fine anxiety-wise.”
(Customer, 21, mental health, PIP and UC LCW)

Independence and self-sufficiency were also important elements of a good life. Participants spoke about wanting to live independently, support themselves or their family, and for some, to have a family of their own. Some who were living with their parents at the time of interview described a desire to move towards greater independence.

“I want to settle with family. I want to have a house, have my own place with kids and a wife and have a really good working job, and be able to travel the world.”
(Customer, 24, long-term condition, PIP)

Financial stability was closely linked to these aspirations. Participants often described it as a foundation that enabled independence, security and reduced stress. Those who had grown up without financial security were particularly likely to describe this as a key aspiration.

“I didn’t get [financial stability] when I was younger. I had to fight for my own survival […] I just don’t want to repeat history.”
(Customer, 24, mental health, PIP)

In contrast, for participants furthest from work, a good life was defined primarily in terms of wellbeing and safety. Their accounts focused on receiving appropriate care and support, maintaining social connection, health stabilisation where possible, and taking part in activities they enjoyed.

“Realistically, [a good life] would be to have carers who help me when I need it at reasonable times, where I have a bit more comfort and less pain, to play […] more games or make new friends, or just be able to be a bit more content and have more capacity. On a theoretical level, I would love to be independent. Not reliant on services dictating my life, such as with benefits and the stress of that.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

For those with more complex or unstable health conditions, the gap between where they were and what they considered to be a good life was large. They described how focusing more narrowly on their immediate needs and goals helped to support their wellbeing, rather than thinking about the disparity between their experience and a life that felt very out of reach.

“It can be quite depressing thinking about where my life could be because I’m not there, so it’s about focusing on the present moment. How can I rest a little bit more today? […] It’s just about those little things.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Participants’ ambitions for the future

Participants reflected both on their ‘blue sky’ ambitions for the future and on aims they considered more realistic. They described ambitions that differed in clarity, how achievable they were, and whether they were more short or long term.

Wellbeing-focused aspirations, rather than education, employment or training

Participants spoke about personal long-term ambitions they hoped to achieve. These focused on where they would live, how they would spend their time, and the kind of life they wanted to build.

“[I would] live on a little farm somewhere with the kids, away from everyone […] But [I’d] also [be] more productive in life […] I know they’re only little but it’s probably the best time to take them places and things. I just can’t do it [because of my health].”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, UC LCWRA) [footnote 16]

Participants with complex health conditions, or their appointees, said future aspirations were focused on wellbeing, quality of life and access to appropriate care, rather than employment. Their aspirations were similar to how they described a good life.

Participants with a clear direction

Participants with more stable or better managed health conditions who wanted to work tended to have a clear sense of the type of work they wanted to move into. For some, their ambitions were shaped by their own lived experience of health conditions and services they had interacted with, and they framed their goals in terms of a desire to help others. This either stemmed from positive experiences they had had with services and wanted to replicate, or a desire to provide the kind of support they felt had been lacking in their own experience. Roles in teaching, healthcare, and youth offending support were spoken about in this context.

“I’ve always wanted to be a teacher that can speak from experience, and can also pick up when other students maybe aren’t doing as well mentally, but they don’t want to talk about it, or physically. Different little things that I would have probably hoped people would have picked up on when I was younger.”
(Customer, 24, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA) [footnote 17].

Other participants with clear ambitions described interest in roles linked to their hobbies or values. This included sectors such as film, art, photography and music. They were connected to activities participants already enjoyed or felt confident pursuing.

A further group of participants wanted to work in roles linked to practical skills they had already developed through previous paid work, training or volunteering. This included participants who had previously worked as construction apprentices, or who had completed vocational courses such as welding. These roles felt achievable because participants had prior experience and confidence in the skills required. For some, working in these areas was also seen as a way to demonstrate what was possible to others with similar health conditions.

“I’ve seen quite a few jobs of NHS things or working in a court, […] where you’re assisting with things, and […] I think they use skills that I’ve already got. […] I think [I would like to do] something that uses the skills and the experience I’ve already got.”
(Customer, 20, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Where participants identified education as their future aspiration, this was described as a way of progressing towards a longer-term career goal, rather than an end in itself.

