Planning policy
Development Plan policies provide an important framework to guide development proposals and aid decision-making for garden communities.
The statutory development plan for an area includes joint or individual local plans and may include a spatial development strategy (SDS) produced by an elected mayor or combined authority (where plan-making powers have been conferred), and a neighbourhood plan.
The development plan for an area can identify broad locations, allocations and principles that create a spatial framework for the development of garden communities. Planning law requires that planning applications must be determined in accordance with the development plan unless material circumstances indicate otherwise. Planning applications for garden communities are then determined in accordance with the development plan.
The National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) is an important material consideration and is the main national policy document for planning and development.
It includes policy relating to the provision of new homes in new settlements or significant extensions to existing villages and towns, and considerations to take on board.
The Planning Policy Guidance (PPG) provides national guidance for planning practice. The Court of Appeal has ruled that PPG and the NPPF are of equal legal standing, meaning planners must consider both documents when making planning decisions.
You should also familiarise yourself with the Local Plan development process.
Where a garden community crosses 1 or more local authority boundaries, it will need to be integrated into all relevant development plans.
A coordinated approach, including a common and robust evidence base, and a consistent approach to policy content is a good way to support a holistic vision for a garden community.
Development plan policies drafted in support of the garden community project are required to meet the tests of soundness as set out in the NPPF.
How to create a planning policy framework for garden communities
You should:
- use clear language that avoids overly technical terms
- ensure policies are fully supported by a strong evidence base proportionate to the type of plan being prepared and the detail needed to support them
- ensure policies, particularly around capacity, phasing and infrastructure requirements, provide sufficient certainty but are flexible enough to respond to changing circumstances — this is because some garden communities will build out beyond the normal local plan timeframe
- ensure policies place particular emphasis on securing comprehensive, master planned development across the site, ensuring that growth is coordinated and infrastructure-led, and avoiding piecemeal development that could prejudice the delivery of the wider vision for the garden community
- consider how the garden community will likely come forward, whether through a single comprehensive planning applications over time — ensure policies are flexible enough to support the garden community being delivered through a single comprehensive planning application or by multiple applications
- set out the main components that the garden community is expected together — like infrastructure, mix of uses, housing mix and tenure, green space typologies and stewardship ambitions
- include clear criteria and, or, targets against which development proposals can be tangibly measured — describe the subsequent guidance to be developed to inform the garden community proposal
- reference certain provisions or infrastructure being in place in the policy if delivery of the garden community depends on these — ensure there’s evidence to support their inclusion and ability to be delivered in a suitable phase and consider whether supplementary plans, such as for design codes, should be developed to ensure quality and consistency in future planning applications or whether such evidence can be embedded into policy at the same time
When planning garden communities there are 2 spatial frameworks to consider:
- Spatial Development Strategy (SDS)
- Broad Location or Strategic Site Allocation identified in a development plan
1. Spatial Development Strategy
Summary
These are high-level plans looking ahead at least 20 years and set the framework for local plans within a defined area, including development which crosses local authority boundaries. SDSs will be prepared by combined authorities, combined county authorities, upper-tier councils and unitary authorities. They will set the spatial development framework for an area and can identify broad locations for growth and development, and the necessary infrastructure needed to support that growth. They cannot be site-specific or allocate and, or, designate particular sites, as these are matters to be dealt with in a local plan.
SDSs can identify broad locations for strategic development including new settlements, major urban extensions, major cross-boundary development and key locations with the potential for new homes and jobs.
2. Broad Location or Strategic Site Allocation identified in a Development Plan
Summary
Development Plans are prepared by local authorities for their area for the following 15 years. They should be in accordance with relevant Spatial Development Strategies.
Broad Locations
Where strategic scaled development will come forward later in the Development Plan period, it can be identified as a broad location for a garden community identified on a diagram, with the boundaries and more detail to be developed at a later stage, subject to further assessment.
It is common for the development plan policy to reference the need to develop a more detailed policy framework for the garden community.
