Skip to main content
Open consultation

GBR licence consultation

Published 12 November 2026

Applies to England, Scotland and Wales

The government is creating Great British Railways (GBR), a new public body that will bring together responsibility for rail infrastructure and most passenger rail services.

GBR will require a licence to legally operate its railway assets. The GBR licence will set out some obligations that GBR must meet to operate those assets.

This consultation seeks views on the proposed contents of the new GBR licence. This covers the proposed requirements for GBR in areas including:

  • providing information and assurance
  • improving the passenger experience
  • ensuring good stewardship and governance
  • meeting shared industry obligations

Welsh translations of the factsheet and full consultation will be published as soon as they are available. 

Bydd cyfieithiadau Cymraeg o’r daflen ffeithiau a’r ymgynghoriad llawn yn cael eu cyhoeddi cyn gynted ag y byddant ar gael.

Ministerial foreword

Our railway has helped shape Britain’s past and will play a vital role in its future. For 2 centuries, it has carried families to one another, people to seek opportunities, and goods to every corner of the country.

Yet too often, passengers and freight customers have experienced a system that can feel fragmented, complex and difficult to navigate. Responsibility has not been clear across multiple organisations, making it harder to deliver expected standards or know who is accountable when things go wrong. The consequences of a system that is not working effectively have been felt acutely: services have been unreliable, customers have been dissatisfied, and taxpayers have not always received the value for money they rightly expect.

At the heart of the government’s rail reforms will be the establishment of Great British Railways (GBR), a new publicly owned organisation bringing together responsibility for rail infrastructure and most passenger services. By establishing a single directing mind for the railway, GBR will provide clearer accountability and operate the services people rely on under public control. This will support long-term decision making in the public interest, making it easier to plan, run and improve the network for the people and businesses that depend on it. That is why we are reforming the railway – to help build Britain’s future.

But organisational change alone is not enough. A railway that connects regions and nations must also be accountable. People should know who is responsible for delivering safe and reliable services, spending public money wisely, and driving improvement when performance falls short.

While the GBR licence is not the primary mechanism through which railway safety is regulated or fares are set, it forms an important part of the framework that will hold GBR accountable for delivering a better railway for all. Affordability will be key to earning passengers’ trust. While ministers will set objectives for fares and affordability, GBR will be responsible for delivering simpler, clearer fares for passengers.

These reforms also recognise that while the railway is a national asset, its success is felt locally. From our great cities to rural communities, the railway must reflect the needs and ambitions of the places it serves. Local leaders will have more influence, with the most established mayors working in much deeper partnership with GBR.

GBR will operate in a framework that builds on devolved governments’ transport strategies and mayoral strategic authorities (MSAs)’ plans, combining national leadership with strong local and regional input. This will give local areas a stronger voice, translating local priorities into better rail outcomes while helping align national investment with the needs and opportunities of each region.

This consultation seeks views on the proposed GBR licence. We want to hear from passengers, freight users, industry partners, local leaders and all those with an interest in the future of our railway. I encourage you to share your views to help build a railway that can serve the country for generations to come.

Heidi Alexander
Secretary of State for Transport

Introduction

This document sets out a proposal for the GBR rail licence (the GBR licence). The licence will be a key part of the new framework for running and regulating the railway. It will set out key obligations that GBR must comply with and provides the legal framework under which GBR operates its railway assets.

Through this consultation, the government is seeking views on the proposed content of the GBR licence, including the illustrative drafting for the licence conditions. This consultation is separate from a subsequent notification procedure for the proposed GBR licence under schedule 1, section 8A of the Railways Bill. That process is expected to take place in 2027, following consideration of the feedback received in response to this consultation.

Broadly following the structure of the proposed licence, this consultation is organised into 5 sections:

  • the scope of the GBR licence - describes what is in and what is not in the proposed GBR licence
  • providing information and assurance - describes conditions relating to GBR’s provision of information, including to ORR
  • improving the passenger experience - describes conditions relating to GBR’s responsibilities to passengers, including compliance with relevant consumer standards
  • ensuring good stewardship and governance - describes conditions relating to GBR’s unique role as a responsible steward for the railway, including long-term asset stewardship
  • meeting shared industry requirements - describes conditions relating to wider, system-wide requirements that apply to GBR

The full proposed draft licence text is included in the proposed text for the GBR licence.

A full list of the questions on which we are consulting is provided. The government welcomes views on whether the illustrative drafting for the GBR licence provides the right framework to support GBR in delivering its responsibilities and creating a railway that works better for passengers, freight customers and taxpayers.

The railway is changing

The railway has a crucial role to play in supporting growth and opportunity across Great Britain and rail links will create growth, develop housing and create jobs. Stations sit at the heart of towns and cities, acting as gateways to communities and supporting local economic activity.

At its best, the railway should make people’s lives easier. Those who use and rely on the railway should be able to plan journeys with confidence, understand their travel options, access the support they need, and trust that they will be treated fairly when things do not go to plan.

The government wants the railway to work as part of a wider transport network to give more people the confidence to use public transport because it will get them where they need to go. It should also be a platform for innovation and growth: making better use of data, technology and partnership working to improve services, unlock new opportunities and support a more productive economy.

The railway should be part of an affordable, joined-up public transport offer with seamless journeys and simpler ticketing to connect people to jobs, education, services and opportunities across their region and beyond.

Responsibilities for different parts of the railway have become spread across multiple organisations and it has made decision-making more complex, reduced accountability and made it harder and more expensive to deliver improvements across the network. Passengers and freight customers experience the effects of this fragmentation through delays, inconsistent performance and a railway that is difficult to navigate.

The creation of an integrated GBR will enable a more joined-up approach to planning, operating and improving the network as a whole system, taking a longer-term view of the railway’s future and aligning railway planning with wider economic, transport and development priorities.

The reformed railway will play an important role in supporting greater local leadership and decision-making. While the railway operates as a national network, its success is experienced locally. Communities, businesses and local economies all depend on rail services that reflect their particular needs and priorities.

GBR will therefore work within a framework that creates a key partnership role for devolved governments and MSAs, building on relevant transport strategies and local transport plans when carrying out its functions.

Passenger representation will also be strengthened through the creation of the Passenger Watchdog, providing a stronger and more prominent voice for passengers.

As responsibilities are brought together within GBR, it is essential that authority is matched by proportionate accountability.

A new accountability framework

The reforms will establish clear roles for government, GBR, the Office of Rail and Road (ORR) and passenger watchdogs, making it easier to understand who is responsible for decisions and outcomes across the railway.

As part of establishing GBR, the government proposes a simpler and more coherent framework for how it will be monitored and held to account. The Secretary of State will set the long-term strategic direction and hold GBR to account for how it delivers its responsibilities. The Secretary of State will also be democratically accountable to Parliament and the public for the overall performance of the railway, with appropriate levers and tools as well as support from the broader sector.

GBR will be responsible for delivering for passengers, freight customers and taxpayers within a proportionate accountability framework. This framework will comprise a set of mechanisms, rules and controls that establish clear roles, responsibilities and oversight arrangements. The accountability framework will ensure that GBR is both empowered to act as the directing mind of the railway and held accountable for the outcomes it delivers.

Alongside the GBR licence, the framework includes, but is not limited to:

Further information on the accountability framework was set out in the GBR licence and accountability framework policy document published in May 2026.

The independent rail regulator, ORR, will support the Secretary of State in monitoring GBR’s business performance across its integrated track and train activities. This represents an evolution of ORR’s role to areas where it did not previously have a monitoring role. As the Secretary of State’s independent expert adviser, ORR will advise the Secretary of State on its view of GBR’s business performance as well as providing direct challenge to GBR.

Partnerships with MSAs will be a central feature of the reformed railway. We will give local leaders more influence over commuter rail services, with the most established mayors working in much deeper partnership with GBR.

Through partnership agreements, local commissioning arrangements, and enhanced engagement, GBR will work closely with mayors to help shape rail services and improve integration with wider local transport networks. GBR will be legally required to have regard to the Local Transport Plans of MSAs, and its local teams will work collaboratively with all levels of local government.

