Guidance

Requests for opinions: 2018

Information about opinions requests we have received this year.

This guidance was withdrawn on

Page no longer current or required.

Overview

The table below shows information about opinion requests we have received in 2018 and what stage each request has reached.

For example, you can see whether:

  • you can file observations on a request or whether the period for doing so has expired
  • we have issued an opinion
  • the person who filed the request has withdrawn it
  • we have refused a request for an opinion. Where we’ve issued a decision refusing the request, you can view this in our decisions database

Further information

If you would like more information about a particular request please contact us by:

2018 requests

Opinion number Patent/SPC number, title and owner Requester and request date Issue (Infringement and/or Validity) Observations deadline Outcome
35/18 GB2405921

A valve assembly for opening and closing a fluid transmission line

The Linden Shield Limited
Mr Sean J Linden

27 December 2018
Infringement 30 January 2019 Opinion issued 20 March 2019

Opinion number 35/18 (PDF, 705 KB, 7 pages)
34/18 GB2528484

Protective garment

Bibado Ltd
Mr Daniel Laxton

20 December 2018
Validity 30 January 2019 Opinion issued 12 March 2019

Opinion 34/18 (PDF, 486 KB, 7 pages)
33/18 EP1744759

Use of loteprednol etabonate for the treatment of dry eye

Bausch & Lomb Incorporated
Urquhart-Dykes & Lord LLP

24 December 2018
Validity 30 January 2019 Opinion withdrawn

6 February 2019
32/18 GB2435766

Window stay arrangement

Assa Abloy Limited
Lucas & Co

19 December 2018
Validity 30 January 2019 Opinion issued 14 March 2019

Opinion number 32/18 (PDF, 494 KB, 14 pages)
30/18 EP3162841

A Biodegradable biocompostable biodigestible plastic

Valipat S.A.
T.S. Shankar

16 November 2018
Validity 27 December 2018 Opinion issued 8 February 2019

Opinion 30/18 (PDF, 261 KB, 13 pages)
29/18 EP2532858

Flexible support structure for a geared architecture gas turbine engine

United Technologies Corporation
Rolls Royce Plc

8 November 2018
Validity 21 December 2018 Opinion issued 1 March 2019

Opinion number 29/18 (PDF, 471 KB, 16 pages)
28/18 EP2737180

Flexible support structure for a geared architecture gas turbine engine

United Technologies Corporation
Rolls Royce Plc

8 November 2018
Validity 21 December 2018 Opinion issued 1 March 2019

Opinion number 28/18 (PDF, 753 KB, 19 pages)
27/18 EP2532841

Flexible support structure for a geared architecture gas turbine engine

United Technologies Corporation
Rolls Royce Plc

8 November 2018
Validity 21 December 2018 Opinion issued 7 March 2019

Opinion 27/18 (PDF, 647 KB, 16 pages)
26/18 GB2483109

Wheel clamp

Purple Line Limited
Milenco Limited

6 November 2018
Validity 7 December 2018 Opinion issued 31 January 2019

Opinion 26/18 (PDF, 496 KB, 12 pages)
25/18 EP1257290

Method For Antigen-Specific Stimulation Of T-Lymphocytes With Synthetic Peptide Libraries

Florian Kern
Greaves Brewster LLP

25 October 2018
Validity 27 November 2018 Opinion issued 22 January 2019

Opinion 25/18 (PDF, 268 KB, 12 pages)
24/18 EP2964357

Fluid treatment apparatus & method

VEXO International (UK) Limited
Intatec Limited

16 October 2018
Invalidity and Infringement 15 November 2018 Opinion issued 11 January 2019

Opinion 24/18 (PDF, 222 KB, 7 pages)
23/18 EP3162841

A biodegradable biocompostable biodigestible plastic

PEP Licensing Limited
T.S. Shankar

21 September 2018
Validity 31 October 2018 Opinion withdrawn

16 October 2018
22/18 EP2121236

Polycrystalline Diamond Elements Having Convex Surfaces ; Method Of Cutting A Rotational Symmetrical Surface Of A Diamond Element Using A Laser; Method Of Polishing A Spherical Surface Of A Polycrystalline Or Coated Diamond Element

