Skip to main content
Guidance

Approved Tachograph Centre (ATC) manual section 8: disciplinary process

Published 17 November 2026

Applies to England, Scotland and Wales

This disciplinary process replaces section 8 of the Approved Tachograph Centre (ATC) manual.

8.1 Introduction

The current disciplinary scheme has been in force for many years without change. The current system makes it difficult to maintain a consistent approach to decisions being made, with the framework being open to interpretation.

The current MOT disciplinary scheme has evolved and has resulted in a points-based system being applied for several years. This gives set responses in relation to shortcomings found and allows a consistent standard to be applied. It also provides those within the scheme with the knowledge of the shortcomings they may encounter, if they do not meet the required standard. The tachograph disciplinary scheme will therefore now be modelled on the MOT disciplinary framework.

8.2 Rollout

The Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency (DVSA) will be introducing the new scheme using a soft rollout. Here, except for serious shortcomings, points will be awarded, but without the action taken. Centres will be informed of the action which could have taken place.

Formal warnings issued during this soft rollout period will however be recorded and could impact future audits or inspections, and formal warnings in this period will contribute to the increasing point totals for repeated issues.

During this period, audits will be checked and tallied. Prior to full implementation DVSA will re-assess the potential impact of a full rollout and may adjust the scheme as necessary to ensure that proposed system is both effective and proportionate.

Disciplinary points will be awarded against both approved tachograph centres and nominated technicians for all issues.

All audit reports will still result in the current process where all parties will respond to the list of shortcomings and provide a written response within 15 working days. All decisions can be appealed.

8.3 Underlying principles

When a problem is brought to DVSA’s attention, either by a nominated technician who is being pressurised by an approved tachograph centre to test improperly or by an approved tachograph centre who is unhappy with a nominated technician’s performance, this will not normally count against the party reporting it. However, where an approved tachograph centre is unhappy with the tachograph related work standards of a nominated technician the approved tachograph centre should consider stopping the nominated technician from conducting that work pending the outcome of any action by DVSA.

Nominated technicians must be in a fit condition, both physically and mentally, to carry out tachograph work to the required standard. A nominated technician taking medication should read the instructions for its use and, if in doubt, not continue tachograph work without their doctor’s confirmation that the medication will not affect their ability to test. If a nominated technician is recovering from illness or injury, they should conduct tachograph related work only if confirmed as fully fit to do so. A nominated technician being on medication or recovering from illness will not normally be treated as mitigation for errors relating to the scheme.

The effectiveness of a nominated technician who is under severe emotional stress must also be suspect. If the stress is likely to affect the nominated technician’s ability to undertake tachograph related work, they should not. Similarly, a nominated technician whose judgement may be affected by alcohol or other substances should not undertake tachograph related work. In either event, these factors will not normally be regarded as mitigation, however, each case will be treated on the merits of the evidence available. Designated managers should implement reasonable management controls to try to ensure that the nominated technicians they use are in a fit condition to conduct tachograph work.

Where an approved tachograph centre is unhappy with the working standards of a nominated technician, the centre should consider stopping the nominated technician from conducting further work within the scheme until corrective action or retraining is completed. This may be particularly appropriate where disciplinary action for shortcomings is being considered by DVSA.

8.4 Actions taken (nominated technician and approved tachograph centre)

Where shortcomings have been identified and recorded in writing via approved tachograph centre quality control systems and have also been resolved prior to audit, and provided these issues are not serious in nature, DVSA will halve the points allocated.

A historic shortcoming is when the issue occurred prior to the audit or inspection. For example, a substantial gap in quality control checks that is subsequently resolved. If no current quality control checks are recorded, this would be a current shortcoming.

8.4.1 Thresholds for action being taken against nominated technicians

Points Action Training requirement Cessation period
1 to 39 Advice None None
40 to 49 Formal warning, valid for 5 years None None
50 to 69 Formal warning, valid for 5 years None 4 weeks
70 to 89 Formal warning, valid for 5 years Refresher nominated technician course 4 weeks
90 to 99 Formal warning, valid for 5 years Initial nominated technician course 4 weeks
100 to 199 Formal warning, valid for 5 years Initial nominated technician course 8 weeks
200 to 299 Formal warning, valid for 5 years Initial nominated technician course 12 weeks
300 to 399 Formal warning, valid for 5 years Initial nominated technician course 16 weeks
400 to 499 Formal warning, valid for 5 years Initial nominated technician course 20 weeks
500 to 1000 Formal warning, valid for 5 years Initial nominated technician course Disqualified for 6 months to 5 years

When shortcomings result in a formal warning, any repetition of the same shortcoming during the period of a formal warning will result in points being doubled.

