Skip to main content
HMRC internal manual

Economic Crime Supervision Handbook

ECSH34020 - What if you're unable to complete your compliance check

Introduction

Tthere may be scenarios where you are unable to check the business’s compliance with The Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017 (MLR 2017). For example, you may be unable to trace the business and consider it is “missing”, or you establish that a business has registered in error and is not a “relevant person”.

For compliance, you must not give a “compliant” outcome, such as a closure letter or advice letter, where you have been unable to test the business’s compliance with MLR 2017. Please discuss the circumstances of your case with your line manager, and where necessary the Operational Technical Specialist Team, to decide the most appropriate outcome. 

The case may meet the rejection criteria following your initial review as detailed in the project initiation document (PID)  or your manager may agree the risks are no longer present and there is no further action (NFA) to take.

Examples of scenarios you may come across are detailed below.

Unable to proceed due to law enforcement or other HMRC action

You may be unable to proceed with your case due to law enforcement or other HMRC action. For more information see ECSH34130 withholding or postponing Economic Crime Supervision (EC-S) operational activity. You must discuss the circumstances of your case with your line manager and the other stakeholders to decide how you will close your enquiry or whether parallel investigation is required – See ECSH32720 Linked investigations. For authorisations, you must still determine the business’s application in line with regulation 59.

The business no longer exists

Following your initial review and/or attempts to contact the business during your initial contact - see ECSH32800 and ECSH32835  - you may suspect that the business no longer exists. 

For example, the contact telephone numbers do not connect, your emails are undelivered, the business is no longer present at the premises (a different business is present), and you have been unable to locate the business owners. You should discuss the evidence you have to support this view with your team leader.

Depending on the circumstances of your case, you may need to consider adding details about individuals and the business/es to the Watchlist.

The business has ceased trading

Similar to the scenario above where you suspect the business no longer exists, if you established that the business has ceased trading, and you are unable to speak to anyone involved in the business, you should discuss the circumstances of your case with your team leader. You may wish to conduct an intervention with an individual who was at the time an officer of the business – See ECSH70000 HMRC Powers.

The business is trading but no longer conducts relevant activity

Where you establish that the business is not a relevant person but has been within the last 12 months, you should continue with your compliance check as usual and test the relevant activity undertaken. Ensure you understand why the relevant activity has stopped – for example, has the business model changed? The outcome will depend on whether the business has complied with all the relevant requirements of MLR 2017.

The business is registered but is not a relevant person and has never carried out relevant activity

If you have confirmed the business has never carried out relevant activity and won’t in future, they are not a relevant person and do not need to comply with the relevant requirements. You must first have made sure you understand the business activities, their reason for registering for anti-money laundering (AML) supervision and addressed any other risks . For compliance, you should review and address any other risks shown in the Standard Information Package (SIP).  You should review whether this is possible to achieve by doing a desk-based intervention as opposed to a face-to-face, in line with the risks and discuss this with your manager. Remember, a change of intervention approach set out in the PID must be authorised by the G7 compliance lead - see ECSH32600 Types of intervention.

You must ensure that the business does not need to be registered and check this with your team sector single points of contacts (SPOCs), line manager and Operational Technical Specialist Team. If they are in agreement, you should then ask the business to deregister 

You should monitor the enterprise tax management platform (ETMP), to confirmand rewcord this in your case management system and case trackers.

If the business is unable to deregister (for example, if there is an “open” form on ETMP, where it has submitted its annual declaration, but it has not yet been determined), compliance caseworkers may need to contact Authorisations. Where a case has been allocated to a caseworker in registration case management (RCM), you should contact the caseworker direct; if not, send an email to “ECS Authorisations WFMs, (FIS)” mailbox, providing as much detail as possible regarding the issues encountered.

You must issue a letter summarising the information given and current position of the business. For example, the reasons why the business is not required to be registered for AML supervision and confirmation that the business has deregistered. You must make it clear to the business that should it intend to begin relevant activity as defined by MLR 2017 in the future, it must register for AML supervision without delay.

If the business remains registered, you must continue to review the business’s risk assessment, policies controls and procedures and training records. For example, this may be relevant for a business who is not a relevant person but intends to start trading as a relevant person within the next 12 months. There will be no customer due diligence to test as it won’t have conducted any relevant transactions or had any relevant business relationships. If the documents meet the requirements of MLR 2017, you should issue a closure letter or advice letter - see ECSH34025 what if nothing is wrong - If not, you should issue a warning letter.

If a review of the business’s documents demonstrates the business will not comply, you should consider if you have reasonable grounds to cancel the registration using regulation 59(1)(e) MLR 2017. There may also be grounds under regulation 59(1)(b) MLR 2017. See ECSH83585 When a business has failed to comply with any conditions in regulation 59(1)(a) to (e) MLR 2017 for further information.

It is important that if the case has been packaged as an intelligence led case, you must continue with your case as usual.

If the business stops communicating with you, you may not be able to use powers under regulation 66 MLR 2017 – see ECSH71500- unless you have grounds to suspect they are or were a relevant person, a payment service provider, or a connected person. If you are not sure, speak to your manager.

HMRC delay or official error 

Where breaches of MLR2017 have been identified but HMRC action has been delayed, or an error has been made by an officer of HMRC, it may not be possible to continue with your proposed action due to reputational damage. In these circumstances, you must discuss the case outcome with your manager and Grade 7, who will liaise with the relevant sector strategy leadand agree a way forward.