Element Six Technologies Limited
Renishaw plc

6 September 2018
Validity 9 October 2018 Opinion issued 5 December 2018

Opinion 22/18 (PDF, 695 KB, 19 pages)
21/18 EP1641572B

Laser Removal Of Layer Or Coating From A Substrate

Spectrum Technologies Plc
Laser Wire Solutions Ltd

20 August 2018
Validity 1 October 2018 Opinion issued 15 November 2018

EP1641572 (PDF, 198 KB, 10 pages)
19/18 EP2801443

Processing medium for processing stainless steel or other metallic surfaces, method for processing stainless steel or other metallic surfaces using such a

PHIBO INDUSTRIES BVBA
Barker Brettell

16 August 2018
Validity 18 September 2018 Opinion issued 14 November 2018

EP2801443 (PDF, 437 KB, 19 pages)
18/18 EP2615943

Spacing device and method

Clifford Steven Petit
Mohun Intellectual Property Limited

19 July 2018
Validity 22 August 2018 Opinion issued 16 October 2018

Opinion number 18/18 (PDF, 188 KB, 7 pages)
17/18 GB2389824

Improvements in or relating to funeral vehicles

Paul Sinclair
Paul Sinclair

2 July 2018
Infringement 9 August 2018 Opinion issued 27 September 2018

Opinion 17/18 (PDF, 256 KB, 7 pages)
16/18 EP2321150

Method of producing upholstery or automotive trim comprising stitched perforated sheet materials

Bentley Motors Limited

Jaguar Land Rover Limited

12 June 2018
Infringement 13 July 2018 Opinion issued 5 September 2018

Opinion 16/18 (PDF, 894 KB, 12 pages)
15/18 GB2455958

Underwater Excavation Apparatus

James Fisher MFE Limited

James Fisher MFE Limited

17 May 2018
Infringement 20 June 2018 Opinion issued 10 August 2018

Opinion 15/18 (PDF, 370 KB, 8 pages)
14/18 GB2456085

Bait dispenser

Spomb Fishing Limited

Boult Wade Tennant

14 May 2018
Validity 15 June 2018 Opinion issued 7 August 2018

Opinion 14/18 (PDF, 548 KB, 14 pages)
13/18 EP2121236

Polycrystalline Diamond Elements Having Convex Surfaces; Method Of Cutting A Rotational Symmetrical Surface Of A Diamond Element Using A Laser; Method Of Polishing A Spherical Surface Of A Polycrystalline Or Coated Diamond Element

