Collision between offshore safety standby vessel Toisa Puffin and stern trawler LUC

Location: 8.5 miles east of the River Tyne, England.

Accident Investigation Report 13/2000

Read our marine accident investigation report, which includes what happened, actions taken, and recommendations:

luc and toisa puffin.pdf (1,116.74 kb)

Summary

On 13 June 1999, the Bahamian registered offshore safety stand-by vessel Toisa Puffin collided with LUC, a stern trawler, 8.5 miles east of the River Tyne, England. Toisa Puffin was on passage towards Aberdeen Bay and LUC was trawling at the time of the accident. Toisa Puffin failed to detect it was on a collision course with another vessel early enough to take effective avoiding action. Both vessels sustained minor damage above the waterline.

Safety Issues

The collision was caused by the mate of Toisa Puffin failing to detect he was on a collision course with another vessel early enough to take effective avoiding action. Contributory causes included Toisa Puffin’s mate failing to maintain a proper lookout, and LUC ’s skipper neither making an appropriate sound signal nor taking avoiding action early enough, contrary to the Collision Regulations.

Recommendations

No recommendations have been made as a result of this investigation.

This report was published on 25 May 2000.

Published 23 January 2015