It is possible for a nominated technician or approved tachograph centre to face cessation or disqualification as a result of a single issue.

8.4.2 Thresholds for action being taken against approved tachograph centres

Points Action Cessation period
1 to 79 Advice None
80 to 99 Formal warning None
100 to 199 Formal warning 4 weeks
200 to 399 Formal warning 8 weeks
400 to 599 Formal warning 12 weeks
600 to 799 Formal warning 16 weeks
800 to 999 Formal warning 20 weeks
1000 to 2000 Formal warning Disqualified for 6 months to 5 years

All cessations require shortcomings to be satisfactorily resolved prior to authorisation being re-granted. Following disqualification, a full authorisation application and fee must be submitted prior to the approved tachograph centre being re-authorised.

Any repetition of the same shortcoming during a period of formal warning will result in double points being awarded for the repeated issues.

Matters formally reported by an approved tachograph centre in writing to tachosection@dvsa.gov.uk prior to the commencement of a DVSA audit or investigation will not normally result in points being awarded to the approved tachograph centre. A formal warning will however be recorded.

Cessation may occur without previous warning if centres exceed points values. Where fraud has been committed, prosecution action may follow.

8.5 Shortcomings

Shortcomings that are not serious

Reference Description Points
1.1 Missing print (per calibration) 10
1.2 No pre-check or ineffective pre-check 30
1.3 No sender check or ineffective sender check 30
1.4 No diagnostic speed check or ineffective diagnostic speed check 30
1.5 No diagnostic distance check or ineffective diagnostic distance check 30
1.6 No mode check or ineffective mode check 30
1.7 No slot 1 and 2 check or ineffective slot 1 and 2 check 30
1.8 Failure to use an average of 3xW measurements (within 1%) or 2 exact measurements of W for tachograph settings 30
1.9 No speed or road test 30
1.10 Incorrectly sealed 30
1.11 Workshop card insecure 30

Shortcomings that are serious

Reference Description Points
1.12 PIN insecure 50
1.13 Incorrect calibration type (for example, installation only) 60
1.14 Any calibration shortcoming which would result in a prohibition or annual test fail (cumulative with specific shortcoming) 60
1.15 DNSS/DSRC/IMS not checked or defective when required 60
1.16 Failure to ensure correct tachograph components fitted - this includes incorrect vehicle or sender unit type, DNSS, DSRC and IMS 100 per component
1.17 Use of equipment out of calibration (approved tachograph centre only) – if current, calibrations are to cease immediately 100
1.18 Use of retread or illegal tread tyres on calibration axle 500
1.19 Incorrect recording of tyre size, for example, 315/80 R22.5 recorded when 295/80 R22.5 tyres are fitted 500
1.20 A nominated technician records a calibration without personally completing it 500
1.21 Insufficient time is taken to complete a calibration 500
1.22 Unjustified changes are made to tachograph settings 500
1.23 The recording of a tachograph calibration for a vehicle attending an approved tachograph centre, in which their start and finish times of the inspection would not allow a full calibration to be carried out 500
1.24 A bribe is accepted resulting in altered calibration settings 1000
1.25 The fitment of any device by an approved tachograph centre, their employee or agent, or a nominated technician, which interferes with the accurate recording of any data by the tachograph 1000
1.26 Any prosecution against a nominated technician or approved tachograph centre in relation to EC tachograph regulations 100 to 1000

8.6 Accuracy checks

DVSA may inspect any vehicle on site which is there for calibration or has recently been calibrated by the approved tachograph centre. Part of this inspection may include repeating a calibration to compare the calibration settings undertaken to ensure the previous settings are accurate.

All accuracy shortcomings are serious.

