EM6413 - Contract Settlement: Post Settlement Issues - Adjusting Figures
The guidance about contract settlements at EM6000+ only relates to direct tax. You must never include VAT or VAT penalties in a contract settlement.
Where a customer has entered into a legally binding contract settlement, HMRC is not obliged to make any adjustment to the agreed settlement figures. You must not agree to revisit a settlement on general grounds, or because the calculation of a liability included in the settlement is subsequently questioned.
Customers who have settled their liabilities by contract must not, however, be disadvantaged because they settled by contract rather than through HMRC proceeding formally.
Where a contract settlement conclusively determines the position, there is no contractual basis for varying the agreement simply to enable the customer to make a claim for relief or obtain some other reduction in the agreed liability.
There is, however, an exception. Where, following conclusion of a contract settlement, the customer has a statutory right to claim relief, that statutory entitlement may provide a basis for HMRC to revisit the position notwithstanding the concluded settlement.
For example, a claim to overpayment relief (OPR) may be dealt with either by contract or through a formal claim made by the taxpayer. Paragraph 8 of Schedule 1AB provides for OPR claims following a contract settlement. See the guidance at SACM12060. Where this section of the guidance applies and a replacement Letter of Offer template is required, please contact TALA through contact link.
OPR is only one form of relief. There may be circumstances where, had HMRC proceeded formally, the taxpayer would have had access to a statutory remedy, but that remedy is not available because the liability has been settled as a contractual debt. In those circumstances, the contract settlement itself should not be disturbed. Consideration may, however, be given to whether a discretionary ex gratia payment is appropriate to address the position. Please contact TALA through contact link where this section of the guidance applies.
When considering such cases, you must focus on whether the claim to relief would otherwise be valid and satisfy the relevant statutory conditions, rather than on the method by which the liability was settled. Relief must not be given where the claim is outside the relevant statutory time limit, fails to satisfy the applicable statutory conditions, or would not have been available had HMRC proceeded formally.
You must therefore only allow such a claim where all the conditions for the relevant relief are satisfied, other than the fact that the liability was settled by contract.
For the purposes of any statutory time limits relating to liabilities that could have been assessed formally but were instead included in the contract settlement, the position should be considered as if the relevant assessments had been issued on the date the offer was accepted.
Where an application to revisit a settlement cannot be accepted, you must write to the taxpayer explaining the reasons for the decision.
Where HMRC's decision not to allow relief carries no right of appeal, irrespective of the method of settlement, the taxpayer may be able to seek Judicial Review. See ARTG12010.