DWP Customer Experience Survey: Child Maintenance Service 2022 to 2023
Updated 21 November 2024
© Crown copyright 2024
This publication is licensed under the terms of the Open Government Licence v3.0 except where otherwise stated. To view this licence, visit nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3 or write to the Information Policy Team, The National Archives, Kew, London TW9 4DU, or email: psi@nationalarchives.gov.uk.
Where we have identified any third party copyright information you will need to obtain permission from the copyright holders concerned.
This publication is available at https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/dwp-customer-experience-survey-child-maintenance-service-2022-to-2023/dwp-customer-experience-survey-child-maintenance-service-2022-to-2023
DWP Research Report No: 1063
Crown copyright
First Published: 29 August 2024
ISBN: 978-1-78659-686-4
The Customer Experience Survey (CES) is designed to monitor customer satisfaction with the services offered by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) to inform improvements in service delivery. It is an ongoing cross-sectional study with quarterly interviewing. This research was externally commissioned by DWP with fieldwork independently conducted by Ipsos (previously known as Ipsos MORI).
The data in this report is based on 1,658 interviews conducted with Child Maintenance Service (CMS) customers who had contact with the service between July 2022 and March 2023. This report presents data on overall customer satisfaction and looks at survey data that is mapped to the DWP Customer Experience Drivers. The DWP Customer Experience Drivers provide standards against which customer service delivery can be measured. This report includes data relating to:
- Get it Right
- Make it Easy
- Communicate Clearly
- Professional and Supportive.
An annex has been included at the end of the DWP Customer Experience Survey: Benefit Customers 2022 to 2023 report outlining the results of the Customer Priorities Survey, an ad hoc survey conducted by Ipsos in 2022 which also included CMS customers.
Our thanks go to all those who gave up their time to take part in this study.
About the Child Maintenance Service
CMS helps separated families to make financial choices to provide for their children when needed. Child maintenance is an arrangement between parents to cover the child’s living costs when one parent no longer lives with them. Parents use CMS to arrange child maintenance if they do not want to contact the other parent themselves, and many have tried family-based arrangements before deciding to use CMS. CMS is unique in that there are two customers for each case (a Receiving Parent and a Paying Parent), often with an opposing position about their maintenance arrangement. This means that, in many instances, when a positive result for one customer is achieved, the other customer may be less satisfied.
At a glance – Overall
Customer satisfaction
Less than half of customers were satisfied with CMS services overall.
Satisfied: 45%.
Dissatisfied: 55%.
About the survey
Survey methodology
CES replaced the previous Claimant Service and Experience Survey (CSES) in 2019 and CMS customers were included in the survey from this point onwards.
Sample
CES is a survey of customers who have had recent contact with CMS, rather than all CMS customers. The sample includes parents who have been in contact with the service during each 3-month quarter to either make a new application or report a change of circumstances. ‘Contact’ includes any time a customer has phoned, written a letter, emailed, filled in an online form, used the Child Maintenance online portal, or otherwise got in touch with CMS. Customers are also included in the sample if they were contacted by CMS through any of these methods. For the contact to be identified and the customer included in the overall survey population, the contact needs to have triggered a change in CMS administrative data during the 3-month quarter.
A quota sample design is used to meet minimum interview targets for each parent type and contact reason, with a random sample of CMS customers drawn from the population to meet these quotas. Weighting is then applied to the data so that findings are representative of the survey population: data is weighted by age, gender, length of service use, and contact reason.
Fieldwork
The survey moved to a mixed-mode online and telephone approach from 2019, with fieldwork conducted quarterly with CMS customers. The data in this annual report is based on interviews completed with 1,658 CMS customers who had contact with the service between July 2022 and March 2023.
From July 2022, the CMS survey sample was changed to exclude all customers who had contact with CMS because of arrears. For this reason, the present report does not include results from the first fieldwork quarter (April to June 2022). Due to these sample changes, the results from July 2022 to March 2023 are not comparable to previous CMS reports.