“I [have been] waiting to see if I could get a Level 1 course in floristry because you cannot be a florist without the Level 1. I [have now] completed that.”
(Customer, 23, multiple conditions, UC LCWRA)

Participants with ambitions, but no clear pathway

A distinct group of participants had clear aspirations to work but were uncertain how to pursue them. This included participants who had limited prior work experience to draw from, as well as those who had encountered repeated negative experiences in education or the workplace in the past and were worried about re-engaging as a result. Some had an idea of specific careers but did not know what their next step would be towards it; others knew they would like to work but had not identified what would suit them. The barriers these young people faced are presented in more detail in the next chapter.

6.3 Summary

Participants had aspirations to work or study but varied in their readiness to engage

While some were motivated to participate and actively looking for roles or courses, others prioritised managing their health or achieving stability before considering next steps. For some, work was not something they were interested in at this stage of their life.

Participants thought that work would provide them with a sense of purpose, enable social connection, and help them to achieve independence

While income mattered, it was rarely the only motivator to work and often not the primary one. The purpose of work reflected participants’ life aspirations more broadly which focused on very similar concepts. Participants saw work as a way of achieving these.

Those with complex health conditions described ambitions that focused on improving their wellbeing and quality of life, rather than education or employment

They focused on receiving appropriate care and support, staying connected socially, stabilising their health if possible, and participating in activities they enjoyed.

Those with more stable health conditions who wanted to work had ideas of what they wanted to do

This included working in roles shaped by their own experiences with services, such as teaching, healthcare or youth offending. Others wanted to work in roles they had already acquired skills in, either through previous work, training or volunteering opportunities. These roles felt achievable given the confidence participants had in their existing skills.

Some had ambitions to work but did not know how to get there

This included those with previous negative experiences in education or work which made re-engagement feel difficult, or those with limited prior work experience. Ambitions ranged from having specific careers they would like to pursue but not knowing what to do to get there, to knowing they would like to work but being unclear about which roles.

7. Barriers and support needs

Please note, this chapter contains mention of suicide or self-harm which some readers may find distressing.

This chapter outlines barriers participants reported facing in reaching their future goals, the support they said would help them move towards them, and who should provide it. Some were consistent with those identified in the original Work Aspirations study, whereas others were more closely linked to their age and life stage.

7.1 Barriers to achieving goals

Barriers specific to younger participants

Gaps in support, particularly at the transition to adult services

As discussed throughout this report, not all participants felt they received useful guidance and information prior to leaving school about the education, training, and employment opportunities that might be open to them, or support in accessing these. This was a major barrier to education, training and employment for some participants.

However, participants also described gaps in the transition to adult services more generally, including health services and other social services. Participants described this as a barrier to managing their health and progressing towards their goals. This affected those aiming for work, education or training, as well as those focused on simply achieving a better quality of life.

Participants and appointees described how various support systems ended abruptly at age 18, without an equivalent adult provision in place. This included the withdrawal of trusted professionals, medication, and therapeutic input that had previously been effective in managing health conditions. In some cases, participants lost access to medication entirely and were unable to have it reinstated due to long waiting lists for adult services, with GPs unable to prescribe in the absence of specialist oversight. Others described the loss of long-standing relationships with practitioners who had built trust over many years, with no replacement support available. During this period, health often deteriorated and participants felt unable to consider work or education.

“She’s been under the adult mental health services since she turned 18. [… and is] turning 23 soon. […] There’s never been anyone available.”
(Appointee of: 22, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Participants highlighted further gaps in current health support, which was often focused on managing symptoms in the short term, rather than supporting longer-term participation in education, training or work. In some cases, this contributed to a cycle where receipt of health support enabled a return to education or work, only to find their health worsened, participation was not sustainable, and they withdrew.

Challenges were also described in relation to a lack of social care and housing-related support, particularly for participants with more complex health needs. Appointees spoke about the difficulties accessing advice or guidance about care, future planning, and independent living options.

Psychological impact of negative experiences in education and employment

Participants with autism, ADHD and other cognitive or neurodevelopmental conditions described the psychological impact of previous negative experiences in education or work as a barrier to future engagement. Experiences such as bullying; feeling misunderstood; and previous attempts to engage in work that had led to rejection or health deterioration created a cycle where the prospect of trying again felt too daunting. Appointees said that rejection was directly related to symptoms of ADHD, including struggling to follow instructions while working and poor timekeeping. Some avoided settings associated with these experiences, and in some cases disengaged completely due to fear of repeating earlier failures.

