Farming: tax treatment of grants and subsidies: general principles
S25, S33 Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005, S46, S53 Corporation Tax Act 2009;
The principles governing the tax treatment of grants and subsidies, together with examples from case law, are set out at BIM40450 onwards to which reference should be made in any case of doubt or difficulty.
In summary, regardless of the accounting method used to determine the recognition of grant income, what has to be determined is whether the subsidy is a trading receipt and whether it is a capital or a revenue receipt. The main determining factor is the purpose for which the grant is paid. Usually there is little doubt in the case of farming grants (but see BIM55165). In cases of doubt you will need to examine the formal documentation.
Decided cases on farming grants include:
- Higgs v Wrightson  26TC73 (ploughing grant held to be a trading receipt).
- Watson v Samson Brothers  38TC346 (payments for rehabilitation of flood-damaged land held to be capital receipts).
- White v G & M Davies  52TC597, and CIR v Biggar  56TC254 (premiums payable under scheme for conversion of dairy herds to beef production held to be trading receipts).