- Nearly half of parents are unhappy with programmes or adverts on TV before the 9pm watershed
A survey of over 1,000 parents of all backgrounds has revealed that 88% think that children are under pressure to grow up too quickly.
The survey forms part of the independent Bailey Review of Commercialisation and Sexualisation of Childhood, commissioned by the Department for Education to unravel and tackle issues around the premature sexualisation and commercialisation of children.
Celebrity culture, adult style clothes and music videos are all guilty in parents’ eyes of encouraging children to act older than they are.
The survey aimed to find out what parents think and what help they need to manage the pressures on their children. The Bailey Review has also been listening to parents through focus groups and a call for evidence, which received an overwhelming response from parents.
Specific areas of concern are emerging from parents. These include:
- clothes to be clearly age appropriate and not simply scaled down versions of adult fashion
- Increasingly sexualised content in music videos and pre-watershed TV with ‘too adult’ themes in some soap operas
- Pressure to buy non-essential items for their children so they don’t feel left out
Reg Bailey, Chief Executive of the Mothers Union, is leading an independent review into the Commercialisation and Sexualisation of Childhood.
Parents are telling us in no uncertain terms that they are worried about the pressures on children to grow up too quickly. It is clear that their concerns have not been created out of a moral panic but from their everyday experience. They are struggling against the slow creep of an increasingly commercial and sexualised culture and behaviour, which they say prevents them from parenting the way they want.
Parents are disappointed that some of the existing regulation and self-regulation is starting to let them down. They feel that traditionally trusted controls like the TV ‘watershed’ have become less rigorous and the lines have become more blurred.
They are also uneasy about marketing to children through new digital media. Almost all the parents that responded did not think it was appropriate for companies to send phone and text adverts to children. They are particularly frustrated when sophisticated marketing techniques are used which they are unaware of and therefore unable to manage the pressure it creates.
It is very interesting to look at why parents are not complaining directly to companies and regulators about this in the numbers we might expect given the strength of feeling. In the busy hectic schedule of families’ lives it is understandable that many parents feel it would be too difficult and time consuming. But a large number of parents told us they are worried that they will be seen as prudish or out of touch if they complain. They have little faith in regulators or businesses taking their concerns seriously.
The increasingly commercialised and sexualised world we live in can be a challenging environment for adults, but even more so for children. So far I have encountered two very different approaches in dealing with this. Either we can try and keep children wholly innocent until they are adults, which I believe is unrealistic and unhealthy. Or we accept the world the way it is and simply give children the tools to navigate their way through it better. Neither approach works in my view.
For us to let children be children, we need to let parents be parents. That means giving parents the support and encouragement they need to help their children understand and resist the harms they face. But it also means putting brakes on ever greater commercialisation and sexualisation facing children in modern society. Only then can we look to create a truly family friendly society that protects children.
Findings from the survey show that:
- 40% of parents said they had seen things in public places (shop window displays, advertising hoardings) that they felt were inappropriate for children to see because of their sexual content.
- 41% of parents said they had seen programmes or adverts on TV before 9pm that they felt were unsuitable or inappropriate for children due to their sexual content
- Of those parents who had felt the need to complain about these issues but hadn’t, over 60% said that they had not done so either because they didn’t think anything would be done or they didn’t know who to complain to
- Around half of parents felt that celebrity culture, adult style clothes and music videos are encouraging children to act older than they are.
Other emerging findings from the call for evidence and focus groups show:
- Two-thirds of parents had come across clothes, toys, games, music videos or other products that they thought were inappropriate for the age group they were aimed at
- Almost all parents did not think it was appropriate for companies to use phone and text adverts when promoting products for children
- Parents feel that children are behaving in an overtly sexual manner before they are old enough to really understand what sexually provocative behaviour means
- Parents have said they want to deal with these pressures themselves but they want more responsible action from business and help from government to support them in this role
The survey results, focus groups responses and findings from the call for evidence will be published in the final report of the Bailey Review in May.
Notes to Editors:
A face to face survey of 1,025 parents of 5- to 16-year-olds was carried out between 16 February and 6 March 2011 by TNS Omnibus.
A call for evidence ran from 11 February to 18 March 2011. There were 997 responses from parents and over 100 responses from industry and stakeholders.