Skip to main content
HMRC internal manual

Capital Gains Manual

CG30900 - Death and personal representatives: distribution and vesting of assets: introduction

Introduction

The personal representatives have a duty to distribute the assets of the estate to the legatees. Normally this is not done until the personal representatives know all the facts about the estate and can see how to deal with the distribution of all the remaining assets. Therefore it is done when residue is ascertained or at some time thereafter. However in certain circumstances personal representatives may distribute some of the assets of the estate before residue is ascertained.

The final stage in the distribution of assets involves passing the legal title to the legatees. This is done by the personal representatives giving an assent to the assets vesting in the legatee. In the case of chattels there may not be a written assent but merely delivery of the asset to the legatee. For other assets a written assent may be given. But sometimes an assent has to be inferred from the actions of the parties. However an assent in respect of the legal ownership of land must be in writing, but see below.

Even though the personal representatives have not finally ascertained residue they may reach a point where it is clear to them that they can distribute certain assets without prejudicing their position. Quite often they will do this with specific legacies and they may sometimes also do this with certain assets comprising part of the residue of the estate.


Beneficial ownership - England and Wales

If the estate is in England and Wales the personal representatives will have power to distribute assets in advance of residue being ascertained under the provisions of Section 41 Administration of Estates Act 1925. That section lays down rules that must be observed if the personal representatives follow this course of action. Amongst other things the personal representatives must have ensured that the distribution will not prejudicially affect any specific bequest and that they obtain the consent of any person or trustee to whom the distribution is made. Therefore when the personal representatives are acting in accordance with the powers provided by the Act there should normally be formal evidence that steps were taken to vest assets in the legatee in advance of residue being ascertained.

Certain wills may provide the personal representatives with powers additional to the powers provided in the Act. For example, the will may remove the requirement to obtain consents from the person or trustee to whom the distribution is made. In such cases there may be little formal evidence concerning the vesting and establishing the facts may become more difficult.


Beneficial ownership - Scotland

For estates in Scotland there is no assent to the assets vesting in the legatee and no equivalent to the Administration of Estates Act 1925. As a result, executors do not have a specific power to distribute assets in advance of residue being ascertained unless further such powers are provided in the will. Where the will does not contain such a power, or there is no valid will, therefore, it is arguable that the executor is able to make only a revocable distribution of the assets to legatees, in advance of the residue being ascertained. We would not accept a revocable distribution as vesting the beneficial ownership of the asset in the legatee. However, care should be taken in advancing this argument without first consulting with Trusts & Estates Technical in Edinburgh.


Liability after distribution

If personal representatives distribute assets of the estate before taking reasonable steps to ascertain and settle the debts of the estate they incur a personal liability. This liability will be for the excess of the debts of the estate over the assets they still hold up to a limit of the value of the assets they have already distributed. You should therefore not be dissuaded from attempting to establish the full Capital Gains Tax liabilities of an estate where there have already been distributions of assets by claims from the personal representatives that they have not retained sufficient assets to enable them to pay any further liability.


Ownership - when residue ascertained

For Capital Gains Tax purposes we are not concerned with the legal ownership of assets but only with the beneficial ownership. If these differ then the legal owners are merely nominees or bare trustees for the beneficial owners, see CG34300+.

The legal ownership of property may remain with the personal representatives for some considerable time after residue has been ascertained. For example, this may happen if there are complications in preparing a written assent for land, or where the personal representatives are simply dilatory in preparing an assent for any type of asset. However this does not prevent the beneficial ownership from passing to the legatees at an earlier date.

The beneficial ownership can pass when specific steps are taken to vest it in the legatees in advance of residue being ascertained. But this is fairly unusual. Normally vesting will happen when residue is ascertained and we can infer an assent to the vesting of the beneficial interest. Only occasionally will it happen at some later date where the period of administration has to be extended.

The leading case providing authority for this principle is CIR v Sir Aubrey Smith 15TC661. In that case Lord Hanworth MR said at the bottom of page 675, top of page 676

`The question is, in all cases: has the administration of the estate reached a point of ripeness at which you can infer an assent; at which you can infer that the residuary estate has been ascertained and that it is outstanding and not handed over merely for some other reason.'

The requirement that assents in respect of land must be in writing, see CG30900, should be regarded as applying only to the legal ownership of the land. Therefore the beneficial ownership of all assets should, except in the exceptional cases detailed in CG30710, be considered to have vested in the legatees once residue of the estate has been ascertained, see CG30780+.