For some participants, disengagement was shaped not only by negative experiences such as bullying or rejection, but by repeated experiences during education of promised support or adjustments failing to materialise in practice. This reduced trust in education providers and left participants reluctant to re-engage, even where they had initially approached new settings with optimism.

Barriers shared with other health and disability benefit customers

The impact of health conditions

Health conditions or disabilities were a central barrier to achieving goals. For those furthest from work, the severity of their conditions meant goals often focused on quality of life rather than employment. In some cases, this limited their ability to take part in structured activity or access appropriate care and support.

Health-related barriers were broadly consistent with the findings in the original Work Aspirations report. Participants closer to work said that health conditions limited the range of roles they could realistically consider, by limiting the tasks, environments and hours they could manage. Physical impairments restricted jobs involving prolonged standing or heavy lifting, while mental health or neurodevelopmental conditions could make working alongside others difficult. Where participants had co-occurring conditions, these compounded barriers by closing off options that a single condition may have left open.

“If you’ve got [a] visual impairment and not the learning difficulties, then you might be able to work from home using computers or [doing] telephone stuff… [but it’s] the combination of the two [health conditions] we are finding too much of a barrier, really.”
(Appointee of: 24, multiple conditions) [footnote 18]

Employers and the labour market

Participants whose goal was to work identified labour market barriers. Accessible roles were seen as limited, with options further narrowed by contextual factors. Those living in rural areas described fewer local opportunities, while appointees thought that technological change had reduced entry-level roles that had historically offered pathways into employment, such as filing or post room work. Appointees also described a mismatch between participants’ needs and what employers could offer in practice, in terms of pace of learning, flexibility, and workplace support.

“It would take [customer] probably weeks […] if not months to learn certain things, so I guess employers can’t really justify paying […] if you can’t do the job straightaway.”
(Appointee of: 24, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment) [footnote 19].

Some participants perceived that employer attitudes towards disability at recruitment reduced access to roles, believing that candidates requiring fewer adjustments were seen as more competitive. This was expressed as a perception rather than something directly experienced.

“Despite it being legally [required], not everyone’s willing to [make reasonable adjustments] and they will just probably ignore you. It’s like, you need a little bit extra work compared to this guy, I’ll go for the person who’s more able than you.”
(Customer, 23, multiple conditions, UC LCWRA)

The cost of training was a further barrier for those looking to build specific skills for work. Relevant courses, such as typing qualifications for administrative roles, were often unaffordable for people claiming benefits.

Financial implications

Financial concerns were a barrier for some participants whose goals included work, education or training. Some perceived that moving into work or education would leave them little, if any, better off than receiving benefits. Participants who had experienced this previously said such financial implications reduced the appeal of returning to employment.

“With full-time work, after tax and things I was earning around the same like I would sitting at home all day doing nothing, and I feel like there wasn’t much of an incentive to work when I could just sit at home and not spend money on fuel or buses or whatever to get to work.”
(Customer, 24, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Others had uncertainty about how participation would affect their entitlement. As a result, some disengaged completely due to concern that indications of interest would result in loss of benefits. Others who planned to return to work or college were unsure how their entitlement to UC would be affected, resulting in worry about covering essential bills. This didn’t affect their plan to return but did cause anxiety.

“It’s almost like he’s frightened that [his benefits are] going to be snatched away from him if he shows any indication of wanting to find a job.”
(Appointee of: 22, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC LCWRA)

7.2 Support needed to move closer to education, employment and training

Support needs specific to younger customers

Support at transition to adulthood

Participants described a need for more consistent, coordinated support when moving from children’s to adult services. As outlined in Section 7.1, support often ended at 18 without an adult equivalent, leaving gaps in health, social care and employment support at a critical stage. They emphasised continuity in medication, therapeutic input and trusted professionals to prevent deterioration and support progress towards education or work.

“If he had moved smoothly to adult mental health and was prescribed the ADHD medication, I 100 per cent think he could work. It is because he is not medicated. His brain is completely frazzled all the time. If he was medicated, he could hold down a job, no question.”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP) [footnote 20].

Emotional support and confidence building

Participants and their appointees told us that emotional and psychological barriers could be as significant as practical ones. One view was that building confidence and self-belief was important before engaging in education and/or work was realistic. Some appointees recognised that they too needed support to feel confident in encouraging the person they supported forward. Their own fears about re-engagement, rooted in what they had witnessed them go through previously, were themselves a barrier. They explained that the support they needed and had requested for themselves and the person they supported was simply not available.

