Skip to main content
Press release

Ofqual fines AQA £350,000 over repeated errors in braille assessments

AQA has been fined £350,000 by Ofqual following significant repeated failings in the production and quality assurance of braille assessment materials.

AQA has been fined £350,000 by Ofqual following significant repeated failings in the production and quality assurance of braille assessment materials.  

These failings included errors in GCSE geography and recurring errors across other qualifications between 2024 and 2026.  

The action reflects Ofqual’s commitment to improving the accessibility of assessments for all students and driving improvements in modified assessment materials.  Where failures are identified, awarding organisations will be held to account. 

A total of 56 accessibility errors were identified across the braille versions of AQA’s GCSE geography assessments, including pre-release materials. The errors included problems with tactile maps, diagrams and graphs and visual descriptions. 

The regulator also found weaknesses in AQA’s quality assurance, oversight and risk management arrangements. After accessibility concerns were raised with AQA about its GCSE geography braille materials in mock assessments in 2023, Ofqual found that opportunities to address those concerns before the summer 2024 examinations were missed. AQA also failed to follow its escalation procedures, leading to delays in identifying, investigating and reporting the full extent of the errors.  

Ofqual found that AQA: 

  • failed to identify and correct accessibility errors before assessment materials were used in live examinations 

  • missed opportunities to address concerns raised following mock assessments 

  • failed to follow its escalation procedures when concerns emerged 

  • did not establish the full extent of the errors until well after the assessments had been taken 

  • had weaknesses in its quality assurance, oversight and risk management arrangements 

When deciding the level of the penalty, Ofqual considered further braille assessment material errors identified in 2024, 2025 and 2026 across a range of regulated qualifications. These errors indicated that the failings identified in this case were not isolated incidents and reflected broader weaknesses in AQA’s approach to producing and quality-assuring braille assessment materials. 

Amanda Swann, Executive Director for Delivery at Ofqual, said: 

Every student deserves an equal opportunity to demonstrate their abilities in an exam, including those who are blind or partially sighted. Exam boards must make sure that they can all demonstrate their knowledge, skills and understanding. 

AQA failed to ensure that its braille assessment materials were accurate and accessible. These were not isolated failings, and this fine reflects both the seriousness of those failings and the importance of getting modified assessment materials right.

AQA introduced new checks and strengthened oversight of its braille assessment materials ahead of the 2026 summer exams. The exam board will be required to implement a formal action plan addressing the weaknesses identified, and Ofqual will monitor its implementation and effectiveness. 

Ofqual is continuing to work with exam boards and the Joint Council for Qualifications to strengthen arrangements for modified assessment materials. This work is focused on preventing errors, improving quality assurance and increasing the likelihood that materials are right first time. 

AQA has accepted responsibility for the failings and agreed to pay a £350,000 fine. It will also pay Ofqual’s reasonable legal costs and implement a formal action plan to address the issues identified. 

Notes to Editors: