Skip to main content
Independent report

Statement on the potential health risk from Echinacea in the maternal diet: Lay summary

Published 9 November 2026

1. The Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition (SACN) is reviewing the scientific evidence that informs the Government’s dietary recommendations for women of childbearing age. To help SACN in this, the Committee on Toxicity of Chemicals in Food, Consumer Products and the Environment (COT) was asked to review the risks of toxicity from certain chemicals and products in the maternal diet. This statement focuses specifically on the possible health risks from Echinacea-based food supplements and foods containing Echinacea before and during pregnancy, childbirth and up to 24 months after delivery.

2. Echinacea is a genus of herbaceous flowering plants. Three Echinacea species, Echinacea purpurea, Echinacea pallida, and Echinacea angustifolia, are used medicinally. Echinacea herbal products are marketed to enhance immune function and to reduce the symptoms and duration of cold, flu and other upper respiratory tract infections. Studies show that about 0.5% to 9.2% of pregnant women use Echinacea products during pregnancy.

3. Echinacea products are complex because they contain many different substances. This means that the effects of Echinacea cannot be fully attributed to a single substance but are the result of a combination of different substances working together.  Because of that, there is no agreed way to measure, standardise, or compare different Echinacea products. The amount and type of substances present can vary between Echinacea products, depending on the Echinacea species, the part of the plant and the preparation method used.

4. This statement focuses on foods containing Echinacea, including teas and honey, as well as food supplements such as tablets, capsules, and tinctures that contain Echinacea. Some Echinacea products in the UK are registered as traditional herbal medicines to help relieve symptoms of colds, flu-like illnesses, minor skin problems such as spots or pimples, and mild urinary issues in women, but these are regulated by the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) and are not addressed in depth in this statement. The MHRA does not recommend the use of Echinacea herbal medicines in pregnant or breastfeeding women because there is not enough safety information available. Many Echinacea food supplements, particularly tablets and capsules, also include warning labels advising against use during pregnancy and breastfeeding.

5. The content of Echinacea products on the market can vary widely, making it challenging to assess their safety, especially when looking at research findings. To circumnavigate this problem, most studies on Echinacea reviewed in this statement have used Echinacea medicinal products rather than foods or food supplements. Traditional herbal Echinacea medicines usually contain only Echinacea and are made in a consistent way, with clear information about how strong the product is and how much plant material it contains. In contrast, Echinacea food supplements often contain a mix of other ingredients and may use different parts of the plant or extracts of varying strength. Key details, such as the species of Echinacea used or how much is in the product, are sometimes missing from labels. This makes food supplements more variable and harder to compare with traditional herbal medicinal products.

6. Studies in animals suggest that Echinacea has low toxicity. In clinical studies, Echinacea products were generally well tolerated by non-pregnant women, who experienced only mild and temporary side effects such as stomach upset or minor allergic skin reactions. Some safety reports also show that Echinacea can, rarely, trigger allergic reactions, including severe reactions like anaphylaxis, especially in people who already have allergies or conditions like eczema or asthma. Because of this, regulatory authorities advise that people with asthma or a history of allergies avoid Echinacea or use it with caution. Since Echinacea can affect how the immune system works, it is also not recommended for people with autoimmune diseases, weakened immune systems, those taking medicines that suppress immunity, or people with disorders affecting white blood cells.

7. There is limited information on how safe Echinacea is to use during pregnancy or while breastfeeding. Laboratory and animal studies suggest that Echinacea does not damage genetic material (DNA). A small number of studies in animals (mice, pigs, and rabbits) have looked at Echinacea use during pregnancy. Some mouse studies suggested possible risks, such as increased pregnancy loss or changes in blood vessel development in the foetus. However, the COT considered that these studies involved small numbers of animals and the results were not consistent. Studies in pigs and rabbits did not find any differences in pregnancy outcomes, birth weight, or birth defects compared with animals that did not receive Echinacea.

8. Studies in humans have also looked at pregnancy outcomes after Echinacea use and did not find evidence of harm. However, these studies relied on women reporting their own use, and details such as the dose, type of product, and how long Echinacea was taken were not known. Overall, because the available evidence is limited and incomplete, the safety of Echinacea during pregnancy and breastfeeding remains uncertain.

9. Herbal products can sometimes contain unwanted substances like heavy metals, bacteria, fungi, mould toxins, or pesticide residues. As the information on the presence of these substances in Echinacea products is limited, it is not possible to determine whether there is a risk from these contaminants to consumers of Echinacea products.

10. Overall, the COT concluded that there is not enough reliable information to properly assess how safe Echinacea is to use during pregnancy or while breastfeeding. While harmful effects are considered unlikely when Echinacea is used for a short time at the levels found in food and food supplements, the available data are limited and considerable uncertainty remains. As a precaution, pregnant women are advised to avoid the use of Echinacea-containing food supplements unless a qualified healthcare professional recommends their use.