Interaction of UK law and treaties - up to 5 April 2015: remittance basis and time apportionment - example 5
Jasjeet is UK-resident but not ordinarily resident in the UK when an option is granted, on 6 April 2009, and is on the remittance basis in year 1, 2009/10 and year 2, 2010/11. The option vests at the end of Year 2 on 5 April 2011 and is exercised at the end of Year 3 on 5 April 2012. For the purposes of the UK remittance basis rules the relevant period is two years. For the purposes of time apportionment, in accordance with the UK/US DTA, the gain of 10,000 relates to a 3 year period (a total of 720 workdays).
Jasjeet’s UK/US workdays are 120/120 days in each of Years 1 and 2 and 60/180 days in Year 3. She is not resident in the UK and is treaty resident in the US when she exercises her option
ITEPA03/S41A(4) produces a UK tax charge as follows:
|Overseas workdays 240/480 x 10,000 gives foreign securities income of||5,000|
|Taxable specific income under S41A(4)||5,000|
If Jasjeet makes a claim for time apportionment under the UK/US Double Taxation Treaty, the gain that will be taxed as specific employment income will be apportioned on the basis of the UK workdays as a proportion of total workdays in the period from the grant of the option to its exercise, in contrast to the remittance basis rules of Chapter 5A which use the relevant period from grant to vest. US will tax 100% of the gain and will give a foreign tax credit in respect of the proportion of the gain that is from a foreign source, using the same basis of apportionment - workdays from grant to exercise.
So the UK will tax, and US will give credit for tax paid on, the UK part of the gain which is:
|UK gain of 300/720||4,167|
In this example, while the remittance basis rules make £5,000 of the gain taxable on the arising basis and the remaining £5,000 taxable if remitted to the UK, the time apportionment offered by the double taxation agreement means that only £4,167 is taxable in the UK and remittance basis will not apply to any of the remaining amount.
For the application of this and the other examples to periods from 6 April 2013, see ERSM161335.