Skip to main content

Garden communities toolkit

Delivery mechanisms

At an early stage in your project, you should explore the mechanisms and options available for delivery of your garden community.

A clear delivery model will create confidence in investors and stakeholders. It can also shape the approach to governance.

Before deciding your delivery structure

You should consider:

  • the objectives and outcomes you want to achieve and any potential barriers to delivery that need to be addressed, such as the level of infrastructure needed to unlock development
  • what additional control or influence over and above statutory planning controls will be necessary to achieve those objectives
  • land ownership, the extent to which individual land parcels have been assembled for development and whether a master developer is in place
  • the scale of the garden community and whether it spans across multiple local planning authorities or mayoral areas
  • what skills and resources are available and how they fit with partners’ capabilities
  • the effectiveness of the working relationship with the landowners and any developers involved, and the extent to which objectives and ambitions for the garden community are aligned
  • level of private sector involvement required and opportunities to make the garden community proposition more commercially attractive to the private sector to support delivery
  • expectations and mechanisms for land value capture and long-term stewardship of the garden community
  • public sector appetite and opportunity to invest in delivery of the garden community
  • motivations and drivers for landowners to put forward their sites to be developed as part of a garden community

You should also consider the nature of any developer or commercial interest in the garden community landholding. These may include:

  • option agreements where a landowner agrees a developer can buy their land subject to obtaining a planning permission, formalised in an options agreement
  • land promotion agreements, in which the developer seeks the planning consent for development, and then offers the land for sale on the open market
  • developer agreements and collaboration agreements where 2 or more parties agree to work jointly to bring a development proposal forward
  • equalisation agreements where all landowners and any developers involved get a fair return for including their land in the development — this is regardless of what use it is specifically allocated for, or when it might be developed

Types of delivery mechanisms

Different delivery vehicles offer varying degrees of control, flexibility, and risk-sharing between public and private stakeholders. The choice and value of each delivery mechanism depend on the specific conditions of the garden community. The selected mechanism should be agreed through robust stakeholder engagement.

Determine the most suitable option by weighing the advantages, disadvantages and important considerations of each mechanism to ensure it aligns with the garden community’s context and objectives.

Review the delivery mechanisms as your project progresses and when considering potential future expansion and densification (or both) of the garden community.

1. Developer-led

A developer secures planning consent and implements it. This relies on a robust planning policy framework, agreed masterplan and delivery strategy supplemented by a good governance structure, design and delivery review process, planning conditions and Section 106 obligations to guide consistent and high-quality development. 

Advantages

Advantages of a developer-led approach include:

  • the effective use of existing planning powers and policy frameworks and strategies  
  • existing governance structures can be maintained, and no additional levels of bureaucracy are added 
  • that the local authority can exercise other tools at their disposal, including compulsory purchase order powers 
  • that no set up time is needed to establish a new delivery vehicle  

Disadvantages

Disadvantages of a developer-led approach include:

  • the need for strong collaboration with private sector delivery bodies over the long-term to ensure development is of the right quality and meets garden community objectives 
  • the reliance on market conditions for continued delivery
  • limited opportunities for the public sector to influence the proposals
  • the lack of joined up oversight for infrastructure delivery 

Considerations 

You should make sure:

  • planning policy, and masterplans, and planning permission strategies and Section 106 agreements are in place and can deliver the development to the quality and pace required 
  • there is a single lead promoter or master developer in place to coordinate land assembly and drive delivery and liaise with the local authority 
  • the development is viable and deliverable and there is an equalisation or other agreement among the developers involved about who will deliver what — if equalisation arrangements are unclear, they may cause disputes 
  • there is limited risk of the development stalling or not being delivered to the agreed pace 
  • there is a strong collaborative working relationship between the parties involved 
  • there is a clear lead promoter or master developer to avoid the risk of fragmented development
  • to mitigate the risk of delivering sub-optimal community assets and facilities which do not generate value

2. Private sector master developer 

A company or entity is appointed to take on the lead role in overseeing and executing large-scale development projects, often partnering with other housebuilders at the delivery stage. It is responsible for coordinating all aspects of the project, from land acquisition to construction and marketing. 

