Administration: losses: targeted rules to prevent the contrived creation of capital losses - tax advantage - choice of commercial options
The existence of a tax advantage, such as obtaining a deduction for tax purposes, isnot enough in itself to show that the arrangements have a main purpose of obtaining a taxadvantage.
Where there is evidence that a group considered two ways to achieve a commercial objectiveand chose on commercial grounds to pursue one of them, the fact that there was abeneficial difference in tax treatment for the chosen route would not meet the mainpurpose test. Where the potential tax treatment was a factor in choosing betweenalternative arrangements, then it would still be necessary that securing a tax advantagewas a main purpose to the arrangements. There may be situations where the tax advantagesecured through undertaking one arrangement rather than another is so significant thatthis indicates that achieving a tax advantage was a main purpose. This is unlikely to bethe case where the arrangements chosen do not involve additional, complex or costly stepsincluded solely to secure or enhance a tax advantage.