Skip to main content

Z and Z v Norfolk County Council (SEN): [2026] UKUT 401 (AAC)

Upper Tribunal Administrative Appeals Chamber decision of Judge Stout on 19 October 2026.

Read the full decision in UA-2025-001127-HS.

Judicial Summary

The appellants in this case consider that their daughter does not require an EHC plan. They sought to appeal to the First-tier Tribunal against the local authority’s refusal to cease maintaining her EHC plan. The First-tier Tribunal refused to register their appeal.

The Upper Tribunal decides that there is no freestanding right of appeal to the First-tier Tribunal against a local authority’s decision to make or maintain an EHC plan, or its refusal to cease maintaining one. However, the First-tier Tribunal had erred in law in failing to register the appeal as a ‘standard’ appeal under section 51(2)(e) of the Children and Families Act 2014 against the contents of Sections B and F of the EHC plan.

Further, the First-tier Tribunal should not have taken a decision refusing to register the appeal on the papers without a hearing. The First-tier Tribunal’s practice of registering claims and appeals is not one expressly provided for in its rules of procedure and it should be operated only in accordance with the Practice Direction: Special Educational Needs or Disability Discrimination in Schools Cases (20 April 2021) (UW v Cheam Academies Trust (SEN) [2026] UKUT 53 (AAC) applied). The effect of that Practice Direction is to enable preliminary decisions on time points to be made on the papers at registration stage, subject to review at a hearing. However, if another ground for striking out part of a case exists, the First-tier Tribunal should notify the relevant party and make directions for determination of strike-out at a hearing.