Skip to main content
HMRC internal manual

Enquiry Manual

EM3269 - Discovery: alternative assessments

Alternative assessments

There are situations where legal or factual uncertainty means that more than one assessment is needed because a single assessment cannot encompass all potential outcomes when the uncertainty is resolved. In those situations, HMRC are able to make alternative assessments.

Situations where this may occur include where there is uncertainty surrounding transactions which, when resolved, could result in a charge to Income Tax or Capital Gains Tax, could result in a charge in separate years, or could result in a charge on more than one person.

This method has long been accepted by the courts and is considered a sensible way of dealing with difficult cases. It is therefore established that there is nothing objectionable in principle of alternative assessments.

Officers should look for the following factors when deciding whether alternative assessments are required:

  • genuine uncertainty regarding the tax position, this could be from an uncertainty over the facts or the law,
  • a genuine risk of a loss of tax if alternatives are not used

HMRC should be clear with the relevant parties that the assessments are alternatives and take all reasonable steps to mitigate the risk of double assessment. It is best practice to set out the various legal arguments in your explanation letter.

HMRC should not make a cumulative assessment. A cumulative assessment is a single assessment which charges more tax than necessary to address alternative tax outcomes. For example, if there is uncertainty over whether the issue results in a Capital Gains Tax or an Income Tax liability the Officer should not make a single assessment which includes both tax amounts. The Officer may make alternative assessments for the Income Tax and Capital Gains Tax amounts if the situation merits it.

The taxpayer’s recourse in alternative assessment situations is to appeal both assessments and to resolve the uncertainty via one of the methods used to resolve disputes.