GBR will also be legally required to have regard to the relevant Transport Strategies of Scottish and Welsh Ministers when exercising its functions. Scottish ministers will remain accountable to the Scottish Parliament and the public for their role as funder of the railway in Scotland, and for the strategic direction they set in devolved rail matters in Scotland.

Although Welsh ministers do not have a role as funders of GBR infrastructure in Wales, Welsh ministers will have an enhanced role in informing infrastructure decisions within Wales.

A similar proportionate accountability framework will be in place for Ministers of the Scottish and Welsh Governments reflecting their respective roles on the railway. 

The role of the GBR licence

GBR will require a licence to legally operate the railway. The draft GBR licence sets out proposed core obligations (known as ‘conditions’) that GBR must meet and provides an independent basis for regulatory oversight by ORR.

The current licensing regime was originally designed to improve performance and prevent non-compliance in a largely private-sector railway. Although it has evolved over time, including to reflect Network Rail’s status as a public body, it is not fully aligned with the GBR model.

Under the current licensing regime licence holders hold separate licences for each railway asset they operate. As defined by the Railways Act 1993, railway assets cover network, stations, passenger and freight trains, and light maintenance depots. GBR’s railway assets will include the mainline network, its stations, passenger trains and light maintenance depots.

The new GBR licence will enable GBR to operate each of its railway assets under a single licence, reducing duplication and fragmentation, and providing a structure that reflects GBR’s integrated role.

The GBR licence will be issued under the Railways Act 1993 by the Secretary of State and independently enforced by ORR. It has been designed specifically for an integrated public sector rail body, to provide stability and certainty to GBR and the wider industry about what GBR’s licensed activities across Great Britain are.

Design of the GBR licence

In developing the draft GBR licence, we have been guided by several key principles that recognise the wider context of the mission to fundamentally reform the rail sector. The GBR licence is intended to provide a simplified and streamlined regulatory tool that:

  • establishes consistent, clear and outcomes-focused expectations that reflect GBR’s integrated responsibilities
  • aligns with GBR’s role as the directing mind for the railway, providing the flexibility needed for GBR to make strategic decisions and respond to changing circumstances
  • promotes certainty and stability both for GBR and wider industry through a proportionate and durable set of targeted conditions

The GBR licence is intended to be outcomes-focused rather than prescriptive, reflecting its role within a broader accountability framework. It will establish clearer responsibilities while giving GBR sufficient flexibility to exercise its judgement as the directing mind of the railway. Many of GBR’s roles and responsibilities will also be set through legislation, strategy, business planning and ministerial oversight.

The licence is therefore designed to complement, rather than duplicate, these mechanisms by focusing on a targeted set of conditions that can be independently monitored and enforced by ORR. This approach supports proportionate regulation while ensuring that expectations remain clear, and stakeholders can understand how important issues are being managed.

The proposed GBR licence is also designed to complement existing devolution arrangements and proposals for stronger mayoral partnerships and support the wider programme of rail reform. It supports a more integrated railway while recognising the distinct roles of devolved governments and MSAs in setting transport priorities and strategies in areas of their responsibility, helping to ensure that GBR’s decision-making reflects the needs of rail users across Great Britain. It also recognises the role of Scottish Ministers funding and specifying rail services and infrastructure in Scotland.

GBR will operate through a parent company structure, supported by a range of subsidiary companies carrying out operational activities. GBR subsidiaries will not require their own separate licences, as they will be covered by the single GBR licence where relevant.

Any licence enforcement action by ORR will be against GBR as the licence holder, rather than its individual subsidiaries. GBR will be accountable for delivering on its licence requirements and ensuring that all its railway assets (including those operated by subsidiaries) are operated in accordance with its licence.

The licence is intended to be an enduring document, while remaining adaptable to reflect changes in the wider industry. It will be reviewed approximately every five years, taking account of relevant strategic, business planning and funding cycles, to ensure it remains fit for purpose.

The Secretary of State will manage modifications to the GBR licence, in line with a statutory process that is set out in legislation. ORR will also be able to make modifications to the GBR licence with GBR’s agreement. In practice, ORR-led modifications to the GBR licence are expected to focus on technical matters where a Secretary of State-led process is not necessary.

Monitoring and enforcement

ORR will continue to play an important role within the reformed railway. The GBR licence will support a proportionate regulatory role for ORR by providing a clear framework against which it can independently monitor and enforce GBR’s compliance with its licence obligations.

Enforcement of the GBR licence will be one aspect of ORR’s wider regulatory activity, alongside its continuing responsibilities for health and safety regulation and competition law enforcement.

If GBR does not comply with its licence, ORR will retain a broad range of approaches it can use to remedy non-compliance, including its statutory enforcement powers. ORR will consult on its monitoring and enforcement approach to GBR in due course.

We expect that ORR’s approach will be graduated, proportionate and risk based, with formal enforcement action a last resort. Tools could include:

  • early engagement and dialogue
  • requiring GBR to create an improvement plan
  • escalation to the GBR Board
  • issuing a provisional or final order requiring specific corrective action

The Passenger Watchdog (legally known as the Passengers’ Council), will take on some consumer functions from ORR, including setting standards in areas relating to the passenger experience.

The watchdog will monitor adherence to these standards, which will be enforced by ORR through relevant licences including the GBR licence and holders of passenger and station licences. A memorandum of understanding will set out how ORR and the Passenger Watchdog will work together to secure improved outcomes for passengers, including through monitoring and enforcement of standards.

Issuing the GBR licence

The GBR licence is being designed to ensure a smooth transition. It will be finalised and granted at the point GBR takes on responsibility for operating the railway, which is expected to be in autumn 2027.

Ahead of granting the GBR licence, a process to revoke the current Network Rail network and station licences, and those operator licences for publicly owned train operators currently within the Department for Transport Operator Limited (DFTO), will be undertaken.

The process to revoke the Network Rail licences will be managed by the Secretary of State, in line with the revocation schedules set out in these licences. ORR will be responsible for the process to revoke the DFTO operator licences.

The department is working closely with ORR to plan this work and to ensure the transition to the single integrated GBR licence is orderly. This includes a programme of work to prepare relevant licence holders for the transition to the GBR licence at the point GBR takes on responsibility for operating the railway.

Other licence holders in the sector

Alongside GBR, other ‘non‑GBR’ operators of trains, stations, depots and networks will continue to hold licences. These include open access operators, devolved operators, freight operators, heritage operators and charter operators. ORR will remain responsible for overseeing the management of non-GBR licences, including the granting, modification, enforcement and revocation of these licences.

As the railway transitions to the new model, it will be important to ensure that the GBR licence and other licences are appropriately aligned, to ensure a coherent and consistent licensing regime. This will be particularly relevant where licence conditions address matters that apply across the industry.

In July, ORR published a discussion document that set out ORR’s emerging policy intent for proposed changes to non-GBR licences. ORR will formally consult on proposed changes to non-GBR licences later this autumn. Accordingly, this consultation focuses on the proposed GBR licence and does not seek views on changes to non-GBR licences. However, the department is working closely with ORR to ensure appropriate alignment between GBR and non-GBR licence holders.

The scope of the GBR licence

This consultation builds on the GBR licence and accountability framework policy document published in May 2026. That document set out the emerging thinking for the policy intent and structure of the draft GBR licence, including proposed content areas. Since the publication of that document, we have further refined the policy to produce a proposal for a full draft GBR licence, presented in this consultation.

The GBR licence will focus on areas where GBR has core public stewardship and system-wide responsibilities, and where independent assurance by ORR is most valuable. The proposed conditions for the GBR licence have been categorised under 4 thematic ‘parts’, which will form the main substance of the licence. These reflect the different aspects of GBR’s licence activities and provide a clear structure for its organisation.