Advantages

A private sector master developer:

  • brings specialised expertise in managing large-scale projects 
  • often delivers projects faster due to streamlined decision-making and fewer bureaucratic delays 
  • means that, with fewer stakeholders involved, there is only a single relationship to manage 
  • enables better coordination of on-site infrastructure  

Disadvantages  

Use of a private sector master developer:

  • means the public sector holds no financial stake in the development and has only planning powers through which to exert influence 
  • can mean higher costs due to profit margins 
  • can mean over-reliance on a single entity and this may create vulnerabilities if the company underperforms or withdraws 

Considerations

Use of a private sector master developer:

  • means market fluctuations may impact viability and timing of development coming forward
  • can ensure effective collaboration among stakeholders including contractors, authorities and community groups

3. Informal partnership 

This is an arrangement between main private and public sector partners to strengthen collaborative working and the use of statutory planning mechanisms.

An informal partnership is usually underpinned by a memorandum of understanding or other collaborative agreement.

Advantages 

An informal partnership:

  • can strengthen and streamline how partners use the statutory planning process 
  • is relatively quick to establish through a route, such as memorandum of understanding or planning performance agreement 
  • is relatively quick to adapt to changing circumstances  
  • can be suitable when delivery will be led by a master developer 
  • means no changes are usually required to existing scheme of local authority delegation 
  • no transfer of planning powers 

Disadvantages

An informal partnership

  • is an informal arrangement only — and can be affected by changes in circumstance on any side, as well as political or commercial shifts 
  • relies on establishing and keeping a high level of trust between the parties involved and close working
  • may not provide additional confidence to private sector to encourage investment

Considerations

When setting up an informal partnership you should:

  • clarify respective roles and responsibilities of the parties involved from the outset
  • identify potential risks or changes in circumstances (including political and economic) that affect how the project moves forward and plan mitigation measures
  • be clear on how differences of opinion or disputes between the partners will be dealt with
  • risks from changes in leadership or funding availability 

4. Formal public-private partnership 

This establishes a long-term cooperative agreement between 2 or more public and private sector partners. 

The partnership can take the form of a: 

  • development agreement — a negotiated legal agreement where a set amount is paid to the local authority at a later stage, in return for an upfront infrastructure investment — it enables early delivery of infrastructure and an appropriate return which can be reinvested by the local authority 
  • contractual joint venture — based on agreements between public and private parties without forming a separate legal entity — this means ach party retains independence but contributes resources 
  • corporate joint venture — a separate legal entity jointly owned by public and private sector partners that operates as an independent business 

Parties involved usually invest some assets and resources or both in the partnership. 

Advantages

Using a formal public-private partnership:

  • signals a commitment to growth  
  • enables risk to be shared between the public and the private sectors by allocating a particular project risk to the partner best able to manage that risk effectively 
  • provides formal clarity on roles and responsibilities and enables effective use of resources for the parties involved 
  • a whole-life cycle approach that provides a collaborative approach to delivery over a long-term timescale 

Disadvantages 

Using a formal public-private partnership:

  • can be time-consuming and costly to establish 
  • has the potential to include significant costs associated with the competitive tender approach of choosing project partners 
  • means significant time and resources need to be committed by all partners given the long-term nature of the contract  
  • means delivery of development is reliant on the private sector 

Considerations

When using a formal public-private partnership, you should:

  • be aware that the value of this approach will depend on the parties involved bringing value and any assets to the project such as land, funding and expertise 
  • be clear about who the different parties involved are and what value or assets they bring to the project 
  • consider if there is appetite in the local authority to take an active role in investing in delivery of the garden community 
  • assess whether there are significant risks associated with the development that would benefit from this risk-sharing approach 
  • consider if there’s an agreed approach to equalisation where there are multiple landowners involved 
  • be aware that political and economic changes could impact viability and timing of development  
  • ensure alignment of objectives and equitable risk-sharing 
  • be aware of potential governance challenges between public and private interests

5. Development corporations 

A development corporation is a statutory body established to facilitate development in areas that require large-scale coordination of investment and planning over a long period.