Element Six Technologies Limited
Renishaw PLC

4 May 2018
Validity 7 June 2018 Opinion issued 2 August 2018

Opinion 13/18 (PDF, 749 KB, 16 pages)
12/18 EP2989262

Balcony

Sapphire Balconies Limited
Brooksby Projects Ltd

2 May 2018
Infringement 5 June 2018 Withdrawn

19 September 2018
11/18 GB2507365

Balcony

Sapphire Balconies Limited
Brooksby Projects Ltd

18 April 2018
Infringement 5 June 2018 Withdrawn

19 September 2018
10/18 EP2670682

Lid For Drinking Vessels

Donna-Marie Sabga
The Barista Cup Ltd

23 April 2018
Validity 23 May 2018 Opinion issued 19 July 2018

Opinion 10/18 (PDF, 496 KB, 16 pages)
09/18 GB2423721

Method and apparatus for controlling a ventilator

Fleur T Tehrani
Fleur T Tehrani

8 March 2018
Infringement 9 April 2018 Opinion issued 6 June 2018

Opinion 09/18 (PDF, 458 KB, 18 pages)
08/18 EP1912515

Butterfat filling or imitation chocolate for cereal cooking products

Intercontinental Great Brands, LLC
Bailey Walsh & Co LLP

26 February 2018
Validity 5 April 2018 Opinion issued 24 May 2018

Opinion 08/18 (PDF, 228 KB, 13 pages)
07/18 GB2545799

Nozzle with radial spray jet capability

Akron Brass Company
Delta Fire Limited

20 February 2018
Validity 3 April 2018 Opinion issued 21 May 2018

Opinion 07/18 (PDF, 362 KB, 8 pages)
06/18 GB2543475

Window or door locking system

Easyfit Hardward Limited
Dr Thomas Morgan

13 February 2018
Validity 15 March 2018 Opinion issued 10 May 2018

Opinion 06/18 (PDF, 352 KB, 11 pages)
05/18 EP2156014

Subsea Cooler

FMC Kongsberg Subsea AS
Protector IP Consultants AS

1 February 2018
Validity 6 March 2018 Opinion issued 2 May 2018

Opinion 05/18 (PDF, 267 KB, 9 pages)
04/18 EP2811470

Moire Magnification Device

De La Rue International Limited
Stephen Walker, Lincoln IP Limited

12 January 2018
Validity 13 February 2018 Opinion issued 12 April 2018

Opinion number 04/18 (PDF, 1.68 MB, 20 pages)
03/18 EP2194596

A Method of Fabricating Structured Particles Composed of Silicon or a Silicon-Based Material and their use in Lithium Rechargeable Batteries

Nexeon Limited
OneD Material

10 January 2018
Validity 9 February 2018 Opinion issued 29 May 2018

Opinion 03/18 (PDF, 376 KB, 22 pages)
02/18 EP2801443

Processing medium for processing stainless steel or other metallic surfaces, method for processing stainless steel or other metallic surfaces using such a processing medium and nozzle arranged to be fitted on a process gun

Phibo Industries BVBA
Barker Brettell LLP

8 January 2018
Validity 9 February 2018 Opinion issued 29 March 2018

Opinion number 02/18 (PDF, 190 KB, 13 pages)
01/18 EP2003466

Mobile Phone Localization Method

Eryk Szweryn And Lukasz Strzalkowski
ip.access Ltd

4 January 2018
Infringement 8 February 2018 Opinion issued 28 March 2018

Opinion number 01/18 (PDF, 93.2 KB, 6 pages)
Published 12 January 2018
Last updated 20 March 2019 + show all updates
  1. Final opinion 35/18 added.

  2. Final opinion 32/18 added.

  3. Final opinion 34/18 added.

  4. Final opinion 27/18 added.

  5. Final opinions 28/18 and 29/18 added.

  6. Final opinion 30/18 added.

  7. Opinion 33/18 has been withdrawn.

  8. Final opinion 26/18 added.

  9. Final opinion 25/18 added.

  10. Final opinion 24/18 added.

  11. New opinion 32/18, 33/18, 34/18 and 35/18 added.

  12. Final opinion 22/18 added.

  13. Opinion number 23/18 withdrawn.

  14. New opinion 30/18 added.

  15. New opinions 27/18, 28/18 and 29/18 added.

  16. Final opinions 19/18 and 21/18 added.

  17. New opinion 26/18 added.

  18. New opinion 25/18 added.

  19. New opinion 24/18 added.

  20. Outcome for opinion number 18/18 published.

  21. New opinion 23/18 added.

  22. Final opinion 17/18 added.

  23. Opinions 11/18 and 12/18 have been withdrawn.

  24. New opinion 22/18 added.

  25. Final opinion 16/18 added.

  26. New opinion 21/18 added.

  27. Opinion number 19/18 added.

  28. Final opinion 15/18 added.

  29. Outcome for opinion number 14/18 published.

  30. Final opinion 13/18 added.

  31. New opinion 18/18 added.

  32. Final opinion 10/18 added.

  33. New opinion 17/18 added.

  34. New initial opinion 16/18 added.

  35. Final opinion 09/18 added.

  36. Final opinion 03/18 added.

  37. Final opinon 08/18 added.

  38. Final opinion 07/18 and new opinion 15/18 added.

  39. Opinion number 14/18 added.

  40. Final opinion 06/18 and new opinion 13/18 added.

  41. Opinion number 11/18 and 12/18 added.

  42. Final opinion 05/18 added.

  43. Opinion 10/18 added.

  44. Outcome for opinion number 04/18 published.

  45. Outcome for opinion 01/18 and 02/18 published.

  46. Opinion 09/18 added.

  47. Opinion number 08/18.

  48. Opinion 07/18 added.

  49. Opinion 06/18 added.

  50. Opinion 05/18 added.

  51. Opinion 04/18 added.

  52. First published.