“I’ve seen how much he suffered at school. I would like to be able to think of him getting a job and fulfilling everything he can be, but I also, at the same time, remember a little boy who was cutting himself [at school] with a pair of compasses, and I never want to get into that situation again.”
(Appointee of: 22, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Where participants described what confidence-building support should look like, this took 3 different forms. The first was structured exposure to situations they found daunting, such as going back to college, to gradually build familiarity. The second was peer interaction opportunities, such as small groups of similar age people meeting regularly, to develop social skills and confidence. The final was encouragement from a trusted family member with knowledge of the participant’s history and health conditions.

“I think he had such a bad experience younger, I think he carries some of that with him. […] It would have been nice if [customer] could maybe access […] some […] recommendations for online courses or self-improvement [through the Jobcentre Plus]. Anything maybe for his age group, maybe in small groups, just to learn how to mix. One afternoon a week if a few people met up and chatted to each other, something like that would be nice.”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Some participants said it was not the responsibility of JCP to deliver this support, but that signposting to relevant organisations that did would be useful. As noted, others described family as the primary source of confidence-building support, particularly where it felt essential to have a trusted family member accompanying the participant to new situations. Others felt it wasn’t possible to teach someone confidence and instead was something people had to develop internally themselves in their own time.

Support needs shared with other health and disability benefit customers

Health and social care support

Reflecting the findings of the original Work Aspirations research, participants felt that getting appropriate health support in place was one of the most important steps towards future progress. This included both enabling their engagement in work and managing their health more generally. Types of health support discussed included mental health assessments, talking therapies, and medication, for both mental and physical health conditions.

“[When] I’m mentally stable, which I’m getting [to] over time [through therapy…] I should be in a lot better position […] to pursue anything I want to pursue.”
(Customer, 24, mental health, PIP and UC LCWRA) [footnote 21].

Participants with mental health conditions said that accessing an assessment and treatment as a key step towards future participation in work. They described therapy or medication as helping to stabilise their mental health by reducing anxiety, improving concentration and building emotional resilience. Participants with ADHD shared similar thoughts about how medication would support improved focus and daily functioning.

Participants with physical health conditions described condition-specific health support that would benefit them. Examples included advanced hearing aids making communication in work settings more achievable, and medication to reduce chronic fatigue.

For participants whose goals centred on quality of life rather than work, social care support was the more pressing need. This included access to funded activities available beyond standard daytime hours, including evenings and weekends, to increase opportunities for social participation and integration in the community. Appointees also described a need for respite for family carers, to ensure the sustainability of caring arrangements which participants depended on.

“It would be nice for her to go with a support worker or somebody. They would be paid […and] she that money there to pay that support worker to take her out and give me a break. Not being horrible but it’s just […] respite for me.”
(Appointee of: 24, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC pre-WCA)

Support to identify and access opportunities

Participants described a need for hands-on, one-to-one support to guide them through the process of finding work. This went beyond signposting to opportunities and included help to identify suitable roles, write CVs, complete applications (a source of anxiety mentioned by participants), and prepare for interviews. Participants felt this should be provided by DWP/JCP, and that current provision was too generic to meet their needs.

Participants said that DWP/JCP staff needed greater knowledge of different health conditions to provide more tailored, condition-specific support. They also had clear preferences about how support should be delivered. Preferences for in-person, telephone, or online appointments differed between participants, but were always linked closely to their health needs. Some found attending the JCP in person unmanageable without accompaniment or adaptation.

Regular, low-pressure check-ins with JCP were suggested as a way to maintain engagement and prevent people from drifting, including for people in the “Limited Capability for Work-Related Activity” group, who were not required to regularly engage with a Work Coach.

“It’s easy for him to just fly under the radar and just carry on plodding on as he is for the rest of his life. Well, why don’t we just check in on him occasionally and see if there’s anything we can do to help him?”
(Appointee of: 23, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP) [footnote 22]

Participants also wanted support to move towards goals beyond education or work, such as independent living for those with complex needs. They suggested DWP could provide online signposting to relevant organisations.

Information and advice about benefits

Participants voiced a need for information about how their benefits would be affected by attempts to engage in education and work. Rather than generic information, they wanted guidance to be tailored to their specific circumstances and benefits. Access to accurate, tailored information would help reduce anxiety about potential loss of income and enable people to make informed decisions about their options.

