Skip to main content

Mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind and expenses — interim guidance and legislation

Common payrolling scenarios

Information about the most common payrolling scenarios when reporting benefits in kind.

Reporting benefits in kind with no tax liability

If an employee is in receipt of a benefit in kind that has no tax liability, there will be no need to report this to HMRC. This is the same as the current reporting rules. These include: 

  • a loan for an amount below £10,000
  • a benefit in kind with a nil cash equivalent
  • an exempt benefit in kind

Find out more about non-taxable payments or benefits for employees.

PAYE Settlement Agreements 

Mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind does not change any existing PAYE Settlement Agreement (PSA) employers have agreed.

Benefits and expenses covered by an agreed PSA must not be reported through payroll. They should continue to be dealt with through the existing PSA process.

Employees and directors who receive benefits in kind but have no earnings

Employees and directors may receive benefits in kind but are not paid cash earnings from which the tax due can be deducted.

From April 2027, you’ll still report the benefit through a Full Payment Submission (FPS), even where no cash earnings are paid. We will recover any tax that cannot be collected through payroll after the end of the tax year, through the existing P800 or Simple Assessment process. 

Directors who are paid annually can continue to operate an annual payroll. Where a director receives a benefit in kind but no cash earnings from which sufficient tax can be deducted, the benefit should still be reported through the FPS submitted for that payroll. We will recover any tax that cannot be collected through payroll after the end of the tax year, through the existing P800 or Simple Assessment process. 

If the employee or director has no earnings but is provided with benefit in kind or expense, you’ll need to:

  • send details of the benefits in kind and expenses provided using an FPS
  • pay the Class 1A National Insurance contributions due

The FPS will need to show no payments of earnings and tax, as none were provided.

Reporting the benefits of employees who continue to receive them after they have retired 

If you continue to provide benefits in kind to a former employee after retirement, this will constitute the provision of relevant benefits under an employer-financed retirement benefits scheme.

You should report these benefits in line with the existing information provisions in the Employment Income Manual (EIM15200), including the addresses to which you should send any reports. 

By 31 January following the end of the tax year in which the benefit is first provided after the former employee’s retirement, you must report the following information to HMRC: 

  • the name of the employer-financed retirement benefits scheme
  • the address of the responsible person (this will usually be the employer, where benefits are provided directly)
  • the date the scheme came into operation (this will be the date that a relevant benefit is first provided)

The employer (or other responsible person, where applicable) will also need to provide an annual report to HMRC by 7 July following the end of the tax year in which any relevant benefit is provided.

This report must set out: 

  • the name, address and national insurance number of the person to whom the relevant benefit was provided
  • the nature of the relevant benefit
  • the amount of the relevant benefit

For these purposes, the amount of the relevant benefit is the greater of the benefit’s: 

  • value in cash (money’s worth)
  • cash equivalent under the benefits code

Find out more about calculating the amount of non-cash benefits in the Employment Income Manual (EIM15120).

Long service awards 

Existing exemption rules continue to apply to long service awards. Awards that meet the conditions for exemption do not need to be reported through payroll. Awards covered by an agreed PAYE Settlement Agreement (PSA) remain subject to the existing PSA arrangements and must not be reported through payroll. 

If the long service award provided is not exempt, you must report the amount through a Full Payment Submission (FPS). You’ll need to add cash awards to the employee’s other earnings and deduct Class 1 National Insurance contributions and Income Tax.

For non-cash awards, you must report the details of the award as a benefit in kind on the FPS and Income Tax and deduct Class 1A National Insurance contributions as normal.

Find out what to do if the amount of tax due is over 50% of the pay for that pay period. 

Any uncollected amounts in excess of the 50% limit will be collected by HMRC after the end of the tax year through the existing end-of-year reconciliation (P800) process or Simple Assessment.

If the employee is already registered for Self Assessment, then uncollected amounts of tax will be collected through the Self Assessment process. 

