How to report a benefit in kind in real time
Setting out the general principles of how to report different benefits in kind in real time and how to apply those general principles to various specific situations.
The collection of tax liability on benefits in kind will follow the principles of payrolling other pay and rewards from employment.
For each benefit in kind provided to each employee, you’ll first need to identify the cash equivalent or relevant amount for a benefit in kind or expense, and divide this by the number of pay periods in the tax year for the employee. This figure will then need to be rounded down to the nearest 2 decimal places. The resulting figure is included alongside employee earnings in each pay period so that the Income Tax due on the benefit is calculated and deducted from the employee’s pay and shown on their payslip.
For example, if a monthly paid employee receives a benefit which has a cash equivalent of £2,100 for the tax year 2027 to 2028, add £175 to each month’s earnings to calculate the Income Tax and Class 1A National Insurance contributions due, and payroll the £175 benefit each month that the employee is paid.
If a change to the cash equivalent occurs during the tax year, work out the revised taxable amount (the cash equivalent or relevant amount) to payroll for the remaining pay periods for that tax year. You’ll need to identify what has been payrolled so far for that benefit and deduct this from the revised taxable amount. The balance should be divided equally and added to the employee’s earnings across the rest of the tax year.
For example, a 4-weekly paid employee, with 13 pay periods in a tax year, is provided with a benefit in kind with a cash equivalent of £2,600 for the whole of the tax year. This benefit changes in September 2027, after 6 pay periods, so you should recalculate the total cash equivalent for the entire tax year (now £2,800) and then deduct what has been payrolled so far (£1,200). The balance of £1,600 is payrolled over the remaining 7 pay periods.
Read annex 1 for payrolling examples for different scenarios.
It may be difficult to accurately determine the taxable value of a benefit in kind, due to insufficient information or knowledge of the benefits provided to employees.
If you’re not sure what the value of the benefit is at the start of the tax year, you can make an estimate of the cash equivalent of the benefit. You can then adjust it later in the year when you know the exact value.
An updated Full Payment Submission (FPS) can be submitted in the next pay period if information about a benefit is received too late for the current payroll run. Benefit values can be updated any time during the tax year.
You can use known taxable values, from previous years, for similar benefits in kind if accurate information is not available. Every effort must be made to make a reasonable estimate.
A reasonable estimate is an amount that, at the time it is estimated, you reasonably believe represents the cash equivalent of the benefit, taking into account all information available to you.
Examples of reasonable estimates include, but are not limited to:
- the best information available at the time
- previous year’s figures for a comparable benefit
- market estimates for a comparable benefit
- figures from a comparable employee for a comparable benefit
- accurate estimated final figures from the benefit provider
- the method you normally use to calculate the benefit
- any historical data or comparable benefits
- the terms on which the benefit is provided
- any expected adjustments, for example, amounts made good, private use, or availability
The estimating method must be consistent across employees in similar circumstances.
Examples of inaccurate estimates may include:
- notional or ‘peppercorn’ values such as £1 or £0.01
- round values, such as £100, that are based on no evidence
- non-reporting of values
It is your responsibility to ensure that employees are paying the correct tax, or as close to the correct amount of tax as possible, on the benefits in kind provided. While it is expected that there will be small amounts of underpaid or overpaid tax, employees should not be put in a position where they owe too much tax and have difficulties paying it.
If you does not know the value of a benefit in kind at the beginning of the tax year or is made aware of the provision of a benefit in kind much later in the year, HMRC expects employers to:
- report benefits either when they become aware of the provision of a benefit and its taxable value or are able to estimate the value
- take reasonable care when reporting benefits information through payroll software when estimating taxable values
- report benefits as close to the relevant pay period as possible and not wait until the end of the year to do so
- comply with current record keeping requirements as we may ask for evidence of how you accounted for each expense or benefit at the end of the tax year
You’ll need to:
- record the date and details of every expense or benefit you provide
- keep any information needed to work out the amounts you report to us
- record any payment your employee contributes to an expense or benefit
- keep any correspondence you have with us
- keep records for 3 years from the end of the tax year they relate to
We expect any adjustment to be processed within a reasonable timeframe of the changes occurring, understanding that data flows through businesses are not and cannot be instant.
Making good is where an employee makes a payment in return for a benefit in kind that they receive. This can reduce the benefit’s taxable value, often to zero.
Making good does not apply to company car and company van benefit charges, which are instead subject to separate employee contribution rules.
If an employee intends to make good on a benefit provided to them, you should always payroll the cash equivalent, taking into account what the employee reasonably expects to make good. For example, if a benefit has a cash equivalent of £1,000 and you reasonably expect that the employee will make good £400 in March during the tax year, then you will payroll the difference (£600) across the tax year.
If making good does not occur, is overpaid or made good early, corrections can be made in subsequent pay periods.
Where a benefit has been payrolled and the employee makes good after the end of the tax year, report any resulting change to the taxable value by submitting an amended month 12 Full Payment Submission (FPS) showing the correct year-to-date figures for that tax year. HMRC’s end of year reconciliation processes will then pick up the corrected figures.
You must keep records of any amounts made good by an employee as part of their general PAYE record keeping requirements. These records should include the employee’s details, the benefit provided, its original value, the amount and date made good, evidence of how the payment was made, and the resulting taxable value.
Some worked examples for payrolling benefits in different scenarios have been included in annex 1.
Where earnings from multiple employments are aggregated and reported under a single payroll ID, benefits in kind should be payrolled through the same payroll ID used to report the associated earnings.
The taxable value of the payrolled benefits and any Class 1A National Insurance contributions liability should be included within the Real Time Information submission for that payroll ID.
Where a payslip that includes a payrolled benefit in kind is subsequently reversed, you should correct both the earnings and the benefit through your normal payroll amendment process.