Statistical conventions
Percentages in charts may not always add to 100% due to rounding.
Responses for sub-groups with larger base sizes will be more robust and have a lower margin of error than sub-groups with smaller base sizes. Therefore, it is possible to identify relatively small differences as being statistically significant when comparing sub-groups which have larger sample sizes. The issue of sub-group size particularly applies to the customer characteristics sections where the sample sizes for some ethnicities are smaller.
The differences between Paying Parents and Receiving Parents illustrated in this report are found to be statistically significant at the 95% confidence level. Receiving Parents give higher scores, reflecting the differences between these two CMS customer groups. A statistically significant difference at the 95% confidence level means that you would only expect to see the result caused by chance 1 in 20 times.
Results: Overall satisfaction
CMS respondents were asked how satisfied they were about the service they had received. It is important when considering the satisfaction of these customers to note that CMS is unique in that there are two customers for each case, often with an opposing position about their maintenance arrangement. This means that, in many instances, when a positive result for one customer is achieved, the other customer may be less satisfied. This can include, for example, where collect and pay arrangements are implemented, and where payments and liability are calculated based on known circumstances. Parents often contact CMS at a time where their personal relationships are strained and they may have a poor quality or non-existent relationship with the other parent. Many have tried family-based arrangements before deciding to use CMS.
These circumstances of CMS customers mean that they may not necessarily be expected to have high levels of satisfaction.
More than 4 out of ten customers reported being satisfied with the services provided by CMS
In 2022 to 2023, 45% of all CMS customers said they were either fairly or very satisfied with the overall service provided by CMS. This figure includes both Paying and Receiving Parents. ‘Don’t Know’ responses to the overall satisfaction question are excluded from analysis throughout.
Table 1: Percentage of customers who were satisfied or dissatisfied with the services provided by CMS
| Response | 2022 to 2023 (%) |
|---|---|
| Satisfied | 45% |
| Dissatisfied | 55% |
Base: All customers (excluding Don’t Know responses). Overall (1,618); Receiving Parents (818); Paying Parents (800).
More than half of Receiving Parents and over two thirds of Paying Parents were satisfied with the services provided by CMS
Receiving Parents were more likely to be satisfied than Paying Parents. Table 2 shows that in 2022 to 2023, 54% of Receiving Parents were satisfied compared to 35% of Paying Parents.
Table 2: Percentage of customers who were satisfied with the services provided by CMS by parent type
| Parents | 2022 to 2023 (%) |
|---|---|
| Overall | 45% |
| Receiving | 54% |
| Paying | 35% |
Base: All customers (excluding Don’t Know responses). Overall (1,618); Receiving Parents (818); Paying Parents (800).
One third of Change of Circumstances customers and almost 6 out of ten New customers reported being satisfied with the services provided by CMS
In 2022 to 2023, 59% of New customers were satisfied compared to 33% of Change of Circumstances customers.
Table 3: Percentage of customers who were satisfied with the services provided by CMS by contact type
| Customers | 2022 to 2023 (%) |
|---|---|
| Overall | 45% |
| New customers | 59% |
| Change of circumstances customers | 33% |
Base: All customers (excluding Don’t Know responses). Overall customers (1,618); New customers (693); Change of Circumstances customers (925).
Results by Customer Experience Driver
This section of the report is structured around four Customer Experience Drivers:
- Get it Right
- Make it Easy
- Communicate Clearly
- Professional and Supportive.
These questions have been selected on the basis that they have the best coverage of survey respondents, as some questions are only asked to particular customer groups.
Get it Right
Questions that relate to the Get it Right Driver are reported below.
Table 4 shows that, overall, more than half of customers agreed that staff[footnote 1] did what they said they would (54%) and that staff provided accurate information (54%). The third question was only asked to New customers: more than 6 out of ten of these customers were satisfied with the time it took CMS to communicate the outcome of their application (62%).