These are not mandated to be payrolled until April 2028.

Reporting a benefit provided in March 2027 when payroll is notified in April 2027 

If an employee receives a new benefit in kind in March 2027, but you do not notify payroll until April 2027, you should follow the reporting process that applies to you for the tax year 2026 to 2027.

The benefit provided in March 2027 relates to the tax year 2026 to 2027 and should not be treated as a new benefit for the tax year 2027 to 2028.

If you’re using the existing P11D reporting process you should report the taxable value on form P11D and the associated Class 1A National Insurance contributions on form P11D(b). 

If you’re already operating voluntary payrolling, you should follow the appropriate payroll correction process. 

If the benefit continues into the tax year 2027 to 2028 and is subject to mandatory payrolling, you should begin reporting the taxable value relating to that tax year through payroll from the next available pay period after payroll is notified. You must report the amount relating to the tax year 2026 to 2027 separately using the process you used for the tax year 2026 to 2027. 

If the same situation arises in March 2028, you should report the additional benefit in kind by updating the final Full Payment Submission for the tax year 2027 to 2028.

Payrolling annual parties, social events and one-off costs 

Existing exemption rules continue to apply to annual parties and social events. Exempt events do not need to be reported through payroll. Taxable costs covered by an agreed PAYE Settlement Agreement (PSA) remain subject to the existing PSA arrangements and must not be reported through payroll. 

If any of the events you provide to your staff are not exempt, the costs will have to be reported to HMRC through payroll software from April 2028, unless voluntarily payrolled in the tax year 2027 to 2028. 

You must report the details on a Full Payment Submission for each employee, and pay Class 1A National Insurance contributions.

You can account for taxable costs either in Full Payment Submissions spread out across the full tax year (where a cash equivalent or an estimate is known at the start of the year), or in the remaining pay periods once the cash equivalent can be estimated or becomes known.

These payrolling methods can be applied to all one-off costs related to benefits in kind.

You’ll need to decide the most appropriate way to report the costs depending on individual circumstances. 

If you’re not sure what the value of the benefit is at the start of the tax year, you can make an estimate of the cash equivalent of the benefit. You can then adjust it later in the year when you know the exact value.

These are not mandated to be payrolled until April 2028.

Employee expense payments 

How employee expenses are reported depends on whether the expenses are taxable and whether you make a payment of money to the employee. 

Expenses that qualify for an exemption or deduction are not taxable and generally do not need to be reported to HMRC. These expenses will be unaffected by the introduction of mandatory payrolling for benefits and expenses from April 2027. 

Taxable expense payments, where you pay an amount of money to an employee to fund or reimburse an expense, already need to be payrolled in most cases. They will not be affected by the introduction of mandatory payrolling. 

Taxable expense payments that do not involve a payment of money to an employee (for example, where you pay a supplier on the employee’s behalf) are currently reported on form P11D. You can voluntarily payroll these expenses and deduct tax and National Insurance contributions through the payroll.

Taxable expenses payments that are currently reported on form P11D will have to be reported to HMRC through payroll software from April 2028, unless voluntarily payrolled in the tax year 2027 to 2028. 

Expenses covered by an agreed PAYE Settlement Agreement (PSA) must not be reported through payroll and should continue to be dealt with through the existing PSA process.

Employees can claim deductions for non-reimbursed expenses from HMRC. This process will be the same from April 2027.

Student loans and payrolled benefits in kind

The student loan liability of employees is calculated on earnings subject to Class 1 Secondary National Insurance contributions. The student loans calculation via payroll for benefits in kind remains correct, as payroll software ensures the correct earnings are taken into account to assess the student loan liability.

We have added a box to the Self Assessment tax return to resolve the issue of incorrect student loan calculations due to the inclusion of benefits in kind liable to class 1A National Insurance contributions.

This box will capture benefits subject to Class 1A only, so that they are not included for student loan purposes.

Find out more about filling in a Self Assessment tax return.

