Skip to main content
HMRC internal manual

Enquiry Manual

EM3202 - Discovery: overview

Pre Self-Assessment (SA) years

The guidance in this manual covers SA years only.

If HMRC officers need advice about pre-SA years then please send a request to the Specialist Technical Team, see EM21000.

The Discovery provisions

Discovery provisions allow an officer of HMRC to make an assessment to recover a loss of tax. Assessments are for an amount of tax and do not amend any returns filed for a period. The conditions that allow a discovery assessment to be made must be met are outlined at EM3230.

Appropriate use of the Discovery provisions

Where a notice to file has been issued to a customer under s8 TMA 1970, or Paragraph 3, Schedule 18 FA 1998, but no return has been submitted, a discovery assessment should not ordinarily be used. Where time limits permit, a determination should usually be made instead, see EM2027+, for guidance about determinations.

Where there is no return and HMRC are out of time to issue a notice to file, a discovery assessment may be made. A discovery assessment may also be made where a notice to file has been issued, no return has been submitted and HMRC are out of time to issue a determination providing HMRC are in time to make an assessment.

If HMRC are still in time to open an enquiry into a filed return, a notice of enquiry should be issued instead of making a discovery assessment. Normal enquiry procedures will apply.

If HMRC are outside the enquiry window, then it might be appropriate to make a discovery assessment. HMRC must meet the conditions to validate a discovery assessment and must be within time limits that apply to discovery assessments, see EM3214.

Where both a simple assessment, see PAYE96300, and discovery assessment are applicable, HMRC officers should contact the Specialist Technical Team, see EM21000, for advice on which is appropriate.