The 4 proposed parts are:

  • Part A: information requirements – conditions relating to GBR’s provision of information, including to ORR
  • Part B: passenger experience – conditions relating to GBR’s responsibilities to passengers, including compliance with relevant consumer standards
  • Part C: stewardship and governance – conditions relating to GBR’s unique role as a responsible steward for the railway, including long-term asset stewardship
  • Part D: industry obligations– conditions relating to wider, system-wide requirements that apply to GBR

Areas not included in the GBR licence

The draft GBR licence reflects the unique role of GBR in a reformed railway. GBR will be a new organisation, with a new culture and objectives. As a single directing mind that will run our rail infrastructure and the majority of passenger journeys in the public interest, it has a much wider scope and role compared to Network Rail and existing passenger operators.

It is vital that GBR can operate with authority, independence, and clear strategic direction, without the day-to-day influence of government or disproportionate regulatory burden. A targeted and proportionate approach to regulation will give GBR the flexibility to make long-term decisions and manage trade-offs, while also maintaining confidence that taxpayers’ money is being spent responsibly and that third parties on the network are being treated fairly.

We have reviewed existing railway licences and regulatory models in other sectors to assess which elements remain appropriate for an integrated public sector body for the railways. Where existing licence conditions continue to support the effective operation of the railway and provide value, we propose to retain them or adapt them accordingly to the new model. Where they no longer reflect GBR’s role or duplicate requirements that are now better provided for elsewhere in the accountability framework, we have proposed that they are omitted.

The enduring nature of the GBR licence will mean it is most suitable for defining high-level obligations, rather than specific delivery requirements or metrics. It is also not designed to be a comprehensive operating manual or performance tool for GBR. As such, the licence will not replicate broadly framed network performance or corporate governance conditions found in existing licences. This includes existing conditions such as Network Rail’s network management duty, noting that core elements of this are now captured as part of GBR’s proposed statutory functions.

We have also considered whether some obligations are better dealt with elsewhere in the wider accountability framework, so that lines of responsibility remain clear and the GBR licence stays focused on its intended role. For example, we do not propose to include a non-discrimination condition in the GBR licence as GBR will already be subject to a range of legal and regulatory obligations which will require it to act fairly, reasonably and in a non-discriminatory manner.

GBR will already be bound by public law principles (including requirements around fairness and impartiality) and competition law. Likewise, GBR’s corporate requirements and expectations for what it can and cannot do as an organisation will be captured in alternative mechanisms, including GBR’s framework agreement. These matters are more appropriately addressed through direct bilateral arrangements between DfT and GBR.

GBR will be expected to set out its view of its own performance transparently by reporting on how it is delivering its business plan. The Secretary of State will ensure GBR remains accountable for its performance, and ORR will support the Secretary of State to do this. ORR will have a strengthened independent expert advisory role in legislation to monitor GBR’s performance and advise the Secretary of State and Scottish ministers.

Therefore, requirements relating to business planning and strategy are not required to be set out in the GBR licence. Similarly, while the safety of passengers, including women and girls, is a fundamental priority for the railway, there will not be specific obligations on personal security or violence against women and girls in the GBR licence, as these matters are more appropriately addressed through operational policy, policing and other accountability arrangements. Comparison with existing licences provides a fuller description of areas not proposed for inclusion in the GBR licence alongside an explanation of the rationale.

Ensuring GBR subsidiaries comply with the licence

The GBR licence will be granted to the GBR parent company, which will be the licence holder, and compliance will be enforced by ORR at that level. However, some functions and activities covered by the licence may be carried out by subsidiaries within the GBR group. Appropriate arrangements are therefore required to ensure that those subsidiaries comply with the relevant licence obligations when carrying out railway functions or activities.

We intend to include a general condition in the GBR licence that explicitly requires GBR to make sure its relevant subsidiaries comply with the licence. This will ensure that GBR, as the licence holder, remains accountable for compliance irrespective of how responsibilities are allocated across the GBR group.

The focus therefore remains on whether GBR has complied with its licence obligations. The obligation on GBR to secure compliance by relevant subsidiaries will support that outcome. It will require GBR to establish arrangements that ensure relevant subsidiaries act consistently with the licence obligations and will enable ORR and, where relevant, the Passenger Watchdog to hold GBR to account for delivering the substance of the licence.

A proposed definition of ‘relevant subsidiaries’ is intended to clarify which entities fall within scope without listing each subsidiary individually. The proposed definition is:

Means any Subsidiary of the licence holder, but only to the extent that its activities relate to, support, facilitate or are ancillary to the licence holder’s activities in respect of railway functions and are relevant to the discharge of the licence holder’s obligations under this licence.

As a matter of good governance, GBR would be expected to maintain an up-to-date record of its relevant subsidiaries and have effective internal processes in place to ensure those entities are complying with the GBR licence.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • GBR must establish, maintain and keep up to date a list of Subsidiaries authorised, by virtue of this licence, to operate railway assets under section 7B of the Act, and must make that list available to ORR.

  • Where any condition of this licence requires the licence holder to comply with an obligation, the licence holder must secure that each Relevant Subsidiary, as appropriate:

    • complies with that obligation as if the Relevant Subsidiary were the licence holder; or

    • provides such assistance as is necessary and takes any other action to enable the licence holder to comply with that obligation.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed scope of the licence allows GBR the flexibility to make strategic decisions, whilst providing a clear framework for ORR’s independent enforcement role? Explain your answer.

Question:

In your view, are there any aspects of the proposed licence that could have impacts for particular groups? Explain your answer.

If any, what measures could address these impacts for groups within the scope of this licence, including through measures that promote equality of opportunity?

Providing information and assurance

This section discusses 2 conditions, focused on making sure the regulator can get the information and additional advice it needs to effectively hold GBR to account:

  • relates to GBR’s provision of information to ORR

  • relates to the use of independent reporters

Providing information to the regulator

Effective information sharing supports transparency and accountability across the railway. By ensuring ORR has access to the information it needs, passengers, freight customers and taxpayers can have confidence that there is transparent and proportionate independent oversight of GBR’s performance.

The aim is to create a flexible and proportionate route for ORR to obtain the information it needs from GBR, without placing disproportionate administrative burdens on the licence holder.

The proposed condition would complement ORR’s existing statutory information-gathering powers by making routine information sharing easier and quicker, reducing the need to rely solely on legislative powers to obtain information.

Rather than prescribing detailed reporting requirements in the licence itself, the drafting requires both ORR and GBR to act reasonably and proportionately, taking account of the nature and scope of information requests and the resources required to comply with them.

To encourage effective ways of working, the proposed condition also introduces a requirement for GBR to have regard to a reporting framework, developed with ORR, which should set out jointly agreed principles and criteria in relation to the collection and sharing of information. We would expect the reporting framework to take into account GBR’s legal requirements on the handling and use of protected information.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • The licence holder shall provide to ORR, on request, any information which ORR reasonably and proportionately requires for the purpose of carrying out any of ORR’s functions under [the Railways Bill] and Part 1 of the Railways Act 1993.

  • Information required to be provided under this condition shall be provided in such form and manner and at such times as reasonably and proportionately requested by ORR. In complying with such requests, the licence holder shall have regard to any reporting framework agreed between the licence holder and ORR for the purposes of this condition. Where the licence holder considers that a request raises material practical, timing or resource implications, it shall notify ORR as soon as reasonably practicable and engage constructively with ORR regarding the arrangements for compliance.

  • The licence holder shall undertake appropriate assurance to ensure that any information provided under this condition is sufficiently accurate and complete for the purpose required so far as is reasonably practicable.

Working with independent reporters

There may be times when independent expert advice may be helpful to ensure ORR has a better understanding of certain issues or activities affecting the railway. Reporters can provide objective oversight that helps build regulatory confidence across the sector and drives improvement for customers and taxpayers.

This proposed condition would require GBR to appoint and cooperate with independent reporters when requested by ORR. Independent reporters are external experts who can review specific issues and provide independent, objective advice. The use of reporters can help investigate concerns, test evidence and identify opportunities to improve performance, while also supporting GBR and ORR to develop a shared understanding of issues. The proposed condition is similar to the independent reporters’ condition in Network Rail’s current network licence.

