Skip to main content
Notice

Imposition of a monetary penalty on AQA

Published 20 November 2026

Applies to England

Introduction

  1. 1. The Office of Qualifications and Examinations Regulation (“Ofqual”) has decided to issue AQA with a monetary penalty under section 151A of the Apprenticeships, Skills, Children and Learning Act 2009 (“ASCLA”) in the sum of £350,000.

  2. 2. This Monetary Penalty Notice (“the notice”) contains the reasons why Ofqual has decided to impose a penalty. Further information about Ofqual’s statutory powers and the Conditions of Recognition are set out in Annex A of this notice.

  3. 3. On 2 November 2026, AQA entered into a voluntary settlement agreement with Ofqual to resolve this investigation. AQA made full admissions and agreed to pay a penalty of £350,000.

  4. 4. On 5 November 2026, in accordance with section 151A (4) of the 2009 Act, Ofqual served AQA with a Notice of Intention to impose a monetary penalty. Ofqual determined it was not necessary to publish the Notice of Intention.

  5. 5. On 6 November 2026, and in accordance with the settlement agreement, AQA confirmed it had no representations to make and was content for Ofqual to proceed to final decision.

Background

  1. 6. AQA, recognised by Ofqual since 1 April 2010, develops, delivers and awards regulated qualifications including GCSE Geography (8035).

  2. 7. AQA GCSE Geography is intended to develop and extend students’ geographical knowledge, understanding and skills, including the ability to investigate, analyse and evaluate geographical issues and interactions. It is a high-stakes general qualification used for progression to further education and training.

  3. 8. In the Summer 2024 examination series, AQA delivered three GCSE Geography assessments:

    1. a. Paper 1: Living with the Physical Environment (88 marks);

    2. b. Paper 2: Challenges in the Human Environment (88 marks); and

    3. c. Paper 3: Geographical Applications (76 marks), for which learners were provided with pre-release material in advance of the assessment.

    4. (together, “the assessments”).

  4. 9. AQA produced modified versions of the assessments as a Reasonable Adjustment for learners who required assessment materials in braille. The modification process involved adapting visual content, including maps, graphs, diagrams and figures, into accessible braille and tactile formats.[footnote 1]

  5. 10. In total, five visually impaired learners were entered for and sat the braille versions of the assessments (“the learners”).

The incident

  1. 11. Between 27 March 2024 and 20 April 2026, AQA submitted 47 assessment material error event notifications relating to 56 accessibility issues affecting the braille versions of the assessments.[footnote 2]

  2. 12. Accessibility issues were identified across all three examination papers including the pre-release materials for paper 3. All but one of those issues were identified after the assessment materials had been issued to and sat by the learners.

  3. 13. In producing braille assessment materials, AQA was required to have regard to Ofqual’s guidance for designing and developing accessible assessments, which requires awarding organisations to have regard to relevant UK Association for Accessible Formats (“UKAAF”) standards and guidance for accessible assessment materials. The errors reported by AQA included, but were not limited to:

    1. a. insufficient tactile distinction between symbols, textures and lines, where features such as buildings, reference points, transport infrastructure and land use could not be reliably differentiated by touch;

    2. b. overly compact diagrams and maps, where textures and symbols were placed in close proximity, contrary to UK Association for Accessible Formats (“UKAAF”) guidance, resulting in information becoming indistinguishable in tactile form;

    3. c. inappropriate grid spacing, including repeated use of 1cm grids where UKAAF guidance recommends 1.5–2cm spacing, affecting a learners’ ability to interpret graphs and complete data-handling tasks;

    4. d. oversimplification of figures during the braille adaptation process, which removed or distorted essential information required to answer questions, including reference points, scale bars and geographic features;

    5. e. missing or incomplete written visual descriptions, where braille learners were expected to rely on descriptions that did not convey equivalent information to the visual figures provided to other learners; and

    6. f. raised texture failures and production issues, including diagrams, symbols and titles that were not correctly produced using the swell paper process, rendering critical tactile features inaccessible.

  4. 14. Across the modified braille assessments, the following errors occurred:

    1. a. Paper 1 included 24 assessment material errors. Of these, 18 were categorised as Category 1[footnote 3] and 6 as Category 2.[footnote 4]

    2. b. Paper 2 included 23 assessment material errors, comprising 18 Category 1 errors and 5 Category 2 errors.

    3. c. Paper 3 included 9 assessment material errors, comprising 7 Category 1 errors and 2 Category 2 errors.

Impact on learners

  1. 15. AQA accepted that learners requiring modified braille assessments did not have equal access to the assessments and were placed at a disadvantage compared to learners sitting assessment materials that did not contain errors. In particular, AQA accepted that learners could not access the full range of marks available, or could do so only without reference to adapted figures that examiners would ordinarily have expected them to use.