Table 4: Percentage of customers who agreed with key questions related to the Get it Right Driver by parent type
| Parent | Staff did what they said they would | Staff provided accurate information | Satisfaction with the time for CMS to tell new customers the outcome of their application |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 54% | 54% | 62% |
| Receiving parent | 59% | 62% | 73% |
| Paying parent | 49% | 46% | 53% |
Bases: Staff did what they said they would do: All customers who had phone/online/in person contact (excluding Not Applicable responses). Overall (1,440); Receiving Parents (724); Paying Parents (716).
Staff provided accurate information: All customers who had phone/online/in person contact (excluding Not Applicable responses). Overall (1,483); Receiving Parents (752); Paying Parents (731).
Satisfaction with the time it took for CMS to tell New customers the outcome of their application: All New customers. Overall (713); Receiving Parents (368); Paying Parents (345).
Make it Easy
Questions that relate to the Make it Easy Driver are reported below.
Table 5 shows that, of those who used GOV.UK, around 3 quarters of customers reported that it was easy to find the information they needed (76%). Around 6 out of ten customers found it easy to make a new application or report a change of circumstances (61%)[footnote 2].
Around 4 out of ten customers said they did not have to contact CMS more than once to explain the same information (41%). At the same time, more than half of customers reported that when they were first in touch with CMS, they were able to get the information they needed the first time they tried (54%).
Table 5: Percentage of customers who agreed with key questions related to the Make it Easy Driver by parent type
| Parent | Easy to find information | Easy to make a new application/report change of circumstances | Did not have to contact CMS more than once to explain same information | Got information needed first time |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 76% | 61% | 41% | 54% |
| Receiving parent | 86% | 73% | 51% | 63% |
| Paying parent | 62% | 37% | 31% | 43% |
Bases: Reported it was easy to find all the information they needed on GOV.UK: All customers who used the government website (GOV.UK). Overall (576); Receiving Parents (340); Paying Parents (236).
Found the process of making a new application/reporting a change of circumstances easy: All New Receiving Parents and all Change of Circumstances customers. Overall (1,313); Receiving Parents (837); Paying Parents (476).
Did not have to contact CMS more than once to explain the same information: All customers. Overall (1,658); Receiving Parents (837); Paying Parents (821).
Able to get the information they needed the first time they tried: All customers who had communications by phone, online, video call, or in person. Overall (1,526); Receiving Parents (786); Paying Parents (740).
Communicate Clearly
Questions that relate to the Communicate Clearly Driver are reported below.
Table 6 shows that, overall, more than half of customers agreed that the communication they received was easy to understand (57%) and that they had a good understanding of what would happen next during the application process/when reporting a change of circumstances (55%). The other 2 questions were asked of New customers only: more than 6 out of ten New customers agreed that CMS provided them with timescales for processing the decision of their application (64%) and that the outcome of their application was explained with enough detail (62%).
Table 6: Percentage of customers who agreed with key questions related to the Communicate Clearly Driver by parent type
| Parent | CMS communicated clearly | Had a good understanding of what would happen next | CMS provided timescales for processing the decision around their application | Decisions about their application were clearly explained |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 57% | 55% | 64% | 62% |
| Receiving parent | 65% | 59% | 72% | 69% |
| Paying parent | 49% | 50% | 55% | 55% |
Bases: The communication they received was easy to understand: All customers (excluding Not Applicable responses). Overall (1,627); Receiving Parents (818); Paying Parents (809).
They had a good understanding of what would happen next: All customers (excluding Not Applicable responses). Overall (1,644); Receiving Parents (827); Paying Parents (817).
CMS provided them with timescales for processing the decision around their application: All New customers. Overall (713); Receiving Parents (368); Paying Parents (345).
The outcome of their application was explained with enough detail to allow them to understand CMS’s decision: All New customers (excluding those who are awaiting an outcome). Overall (681); Receiving Parents (355); Paying Parents (326).
Professional and Supportive
Questions that relate to the Professional and Supportive Driver are reported below.