The condition would require GBR to adhere to a framework, jointly agreed with ORR, setting out the principles and arrangements for the appointment and use of independent reporters, including expectations around proportionality and value for money. This framework, which will sit outside the licence but will be enforced through it, will embed consistent ways of working and detail clear expectations on the use of reporters. The proposed approach is intended to ensure that independent reporters are used in a proportionate and collaborative way, whilst recognising the value they can bring both to GBR as the licence holder and ORR.

An important principle is that reporters should be used where additional specialist input or assurance is needed to support ORR in carrying out its functions. The use of independent reporters should support ORR’s monitoring and information gathering powers, rather than duplicate or replace them.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • The licence holder shall, in accordance with a jointly agreed framework, appoint an independent Reporter to review, and report on, any matter as ORR may reasonably require for the purpose of carrying out ORR’s functions under Part I of the Railways Act 1993 and [the Railways Bill].

  • The licence holder shall comply with the jointly agreed framework, as maintained and kept under review by GBR and ORR, which establishes the principles and working arrangements, including value for money and proportionality, governing the appointment and use of independent Reporters.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed information conditions strike the right balance between enabling effective regulatory oversight and allowing GBR the flexibility to deliver its responsibilities? Explain your answer.

Improving the passenger experience

GBR will be a new organisation, with a new culture and mindset from the outset. It will be responsible and equipped for leading the continued improvement of the passenger experience and will place passenger needs at the heart of its decision-making. GBR will be guided by its statutory duties and supported by incentives that encourage it to grow rail use by delivering services that passengers want to use.

The streamlined GBR licence will support this role by establishing key protections, while giving GBR the flexibility to own and improve its overall customer offer. Underpinning this will be a Passenger Watchdog that will set minimum standards that will apply to all passenger train and station operators.

Passengers rightly expect clear information, accessible services and fair treatment when things go wrong. In this section, the proposed licence conditions provide a framework of minimum protections and safeguards that passengers can rely on, and for the development of higher minimum standards over time. GBR will be expected to meet these minimum standards and protections, while continuing to develop its own approach to improving the passenger experience it provides.

The first passenger-related condition focuses on supporting the passenger experience, combining compliance with consumer standards set by the Passenger Watchdog with a wider range of passenger protections. The second requires GBR to engage and cooperate with the Passenger Watchdog and London TravelWatch.

Consumer experience

The GBR licence is not intended to determine every aspect of the passenger experience or provide a comprehensive strategy for improving passenger services. Passenger outcomes will also be driven and supported through the wider accountability framework, including legislation. This is in addition to GBR’s own operational arrangements and culture, and the work of organisations such as the Passenger Watchdog, which will be an advocate for all passengers.

The proposed consumer experience condition has 2 complementary parts:

  • setting and enforcing consumer standards
  • wider passenger protections

Enforcing consumer standards

The first part of the condition establishes a mechanism through which consumer standards set by the Passenger Watchdog can be enforced through the licensing framework. These standards establish a common baseline of consumer protection and service expectations across the railway.

Initially, the Passenger Watchdog will adopt standards and ancillary guidance currently managed by ORR covering areas where established consumer protections already exist, including passenger information, accessibility, complaints handling and delay compensation. This will ensure continuity for passengers as GBR is established and avoid disruption to protections that people already rely upon today.

The current consumer standards that will be adopted as GBR is established cover:

  • how travel information should be provided to passengers so that they can plan their journey, including during disruption
  • how to handle complaints
  • how delay compensation should be handled
  • the accessibility requirements operators must provide for disabled passengers and passengers requiring assistance, including consistent provision of passenger assistance whether pre-booked or requested at a station

The Passenger Watchdog will monitor compliance with these standards and promote improvements where standards are not being met. The Passenger Watchdog’s role in setting and monitoring these standards is set out in the Railways Bill and complements GBR’s own responsibility for improving services and responding to passenger needs. ORR will retain responsibility for enforcement through the licensing framework, with the Passenger Watchdog able to recommend enforcement action where appropriate.

The two organisations will agree a memorandum of understanding setting out how they will work together. A heads of terms document describing the areas this is expected to cover is published here.

The condition is designed to support future evolution in the standards framework. In line with its statutory powers, the Passenger Watchdog will be able to review and amend existing standards, and develop new standards where needed, to respond to passenger needs. This will help ensure that the regulatory framework can respond to changing passenger expectations and emerging challenges.

Any new or amended standards will be subject to consultation and will require the approval of both the Secretary of State and ORR, providing assurance that they are proportionate, deliverable and affordable. The watchdog will consult widely on the development of any new or amended standards as ORR does today. ORR will also separately consult on how these changes might be implemented for non-GBR operators.

Wider passenger protections

The second part of the condition includes a number of wider consumer-related requirements that GBR will also be required to meet. These are separate from the standards set by the Passenger Watchdog. Together they provide an important foundation of passenger protections but are not intended to be an exhaustive statement of GBR’s responsibilities to passengers.

This part of the condition covers additional areas that support passenger protections and a consistent passenger experience. These include requirements for GBR relating to passenger rights, conditions of carriage, and membership of the Rail Ombudsman.

Accessibility remains a fundamental part of the government’s vision for the railway. This part of the proposed licence condition also reinforces requirements to ensure that when station infrastructure is being designed, accessibility is fully considered so that disabled passengers can travel with confidence and independence.

Likewise, access to clear, accurate and timely information is another fundamental part of the passenger experience. The second part of this condition therefore also includes requirements relating to the provision and sharing of information on train movements to other passenger operators across the railway. This will help to ensure that operators are able to provide passengers with the information they need to plan their whole journey and to travel with confidence. This in turn will support passenger operators to meet the Passenger Watchdog standard on passenger information.

The intention is not to prescribe in this condition the detailed operational processes, governance arrangements or information-sharing mechanisms through which these outcomes are delivered. Where appropriate, such matters will continue to be addressed through industry arrangements, contractual frameworks and other regulatory instruments. This includes arrangements developed through the transfer of Rail Delivery Group functions and, where relevant, provisions in the future GBR code.

This approach is intended to ensure that the GBR licence remains focused on the outcomes that must be achieved for passengers, while allowing flexibility for industry participants to determine the most effective means of delivering and evolving the supporting arrangements over time.

Taken together, the requirements of this condition seek to help establish a common foundation of protections for passengers and expectations on GBR. It is intended to support a network that is easier to use, more accessible, and better able to meet the needs of the people who rely upon it.

The proposed text for this condition uses the legal name for the Passenger Watchdog which is the Passengers’ Council. The proposed text is:

Part 1: Compliance with Passengers’ Council  standards or guidance

  • The licence holder shall:
    • comply with any Passengers’ Council Standards;
    • have regard to any Passengers’ Council Published Guidance on accessible travel policies.
  • The Passengers’ Council Standards or Published Guidance may cover, but are not limited to:
    • Delay compensation;
    • Complaints handling;
    • Information for passengers; and
    • Accessible travel.
  • In relation to Published Guidance on accessible travel, the licence holder shall:
    • Develop, publish and comply with policy and procedures created in pursuance to the Passengers’ Council Published Guidance, unless this has been superseded by a new Passengers’ Council Standard on accessibility;
    • Submit any such policy and procedures and material changes to it for approval by the Passengers’ Council, and as requested by the Passengers’ Council.

Part 2: Compliance with other consumer related requirements

  • The Licence Holder shall: 

    • comply with the Secretary of State’s Design Standards for Accessible Stations under s.71B of the Railways Act 1993;
    • comply with the Rail Passengers’ Rights, and Obligations Regulations (PRO regulations);
    • adopt, publish, apply and comply with the National Rail Conditions of Travel, or any successor conditions approved or otherwise required under the applicable regulatory framework;
    • participate in, and secure passengers’ reasonable access to, a national passenger enquiry service;
    • become and thereafter remain a member of the relevant Alternative Dispute Resolution Scheme, and shall comply with its obligations, making such payments as required for the relevant ADR Scheme on the terms notified to the licence holder in writing by the Passengers’ Council;
    • Secure the provision of appropriate, accurate and timely information relating to planned and actual movements of trains on the Network (including when there is disruption) to enable train operators to meet their information obligations to passengers and prospective passengers (including obligations to enable railway passengers to plan and make their journeys with a reasonable degree of assurance).