Accuracy checks when the vehicle has not left the site

Reference Shortcoming Points
2.1 Unexplainable inaccuracy in K, and /or W, and /or L recorded (more than 2%) 500
2.2 Unexplainable inaccuracy in K, and /or W, and /or L recorded (more than 4%) 700
2.3 Unexplainable inaccuracy in K, and /or W, and /or L recorded (more than 6%) 1000

Accuracy checks when the vehicle has left the site (historic calibration)

Reference Shortcoming Points
2.4 Unexplainable inaccuracy in K, and /or W, and /or L recorded (more than 4%) 500
2.5 Unexplainable inaccuracy in K, and /or W, and /or L recorded (more than 6%) 700
2.6 Unexplainable inaccuracy in K, and /or W, and /or L recorded (more than 8%) 1000

8.7 Approved tachograph centre audit shortcomings

All items found must be investigated and rectified when practicable prior to the audit visit being finished, or at minimum prior to the 15 days response period expiring. Failure to do so will result in double points being awarded for the affected elements.

These shortcomings are not recorded against nominated technicians.

Reference Description Points
3.1 Quality control checks missed (3 monthly equipment checks or 6 monthly nominated technicians checks) 20 per check
3.2 Quality control checks failed to record evident shortcomings 50 per check
3.3 Missing calibrations from the register of tachograph plaques issued (GV212) 20 per calibration
3.4 20m track badly worn 10
3.5 20m track inaccurate 20
3.6 Unauthorised changes to relevant approved tachograph centre facilities 100
3.7 Tachograph office left insecure 10
3.8 Parking slots not used for tachograph vehicles 5
3.9 Signage missing or significantly damaged 5
3.10 Notice board not present, or missing required items 5

Appendix 8.8 Disciplinary procedures

Reasons for cessation of authorisation for nominated technicians, quality controllers, designated managers and approved tachograph centres.

Test results

Passed, passing or issuing a ‘Tachograph Calibration’ means either issuing:

  • a calibration certificate or plaque for a tachograph
  • a minor repair certificate for a tachograph
  • an inspection certificate or plaque for a tachograph

8.8.1 Surrendering workshop cards to DVSA

Some shortcomings record that the card must be surrendered to DVSA. In these cases, the relevant cards, when to hand or on site, must be handed over immediately on DVSA request. Failure to do so, regardless of the impact on business, may be considered as shortcoming h under other serious offences.

8.8.2 Approved Tachograph Centre (ATC)

Normally an Approved Tachograph Centre (ATC) authorisation will be subject to cessation for disciplinary reasons following a single instance of the types mentioned under sections 8.8.7 Fraud, dishonesty or gross negligence, 8.8.8 Conviction and 8.8.9 Repute, whether committed by the nominated technician or their employee or agent.

Where fraud has been committed or where calibrations result in breaches in legislation, prosecution may be considered.

Authorisation may also be subject to cessation following a single instance of the types mentioned in sections 8.8.5 Other very serious offences and 8.8.6 Other serious offences, again whether committed by the approved tachograph centre or their employee or agent.

8.8.3 Conviction

The points in this section are only awarded to approved tachograph centres when directors, partners or sole traders (known as ATC principals) have been convicted.

Shortcoming Points
Convictions, as defined in Appendix 7: convictions and repute of the MOT testing guide, of any persons involved in the tachograph scheme under the authorisation. This includes ATC principals, designated managers, quality controls and nominated technicians. 500

8.8.4 Repute

The points in this section are only awarded to approved tachograph centres when directors, partners or sole traders (known as ATC principals) are those affected.

Shortcoming Points
Loss of good repute, as defined in Appendix 7: convictions and repute of the MOT testing guide 500

