Skip to main content
HMRC internal manual

Enquiry Manual

EM3295 - Enquiry manual: discovery: Scope of an Assessment

The scope of an assessment, and therefore the issues and arguments which can be considered in any appeal against an assessment, will depend on the scope of the officer’s subjective discovery which led to the assessment. The scope of an assessment cannot be extended via the appeal process.

As the scope of an assessment is determined by the subjective discovery made, the facts and circumstances of each case will be determinative. An officer does not need to have had issues specifically in mind for them to be within scope.

There is a difference between the assessment and the reasons supporting it. HMRC are not restricted to the reasons that the officer had explicitly considered at the time of the discovery. The reasons for an assessment are not part of the assessment itself. Therefore, whilst the scope of the assessment is determined by the scope of the discovering officer’s discovery, HMRC are not limited to the discovering officer’s reasons for their assessment when making arguments in support of the assessment.   

An assessment for one type of tax cannot be converted into another on appeal; for example, an assessment that is only for Capital Gains Tax cannot become an assessment for Income Tax on appeal.