“‘She says to me, ‘Oh God, but if I go back to college I’m going to lose my benefits, and then I’ve got to come up with £60 a day for childcare […] for all the time I’m there.’ […] We don’t know who to ask.”
(Appointee of: 20, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Linked to this, participants also discussed a need for clear information and reassurance about being able to access their benefits again if employment or learning they tried was not manageable for them. This was particularly important given the difficulties some participants had experienced in accessing health and disability support previously.

“I would like someone [from the JCP] to be able to say to him […] ‘Look, it’s okay, try this; if it doesn’t work out, you can go back on this or go back on that’.”
(Appointee of: 22, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Skills development

Participants identified a need for free or subsidised training in sector-specific skills, to help address gaps in their skills and qualifications that were preventing them reaching their desired role. These gaps were vocational rather than academic. Examples included administrative skills such as typing qualifications, animal care training, and practical skills-based learning for trades.

Participants also said that training needed to be available in a wider range of modes or formats, tailored to individual needs. Examples included opportunities to access one-to-one learning, which some felt better supported their learning than standard classroom-based teaching. Participants also discussed a need for learning approaches that relied less on written information or that offered additional support for people for whom literacy/writing were challenging.

“[When training for a job] it’s not the training, like taking her out and showing her what to do; it’s the written work, because of her dyslexia […], that’s what she would find hard […]. [It’d be good] if the government [said] that’s fine […] because you can go to this place and they will help you do your written work to get into that.”
(Appointee of: 24, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Reasonable adjustments

Participants moving towards work or education described 3 key reasonable adjustments they would need from employers and education providers.

The first related to flexibility in working patterns, needed by participants with mental health conditions and those with fluctuating physical health conditions. This included being allowed to work from home, work reduced hours on difficult days, or adjusting shift patterns without loss of earnings.

“I think he’d definitely need flexibility at work, that if he is suffering from [symptoms] that he’s got the flexibility […] to work from home or […] take TOIL or reduced hours on certain days if he’s not feeling up to it. So, he would need a high level of flexibility.”
(Appointee of: 22, long-term condition, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Participants with physical health conditions, including chronic pain, noted needing adjustments to reduce the physical demands of roles. This included limiting heavy lifting, offering seating to avoid prolonged periods of standing, and allowing regular breaks.

Finally, appointees of those with more complex neurodevelopmental conditions emphasised that structured training and ongoing supervision would be crucial to enable them to carry out tasks effectively and safely. It was not clear to some whether such intensive support would be feasible in practice, leaving them uncertain as to what participants’ futures might look like.

7.3 Summary

Two key barriers to reaching future goals were identified by this younger cohort, in comparison to the previous Work Aspirations research:

  1. Gaps in healthcare, employment and education support, particularly at transition to adulthood meant that participants were left without appropriate support, their health deteriorated and they were unable to consider participation in work.

  2. Previous negative experiences in education or employment created lasting psychological barriers to re-engagement. Bullying, being misunderstood, or previous failure damaged confidence to try again.

The remaining barriers were shared with the wider health and disability population:

As outlined throughout, the impact of health conditions remained a key barrier

They constrained the type of work participants could consider and for some, meant participation in education, training or work was not possible.

Labour market factors also hindered progress

Participants described a lack of suitable roles that could accommodate their health needs, alongside structural issues such as fewer entry-level roles, limited flexibility, and employer ability to support adjustments.

Concerns around finances and uncertainty around benefits reduced motivation to engage

Some perceived that work or education would not leave them better off financially. Others noted uncertainty about benefit rules and fear of losing income which created anxiety and discouraged participation.

The support needed to move closer to education, employment and training was understandably structured around these barriers. The support needs identified were:

  • co-ordinated and sustained support at the transition to adulthood, as provision often ended abruptly leaving young people with limited help
  • emotional and confidence-building support to re-enable engagement after negative experiences
  • access to health and social care support to stabilise conditions and make participation feel feasible – for those with goals focused on quality of life rather than employment, social care support was the more pressing need
  • hands-on, tailored one-to-one support from JCP to identify and access opportunities, including help with CVs, applications and interview preparation
  • clear, personalised advice about benefits from JCP about how participation would affect entitlement
  • access to free or subsidised skills development to address gaps in vocational skills
  • appropriate reasonable adjustments at work, including flexibility in working patterns, reduced physical demands, and structured training

8. Conclusion

This study highlights 3 closely connected findings about the experiences of young people claiming health and disability benefits who are not in education, employment or training. First, challenges accumulated over time, rather than being related to a single event. Second, challenges occurred across multiple systems that young people had contact with. And third, many had low confidence and self-esteem because of these accumulating and interacting challenges.

