Independent Panel process guidance
Updated 18 November 2026
This guidance sets out the intended process in respect of preliminary issue referrals and appeal referrals to the Independent Panel, which exists to provide an independent, determinative assessment on disputed elements of a claim. This process has been written by the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade (BIST) to ensure that all parties understand how the Horizon Shortfall Scheme Appeals (HSSA) process is intended to operate in a structured and efficient manner.
Challenging the first offer – where BIST’s offer is higher than Post Office’s offer
Unless the HSSA offer is accepted in full, appellants or their representatives should confirm they have not accepted the offer by sending a challenge letter to Addleshaw Goddard LLP. The challenge letter should be uploaded to the ‘Communication’ folder in the relevant applicant’s specific folder on the HighQ portal, along with any new documentation being relied upon. The challenge letter should set out:
- which heads of loss (if any) are accepted
- which heads of loss are disputed, as well as the reasons for dispute
- the sums sought for each head of loss
- the appellant’s position on interest for each disputed head of loss
Before the case can be considered for Independent Panel referral by Dentons (‘the secretariat’), there is a settlement discussion period which begins on the date the challenge letter is received and lasts for 2 months.
Challenging BIST’s first offer – where BIST’s offer is lower than Post Office’s offer under the Horizon Shortfall Scheme (HSS)
As set out in the HSSA process guidance and principles, where BIST’s offer is lower than Post Office’s, the appellant has an automatic right to refer their case to the Independent Panel.
In this circumstance, where BIST’s offer is lower than Post Office’s offer, the appellant can choose to:
- revert to accepting Post Office’s offer on the HSS
- challenge BIST’s offer
- request that their case be referred to the Independent Panel without entering the settlement period
If appellants decide to challenge BIST’s offer, they should do so following the instructions in challenging the first offer.
If appellants or their representatives decide to refer their appeal to the Independent Panel, they should notify the secretariat, copying in Addleshaw Goddard LLP when doing so.
When notifying the secretariat, appellants or their representatives should confirm:
- which heads of loss (if any) are accepted
- which heads of loss are being referred to the Independent Panel
- the reasons why BIST’s offer is disputed for each head of loss
- the sums sought for each head of loss
- the appellant’s position on interest for each disputed head of loss
Ideally, this information should be in the form of a referral letter, which should also be uploaded to the HighQ portal.
Challenging BIST’s first offer – where causation or another fundamental element is in dispute
If the reason for disputing BIST’s offer is disagreement on a fundamental element that goes to the very heart of the claim (for example, causation), then parties should discuss whether the claim should be referred for a preliminary issue determination by a single legal panel member.
Find more information on the preliminary issue process.
When contacting the secretariat to request that a particular aspect of a claim be referred for a preliminary issue determination, appellants or their representatives should copy in Addleshaw Goddard LLP and confirm the specific aspect of the claim that requires determination.
Rejecting BIST’s second offer after challenging
During the settlement period, BIST may decide to issue an updated offer letter. If applicants do not accept this new offer in full, the case may be referred to the Independent Panel for determination. If appellants or their representatives decide to refer their appeal to the Independent Panel, they should notify the secretariat and copy in Addleshaw Goddard LLP when doing so.
When notifying the secretariat, appellants or their representatives should confirm:
- which heads of loss (if any) are accepted
- which heads of loss are disputed and therefore being referred to the Independent Panel
- the reasons why BIST’s offer is disputed for each head of loss
- the sums sought for each head of loss
- the appellant’s position on interest for each disputed head of loss
Ideally, this information should be in the form of a referral letter, which should also be uploaded to the HighQ portal.
Communication during the Independent Panel process
From the point at which a case is referred to the secretariat for assessment by the Independent Panel, both appellant representatives and Addleshaw Goddard LLP should keep each other copied when corresponding. This includes when providing:
- responses to any clarification questions
- comments on the Panel Bundle
- the key reading list
- list of issues
- written submissions
Contact Details
Contact details for the relevant parties are:
- the secretariat: hssa.secretariat@dentons.com
- Addleshaw Goddard LLP: hssaallhands@addleshawgoddard.com
General points on the process
The Independent Panel exists to provide an independent, determinative assessment on disputed parts of a claim. The Independent Panel should be assessing claims where both parties have presented all relevant information to one another and still cannot agree. While new information can be provided to the Independent Panel, referring a claim while waiting for an updated expert report prevents BIST from first reviewing the claim and considering substantially new information.
There is no way to appeal for decisions relating to expert report or legal cost requests. Decisions about the payment or reimbursement of fees cannot be referred to the Independent Panel or the Independent Reviewer.
This process does not address both parties’ ability to refer decisions, or parts of decisions, of the Independent Panel to the Independent Reviewer.