8.8.5 Other very serious offences

Shortcoming Points
a. A tachograph calibration is carried out by a person who is not properly authorised to carry out calibrations at that approved tachograph centre. A person is properly authorised to test at a particular approved tachograph centre if they are listed on the relevant DVSA issued list of nominated technicians (GV213) and are not disqualified from the scheme. 500
b. Calibration work is carried out on a tachograph that the approved tachograph centre or nominated technician is not authorised to calibrate. For example, calibration of an Annex 1C tachograph without the proper authorisation (100 points), calibration of an Annex 1C tachograph without the proper equipment (500 points), any calibration work by any approved tachograph centre whose authorisation has been withdrawn due to disciplinary action (500 points), any calibration work by any approved tachograph centre whose authorisation has been withdrawn due to non-payment (100 points) or any calibration work being undertaken when training certificates have expired (100 points). Up to 500
c. The improper recording of a calibration result to a vehicle where elements of the hardware or software has not passed the required test. 100
d. Physical or verbal assault on, threats of violence or intimidation made against, or deliberate intimidation of vehicle presenters or DVSA, Civil Service, warranted enforcement personnel or contractors 500 to 1000
e. Undermining approved tachograph centre test standards or the integrity of the approved tachograph centre calibration service by removing, deactivating, bypassing or rendering ineffective any legally required element of the tachograph system. 1000
f. Testing vehicles with calibration equipment known to be faulty or known to be out of calibration. 100

8.8.6 Other serious offences

The following single acts may also result in cessation of authorisation. If the circumstances are not considered sufficiently serious to justify single-case cessation then the penalty will be 100 points.

Shortcoming Points
a. Failure to notify DVSA of a conviction of any persons involved in the approved tachograph centre scheme under the authorisation. This includes directors, partners and sole traders, designated managers, nominated technicians and quality controllers. 100 to 500
b. The use of a workshop card by an unauthorised person or a person not identified as the holder. 500
c. False statement made on an application for approved tachograph centre or nominated technician authorisation. Confirming details when required to do so, that are known to be false. 100 to 500
d. Failure to notify DVSA of a change in the constitution or operation of a business (100 points), a change to an approved site (100 points), the use of an unauthorised site (500 points) or the failure to cease calibrations after such a change pending DVSA’s written confirmation that calibrations may resume (500 points). 100 to 500
e. Disclosure of a workshop card PIN, either deliberately or accidentally to any other person. This includes recording PIN numbers in areas which others may see them. The workshop card must be surrendered to DVSA immediately for replacement. 50 points if accidental, 500 points if deliberate
f. A vehicle calibration is undertaken using a nominated technician’s card who is not present on the premises for the duration of time that a calibration occurs. The workshop card must be surrendered to DVSA. 500
g. Removal of a workshop card from the authorised premises without written approval from the DVSA tachograph scheme coordinator or an enforcement policy manager. The workshop card must be surrendered. 100 points if no evidence of misuse, 500 points if calibration or approved tachograph centre related or regulated work undertaken away from approved tachograph centre approved location
h. Failure to surrender a workshop card without sufficient reason. When workshop cards are to hand, they must be surrendered without delay upon request by DVSA. If cards are off-site without the required written approval as noted above, they must be returned without delay to the site without regard to business needs. 500
i. Other cases of loss of good repute as defined in Appendix 7: convictions and repute of the MOT testing guide 100 to 500
j. Deliberate obstructive behaviour towards vehicle presenters or DVSA staff or contractors 500

Convictions

DVSA understands that certain convictions can be emotive in nature and as such DVSA will take into consideration any conviction which is defined to be a serious offence.

DVSA considers a serious offence to be defined as any criminal conviction of an individual or business entity to which that individual had an association to, where any of the following has been imposed:

  • a prison sentence of 3 months or more, including suspended sentences
  • a fine exceeding level 4 on the standard scale, which is currently £2,500
  • a community service order, or equivalent, requiring unpaid work for more than 60 hours

DVSA considers any punishment outside the UK that corresponds to these penalties a serious offence.

If the conviction does not fall under these categories then the conviction will be considered acceptable for participation within the approved tachograph centre scheme, unless there are grounds for consideration as part of an individual’s good repute.

Examples of deliberate obstructive behaviour

Examples of deliberate obstructive behaviour towards vehicle presenters or DVSA staff or contractors include:

  • failure to offer an appointment for a calibration within a reasonable period of a request, bearing in mind existing bookings and the availability of the vehicle concerned
  • unjustified refusal to calibrate a vehicle presented or to honour, within a reasonable time, an appointment previously made
  • refusal to allow a calibration to be observed by DVSA personnel
  • qhere a recently calibrated vehicle is on site, the failure to allow or preventing of an observation of a re-calibration, where a reasonable request has been made
  • preventing a DVSA audit activity being conducted by authorised DVSA examiners, that has been reasonably requested

Offences for nominated technicians

Normally a nominated technician will be subject to cessation if they are personally involved in any act that could lead to single offence cessation of the authorisation of an approved tachograph centre.