But not all participants felt that work was part of their future. For some of those with more complex or long-term health conditions, a focus on maintaining wellbeing and safety was more appropriate and prioritised over work.

Challenges accumulated over time

Participants’ pathways into NEET status were rarely shaped by a single event. Instead, they described challenges building up gradually over time, with earlier experiences shaping later options and outcomes. For many, these trajectories began at school. Unmet or unrecognised health needs led to difficulties engaging in lessons, periods of absence, and, in some cases, mislabelling of behaviour. These experiences often resulted in disrupted learning, which led to lower confidence and in turn, reduced attainment. This then limited access to suitable further education pathways and shaped subsequent decisions about what was possible.

Difficulties often continued into further education. Where courses did not accommodate health needs or where support was not sustained, participants struggled to continue and, in some cases, experienced worsening health. Some dropped out entirely because of this. These experiences further narrowed future options and made it harder to progress.

For the smaller group who entered work, similar patterns were clear. Some described making repeated attempts to engage, sometimes entering roles that were not well matched to their health-related capacity. Where these attempts led to health deterioration or job loss, this reinforced a pattern of disengagement. Over time, these repeated experiences contributed to withdrawal from work.

Challenges occurred across services and systems

Participants’ experiences were shaped not only by challenges over time, but by the interaction of challenges across the different services and systems they engaged with. This included education, health services, the labour market and the benefits system.

The impact of health conditions was often compounded by how different systems responded. For example, a lack of early diagnosis from health services and/or recognition of health needs in school led to difficulties accessing appropriate support that may have mitigated against them, which affected attendance, attainment and progression. In further education, the absence of appropriate adjustments or specialist support limited participants’ ability to continue, even where they were motivated to do so.

Transitions between systems were particularly important. The move from child to adult health services was described as a point where support ended abruptly, with no equivalent adult provision in place. This led to a loss of effective treatment, including medication and contact with trusted professionals, which contributed to deterioration in health. This had a key impact on participants’ ability to engage in education or work.

Perceptions around how employment and the benefits system interacted with each other actively shaped decisions around engagement. Uncertainty about how benefits would be affected by employment, alongside perceptions of limited financial gain, discouraged some from attempting to engage.

Experiences within one service therefore had direct implications for others. Health-related challenges affected education and employment; gaps in education and training limited access to work; and financial uncertainty influenced decisions about whether to attempt engagement. This highlights the importance of taking a holistic view of the whole ecosystem of services that young people interact with.

This led to low confidence and self-esteem

A key consequence of the accumulation and interaction of multiple challenges was that young people often had extremely low self-confidence and self-esteem.

For many this was rooted in repeated experiences of being misunderstood or unsupported. Negative experiences at school, including bullying or misinterpretation of behaviour related to their health conditions, had lasting effects: participants were nervous about the same patterns repeating themselves should they restart education or work. Similar patterns continued in further education and employment, where unmet support needs or unsuitable environments led to withdrawal.

Over time, these experiences shaped how participants viewed future opportunities. Some avoided education or work settings altogether because they associated them with distress or failure. Others described fear of repeating previous negative experiences, leading to disengagement even where aspirations to work were present. Rebuilding confidence was identified as a key support need and a necessary pre-condition for re-engagement.

Appointees were focused on wellbeing and safety

The views and experiences of appointees have been discussed throughout this report. In many ways, their perspectives are unique and important. All appointees in the sample were parents, grandparents or siblings of young people who claimed health and disability benefits. These young people tended to have some of the most severe health conditions and impairments, in terms of the impact on their ability to carry out day-to-day activities. Often, these young people had cognitive or neurodevelopmental impairments, and/or multiple compounding health conditions. In some cases, they needed near-constant care.

Given this, it is not surprising that appointees tended to express some fairly consistent perspectives. Appointees tended to focus more on what was feasible and sustainable for young people, rather than more aspirational outcomes. They were more intent on achieving goals like improved wellbeing, routine, social connection, and safety, rather than employment, career progression, or earnings. Focusing on these latter outcomes, they felt, was too narrow: it was important to them to have a broader view of what success looks like.