Working with passenger watchdogs 

The purpose of this condition is to strengthen GBR’s engagement with, and accountability in relation to, passenger interests through engagement with the Passenger Watchdog and London TravelWatch. It would require GBR to respond when either of the watchdogs raise issues and to work with them constructively. If these watchdogs raise concerns, GBR would be required to engage with them and respond in a reasonable time.

This proposed licence condition builds on an existing condition in rail licences today. The intent is to ensure that GBR listens to passenger issues raised by the watchdogs and responds to them appropriately. It would also allow the watchdogs to hold GBR to account through ad-hoc meetings on specific passenger issues or periodic meetings on overall performance.

This will help ensure passenger needs and experiences are taken seriously when GBR makes decisions, and that GBR responds appropriately when problems are brought to its attention.

The issues raised and discussed between the watchdogs and GBR could for example include service quality, passenger concerns, or common issues identified through complaints, investigations or other evidence gathered by the watchdogs. GBR will remain responsible for determining how best to address issues and improve services, taking account of the evidence gathered by the watchdogs alongside operational and strategic considerations.

The proposed approach would also include an information-sharing requirement, so that the watchdogs have an escalatory enforcement route through ORR if licence holders are not sharing information they reasonably need to carry out their statutory functions. This builds on and supports the effective operation of the information-gathering powers and statutory functions both watchdogs have in the Railways Bill.

The proposed text for this condition uses the legal names for the Passenger Watchdog and London TravelWatch, which are the Passengers’ Council and London Transport Users’ Committee respectively. The proposed text is:

  • The licence holder shall engage effectively with the Passengers’ Council (PC) and London Transport Users’ Committee (LTUC) and shall respond in a timely manner to representations made by them. Where the licence holder considers that a request raises material practical, timing or resource implications, it shall notify PC and LTUC (as relevant) and ORR as soon as reasonably practicable, and engage constructively with PC, LTUC and ORR regarding the arrangements for compliance.

  • Appropriate representatives of the licence holder shall attend meetings with the PC and LTUC (separately or jointly), when reasonably requested to do so by the PC or LTUC, to discuss matters relevant to the passenger interest. In addition, the licence holder’s senior executives shall, on request, attend at least one meeting with the PC and LTUC in any calendar year to discuss matters relevant to the passenger interest.

  • The licence holder shall provide to PC and LTUC, on request, any information which PC and LTUC reasonably and proportionately require for the purpose of carrying out any of their functions [under the Railways Bill and the Greater London Authority Act 1999 respectively].

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed consumer experience condition provides an appropriate framework for protecting passengers’ interests while ensuring GBR remains responsible for leading improvements in the passenger experience? Explain your answer.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed condition on liaison with the passenger watchdogs sets the appropriate expectation for GBR to engage with the watchdogs and respond to issues they may raise? Explain your answer.

Ensuring good stewardship and governance

This section discusses 6 conditions to make sure GBR acts as a responsible long-term steward of the railway, with the right governance, safeguards and behaviours in place to manage its wider system role.

Long-term asset stewardship

This proposed condition is intended to reflect GBR’s unique role as the long-term steward of the railway. As the organisation responsible for planning, operating and maintaining the mainline network, GBR will need to take decisions that support the long-term condition, performance and value of railway assets.

The condition is intended to support a more reliable and resilient railway by encouraging GBR to take a long-term overall approach to maintaining and renewing its railway assets as a whole. In the long run, this should lead to better performing infrastructure and a reduced risk of prolonged disruption arising from deteriorating railway assets, benefitting passenger and freight customers.

For taxpayers, it should reduce the financial risk of long-term impacts not being appropriately taken into account in decision-making. It should also provide greater certainty for the rail supply chain by supporting a more stable and predictable programme of investment and renewal activity.

GBR will be required to manage its railway assets in accordance with recognised good practice for asset management. This will mean considering factors such as asset condition, performance, risk, efficiency and whole-life value for money, as well as ensuring the network remains resilient and adaptable to future climate conditions. The aim is to support a safe, reliable, efficient and sustainable railway while ensuring that decisions are taken with regard to the longer-term needs of passengers, freight users and taxpayers.

This includes GBR having regard to the long-term rail strategy and relevant circumstances, including funding and outcomes established through the funding review and as reflected or updated through annual business plan updates. This reflects the reality that decisions about asset management must be made alongside broader strategic priorities and funding choices.

GBR’s outcomes established through the funding review and business plan updates provide a key mechanism for demonstrating its adherence with its stewardship obligations. Where GBR’s delivery materially diverges from those outcomes, or is at risk of doing so, GBR would be required to explain to the Secretary of State and ORR how it has continued to act consistently with its obligations. GBR may also be required to provide such assurance where the delivery of its functions indicates a systemic risk to compliance with the condition.

The role of ORR should not be to second-guess GBR’s operational decisions. Instead, ORR’s role will focus on scrutinising the assurances provided by GBR that it has adopted and followed an approach to asset stewardship that is consistent with the licence condition and with recognised good practice.

The proposed text for this condition is:  

  • The licence holder shall secure long-term stewardship of its Railway Assets as a whole in accordance with good practice, having regard to the Long-Term Rail Strategy and relevant circumstances, including the funding and outcomes established through the Funding Review and as may be reflected or updated through annual Business Plan updates, to deliver the safe, reliable, efficient and sustainable operation of the railway.
  • The licence holder shall demonstrate how the outcomes established through the funding review, and as reflected or updated through annual Business Plan updates, are consistent with the long-term asset stewardship requirements in paragraph 1.
  • The licence holder shall demonstrate to the Secretary of State and ORR how it has acted consistently with the long-term asset stewardship requirements in paragraph 1 where:
    • those outcomes materially diverge from the outcomes determined through the Funding Review or updated in the annual Business Plan
    • those outcomes are at risk of materially diverging from those determined or updated outcomes; or
    • the licence holder’s delivery of its functions otherwise indicates a systemic risk to compliance with paragraph 1
  • The licence holder shall provide that demonstration whether on its own initiative or at the reasonable request of the Secretary of State or ORR.

Supporting seamless passenger travel

This proposed condition is intended to ensure that GBR provides and participates in industry systems and processes that are essential to the effective operation of the railway as a single, integrated network. These are currently provided by the Rail Delivery Group and will in the future be delivered by GBR. They support cross-network benefits for passengers, by facilitating seamless travel across services provided by different operators.

As well as being in the interests of passengers, this approach will have the effect of safeguarding continuity of services to non-GBR operators required to participate in such arrangements themselves.

It is intended that detail relating to how GBR will administer cross-industry services, including the terms and conditions of their provision and what non-GBR operators can expect, will be set out in separate contractual arrangements. The licence condition is focused on providing strategic assurance that cross-network benefits for passengers will be preserved.

The condition is separate from and will not duplicate or override the requirements GBR must meet as a result of the planned Retail code of practice, which will be owned and managed by ORR. The Retail code of practice is to be given its force via a standalone licence condition and is described later in this section.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • The licence holder must establish, maintain and administer the cross-industry arrangements reasonably necessary to enable passengers to make seamless journeys involving more than 1 operator. This must include arrangements that relate to through ticketing and the accurate and prompt allocation and settlement of related passenger revenue.

  • The licence holder must participate in each such arrangement that applies to it as an operator and must make each arrangement available to other operators that reasonably require access, on terms that do not frustrate paragraph 1 or make access unreasonably difficult.

  • The licence holder must secure the continuity, resilience and effective functioning of the arrangements so far as necessary to secure the outcomes in paragraph 1 and the access required by paragraph 2. Subject to those requirements, the licence holder may determine the means by which an arrangement or function is provided, including by modifying, replacing, outsourcing or transferring it, but remains responsible for compliance with this Condition where a function is performed on its behalf. Nothing in this Condition permits the licence holder to act inconsistently with Condition 4 [Consumer Experience], Condition 9 (Retail Code of Practice), or any other applicable passenger-protection requirement.