Steps to setting up a statutory development corporation include compiling detailed evidence to show why this is the most appropriate delivery mechanism. The evidence is submitted to the relevant government department for consideration. The establishment of a development corporation must be approved by the Secretary of State.

Development corporations can bring several overarching advantages. These include:

  • a dedicated body focused on coordination and consistent delivery 
  • access to the delivery expertise and leadership of the private sector  
  • visible public-sector commitment that can help attract private investment 
  • broad powers to facilitate delivery of the project 
  • ability to exercise plan-making and development management powers
  • capability to operate across more than 1 local authority area

There are different types of development corporations. The most suitable type will depend on the circumstances of each garden community. The 2 most relevant to garden communities are: 

  • a New Town Development Corporation — a statutory body responsible for developing a designated area that aims to create new settlements or large-scale urban expansions

  • a Locally-led Development Corporation (LLDC) — similar to the New Town Development Corporation but designed to give local authorities more control that have statutory powers but are governed locally

There are also other forms of development corporation, for example: 

  • an Urban Development Corporation — a statutory body responsible for urban development of a designated area, outside of the usual system of town and country planning in the UK

  • a Mayoral Development Corporation Statutory bodies set up by metro mayors in England to deliver regeneration schemes and operate over a defined geography

6. New Town Development Corporation (NTDC) 

Advantages

A NTDC:

  • is overseen by the Secretary of State, with an independent board established to oversee its day-to-day operation
  • can provide a dedicated body to oversee complex projects, ensuring focus, coordination and consistent delivery
  • can leverage the expertise and resources of the private sector for project delivery
  • can have broad powers to facilitate project delivery, including planning and compulsory purchase orders
  • has the ability to acquire land to deliver off-site strategic infrastructure 

Disadvantages 

Disadvantages of a NTDC include:

  • the ability to remove powers and assets from local authorities 
  • boards that are typically  unelected 
  • potential lack of transparency and accountability, which is the top-down nature of planning and development, though plan-making powers remain with the local authority 

Considerations 

When considering an NTDC you should be aware that:

  • timescales for the establishment of a NTDC can vary, and are likely to be around 18 to 24-months
  • substantial upfront investment is required
  • market and economic fluctuations can impact infrastructure and development delivery

7. Locally-led development corporation (LLDC) 

These are responsible for masterplanning and project development, bringing on board private investment, partnering with developers and overseeing the completion of a new town or garden village. 

LLDCs include Locally-Led New Town Development Corporations (LLNTDCs) and Locally-Led Urban Development Corporation (LLUDCs).

These are statutory bodies charged with development of a specific designated area. They are specifically for new settlements or large urban expansions.

LLUDCs are statutory bodies charged with urban development of a designated area, outside of the usual system of town and country planning in the UK.

Advantages

A LLDC:

  • creates a single public sector point of contact
  • enables the large-scale co-ordination of investment, planning and regeneration including providing or facilitating new infrastructure such as roads, health and educational facilities and utility infrastructure
  • aims to create high-quality new settlement, with a focus on sustainable development and good design
  • required to plan from the outset for the long-term stewardship of the assets of the new community
  • supports the use of compulsory purchase powers to acquire land needed to build the garden town or village 
  • can raise funds to support delivery
  • gives greater certainty over planning and co-ordination, decision-making and investment
  • spans political and economic cycles

Disadvantages

A LLDC:

  • can result in an additional tier of governance and administration 
  • can take time and substantial resource to establish 
  • can duplicate powers available locally 
  • can have limited impact if it does not own land  

Considerations 

When considering an LLDC consider:

  • your garden community’s ambitions and challenges are sufficient to justify the establishment of a locally led development corporation 
  • the resource, capacity, expertise and funding needed to establish an LLDC are available
  • there is local political support for establishing an LLDC to drive forward development
  • political and economic changes could impact viability and timing of development coming forward
  • funding sources should be secured for long-term success 
  • it will require clear alignment with local governance structures