“I think it’s very simple things that he is looking towards. Basic things that most people take for granted are things that he’s hoping for.”
(Appointee of: 24, cognitive/neurodevelopmental impairment, PIP and UC LCWRA)

Appointees were understandably cautious about employment, and at times were actively nervous about the prospect. They saw it either as completely inappropriate, or possible only under very specific circumstances, such as roles that were explicitly designed with the young person’s needs in mind, and with extensive support.

“I would never see him working. He potentially could do, but you’d need a high level of supervision. It would need to be completely flexible based on his mood, and subject to change at the last minute, and there weren’t many places that can offer that.”
(Appointee of: 22, multiple conditions, PIP and UC LCWRA)

In the same way that some participants had very low confidence, rooted in previous negative experiences, some appointees acknowledged that they felt the same. They felt scarred by witnessing the young person they supported going through difficult or traumatic experiences at school or work. When asked about support needs, they raised the possibility of support for appointees, to help reassure and build confidence.

Implications

Young people’s current NEET status should be viewed as the result of an extended journey through multiple interacting systems, rather than something with a single proximate explanation. Where participants described positive experiences, these were a result of support that started early, continued as long as needed, and was joined up across services. These factors enabled participants to maintain attendance, participate in learning, and progress towards future education, training or work. These accounts highlight the potential for more coordinated and sustained support to change young people’s trajectories.

It is important that support starts earlier, continues across transitions, and is better coordinated across systems. This includes greater recognition of health needs within education, improving support during the transition to adulthood, and providing tailored guidance on realistic pathways into education, training and work. It also highlights the importance of viewing confidence-building as a necessary step towards participation, rather than an outcome that will follow from it.

Progress will not look the same for all young people. For some, it will involve movement towards education, training or employment. For others, particularly those with more severe or complex health conditions, it may relate to improved wellbeing, stability and quality of life. Reflecting this diversity is key to supporting this group effectively.

References

Addario, G., Khriakova, E., Crowley, J. and Breedvelt, J. (2023) Risk factors for being NEET among young people, Retrieved from National Centre for Social Research.

Office for National Statistics (ONS) (2026) Young people not in education, employment or training (NEET), UK, May 2026. Retrieved from ONS.

Ritchie, J., Lewis, J., Nicholls, C.M. and Ormston, R. (2013). Qualitative Research Practice: A Guide for Social Science Students and Researchers. 2nd ed. London: SAGE Publications Ltd.

Steen, B., Lucas, O., Chapman, B., Cretch, E., Freegard, T., Spray, Y., Leeder, G., Ilic, N., and Mallevays, L. (2025) Work aspirations and support needs of health and disability customers: Final findings report. Retrieved from Department for Work and Pensions, GOV.UK.

Appendix A

Methods

This study’s research questions expand on those addressed by the previous Work Aspirations study, with a more specific focus on the experiences of this young population.

Research questions adapted from the previous Work Aspirations study

  • What are customers’ benefit, education, training and work histories/journeys?
  • What are customers’ health conditions and impairments, and how do these affect their ability to participate in education, training and/or work?
  • What kinds of education, training or work are customers able and willing to do, if any?
  • What are the main barriers to participation in education, training and work experienced by customers?
  • What support do customers want to help them move closer to education, training and/or work? What support, if any, are they receiving, and to what extent do they already or are they willing to engage with DWP support?

New research questions, reflecting high priority areas of interest for DWP

  • What are the circumstances in which customers became NEET, and what attempts, if any, have they made to re-engage with education, training or work since?
  • What are customers’ experiences of education? Do they feel education prepared them for participation in future education, training or work or not, and how does this relate to their NEET status?
  • To what extent do customers feel they should participate in education, training or work? Are customers NEET (in part) because of the benefits system, or are they claiming benefits (in part) because of their NEET status?
  • What aspirations did customers have in the past, and how/why have they changed?
  • What are customers’ life aspirations, both in the shorter and longer term? To what extent do they want to participate in education, training or work, and see them as a potential positive force in their lives? What motivates customers to earn money, find work, or better themselves?
  • What are the circumstances (health, employment, benefits, education, housing) of customers’ closest networks, such as friends and family? What role, if any, does this play in customers’ life and aspirations to engage?

