Independent report

Ignoring the alarms: How NHS eating disorder services are failing patients

A report of our investigation into the care and treatment of Averil Hart. We found that Averil's tragic death from anorexia would have been avoided if the NHS had provided appropriate care.


Ignoring the alarms: How NHS eating disorder services are failing patients

Order a copy


Mr Nic Hart complained to us about the care and treatment provided for his 19 year old daughter, Averil, by 4 NHS organisations. He also complained about how those organisations, a local Clinical Commissioning Group and NHS England handled his complaint about what happened to Averil.

We found that all the NHS organisations involved in Averil’s care and treatment between her discharge from hospital on 2 August 2012 and her tragic death on 15 December failed her in some way. We found her deterioration and death were avoidable.

We found that most of the NHS organisations which dealt with Mr Hart’s complaint failed to respond to his concerns in a sensitive, transparent and helpful way. Their investigations were not sufficiently thorough or joined-up. They did not provide Mr Hart with the answers he sought about Averil’s care and treatment.

These failings led Mr Hart to feel profound frustration with the NHS organisations and exacerbated his and his family’s deep distress resulting from Averil’s avoidable death.

Sadly we can do nothing to remedy the injustice to Averil. We have however made recommendations to remedy the injustice to her family. We have also made recommendations to ensure each of the organisations and the wider NHS learn from the mistakes made in this case.

We hope that our recommendations will mean that no other family experiences what Averil and her family experienced.

Published 8 December 2017