Approach to land disposal

The proposed condition is intended to enable GBR to make land disposal decisions efficiently, whilst ensuring appropriate safeguards are in place for land that may still be required for current or future railway purposes.

As the organisation responsible for planning and managing the railway as an integrated system, GBR will be expected to take strategic decisions about the future use of the railway estate, balancing long-term railway requirements alongside wider public benefits such as regeneration, development, housing and value for money.

Under the current arrangements in Network Rail’s network licence, Network Rail must obtain consent from ORR before disposing of land. This is achieved through a combination of general consent, which covers most routine disposals, and specific consent. In practice, the majority of disposals proceed under ORR’s general consent.

The proposed GBR licence condition will adopt a different approach. GBR will be required to develop, publish and comply with a land disposal policy. GBR will be required to consult with key stakeholders including, but not limited to, the Secretary of State and ORR when developing or materially revising its land disposal policy.

As part of their land disposal policy consultation, GBR would be expected to engage with the devolved governments, MSAs, and other relevant authorities where appropriate. The land disposal policy should set out the principles, criteria and procedures that GBR will follow when considering disposal decisions. This reflects GBR’s role as the long-term steward of the railway estate and places primary responsibility for disposal decisions with GBR.

The proposed approach is intended to enable GBR to take a more strategic approach to balancing the needs of the railway and the wider public interest, while retaining appropriate safeguards.

GBR must comply with its land disposal policy, which should include proportionate, risk-based arrangements for consulting affected stakeholders before decisions are made, as well as requirements for publishing relevant decisions and the reasons for them, including how stakeholder views have been taken into account. This is intended to promote transparency, accountability and confidence in GBR’s decision-making.

A feature of the proposed condition is that stakeholders would be able to refer a proposed disposal decision to ORR where they consider that GBR has not acted in accordance with its land disposal policy.

In such cases, ORR’s role would be to determine whether GBR has complied with the policy and the requirements of the licence condition, rather than to make its own assessment of the merits of the disposal or substitute its judgement for that of GBR. Where a decision is referred, the disposal would not proceed until ORR’s review has concluded, and GBR would be required to comply with ORR’s findings.

We expect GBR’s land disposal policy to be in place when the GBR licence is issued, alongside the arrangements for the referral process that is managed by ORR.

The condition would apply to disposal decisions made by GBR, including transfers of land to Platform4, whose purpose is to lead, invest in and enable regeneration on brownfield railway land, bringing together property, infrastructure and operational rail expertise in one place. However, it would not apply to subsequent disposal or development decisions taken by Platform4 (as a GBR subsidiary that does not carry out railway functions) once land has been transferred in accordance with the land disposal policy.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • The licence holder shall develop, publish and comply with a Land Disposal Policy setting out the principles, criteria and procedures it will apply when considering the Disposal of Land.

  • The licence holder shall consult relevant stakeholders, including the Secretary of State and ORR, when developing, or making material changes to, the policy.

  • The Land Disposal Policy shall provide for proportionate and risk-based consultation with affected stakeholders on proposed Disposals.

  • The licence holder shall publish its decisions and the reasons for them, where required by the Land Disposal Policy, including how consultation responses have been considered.

  • Where a stakeholder is not satisfied that a Disposal decision published by the licence holder has been made in accordance with the Land Disposal Policy, the stakeholder may refer the decision to ORR for review under a process established by ORR. Under this process:

    • ORR shall determine whether the licence holder has acted in accordance with the Land Disposal Policy.

    • The licence holder shall not implement the Disposal decision until ORR’s review has concluded and shall comply with the findings presented from ORR’s review.

  • The obligations of this condition do not apply to Disposal decisions by GBR Subsidiaries if they have already acquired Land from GBR under the Land Disposal Policy.

Keeping rail retail fair

This proposed condition would require GBR to comply with a retail code of practice issued and maintained by ORR and approved by the Secretary of State. As GBR will simultaneously be a retailer and responsible for managing the agreements, systems and schemes that other retailers rely on, the code of practice will be in place to ensure GBR delivers a fair and open market for all retailers in the interests of passengers and taxpayers.

The Railways Bill provides for the establishment of a Retail code of practice. The detailed content of the code is currently being consulted on by ORR. The proposed licence condition therefore focuses on securing GBR’s compliance with the code, rather than prescribing the contents of the code itself.

Having this condition means there is a clear enforcement route if ORR considers that GBR has not complied with the requirements of the code. The proposed approach is intended to support confidence amongst retailers and other market participants that GBR will exercise its market-wide retail-related responsibilities fairly, transparently and consistently.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • The licence holder shall comply with a Retail Code of Practice issued and amended from time to time by ORR and approved by the Secretary of State, pursuant to Section 9A of the Railways Act 1993.

Engagement

This proposed condition is intended to ensure that GBR engages effectively with stakeholders as part of carrying out its licensed activities, alongside working with devolved governments, local leaders and other essential delivery partners to support place-based growth.

As the directing mind for the railway, GBR will make decisions that affect a wide range of interests across the sector. Effective engagement and partnership working can help improve the quality of decision-making, build confidence in GBR’s actions and ensure stakeholders are appropriately engaged about matters that may materially affect them.

The condition establishes a principles-based framework for engagement. Rather than prescribing detailed requirements, it sets clear expectations that GBR’s engagement should be proportionate, inclusive and transparent, while allowing GBR flexibility to design and deliver its approach in a way that reflects the nature of the issues being considered and the stakeholders affected. The condition is also designed to support GBR to make effective and well-informed decisions.

Under the condition, GBR will be required to develop, publish and comply with a stakeholder engagement policy, and to assure itself that its engagement is effective and responsive to the needs of relevant stakeholder groups.

The policy will provide transparency about the principles and approach GBR intends to follow, while the self-assurance requirement will help ensure that GBR regularly reviews whether its engagement arrangements are working in practice and remain appropriate. GBR is expected to have its stakeholder engagement policy in place when it becomes operational.

This condition will be in addition to the requirements on GBR in the Railways Bill to consult with key bodies including devolved governments, MSAs, and the Passenger Watchdog. This will ensure that key bodies will be involved and informed about decisions that affect them. The condition is deliberately broad so that it does not inadvertently exclude any stakeholder groups.

However, consistent with the government’s commitment that accessibility considerations should be embedded within GBR’s decision-making, the condition expressly recognises the importance of engagement with groups consisting of disabled people as part of GBR’s wider stakeholder engagement approach.

The condition focuses on outcomes and behaviours, with ORR’s role centring on providing assurance that GBR is complying with the engagement policy GBR has published, rather than directing how engagement should be conducted. However, if there are concerns that GBR’s delivery is materially diverging from its stakeholder engagement policy, ORR will be able to take action.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • The licence holder shall engage with Stakeholders, devolved governments and local leaders in a manner that is proportionate, inclusive and transparent, to support effective and well-informed decision-making and to ensure Stakeholders are appropriately engaged about matters that may materially affect them.

  • To support this obligation, the licence holder shall develop, publish and comply with a policy setting out the principles and approach it will follow in engaging Stakeholders, including groups consisting of disabled people as part of its overall Stakeholder engagement approach.

  • The licence holder shall assure itself that its Stakeholder engagement is effective and take into consideration relevant Stakeholder groups and their respective needs.

Facilitating third-party investment

The purpose of this proposed condition is to give third parties greater confidence to invest in the railways, where investment would deliver positive outcomes for passengers, freight users, communities and taxpayers.

The intention is that the condition covers third-party investment proposals relating to the railway system where GBR has a role in facilitating, considering or enabling the investment. This is intended to build on the range of investment currently facilitated through the rail network investment framework (RNIF), including investment by freight operators, developers, the devolved governments, local authorities and other third parties.