Advantages
Advantages of this approach include:
- enabling well-considered strategic planning principles to be set at a high level where details of a garden community are not yet established, allowing for further work to establish parameters for development and resolve technical issues affecting delivery
- the fact that major sites are given credibility through the need to appraise viable options and testing through examination
- that a comprehensive framework can be set where a range of different landowners exist but are not working together or to the same timeframes
- engagement can be undertaken with a wide range of stakeholders to ensure the strategic vision reflects local views
Disadvantages
Disadvantages of this approach are that it:
- is less suitable for sites that need to be delivered early, or where a little further work could provide sufficient evidence to support a strategic site allocation
- should not be used as an alternative to strategic site allocation to avoid dealing with significant infrastructure or technical issues, like flooding, major highway infrastructure, environmental designations
Strategic Site Allocations
Summary
Where specific or smaller parcels comprising the wider garden community allocation are deliverable and planned to come forward early in the development plan period, they are allocated for development with boundaries shown on the proposals map and have a related policy (or policies) in the development plan specifying the type and amount of development.
Advantages
This approach:
- provides a clearer policy framework for delivery, including identification of critical infrastructure
- enables engagement with a wide range of stakeholders to set a vision and objectives that can achieve political and community buy-in
- saves time long-term by reducing the need to prepare substantive additional policy framework documents later
- addresses difficult and strategic issues up-front, which can save time at application stage
- gives clearer indication of development costs, land value and viability
- is one where the level of detail provided at this stage is dependent on the status of the proposal; a concept masterplan can be useful to test capacity and impact of the proposal
- allows consideration to be given to appropriate interim or meanwhile uses that can deliver temporary benefits to the community, for land parcels that are not anticipated to come forward until later phases of development - this supports place-making objectives, and ensure the land remains productive pending its intended longer-term development
- supports the development of a strategic design code for the allocation that can help set a clear vision for the site over the lifespan of the development and can also further inform assumptions around the scale of development, the co-location of supporting infrastructure and establish the parameters to create locally distinctive communities
Disadvantages
This approach:
- takes time to prepare and adopt, particularly as the evidence base is necessarily more in depth than for a broad or strategic location
- requires a boundary for the garden community to be identified, including any land requirements, like for environmental mitigation
Supplementary plans
Supplementary Planning Documents (SPDs) have previously been developed by plan-making authorities to provide more guidance on Local Plan policies, for example creating and endorsing a masterplan for a garden community site. As part of planning reforms, SPDs will be replaced by Supplementary Plans. No new SPDs can be adopted or endorsed after 30 June 2026. Existing SPDs will remain in force until the plan-making authority develops its new-style local plan.
Supplementary Plans (SPs) are a new type of plan that plan-making authorities can choose to prepare to set locally-specific design standards or shape and direct site-specific development. They can be used to address specific issues where these are not already covered in other parts of the development plan, for example, setting out locally-specific design standards to provide clear design expectations that support the delivery of development. SPs must undergo consultation and independent examination, and when adopted will formally be part of the local plan.
Advantages
Advantages of this approach include that plans;
- can cover a design code or masterplan to guide the spatial vision for development and ensure high-quality design and placemaking
- will be subject to formal consultation and examination
- will have the same weight as the existing Local Plan once they are adopted
- can include policies that supersede policies in the existing Local Plan
Disadvantages
Disadvantages of this approach include that plans:
- must have regard to the same matters as for local plans, which include national policies and advice contained in guidance issued by the Secretary of State
- may take longer to prepare and adopt
Planning Portal — Policy and legislation
National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF)
Planning practice guidance
Plan-making
East Cambridgeshire District Council — East Cambridgeshire’s approach to writing Local Plan policies supporting a local community-led development
St Cuthbert’s Garden Village — Local Plan — How design coding has been embedded into policies
St Cuthbert’s Garden Village — Strategic Design Supplementary Planning Document
Tendring Colchester Borders Garden Community — Joint planning