KM v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions and DM (CSM): [2019] UKUT 48 (AAC)
Upper Tribunal Administrative Appeals Chamber decision by Judge Poole on 06 February 2019.
Read the full decision in
Judicial Summary
In this case it was found that there was a breach of natural justice because a party did not receive a fair hearing before the tribunal. Being heard includes being able to put a case by calling and producing relevant evidence, whether written or by oral evidence from witnesses. Because relevant witness evidence for one party was not heard by the tribunal there was a breach of natural justice.
The case also comments on who is entitled to be in a tribunal hearing. The default position is that all interested parties may be in a public hearing. In the absence of a specific direction from the tribunal, it would not be correct to tell an accompanying person that they can only be present throughout a hearing if they are there for moral support, and not if they want to give evidence as a witness.