Skip to main content

London Borough of Wandsworth v DMS (JR): [2026] UKUT 426 (AAC)

Upper Tribunal Administrative Appeals Chamber decision of Judge Stout on 28 October 2026.

Read the full decision in UA-2026-001157-JR.

Judicial Summary

The First-tier Tribunal treated the local authority as having been automatically barred for failing to send the parent a paper copy of the bundle as well as an electronic copy. The Tribunal refused the local authority’s application for reinstatement and excluded the local authority’s representative from the hearing. The local authority sought permission to apply for judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision on the basis that it was a “nullity”.

The Upper Tribunal holds:

  • The appropriate route for challenging the First-tier Tribunal’s decision was an appeal under section 11 of the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 (TCEA 2007). Having regard to section 18(6) of the TCEA 2007 and the Lord Chancellor’s direction under Part 1 of Schedule 2 to the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, judicial review in the Upper Tribunal was not therefore available. However, the Upper Tribunal has power under rule 7(2) of the Tribunal Procedure (Upper Tribunal) Rules 2008 to waive the irregularities in the way in which the proceedings were commenced and to allow the application to proceed as an application for permission to appeal. It was appropriate to exercise that power in all the circumstances of this case.

  • Where a case management direction provides that the local authority will be automatically barred if it fails “without reasonable explanation” to comply with the direction, it does not have the effect of automatically barring a local authority that fails to comply: a judicial determination must first be made as to whether the local authority had a reasonable explanation for the failure: London Borough of Enfield v NH and anor (SEN) [2019] UKUT 1 (AAC), [2019] AACR 19 applied. Automatic barring directions in this form under rule 8(2) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Health, Education and Social Care Chamber) Rules 2008 are misleading and should be avoided in future. In standard case management directions, it is likely to be preferable to use the discretionary barring power in rule 8(4)(a).

  • The First-tier Tribunal’s direction in relation to the provision of a paper bundle had, with effect from 15 July 2025, been superseded by paragraph 53 of the Practice Direction on Procedure for the Preparation of Bundles in the Special Educational Needs and Disability and Disability Discrimination in Schools jurisdictions of the Health, Education and Social Care Chamber. Accordingly, a paper copy only needed to be supplied if it was “specifically and reasonably requested”. No such request had been made, so the First-tier Tribunal had erred in treating the local authority as having failed to comply.

  • The First-tier Tribunal’s refusal to reinstate the local authority was also perverse. Barring and strike-out are measures of last resort. The discretion to make them, or to refuse to reinstate, needs to be exercised in accordance with the overriding objective, taking into account the nature and extent of the default and whether there is any prejudice to the other party or the fairness of the hearing that cannot appropriately be remedied by way of an order for costs or other case management direction. In this case, the fairness of the hearing had not been affected because the parent had the electronic bundle and had printed her own paper copy nearly seven months before the hearing. Any prejudice to the parent as a result of having to print her own copy could have been remedied by way of a costs order if the Tribunal considered that appropriate.