All metal-on-metal (MoM) hip replacements: updated advice for follow-up of patients
MHRA is updating advice provided in MDA/2012/036, to assist the early detection of soft tissue reactions in patients implanted with metal-on-metal (MoM) hip replacements (MDA/2017/018)
- Put updated systems in place for the follow-up and investigation of all patients implanted with MoM hip replacements.
- Follow the patient management advice given in table 11 of the appendix in the MDA document below, in conjunction with the following guidance notes:
- MARS MRI scans or ultrasound scans should carry more weight in decision-making than isolated blood metal levels alone.
- Patients with muscle or bone damage shown on MARS MRI are those of most concern.
- An isolated fluid collection (unless very large) around the joint in an asymptomatic patient, can be observed with interval scanning and clinical review.
- Local symptoms may occur in otherwise well-functioning hips; these should be investigated for other causes.
- Rising blood metal levels may indicate potential for soft tissue reaction.
- After revision surgery, whole blood metal levels of chromium and/or cobalt are expected to fall and symptoms to improve. Persistent symptoms should be investigated for potential causes that include: failure of fixation, component loosening, infection and instability. If no cause is found, further blood metal level measurement and cross-sectional imaging should be considered.
- The advice in table 1 has been produced based on current knowledge, it will not necessarily cover all clinical situations. Each patient must be assessed individually.
- Medical directors.
- Orthopaedic departments.
- Orthopaedic surgeons.
- Staff involved in the management of patients with joint replacement implants.
Deadlines for actions
Actions underway: 13 July 2017 Actions complete: 27 July 2017
Problem / background
MHRA, in consultation with its independent Metal-on-Metal Expert Advisory Group (MoM EAG), has continued to monitor the performance of MoM hip joint articulations for the occurrence of soft tissue reaction associated with these devices. The majority of patients with MoM hip replacements currently have well-functioning hips. However, some patients will develop progressive soft tissue reactions to the wear debris associated with MoM articulations. Data from the 13th Annual Report of the National Joint Registry of England, Wales, Northern Ireland and the Isle of Man, published in 20162, continued to show a risk of adverse soft tissue reaction to particulate debris.
MHRA’s clinical orthopaedic experts have also observed that soft tissue necrosis may occur in both asymptomatic and symptomatic patients, and believe early detection of these events should give a better revision outcome should this becomes necessary.
This advice also draws on information from:
- The British Hip Society on the follow up of patients given in the Primary Total Hip Replacement: A Guide to Good Practice, Nov 2012. This publication is also known as the Blue Book3.
- Orthopaedic Data Evaluation Panel (ODEP) device ratings. These ratings are based on the strength of the evidence presented by the manufacturer regarding their device.
There is no agreed threshold value for whole blood metal levels that either predicts outcome, or mandates revision. Decisions to revise are influenced by patient factors, blood metal levels, imaging findings, and implant type and position. Other patient specific factors may need to be considered when interpreting results for blood metal levels.
Measurements of cobalt or chromium blood levels should be carried out: * in England, Northern Ireland or Wales, by laboratories participating in the Trace Elements External Quality Assessment Scheme (TEQAS) - www.sas-centre.org/ * in Scotland, by the Scottish Trace Element and Micronutrient Reference Laboratories - http://www.trace-elements.co.uk/
Note: The recommendations in this Medical Device Alert (MDA) replace the patient follow-up advice previously given in MDA/2012/036, MDA/2013/010, and MDA/2015/024.
This Medical Device Alert is being sent to GPs for information only, in case patients ask about the contents of this notice. GPs need take no further action on receipt of this alert.
If you are responsible for cascading these alerts in your organisation, these are our suggested distribution lists.
Trusts (NHS boards in Scotland)
CAS and SABS (NI) liaison officers for onward distribution to all relevant staff including:
- Clinical governance leads
- Fracture clinics
- Medical physics departments
- MRI units, directors of
- Orthopaedic surgeons
- Outpatient clinics
- Radiation & medical oncology departments
- Radiology departments
- Radiology directors
Public Health England
Directors for onward distribution to:
- Safety officers
NHS England area teams
CAS liaison officers for onward distribution to all relevant staff including:
- General practitioners
- General practice managers
- General practice nurses
Establishments registered with the Care Quality Commission (CQC) (England only)
- Adult placement
- Hospitals in the independent sector
- Independent treatment centres
Please note: CQC and OFSTED do not distribute these alerts. Independent healthcare providers and social care providers can sign up to receive MDAs directly from the Department of Health’s Central Alerting System (CAS) by sending an email to: email@example.com and requesting this facility.
Send enquiries about this notice to MHRA, quoting reference number MMDA/2017/018 or 2016/005/025/264/001.
Orthopaedic team, Devices Safety and Surveillance, MHRA
Tel: 020 3080 7080
Devices Clinical Team, MHRA
Tel: 020 3080 7274
Reporting adverse incidents in England
Alerts in Northern Ireland are distributed via the NI SABS system.
Enquiries and adverse incident reports in Northern Ireland should be addressed to:
Northern Ireland Adverse Incident Centre, CMO Group,
Department of Health, Social Services and Public Safety
Tel: 028 9052 3868
Please report directly to NIAIC using the forms on our website.
Enquiries and adverse incident reports in Scotland should be addressed to:
Incident Reporting and Investigation Centre,
Health Facilities Scotland,
NHS National Services Scotland
Tel: 0131 275 7575
Fax: 0131 314 0722
Reporting adverse incidents in Scotland
NHS Boards and Local Authorities in Scotland – report to Health Facilities Scotland.
Contractors such as private hospitals carrying out NHS work and private care homes that accept social work funded clients – report to Health Facilities Scotland.
Enquiries in Wales should be addressed to:
Healthcare Quality Division,
Tel: 02920 823 624 / 02920 825 510
Reporting adverse incidents in Wales
In all cases, the benefit of ionising radiation screening should be weighed against the risks from radiation exposure on an individual patient basis, in line with the requirements of The Ionising Radiation (Medical Exposure) Regulations 2000. ↩
The National Joint Registry for England, Wales Northern Ireland and the Isle of Man, (2016); 13th Annual Report 2016, National Joint Registry for England, Wales Northern Ireland and the Isle of Man. Last accessed 28 June 2017 ↩
British Orthopaedic Association. (2012). Primary Total Hip Replacement: a guide to good practice. Last accessed 28 June 2017 ↩