Skip to main content
Independent report

Animal Sentience Committee's report on policy statements relating to grey squirrel and deer

Published 10 November 2026

The Animal Sentience Committee (ASC) has considered the Grey squirrel policy statement: managing the impact of grey squirrels, and the Deer impacts policy statement: managing the impacts of wild deer in England, which were released on 29 January and 6 February 2026, respectively. The Animal Sentience Committee (ASC) considered both policy statements together, because they share the core objectives of protecting woodland resilience, biodiversity and the economy from overabundant and/or invasive species.

The committee supports these broad objectives. However, killing wild animals, or otherwise reducing their numbers, will have welfare impacts on target animals and may also have welfare impacts on non-target animals, as well as wider effects on other species. In conducting their review, the ASC also took into consideration the context of these policies in relation to the Great Britain invasive non-native invasive species strategy and the best practice guidance within the Deer Initiative.

The ASC has a statutory remit under the Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act 2022 to assess whether, or to what extent, the government has given all due regard to the ways in which a policy might have an adverse effect on the welfare of animals as sentient beings.

The ASC requested responses to questions relating to these areas and thanks the policy teams for their detailed written responses and for engaging in a constructive and informative dialogue that further explained their approach to the development of these policies. The committee and policy teams agreed that deer, and grey squirrels, have value as individuals and that their welfare is important.

The ASC sought further information on 6 areas:

  • consideration of the humaneness of control methods, including lethal methods
  • monitoring and enforcement of policies and regulations
  • potential negative consequences of commercialising venison, such as poaching
  • impacts of control activities on non-target animals
  • landscape-scale management
  • consideration of non-lethal alternatives.

The policy teams explained that deer and grey squirrel management is governed by a framework of legislation, licensing requirements, grant conditions, training, and best-practice guidance. On competency and welfare standards, there are no statutory minimum qualifications for practitioners during normal daytime open seasons but control activities must comply with relevant legislation and, where public funding or licences are involved, are subject to conditions requiring training, management planning, and adherence to recognised best practice. The exception to this is night shooting, under the CL55 Class Licence to kill deer at night, where Natural England explicitly mandates a minimum level of competence. The government considers the existing framework proportionate and notes that there is no evidence to date that suggests that the current welfare policies and guidance are falling short.

Regarding monitoring, the committee was informed that grant-funded activity requires collection of cull and effort data, habitat impact assessments, and that licensed deer control may be monitored through licence compliance arrangements. Although specific welfare outcomes such as pain, distress, or time to death are not   recorded, the government’s position is that only lawful and humane methods should be used. There are also existing mechanisms to amend licence conditions, grant requirements, guidance, and trap approval standards if evidence of welfare concerns emerges. The ASC understood that the policy teams’ responses indicated due consideration of current policies and practice around monitoring, when drafting the grey squirrel and deer policies. However, the committee also identified an evidence gap with respect to detecting and reducing animal suffering during culling operations.

In relation to venison commercialisation, the policy teams explained that safeguards include existing wildlife and food safety legislation, police enforcement of poaching offences, veterinary inspection within the venison supply chain, and the development of quality assurance initiatives. They emphasised that government support is focused on improving infrastructure and market functioning rather than incentivising culling through bounty-style payments.

On non-target animals and species, the policy teams stated that improving woodland condition, as a result of effective deer and grey squirrel management, is expected to benefit a wide range of wildlife and that there is a strong evidence base for this. They further explained that legislation, licence conditions, trap approval requirements, training, and guidance are intended to minimise risks to non-target animals and require practitioners to take reasonable steps to prevent unnecessary suffering.

The committee also explored the implications of landscape-scale management (which involves collaboration between landowners and agencies over large areas, instead of fragmented sites) and the consideration of non-lethal approaches. The policy teams advised that landscape-scale action is expected to improve woodland health and biodiversity, while acknowledging that welfare protections remain applicable to all management activities.

They further confirmed that non-lethal measures, including fencing, tree protection, fertility control research, and other emerging methods, were considered during policy development and are being pursued. However, the government concluded that lethal control currently remains necessary in many locations to address the scale of deer and grey squirrel impacts.

Conclusion

The ASC considers that sufficient due regard was given to the welfare of sentient animals in the development of the Grey Squirrel Policy Statement and the Deer Impacts Policy Statement, given the currently available evidence on welfare impacts. The committee is satisfied that animal welfare considerations were identified and taken into account throughout policy development, and that Ministers were provided with information on the welfare implications of both lethal and non-lethal management options.

The committee also notes the existence of a substantial framework of legislation, guidance, training, licensing, and grant conditions intended to mitigate welfare harms and promote humane practice.

However, the previous Animal Sentience Committee report on the due regard to animal welfare – legislative compliance and enforcement identified issues with the detection of non-compliance in unmonitored settings, and with the level of resource and expertise available to local authorities and police regarding wildlife crime. This underlines the importance of taking a strategic, coherent approach to policy-making that has the potential to impact on the welfare of sentient animals.

Recommendations

To support continuous improvement in the consideration of animal welfare during the implementation and future development of wildlife management policy, the ASC recommends that Defra should:

  1. Keep under review the case for introducing more formal competency and accreditation requirements for individuals undertaking deer and grey squirrel control activities.
  2. Explore opportunities to improve the collection and publication of data relevant to animal welfare outcomes, particularly where control activities are supported through public funding or licensing.
  3. Continue to review the humaneness of approved control methods and ensure that emerging evidence is reflected promptly in guidance, licensing conditions, and trap approval processes.
  4. Strengthen monitoring of potential impacts on non-target animals and species, particularly where management is conducted at larger spatial scales.
  5. Continue to support the development and evaluation of effective non-lethal approaches, including fertility control and other emerging technologies, and incorporate such methods into future policy where evidence supports their use.
  6. Periodically review the animal welfare implications of both policies as new scientific evidence, monitoring data, and management approaches become available.

Policies and guidelines referenced

The ASC referred to the following policies and guidance:

The ASC members responsible for this report:

  • Anna Meredith

  • Penny Hawkins

  • Richard Cooper