By way of example, third-party investments in infrastructure can help deliver improvements such as new or redeveloped stations, car parks, depots, line-speed and capacity improvements, or other infrastructure that supports growth, connectivity and resilience. This could include investment brought forward through partnerships with MSAs, supporting greater local decision-making.

GBR is being set up to be commercially minded and to support this type of investment where it adds clear value, while protecting public finances and making sure that any long-term costs or risks are properly managed.

The proposed condition would require GBR to have suitable arrangements in place to facilitate appropriate third-party investment in the railways, for example clear guidance on the investment process, or template contracts for different kinds of investment projects. GBR would be responsible for developing, publishing and maintaining those arrangements, reflecting its role as the directing mind for the railway and its ability to consider the whole system.

The proposed condition is intended to give ORR a targeted assurance role. ORR would monitor whether GBR’s general arrangements around third-party investment projects are fit for purpose and whether GBR is complying with them and could take action if GBR did not meet the requirements of the condition. ORR would not, however, prevent GBR from making commercial decisions in line with its statutory duties and objectives.

The main benefit of this condition is to ensure potential investors have a clear and consistent route to bringing forward investment proposals, with independent assurance that GBR’s investment arrangements are fair and fit for purpose. It would also ensure those arrangements are in line with the Secretary of State’s railway objectives and ensuring value for passengers, freight users and the wider economy.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • The licence holder shall develop, maintain and comply with appropriate arrangements to facilitate and support third-party investment in the railway system.

  • The licence holder shall publish such information as is reasonably necessary to explain its approach to third-party investment.

  • The licence holder shall ensure its arrangements are transparent, proportionate and accessible to persons who may be interested in investing in the railway system.

  • In exercising its functions under this condition, the licence holder shall have regard to the Secretary of State’s objectives for the railway, including whole-system outcomes and the delivery of value for passengers, freight users, taxpayers and the wider economy.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed long-term asset stewardship condition provides an appropriate framework to enable effective stewardship of GBR’s railway assets? Explain your answer.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed condition on supporting seamless passenger travel appropriately defines the scope of ORR regulation through the licence in relation to GBR’s responsibilities for providing services that facilitate the provision and use of railway services by operators? Explain your answer.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed approach to GBR’s land disposal provides an appropriate framework for GBR’s decision making? Explain your answer.

Question:

In your view, does the proposed stakeholder engagement condition provide an appropriate framework for GBR’s engagement with its stakeholders? Explain your answer.

Question:

In your view, does the proposed third-party investment condition provide an appropriate level of transparency, assurance and flexibility to support investment in the railway? Explain your answer.

Meeting shared industry requirements

This section discusses 6 conditions focusing on keeping the railway joined up, safe and resilient, so that the people who use it can rely on a railway that works as a unified system.

Safety and rail technical standards

GBR will have responsibility for ensuring everyone feels safe when travelling on the railways while preserving our world-leading culture of rail safety. The proposed safety and rail technical standards condition would require GBR to collaborate with the wider rail sector on the development and application of common technical standards. It is intended to support effective coordination between GBR and other licence holders, and to promote consistency and cohesion across the railway.

In practice, this would require GBR to participate in the Rail Safety and Standards Board’s (RSSB) standards development, and to apply relevant cross-industry standards to its licensed activities. GBR will also be subject to the robust legal framework that currently underpins railway safety, including the Railways and Other Guided Transport Systems (Safety) Regulations 2006 and the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974.

For the initial GBR licence, the proposed approach is to mirror the existing safety and rail technical standards condition in the current Network Rail network licence and train operating company operator licences. This would provide continuity for the transition to GBR and ensure that GBR remains subject to established requirements.

There will be a separate consultation in due course on the future arrangements for technical standards and the role of RSSB. Pending decisions following this consultation, there may be reform of the rail technical standards framework in the coming years, and this licence condition may need to be amended to align with future arrangements for how technical standards are developed, set and applied on Britain’s railway.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • Except where ORR and the Secretary of State consent otherwise, the licence holder shall:

    • be a member of RSSB and a party to the Constitution Agreement;
    • comply with its obligations under the Constitution Agreement and the articles of association of RSSB: and
    • exercise its rights under the Constitution Agreement and the articles of association of RSSB so as to ensure that RSSB acts in accordance with the Constitution Agreement.
  • The licence holder shall comply with:

    • The Railway Group Standards Code;
    • such Railway Group Standards as are applicable to its Licensed Activities;
    • subject to paragraph 3 of this condition, such Rail Industry Standards as applicable to its Licensed Activities.
  • The licence holder is not required to comply with an applicable Rail Industry Standard (or part thereof) where:

    • it has, following consultation with such persons as it considers are likely to be affected, identified an equally effective measure which will achieve the purpose of the standard; and
    • it has adopted and is complying with that measure.

Insurance and liability arrangements

Current insurance arrangements across the rail sector have evolved over time and reflect a combination of statutory, regulatory and contractual requirements. These arrangements are complex, particularly given the relationships between infrastructure managers, train operators, rolling stock companies (ROSCOs) and the wider rail supply chain. The licence regime has previously focused on ensuring third party liabilities are sufficiently covered across the railway network.

The establishment of GBR provides an opportunity to consider how best to deliver value for money while continuing to ensure that liabilities are met and third parties are appropriately protected. The government’s view is that the licence should not pre-empt decisions on GBR’s future approach to insurance and risk management.

The government is therefore consulting on the basis that the draft GBR licence creates an obligation for GBR to have suitable arrangements in place to provide reassurance to those working and travelling on the railway.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • The licence holder shall establish, maintain and keep under review third-party liability insurance or equivalent financial arrangements at a level that, having regard to the nature, scale and risks of its Licensed Activities and the liabilities that may reasonably be expected to arise from them, is adequate to enable it to meet those liabilities. The licence holder shall assess and document the basis on which it considers that level to be adequate.

Handling claims across the sector

When incidents occur on the railway network, the sector needs to have clear and well-established arrangements for determining responsibility and handling claims. This provides certainty for all industry participants, helping claims to be managed efficiently and consistently and reducing the scope for unnecessary disputes between organisations.

This condition would require GBR to participate in claims and liability-sharing arrangements. In practice, this means GBR would be required to be a member of the Claims Allocation and Handling Agreement (CAHA), which sets out how rail operators manage and allocate financial responsibility for certain claims across the industry.

The CAHA relies on participation from relevant licence holders to operate effectively. Including this requirement in the GBR licence will therefore support a coherent and joined-up railway following the creation of GBR and help ensure that established industry processes continue to operate effectively across the network.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • The licence holder shall, except in so far as ORR may otherwise consent, at all times be a party to and comply with such agreements or arrangements (as amended from time to time) relating to:

    • the handling of claims against operators of railway assets; and

    • the allocation of liabilities among operators of railway assets

as may have been approved by ORR.

  • Except with the consent of ORR, the licence holder shall not, in relation to any of the agreements or arrangements described in paragraph 1 (the relevant Claims Handling Arrangements), enter into any agreement or arrangement with any other party to the relevant Claims Handling Arrangements:

    • under which the licence holder agrees not to exercise any rights which it may have under any of the relevant Claims Handling Arrangements; or

    • varying the relevant Claims Handling Arrangements

other than as provided for under the terms of the relevant Claims Handling Arrangements.

Supporting a sustainable railway

An effective approach to environmental management should help support a safer and more reliable railway for passengers and freight customers, reduce disruption caused by environmental risks, and improve long-term value for taxpayers through more effective management of climate-related impacts.

GBR will already be required to exercise its functions in the public interest under its duties at Clause 18 of the Railways Bill, which includes consideration of the effect the provision of railway services has on the environment. It will also be under an obligation to comply with relevant environment legislation (both at national and devolved level) which includes, for example, contributing to targets set under the Environment Act 2021, the Climate Change Act 2008 and the Air Quality Standards Regulations 2010.

More broadly, GBR will need to have regard to the Secretary of State’s Long Term Rail Strategy where environmental sustainability has already been identified as a strategic objective.