  2. 16. AQA confirmed that, in the assessments, the maximum total mark from questions that were error-free was:

    1. a. Paper 1: 52/88;

    2. b. Paper 2: 63/88; and

    3. c. Paper 3: 58/76.

  3. 17. As a result of the errors, AQA was required to implement post-assessment mitigation. This included corrective measures in cases where AQA was able to identify and assess the impact of the braille modification errors on affected learners.

  4. 18. As the scripts and associated item-level data for the Summer 2024 assessments had been destroyed in accordance with AQA’s data retention policy, AQA was unable to undertake an item-level analysis of learner performance. Consequently, neither AQA nor Ofqual was able to determine the precise impact of the errors on individual learners.

  5. 19. AQA submitted evidence showing that one of the five learners achieved a mark higher than the total number of marks available from questions unaffected by the errors on each paper. AQA asserted that the learner was able, to a significant extent, to identify and work around the errors. Ofqual does not accept that this demonstrates that the errors had no impact. The learner was still required to overcome barriers created by the errors and, in some instances, go beyond the question rubric in order to arrive at an answer. The fact that the learner was ultimately able to do so does not establish that they were not disadvantaged or subjected to an additional burden.

  6. 20. Ofqual has not seen evidence that the remaining four learners were similarly able to identify and overcome the errors. In the absence of item-level data, Ofqual cannot determine the extent of the impact on those learners.

Root causes

  1. 21. In considering the root causes of the incident, Ofqual recognises the challenges associated with producing braille assessment materials especially where complex visual information must be adapted into accessible formats. Ofqual examined whether AQA had taken appropriate steps to identify, manage and mitigate the associated risks. Ofqual’s findings are set out below.

  2. 22. Ofqual’s investigation found that accessibility considerations were not always fully considered by AQA during assessment development; this created avoidable difficulties during the subsequent modification of the materials into braille and tactile formats.

  3. 23. Ofqual’s investigation also found that a number of errors arose from known and foreseeable risks associated with the modification process that were not adequately identified, managed or mitigated prior to assessment delivery, and there were missed opportunities to identify and address those risks before the Summer 2024 examination series.

  4. 24. Specifically, after GCSE Geography braille papers were used as mock assessments in 2023, a User identified a number of errors and accessibility concerns and brought them to AQA’s attention ahead of the Summer 2024 examination series.[footnote 5]

  5. 25. Although AQA considered the concerns that had been raised, it concluded that many of the issues did not reveal errors requiring remedial action and consequently took no action in response to those issues. AQA accepted that weaknesses in its quality assurance, oversight and internal control arrangements contributed to a failure to identify and rectify errors in modified assessment materials before their use in live assessments.

  6. 26. Following the Summer 2024 examination series, concerns were raised with AQA through its Special Consideration process which suggested that the unaddressed errors and accessibility issues had affected the live examinations. Those concerns included allegations that issues similar to those identified following the 2023 mock assessments had been present in the Summer 2024 assessments.[footnote 6]

  7. 27. In response, AQA failed to follow its internal escalation procedures. AQA accepted that the concerns raised through the Special Consideration process should have been escalated at an earlier stage and acknowledged that the appropriate procedures were not followed. As a result, there was a delay in identifying, investigating and assessing the full extent of the errors.

  8. 28. AQA’s investigation of the issues, and its subsequent reporting of them to Ofqual, extended over a period of more than 18 months, with final event notifications not submitted until 20 April 2026. During that period, Ofqual engaged extensively with AQA to understand the nature, extent and potential impact of the errors. Consequently, the matter required a significant and sustained degree of regulatory oversight and engagement.

  9. 29. The full extent of the errors was not established until well after the assessments had been delivered. This delayed the identification and implementation of corrective action, created prolonged uncertainty regarding the nature and extent of the failings, and limited the ability of AQA to determine the full extent of the impact on affected learners.

  10. 30. Ofqual considers that the failings and delay were liable to adversely affect public confidence in the qualifications system. The production of modified assessment materials, particularly braille materials, has been the subject of wider public, stakeholder and parliamentary scrutiny. In that context, errors affecting modified assessment materials have the potential to attract public concern regarding the effectiveness of arrangements for their production and quality assurance.

  11. 31. Against that backdrop, the errors identified in this case, together with the prolonged period taken to establish their full extent and impact, had the potential to reinforce concerns regarding the effectiveness of arrangements for the production and quality assurance of modified assessment materials. They were also liable to undermine confidence that learners who rely on modified materials will receive assessments that are accurate, accessible and free from avoidable error. Ofqual considers this to be a significant factor given the importance of maintaining public confidence that regulated qualifications are delivered effectively and are accessible to all learners.