Overview of recruitment process

An advance email was sent to potential participants, outlining the purpose of the research and inviting opt-ins. This included a link to a dedicated study webpage where they could read more about the research.

Recruitment was conducted by NatCen’s Telephone Unit, with interviewers making multiple call attempts to contact potential participants. They used a short screening questionnaire to confirm eligibility and capture key quota characteristics, including current benefit status, primary health condition, and appointee status. Where appropriate, they then booked in the interview. Reminder emails and/or calls were made to the participant one working day before their scheduled interview to minimise non-attendance.

The intended participant sampling criteria, and achieved interview sample, are presented in Table 1 and Table 2, respectively.

Table 1: Primary sampling criteria

Criteria Demographic Target Achieved
Primary health condition Mental health conditions 20 7
Primary health condition Cognitive/neurodevelopmental needs 15 12
Primary health condition Range of other health conditions 15 21
Benefit group PIP only 15 4
Benefit group Range of other benefit groups 35 36
Appointee status Young people with an appointee (interview with appointee or young person) 10 24
Appointee status Young person without an appointee 40 16

Table 2: Achieved interviews sample

Criteria Demographic Number of participants
Age 18 to 19 0[footnote 23]
Age 20 to 21 8
Age 22 to 23 19
Age 24 13
Sex Female 18
Sex Male 22
Primary health condition Cognitive/neurodevelopmental 12
Primary health condition Mental health 7
Primary health condition Mobility/dexterity impairment 0
Primary health condition Multiple - cannot distinguish main 13
Primary health condition Long-term conditions 8
Benefit group PIP only 4
Benefit group UC only 2
Benefit group ESA only 0
Benefit group PIP and UC 33
Benefit group PIP and ESA 0
Benefit group UC and ESA 0
Benefit group PIP, UC and ESA 1
Appointee status Young person with an appointee (interview with appointee or young person) 24
Appointee status Young person without appointee 16

Appendix B

Summary topic guide

A tailored topic guide was used to ensure a consistent approach across data collection encounters and between members of the research team. The guides were used flexibly to allow researchers to respond to the nature and content of each discussion. Researchers used open, non-leading questions, and answers were fully probed to elicit greater depth and detail where necessary.

The main headings and subheadings from the topic guide used for this study are provided below.

Introduction

  • Introduce self and NatCen
  • Briefly introduce the research
  • Explain what taking part involves
  • Explain conditions of discussion: confidentiality, safeguarding, no impact on benefits
  • Explain how data will be used
  • Questions
  • Special arrangements and consent

Contextual information

  • A little bit about them: daily life, living situation, dependants, caring responsibilities

Current health situation

  • About their disability or health condition(s)
  • How their health condition(s) affect(s) their everyday life
  • How they manage their health condition(s) on a day-to-day- basis
  • Which disability payments they receive
  • Broader financial circumstances

Experiences at school

  • Overview of their school experience
  • Preparation for next steps
  • Expectations at end of school

Experiences after school

  • Journey mapping – what participants have done since school
  • Experiences around education beyond school
  • Experiences around training and employment (incl. paid and voluntary work, apprenticeships, traineeships)
  • Experiences related to health and disability since leaving school: impact on choices and participation
  • Influencing factors: health, family, peers, benefits, wider circumstances

The future

  • Expectations, hopes and goals

Barriers and support needs

  • Barriers to reaching goals and aspirations
  • Support they would like

Concluding thoughts

  • Final reflections

Thank and close

  1. 31% of people aged under 25 felt they could work from home, compared to 25% overall. ↩

  2. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  3. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩ ↩2

  4. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  5. Customer reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  6. Customer reports that they are now only claiming PIP. ↩

  7. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  8. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  9. Customer reports that they are now only claiming PIP. ↩

  10. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  11. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  12. Customer reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  13. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  14. Customer reports that they are now only claiming PIP. ↩

  15. Customer reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  16. Customer reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  17. Customer reports that they are now only claiming PIP. ↩

  18. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  19. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  20. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  21. Customer reports that they are now only claiming PIP. ↩

  22. Appointee reports that they are now claiming PIP and UC. ↩

  23. Having no participants aged 18 to 19 reflects that the sample frame was drawn in summer 2024, meaning younger customers were less likely to be represented in this study’s fieldwork, which took place in 2026. ↩