Optional Remuneration Arrangements 

If a benefit is provided under an Optional Remuneration Arrangement (OpRA) (such as a salary sacrifice or cash alternative), the taxable value is the higher of the cash salary given up or the benefit’s normal taxable value.

If you’re payrolling a benefit provided under an OpRA arrangement, you’ll need to put this higher notional value through the payroll each month. Employees will pay tax and National Insurance directly through their pay.

The taxable value is determined using the rules in this guidance and then the value is split over the months within the tax year.

Company cars, car fuel, vans, van fuel and medical benefits provided under an OpRA will need to be payrolled from 6 April 2027.

All other benefits provided under OpRA can be voluntarily payrolled from April 2027 and will be mandated to be payrolled from April 2028. 

The current rules for reporting benefits in kind provided under OPRA will continue if you decide not to payroll these benefits.

Globally mobile employees

You can apply to HMRC for an exception to mandatory payrolling of benefits for eligible globally mobile employees. Find out about eligible employees and start or end an exception from mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind.

Globally mobile employees and EP Appendix arrangements 

The operation of PAYE for globally mobile employees, including EP Appendix arrangements, is not affected by the GME exception process. Existing PAYE obligations continue to apply.

If your employees are covered by an existing EP Appendix 4, 6 or 7A arrangement, you will not need to apply to HMRC to exclude those employees from mandatory payrolling.

If your employees are covered by an EP Appendix 4 arrangement, they are already outside the scope of mandatory payrolling, because you’re not required to operate PAYE for them.

If your employees are covered by an EP Appendix 5 arrangement, you can apply for an exception for eligible globally mobile employees. 

You should continue to operate these EP Appendix arrangements as you currently do.

Further guidance will be published to explain what to do with EP Appendix 8 arrangements.

National Insurance scheme (National Insurance only payrolls)

It is possible that an employee included on a National Insurance only scheme may meet the definition of a globally mobile employee. The National Insurance only payroll should continue to operate for the Class 1 liability. This payroll type is not allowed where expenses and benefits are being provided, so there should be no Class 1A liability to consider.

If you provide expenses and benefits that are subject to UK Income Tax, you should register for a standard ‘P’ scheme, which is the default PAYE scheme type, where there is any liability to Class 1A National Insurance contributions.

Direct payment schemes or collection

It is possible that an employee operating a direct collection or direct payment scheme may meet the definition of a globally mobile employee. However, as these schemes involve an employee operating their own scheme, there is no employer responsible for operating National Insurance contributions and paying them to HMRC. This means that there are no employer liabilities to secondary Class 1 or Class 1A National Insurance contributions.

Direct collection and direct payment schemes should continue to be operated in the same manner, including to account for any Class 1 primary National Insurance contributions due. Find out more about direct collection for employee-only National Insurance contributions in the PAYE Manual (PAYE20090).

Operating PAYE on globally mobile employees’ income

You’re generally already required to operate PAYE on the income that a globally mobile employee earns.

If you’re an eligible employer, you can notify HMRC of your intention to only operate PAYE income tax on the proportion of the employee’s income that is earned within the UK. Find out more and make a PAYE notification. 

The rules for operating PAYE where there is a notification in place will remain the same as they are now. A notification does not affect the amount of any Class 1 or Class 1A NICs liability.

While a notification may mean that you’re only required to operate PAYE income tax on part of a benefit in kind provided to your employee, the full value of the benefit will be subject to Class 1 or Class 1A National Insurance contributions unless disapplied under Social Security Coordination rules. 

Mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind will not change how Overseas Workday Relief operates. Overseas Workday Relief is an Income Tax relief, so can only be claimed by the employee through their Self Assessment return.

However, provisional relief can be given through PAYE where you have made a PAYE notification under section 690D ITEPA 2003. In line with current practice, any provisional PAYE tax relief applied under section 690D will not reduce the chargeable amount of the benefit for Class 1 or Class 1A National Insurance contributions.