Steps taken to prevent a recurrence

  1. 32. Ahead of the Summer 2026 examination series, AQA reviewed and strengthened its arrangements for the production of modified assessment materials. These measures included enhanced governance, quality assurance and supplier oversight arrangements; revised internal controls; the deployment of technology to identify potential discrepancies between standard and braille assessment materials; additional specialist quality assurance support; increased engagement with external stakeholders; and strengthened escalation arrangements for accessibility concerns identified through the Special Consideration process.

  2. 33. These improvements remain ongoing. In addition, AQA has committed, pursuant to General Condition B8, to implement an action plan designed to further strengthen its arrangements for the production and quality assurance of modified assessment materials and reduce the risk of similar failings recurring in future examination series.

  3. 34. AQA has also engaged in wider sector initiatives aimed at reducing the risk of similar issues arising in future. This includes participation in a round-table meeting convened by Ofqual with all exam boards to consider challenges associated with the production of high-quality, accurate modified braille assessment materials. Ofqual considers that AQA’s participation in this initiative is relevant because a number of the issues arose in areas where the production of modified assessment materials presents particular operational and technical challenges. Engagement with sector-wide work supports the identification and dissemination of good practice, promotes greater consistency in approaches to modification, and contributes to efforts to mitigate the risk of similar failings occurring in future examination series.

  4. 35. In addition, AQA continues to commit significant resources to the provision of Reasonable Adjustments and modified assessment materials. AQA informed Ofqual that, in the current academic year, it has spent approximately £950,000 in the modification of current and past papers. The level of expenditure does not diminish the seriousness of the failings identified in this case. However, it provides context on AQA’s ongoing activity in seeking to support access to assessments for learners requiring modified materials.

Non-compliances

  1. 36. AQA has accepted, and Ofqual has found, that AQA failed to comply with the following Conditions of Recognition:

    1. a. AQA failed to ensure that assessment content was fit for purpose, contrary to General Conditions G1.1(a), G9.2(a) and G9.3(a).

    2. b. AQA failed to ensure that the assessments only used appropriate Stimulus Materials, contrary to General Condition G3.1.

    3. c. AQA failed to take all reasonable steps to ensure that the assessments did not contain Stimulus Materials which could lead a group of Learners who shared a common attribute or circumstance to experience an unreasonable disadvantage, contrary to General Condition G3.4.

    4. d. AQA failed to establish and maintain an effective system of control in relation to Reasonable Adjustments, contrary to General Conditions A5.1, A5.2(e), D2.2 and G6.1.

    5. e. AQA failed to manage the risks associated with assessments in advance of assessment delivery, contrary to General Condition A6.2.

    6. f. AQA failed to promptly take all reasonable steps to investigate and mitigate an incident which could have had an Adverse Effect, contrary to General Condition A7.1.

Regulatory action

  1. 37. On 2 November 2026, AQA signed a settlement proposal by which it:

    1. a. Agreed that it failed to comply with its Conditions of Recognition as set out in this Notice,

    2. b. Agreed to pay a monetary penalty in the sum of £350,000 in settlement of those non-compliances,

    3. c. Agreed to pay Ofqual’s reasonable legal costs,

    4. d. Agreed to provide an undertaking.

Determination of monetary penalty

  1. 38. On 5 November 2026, Ofqual’s Enforcement Panel considered the evidence relating to the non-compliances set out above, alongside the settlement proposal presented by AQA. The Enforcement Panel determined that AQA has breached its Conditions of Recognition as set out above.

  2. 39. The Enforcement Panel has considered the settlement proposal presented by AQA. In determining whether or not a Monetary Penalty is an appropriate regulatory outcome in this case and if so what amount would be proportionate to impose, the Enforcement Panel has had regard to Ofqual’s Supporting compliance and taking regulatory action policy (2025).

  3. 40. The Enforcement Panel notes the aggravating and mitigating factors set out below.

Aggravating factors

  1. 41. The following aggravating factors, as taken from Ofqual’s Supporting Compliance and taking regulatory action policy, are relevant in this case:

    1. a. the seriousness of the non-compliances, with the breaches affecting learners with a protected characteristic and arrangements intended to secure equal access to assessment;

    2. b. the non-compliances arose from matters within AQA’s control, including deficiencies in planning, risk management, quality assurance, oversight and internal controls;

    3. c. the significant delay in identifying, investigating and reporting the full extent of the errors, which reduced opportunities for timely intervention and remediation; and

    4. d. the existence of additional braille assessment material errors beyond the GCSE Geography errors, namely a further seven errors identified in the Summer 2024 series, four identified in the Summer 2025 series, and six further errors identified in the Summer 2026 series. This indicates that the failings identified in this case were not isolated incidents. These further errors are relevant to Ofqual’s assessment of the seriousness and persistence of failings.

