Minutes of the National Data Guardian Panel Meeting, 15 September 2026
Updated 17 November 2026
Applies to England
Attendees
Panel members
-
Dr Nicola Byrne (chair)
-
Dr Natalie Banner
-
John Carvel
-
Claire Delaney-Pope
-
Dr George Fernie
-
Dr Fiona Head
-
Dr Jeffry Hogg
-
Mr Adrian Marchbank
-
Maisie McKenzie
-
Dr Jess Morley
-
Professor Daniel Ray
-
Rob Shaw
-
Anna Steere
-
Jenny Westaway
-
Professor James Wilson
Office of the National Data Guardian team
-
Nishat Ahmed
-
Dr Vicky Chico
-
Nisha Karadia
-
Karen Swift
-
Steve Solasta
Observer:
- Helen Dyer
1. Welcome, apologies, and declarations of interest
National Data Guardian (NDG), Dr Nicola Byrne, chaired the meeting.
-
Apologies were received from Dr David Sharp.
-
The panel received an update on recent developments within the Office of the National Data Guardian, including the appointment of a new Head of Office and ongoing plans to strengthen the team through a period of staffing transition. The forthcoming departure of the Business Support Manager was noted, with plans to appoint a replacement in due course.
-
Anna Steere, who leads Understanding Patient Data (UPD), was welcomed as a new member of the Panel.
-
Dr Jeffry Hogg declared a new interest, having formally taken up a 50% FTE position with AI medical device manufacturer Cascader. This will be logged on the register of panel interests.
2. Minutes from previous meeting, actions, and decisions
Panel members accepted the minutes from its 12 May 2026 meeting.
There is one open action. All other actions were agreed as having been completed prior to this meeting.
3. Key updates
Health Bill Report stage
Dr Vicky Chico updated panel on the Health Bill, which has passed through its Commons stages and is currently before the House of Lords. In line with Dr Nicola Byrne’s evidence to the Commons Bill Committee, the NDG’s main concerns remain that staff using the Single Patient Record in line with the regulations would not be legally subject to the duty of confidence, and that safeguards that currently apply to NHS England in respect of the data functions it inherited from NHS Digital, would not apply to the Department of Health and Social Care, assuming that the data functions will transfer to DHSC. Dr Chico explained that the NDG’s position remains that it is an important expectation and protection that health and care professionals accessing patient and service user records should be subject to the duty of confidentiality. Panel members agreed that the protections set out in the Statutory guidance about NHS England’s protection of patient data, included important safeguards, such as the requirement to take independent advice on how health and care data is used and that these were conducive to public trust in a data ‘safe haven’.
Confidentiality Matters
Nishat Ahmed updated the panel on the work she has been leading for the NDG around inappropriate access to confidential health and social care patient and care receiver records. Nishat has led a project that has engaged with a range of stakeholders to investigate factors that contribute to inappropriate access. Nishat reported that root causes were inter-connected which suggested inappropriate access was a wider systemic issue. Nishat has now drafted a report bringing together the findings. Following NHSE’s campaign and Sir Jim Mackey’s published letter, NHSE are now driving the work around addressing inappropriate access, thus, to avoid duplicating work and reflecting on the findings, the NDG’s original plans to launch a campaign has been put on hold, however, the NDG intends to feed into NHSEs work given the key importance of this topic to the NDG’s mission.
National Data Guardian recruitment
The Panel was updated that the recruitment campaign for the next National Data Guardian for Health and Adult Social Care has now closed. It was noted that when the new National Data Guardian takes up post in March 2027, it will mark 30 years since the publication of the first Caldicott Review. The Panel reflected on the enduring impact of Dame Fiona Caldicott’s 1997 report, which established the role of the Caldicott Guardian and the principles governing the use of patient-identifiable information. Three decades on, these principles continue to provide a strong foundation for the safe and trusted use of health and care data.
4. NDG Advice on digital and data programmes
Dr Byrne led a wide-ranging discussion to explore how the NDG could most effectively offer advice about how digital and data programmes should best proceed in order to secure public and professional trust. The panel noted that there is work currently taking place on significant programmes such as the Single Patient Record and the Federated Data Platform and that the NDG was in a position to provide useful insight which could helpfully inform the development of these and other digital and data programmes. Considering the timing of any advice was felt to be critical so that it could be impactful. Members of the panel focused on the particular expertise and contribution that the NDG could bring around ensuring that public benefit and health and care professional confidence.
5. Any other business
No further points were raised.