Where fraud has been committed, or where calibrations undertaken exceed in use tolerances, prosecution may be considered.

A nominated technician will usually be subject to cessation for very serious offences.

Additionally, it is normal practice for a nominated technician to be subject to cessation where there are significant procedural omissions (for example, non-use of designated equipment), and cessation may be applied for a single major incident of substandard calibration that could have significant road safety implications or result in Tachographs not meeting the legislative standard.

Penalty points will be calculated from relevant appendices and the action level determined in accordance with the tables in this section.

8.8.7 Fraud, dishonesty or gross negligence

Shortcoming Points
The improper recording of a successful calibration to a vehicle operated by, or on behalf of, the nominated technician or approved tachograph centre, or which the nominated technician or approved tachograph centre has an interest in selling or seeking to sell. 500

8.8.8 Conviction

Shortcoming Points
a. Conviction for any offence as defined in Appendix 7: convictions and repute of the MOT testing guide. 500
b. Conviction for any offence involving violence, intimidation or obstruction which DVSA considers could put customers or DVSA staff at risk. This also includes graduated fixed penalty deposits or fixed penalty notices. 500

8.8.9 Repute

Shortcoming Points
Loss of good repute, as defined in Appendix 7: convictions and repute of the MOT testing guide. 500

8.8.10 Other serious offences

Shortcoming Points
Production of false documents or false statements to DVSA or approved tachograph training providers. 500

8.9 Action after initial assessment by the DVSA examiner

Following a DVSA audit, the GV211TTA and GV6TTA forms will be forwarded to the designated manager. Where shortcomings are noted, the parties concerned will be invited to make written representations via the designated manager about the circumstances of the case, and any corrective action within 14 days of the date of the correspondence. All parties should be made aware of the evidence submitted and be given the opportunity to respond, either via the designated manager or direct to the approved tachograph centre examiner.

Following this, a report on the case containing the relevant responses will be forwarded by the DVSA approved tachograph centre examiner to the DVSA tachograph and speed limiter scheme coordinator for a full review in accordance with the tables listed in this section, and assessment of the evidence according to the principle of the balance of probabilities. This will also take into account any formal warnings previously listed against the centre.

Any matters successfully prosecuted will be taken as proven as a matter of course and will not have a second assessment under the balance of probabilities.

If, after review of the case report, DVSA consider formal disciplinary action is not justified then appropriate advice will be issued to the approved tachograph centre or nominated technician.

If the nominated technician ceases to work for the approved tachograph centre involved, DVSA must be informed immediately and given a forwarding address for the nominated technician. DVSA will contact them direct and provide the relevant documentation and evidence as required, and give a period for a written response. Nominated technicians who are unable to examine copies of photographs sent to the approved tachograph centre, may contact that DVSA office to make arrangements to see the photographs.

8.10 Notice of disqualification or cessation

The normal notice period before disqualification or withdrawal becomes effective is 35 days. This period may be reduced and the notice may be given early effect, should DVSA believe there to be a serious risk to road safety, or to the integrity or repute of the tachograph scheme. For all parties, this may be reduced to an immediate withdrawal of authorisation on the written authorisation of the scheme manager.

8.11 Guidance and code of practice for informal hearings

These notes explain the procedures for informal hearings which may be held as part of the process of determining appeals from:

  • authorised tachograph centres and nominated technicians who have been served with a notice of cessation or disqualification
  • applicants who have been served with a notice of intent to refuse their application for authorisation

These notes should be read in conjunction with the provisions of the approved tachograph centre manual.

Any appealing parties should make such representations in writing within 14 days from the date of the notice. All written representations or statements should fully set out your case and all the evidence you wish to rely upon. The availability of informal hearings does not affect the requirements of the scheme.

Informal hearings provide an additional process whereby cases may be put personally to officials in DVSA’s appeals section.

Requests for a hearing

Requests for a hearing are at the discretion of DVSA and may be granted if there are exceptional circumstances.

