Commissioner's statement on facial recognition consultation response
Statement on the government's consultation response on the use of facial recognition and similar technologies in law enforcement.
Photo: University of Stirling
The Biometrics and Surveillance Camera Commissioner, Professor William Webster, said:
I welcome the government’s response to its consultation on facial recognition and similar biometric technologies. It marks an important step towards primary legislation that will provide a clear legal basis for their use, protect the public and build confidence in how these technologies are deployed.
Biometric surveillance technologies, including live facial recognition, are intrusive and conflict directly with fundamental human rights, including rights associated with freedom of movement, freedom of expression, the right to peaceful assembly and the right to privacy. The government’s response acknowledges the potential to interfere with these rights, and from my perspective clear legislation and effective safeguards are essential to mitigate these risks. The proposed framework offers the possibility of providing these safeguards whilst at the same time allowing the police to make the best lawful use of emerging biometric surveillance technology.
As I emphasised in my consultation response, there is a need for clear measures of necessity and proportionality, that robust effective oversight must underpin the framework, and that this oversight must include powers associated with audit, inspection and compliance. I am pleased that the proposals for a new oversight body state that it will include compliance powers. The commitments in this response must now translate into effective governance arrangements.
I am also pleased to see that the proposed framework will extend across public services, not just law enforcement, that a new statutory code of practice will be published, as well as the commitment to a similar code for the commercial sector. This is an important step as it recognises that law enforcement and public safety extend across the public and commercial sectors and is not just the remit of the police.
There is also a commitment to future proof oversight by capturing new and unforeseen technological developments. Technology is evolving rapidly. Facial recognition is likely to become increasingly integrated into existing camera networks, and into body-worn video and drones. The framework must keep pace with these developments while maintaining meaningful oversight and public confidence, and the ability for Parliament to add other technologies to the framework in the future is essential. This is especially important in an era of AI and where video analytics will radically evolve the capabilities of traditional surveillance cameras.
Recent live facial recognition deployments I have observed show differences in practice between police forces. The proposed framework offers an opportunity to support consistent compliance with national standards. In this respect, the proposed legal framework offers the potential to build on the national standards for video surveillance camera systems promoted by the Home Secretary’s existing Surveillance Camera Code of Practice. The response to the consultation is clear in that it aspires to build on the work already undertaken by the Office of the Biometrics and Surveillance Camera Commissioner and the principles established in the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012. Furthermore, the commitment to a single oversight body should help clarify the existing cluttered regulatory landscape.
Whilst the government’s response to the consultation signals a clear direction of travel, which I am very supportive of, it lacks detail in a number of key areas, for example:
- What governance, accountability and oversight mechanisms will be committed to in primary legislation and what will be contained in the proposed new statutory code of practice?
- What will the measures necessity and proportionality look like?
- Who will determine the efficacy and acceptability of individual technological applications?
- What will the commitment to meaningful oversight look like in practice?
- How will national technological and operational standards emerge?
- How will compliance in the commercial sector be enforced?
- Will the new oversight body be appropriately resourced?
Further detail is needed on the new oversight body’s powers to assess its ability to deliver audit and compliance, and whether its resources and specialist expertise will match its responsibilities. Clear coordination with other regulators will also be essential to avoid duplication and gaps in oversight.
The direction of travel is positive, and I look forward to seeing the full details when the Police Reform Bill is laid before Parliament. This legislation represents a once in a generation opportunity to put in place legally binding rules and safeguards that will allow for the proportionate and appropriate use of biometric surveillance technologies in society. There is an urgent need for this legislation as technologies like facial recognition are diffusing into society rapidly.
Professor William Webster
Biometrics and Surveillance Camera Commissioner