Table 7 shows that overall, around 6 out of ten customers agreed that their request was handled professionally (61%). More than half of customers agreed that staff understood their needs (53%), and 43% reported that CMS tailored services to their personal circumstances[footnote 3].
Table 7: Percentage of customers who agreed with key questions related to the Professional and Supportive Driver by parent type
| Parent | Their request was handled professionally | Staff understood their needs | CMS tailored services to their personal circumstances |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 61% | 53% | 43% |
| Receiving parent | 70% | 64% | 52% |
| Paying parent | 51% | 42% | 25% |
Base: Their request was handled professionally: All customers who had phone/online/in person contact (excluding Not Applicable responses). Overall (1,499); Receiving Parents (760); Paying Parents (739).
Staff understood their needs: All customers who had phone/online/in person contact (excluding Not Applicable responses). Overall (1,474); Receiving Parents (740); Paying Parents (734).
CMS tailored services to their personal circumstances: All New Receiving Parents and all Change of Circumstances customers (excluding Not Applicable responses). Overall (1,272); Receiving Parents (803); Paying Parents (469).
Customer characteristics
The following section explores overall customer satisfaction by age, gender, ethnicity, and whether customers reported having a long-term health condition. It also looks at customers’ digital propensity.
Age: Younger customers appeared to have higher overall satisfaction than older customers
The youngest age group was more likely to be satisfied. Those aged between 16 and 24 reported a higher satisfaction level (63%) than those in older age groups. These differences (between the 16 to 24 age group and each of the 25+ groups) are statistically significant. Those aged 35 to 44 were also statistically more likely to report being satisfied compared to those aged 45 to 54. However, some of the base sizes for these groups are low (61 for 16 to 24 age group and 80 for the 55+ age group), so these results should be treated with caution.
Table 8: Percentage of customers who were satisfied with the services provided by CMS by age
| Age | 2022 to 2023 (%) |
|---|---|
| Overall | 45% |
| 16 to 24 | 63% |
| 25 to 34 | 44% |
| 35 to 44 | 45% |
| 45 to 54 | 39% |
| 55+ | 46% |
Base: All customers (excluding Don’t Know responses). Overall (1,618); 16 to 24 (61); 25 to 34 (365); 35 to 44 (705); 45 to 54 (407); 55+ (80).
Gender: Women were more likely to be satisfied than men
Female customers were more likely to be satisfied with the service overall than male customers.
Table 9 shows that 53% of women reported they were satisfied, compared to 36% of men, which is a statistically significant difference. This is because male CMS customers are more likely to be Paying Parents, for whom overall satisfaction is lower.
Table 9: Percentage of customers who were satisfied with the services provided by CMS by gender
| Gender | 2022 to 2023 (%) |
|---|---|
| Overall | 45% |
| Female | 53% |
| Male | 36% |
Base: All customers (excluding Don’t Know responses and respondents whose gender was missing in the sample). Overall (1,584); Female (779); Male (805).
Ethnicity: Customers from Black/African/Caribbean/Black British backgrounds had the highest satisfaction score
Almost 6 out of ten customers identifying as Black/African/Caribbean/Black British were satisfied with CMS. The differences between this group and all other ethnicity groups are statistically significant. However, satisfaction was lowest among customers who chose not to disclose their ethnicity. Except for White customers, the bases for the ethnicity groups are below 100 so the results should be treated with caution.
Table 10: Percentage of customers who were satisfied with the services provided by CMS by ethnicity
| Ethnicity | 2022 to 2023 (%) |
|---|---|
| Overall | 45% |
| Black/African/Caribbean/Black British | 58% |
| White | 45% |
| Other/Mixed/Multiple ethnicities | 40% |
| Asian/Asian British | 38% |
| Prefer not to say | 27% |
Base: All customers (excluding Don’t Know responses). Overall (1,618); Black/African/Caribbean/Black British (91); White (1,340); Other/Mixed/Multiple ethnicities (55); Asian/Asian British (56); Prefer not to say (74). The Other and Mixed/Multiple ethnicities groups were combined to give a larger base size for analysis.