If you wish to present your case at a hearing, you should submit your request to the email address on the decision letter. We will accept postal hearing requests, however, this might cause a delay in processing the appeal if you use this method.

This request must be submitted as soon as possible after you have received the notice of cessation or intent to refuse to authorise, approve or designate. If a date for the hearing is offered by the appeals team, you will be permitted to refuse the first date offered.

Who may attend the hearing

You may attend, be represented by your trade association, consultant or legal representative or both attend and have a representative. The appeals section may arrange for DVSA personnel involved in the disciplinary or intended refusal action to attend the hearing where their evidence is at issue.

Prior to the hearing

An important element of this procedure is that the appeals officer must be fully aware of the relevant issues and arguments so that they can properly lead the discussion. Your written representations or statement should contain full particulars of the case you wish to make at the hearing including a list of any documents to which you wish to refer.

The provision of your written representations or statement within 14 days of the issue of the notice of cessation or intent to refuse is a necessary procedure. If you are appealing against a notice of cessation you may however, within the 14 day period, state in writing that you wish to rely, at hearing, on the written representations made earlier to the DVSA office that issued the decision.

To assist you the grounds of appeal have been categorised. The following list is not exhaustive, and it is recognised that there are some overlapping grounds:

  • the disciplinary procedures have not been followed by DVSA at each and every stage
  • the technical evidence is disputed
  • other evidence is disputed
  • the wrong interpretation has been placed upon the facts
  • the sanction imposed or the number of disciplinary points allotted is not in accordance with the approved tachograph centre manual
  • the penalty is not proportionate to the offence
  • there are mitigating circumstances
  • the intent to refuse is unreasonable

The venue

Appeals will, where possible, be heard via Microsoft Teams. In extreme circumstances where this is not possible, we will consider conducting them in person at a mutually convenient location.

The hearing will be held by a senior officer of the appeals team. The procedures will be fully explained to you at the start of, and throughout, the hearing.

The appeals officer will first set out the case as it appears from their reading of the papers, outlining what they consider are the main issues. In some cases, this might take the form of an agenda. They will also indicate those matters on which further information is needed. This will not preclude you from referring to other aspects you consider to be relevant.

All evidence will have been disclosed beforehand so that you will have had time to understand it and it will not normally be necessary to read this out at the hearing. If further documents are made available at the hearing the appeals officer may ask or allow questions on any points which emerge which may need further information or clarification.

The hearing will take the form of a discussion which you or your representative will be invited to start. You may, if you wish, decline to do so. The parties will be encouraged to ask questions informally throughout the proceedings, subject only to the discussion being conducted in an orderly manner.

Cross-examination will not be permitted unless the appeals officer considers that cross-examination is required to ensure a thorough examination of the main issues. You will be given the opportunity to make any final comments before the hearing is closed.

If a hearing needs to be adjourned this will be at the discretion of the officer holding the hearing. If a date for the resumption of the hearing cannot be set at the time of the adjournment, the date will be notified to the appellant within 5 working days.

The appeals officer may close the proceedings if, at any time during the hearing, matters are in their judgement not progressing satisfactorily. The appeal will then be determined on the basis of any written representations submitted. Full reasons for the closure of the hearing will be given in the appeal decision letter.

An audio only recording will be made of the hearing. A copy of the recording and a transcript will be available as evidence in the event of subsequent court proceedings.

The decision

Decisions will not be made at the hearing as they are made by DVSA’s chief executive on behalf of the Secretary of State. The administrative target for determining appeals after hearings will be the same as that for appeals determined by written representations with 95% of appeals to be determined within 5 weeks.

In the case of written representations, the target date is calculated from the date the written representations are received. The target date following a hearing will be calculated from the date of the hearing. The decision letter will be issued by the appeals section on the date the appeal is determined.

Notice of cessation and effective date of cessation

If you wish your case to be heard at a hearing you should bear in mind that it is unlikely that your appeal can be determined prior to the notice of cessation becoming effective. The date the notice comes into effect cannot be deferred pending the outcome of the appeal. Whilst the appeals section will try to determine your appeal as quickly as possible, there may be a period during which the approved tachograph centre and nominated technicians must cease testing pending the determination of the appeal.