Mitigating factors

  1. 42. The following mitigating factors were taken into account:

    1. a. AQA accepted the non-compliances and cooperated with Ofqual’s investigation and enforcement process. However, limited weight has been attached to this factor given the delay in identifying and reporting all relevant errors.

    2. b. AQA has implemented enhanced quality assurance and control measures for the production of modified assessment materials and has committed to implementing an action plan designed to address the causes of the noncompliances and mitigate the risk of recurrence. Prior to an enforcement action being contemplated, AQA had already commenced work to strengthen its processes, controls and oversight arrangements. This indicates AQA had recognised the need for improvement and was taking steps to address the underlying issues before the prospect of regulatory enforcement arose.

    3. c. There is no evidence that AQA’s non-compliances were deliberate, nor that AQA obtained any material financial or commercial benefit from them.

Other factors

  1. 43. The Enforcement Panel also considered:

    1. a. the need to deter AQA and other awarding organisations from making similar failings in the future;

    2. b. the need to promote public confidence in qualifications through visible, appropriate and effective regulatory action;

    3. c. the nature and circumstances of these non-compliances in comparison to other non-compliances for which fines have been imposed by Ofqual on other awarding organisations;

    4. d. AQA’s relative size and turnover as an awarding organisation.

Settlement

  1. 44. AQA cooperated with Ofqual’s investigation, promptly admitted the non-compliances and entered into a voluntary settlement in which it has acknowledged Ofqual’s decision in this Notice and agreed not to appeal. In light of this settlement, Ofqual has decided to impose a lower penalty than it would have done in a contested case.

Final decision

  1. 45. Taking all of the above into account, the Enforcement Panel has confirmed its earlier notice of intention to accept a settlement proposal and imposes a monetary penalty in the sum of £350,000.

  2. 46. The Enforcement Panel is satisfied, in accordance with section 151B of the 2009 Act, that the Monetary Penalty does not exceed 10% of AQA’s total annual turnover.

Payment

  1. 47. The monetary penalty must be paid within 28 days of the date of this notice, in accordance with the payment instructions provided with this notice.

  2. 48. In the event of non-payment, interest may be charged and the outstanding amount may be recovered as a debt, in accordance with section 151D of the Act.

Appeals

  1. 49. An awarding organisation may appeal to the First Tier Tribunal in respect of Ofqual’s decision to impose the monetary penalty and/or in respect of the amount of that penalty, in accordance with section 151C of the Act.

  2. 50. An appeal may be made on the grounds:

    1. a. that the decision was based on an error of fact;

    2. b. that the decision was wrong in law;

    3. c. that the decision was unreasonable.

  3. 51. Any appeal must be made within 28 days of the date of this notice. Further information is available from HM Courts and Tribunals Service.

Signed:

Chair of the Enforcement Panel

Date

12 November 2026

Enforcement Panel:

Hardip Begol CBE (Chair)

Clare Pelham

Conor Ryan

  1. Reasonable Adjustment defined in General Condition J1.8: An adjustment made to an assessment for a qualification so as to enable a disabled Learner to demonstrate his or her knowledge, skills and understanding to the levels of attainment required by the specification for that qualification. ↩

  2. An event notification is a notification to Ofqual under General Condition B3.1 - An awarding organisation must promptly notify Ofqual when it has cause to believe that any event has occurred or is likely to occur which could have an Adverse Effect. ↩

  3. Category 1 assessment material errors: Assessment material errors which could or do make it impossible for students to generate a meaningful response to a question or task. This includes mark scheme errors that could or do make it impossible to mark the assessment in a way that accurately and consistently reflects the level of attainment demonstrated by the learner. ↩

  4. Category 2 assessment material errors: Assessment material errors which could or do cause unintentional difficulties for students to generate a meaningful response to a question or task. This includes mark scheme errors that could or do cause confusion or misinterpretation and may prevent accurate and consistent marking. ↩

  5. Users of qualifications defined in General Condition J1.8: Persons who have a legitimate interest in the qualification or type of qualification made available by the awarding organisation, which may include – (a) Learners and Learners’ representatives, (b) Centres, (c) Teachers, (d) employers and employers’ representatives, (e) further and higher education establishments, (f) schools, (g) government departments and agencies, and (h) professional bodies. ↩

  6. Special Consideration defined in General Condition J1.8: - Consideration to be given to a Learner who has temporarily experienced an illness or injury, or some other event outside of his or her control, which has, or is reasonably likely to have, materially affected the Learner’s ability to – (a) take an assessment, or (b) demonstrate his or her level of attainment in an assessment. ↩