Theme of case study
Seeking supplier payment for failure to meet target service levels.
Paragraph 3(1) Variation of supply agreement and terms of supply.
The Co-operative Group Limited.
Summary of the issue
The GCA was approached about suppliers being required to make compensation payments to the Co-operative Group Limited for failure to meet target service levels against actual performance. The Co-operative Group Limited was reported to have said that, there had been an associated loss of profit that was due to be reimbursed. It was reported that the request was not supported by evidence relating to performance nor that an agreed service level target was in place.
The GCA raised the issue with the Co-operative Group Limited and it was discussed at the quarterly meeting on 20th November. A response was received on 16th December 2013.
Outcome and/or GCA decision
The Co-operative Group Limited advised the GCA that following an internal investigation into the service level issue it was found that this type of request originated from one category and from one buyer only. There were no other requests from other buyers across the trading department similar to this. The buyer who sent out these emails has been further trained on the Code and the correct procedures to follow and has subsequently sent out retraction emails to those suppliers who received the request initially. The Co-operative Group Limited stated that: “We do (and will continue to) ask for loss of profit support but only on individual instances where a supplier does not comply with our terms and conditions”.
The Groceries Code Adjudicator is pleased to note that it has been recognised that the practice is not consistent with the Code, the practice has been stopped and all affected suppliers have been notified.