Two participants declared they did not know their ethnicity. They were included in the analysis for the Overall group, although they do not appear separately in the chart or the base sizes.
Long-term health conditions: There were similar levels of satisfaction across all groups
Those who reported having any kind of long-term health condition had slightly higher levels of satisfaction when compared to those with no health condition. However, there are no statistically significant differences between the groups with long-term conditions and the group with no health condition. Those who preferred not to disclose their health condition reported the lowest level of satisfaction at 36%. Just over half of those who reported they have only a physical health condition(s) were satisfied, though as this category has a base lower than 100 this statistic should be treated with caution.
A long-term health condition or disability is defined as any physical or mental health condition or illness lasting or expected to last for 12 months or more, as self-reported by customers responding to the survey.
Table 11: Percentage of customers who were satisfied with the services provided by CMS by whether they reported a long-term health condition
| Health condition | 2022 to 2023 (%) |
|---|---|
| Overall | 45% |
| Physical health condition(s) | 51% |
| Mental health condition(s) | 47% |
| Both physical and mental health conditions | 46% |
| No health condition | 45% |
| Prefer not to say | 36% |
Base: All customers (excluding Don’t Know responses). Overall (1,618); Physical health condition(s) (92); Mental health condition(s) (230); Both physical and mental health conditions (138); No health condition (1,047); Prefer not to say (111).
Long-term health condition profile
This section explores the customer composition by long-term health conditions.
Almost 3 out of ten customers reported having a long-term health condition(s)
More than 6 out of ten customers reported they had no long-term conditions. Six percent of customers reported having only a physical health condition(s); 15% reported having only a mental health condition(s); and 9% reported having both physical and mental health conditions. The percentages do not total 29% due to rounding.
Table 12: Percentage of customers by whether or not they have a long-term health condition(s)
| Condition | Physical health condition(s) (%) | Mental health condition(s) (%) | Both physical and mental health conditions (%) | Total (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No long-term health condition | – | – | – | 63% |
| Long-term health condition(s) | 6% | 15% | 9% | 29% |
| Prefer not to say | – | – | – | 7% |
Base: All customers (1,658).
Note: The group percentages in the chart do not total 100% due to rounding.
Digital propensity
This section explores customers’ digital propensity.
More than 9 out of ten of the customers who participated in the survey declared they had internet access
Overall, digital propensity was high, with 94% of CMS customers stating they could access the internet, either at home or elsewhere. Although Receiving Parents (96%) and Paying Parents (93%) both reported high levels of internet access, the difference between them is statistically significant.
Table 13: Percentage of customers who had access to the internet
| Parent | Access to internet 2022 to 2023 |
|---|---|
| Overall | 94% |
| Receiving parent | 96% |
| Paying parent | 93% |
Base: All customers. Overall (1,658); Receiving Parents (837); Paying Parents (821).
More than 8 out of ten CMS customers said they could have accessed government services using the internet
Customers were asked if, had it been available, they could have used the internet to access government services. Table 14 shows that 82% reported that they could do so without help. A further 5% could have accessed government services online with help.
Table 14: Percentage of customers who could have accessed government services using the internet if it was available
| Parent | Yes, without help 2022 to 2023 | Yes, with help 2022 to 2023 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 82% | 5% | 87% |
| Receiving parent | 83% | 5% | 88% |
| Paying parent | 81% | 5% | 86% |
Base: All customers. Overall (1,658); Receiving Parents (837); Paying Parents (821).
-
This report refers to “staff” to reflect the wording used when the questionnaire was designed. In future, this will be updated to “colleagues ↩
-
For this question, the Paying Parents group only includes Change of Circumstances customers, so the difference in results might partly reflect the lower overall satisfaction level for the Change of Circumstances group. ↩
-
For this question, the Paying Parents group only includes Change of Circumstances customers, so the difference in results might partly reflect the lower overall satisfaction level for the Change of Circumstances group (see page 7). ↩