This proposed licence condition is intended to complement that robust legislative framework and ensure that there is a clear and consistent approach to managing the environmental impacts of GBR’s licensed activities. It also reflects the increasingly important role that climate adaptation and resilience will play in operating and maintaining the railway.

The condition would require GBR to develop, publish, maintain and comply with an environmental policy, or policies, covering its licensed activities. The policy would need to set out practical objectives and arrangements for protecting the environment and improving the resilience and safety of the railway in the face of environmental risks, including the impacts of climate change and extreme weather. We expect GBR’s environment policy (or policies) to be in place when the GBR licence is issued.

GBR would be required to take account of relevant guidance issued by the Secretary of State and ORR when developing its policy, such as any environmental objectives included in the Long-Term Rail Strategy. It would also be required to keep the policy under review, publish significant updates and take reasonable steps to deliver the commitments and objectives it contains, while having regard to relevant funding determined through the funding process.

The condition builds on existing licence requirements while recognising the growing importance of climate adaptation and resilience. It would provide a clear and enforceable mechanism within the licensing framework to support environmental outcomes and help ensure a consistent approach across GBR and other rail licence holders.

ORR’s role would be to provide assurance that GBR complies with the environmental policy in accordance with the condition, rather than to direct individual operational decisions.

The proposed text for the environmental matters condition is:

  • The licence holder shall develop and comply with an Environmental Policy or Policies (the ‘Environmental Policy’) designed to protect the environment from the effects of Licensed Activities and to provide for the adaptation and resilience of the railway to environmental impacts, including those resulting from climate change.

  • The licence holder shall establish operational objectives and management arrangements to give effect to the delivery of its Environmental Policy.

  • The licence holder shall publish, review and revise the Environmental Policy as appropriate, and shall keep ORR and the Secretary of State appropriately informed of any material changes.

  • In developing its Environmental Policy, the licence holder shall have due regard to any relevant guidance issued by ORR and by the Secretary of State, including the Long-Term Rail Strategy.

  • The licence holder shall act with regard to the Environmental Policy when carrying out its Licensed Activities, and shall use reasonable endeavours to operate its management arrangements effectively.

  • Nothing contained in this condition shall require the undertaking of any action that entails excessive cost, taking into account all relevant circumstances including the nature and scale of operations of the type carried out by the licence holder, and having regard to relevant funding determined through the funding process.

Providing access in an emergency

The proposed emergency access condition would require GBR to allow access to any station or light maintenance depot it operates when this is needed to help respond to an emergency affecting the railway. This will help ensure relevant responders can act quickly and effectively during incidents, supporting customer safety and minimising disruption.

This condition forms part of a wider framework for responding to railway emergencies. Separate legislative powers already exist in relation to access to private property in certain emergency situations. The purpose of this condition is different. It applies to operators of stations and light maintenance depots and helps ensure that access to these facilities can be granted where this is necessary or expedient to alleviate the effects of an emergency affecting the railway.

The obligation would apply only where GBR is legally able to grant access, ensuring that the requirement supports effective emergency response while remaining within the limits of GBR’s legal rights and responsibilities. The proposed condition mirrors existing emergency access conditions in station and light maintenance depot licences.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • During any emergency affecting the railway, the licence holder shall, to the extent that it is legally entitled to do so, grant to any person requesting it such permission to use any station or light maintenance depot of which the licence holder is the operator pursuant to this licence as is necessary or expedient to alleviate the effects of the emergency.

Stations and light maintenance depots

Having a clear list of the stations and light maintenance depots operated by GBR (and covered by this licence) will provide clarity to everyone – including the public – about which of these assets GBR will be licensed to operate. The Railways Bill requires that the licence specifies or describes the railway assets that the licence holder is authorised to operate.

The proposed licence condition would provide for a schedule listing the stations and light maintenance depots that GBR is authorised to operate. If GBR stops operating a listed site, or intends to operate a new one, it would need to notify the relevant bodies.

Including the list in a schedule should provide a clear and practical way to keep the licence accurate as GBR’s operational responsibilities change. Rather than needing a formal licence amendment each time a station or depot is added or removed, the list can be updated through a notification process. This should make the licence easier to maintain while still ensuring there is a clear record of what GBR operates.

The condition would also ensure that ORR, the Secretary of State and the Passengers’ Council are informed of relevant changes. This reflects their different roles in the licensing framework: ORR as regulator, the Secretary of State as licence grantor and shareholder, and the Passengers’ Council in relation to consumer standards. The aim is to maintain transparency and avoid uncertainty about which stations and depots fall within GBR’s licence obligations.

The proposed text for this condition is:

  • If the licence holder ceases to be the operator of any stations or depots listed in Schedule [2/3], it shall within one month  notify ORR, the Secretary of State and the Passengers’ Council of such cessation.

  • If the licence holder intends to operate an additional station or light maintenance depot, it must notify ORR in advance. The station or depot shall be added to the Schedule on a date agreed with ORR or, if no date is agreed, the licence holder may add it to the Schedule after 1 month beginning with the day on which the licence holder gives notice to ORR.

Question:

In your view, does the proposed condition on insurance provide adequate reassurance to other parties operating on GBR’s network about how third-party liabilities will be covered by GBR? Explain your answer.

Question:

In your view, does the proposed environmental matters condition provide an appropriate framework for GBR to identify and respond to environmental priorities and exercise its wider stewardship role across the railway? Explain your answer.

Proposed text for the GBR licence   

The illustrative text for the full GBR licence is set out below.

Part I - Scope

1) The Secretary of State, in exercise of the powers conferred by section 7B of the Railways Act 1993 (as amended) (“the Act”), hereby grants to Great British Railways (“the licence holder”) an integrated licence authorising the licence holder to be the operator of:

  • (a) a Network;
  • (b) a train being used on a Network for any purpose comprised in the operation of that Network;
  • (c) the stations listed in Schedule [2/3] and any such other station as the licence holder specifies in a notice given to the Office of Rail and Road;
  • (d) light maintenance depots listed in Schedule [2/3] and any train being used on a Network for a purpose preparatory or incidental to, or consequential on, the provision of light maintenance services at any light maintenance depot listed in Schedule [2/3];
  • (e) trains being used on a Network for the purpose of carrying passengers by railway;
  • (f) a train being used on a Network for a purpose preparatory or incidental to, or consequential on, using a train as mentioned in (b) and (e) above;
  • (g) trains being used on a Network for the purpose of assisting other operators of railway assets; 

subject to the conditions set out in [Part III] hereof (‘the conditions’).     

2) This licence shall come into force on [date tbc] and shall continue in force unless and until revoked in accordance with the provisions of the Revocation Schedule hereto or by not less than 10 years’ notice given to the licence holder by the Secretary of State, such notice not to be given earlier than 25 years after the date on which this licence comes into force.

Part II - interpretation

This section explains terms used in the GBR consultation and what they mean.

Adaptation and resilience of the railway to environmental impacts

The ability of railway assets, networks and systems to anticipate, absorb, adapt to and recover from environmental impacts, including adverse or extreme weather conditions.

Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) scheme

The alternative dispute resolution scheme [sponsored by the Passengers’ Council] and approved by the designated competent authority, currently the Rail Ombudsman. The designated competent authority is the relevant designated competent authority under The Alternative Dispute Resolution for Consumer Disputes (Competent Authorities and Information) Regulations 2015.

Railway Assets

Means a Railway Asset as defined by section 6 of the Railways Act 1993.

Business Plan

Means the Business Plan approved by the Secretary of State pursuant to [paragraph 4 of Schedule 2 to the Railways Bill].

Claims Handling arrangements

Means the approved arrangements for allocating and handling claims in the railway industry from time to time, currently set out in the Claims Allocation and Handling Agreement (CAHA).

Disposal

Includes any sale, assignment, gift, lease, licence, the grant of any right of possession, loan, security, mortgage, charge or the grant of any other encumbrance or knowingly permitting any encumbrance to subsist (other than an encumbrance subsisting on the date on which the land was acquired by the licence holder or on the date on which this condition came into force), or any other disposition to a third party.

Environmental Policy

A written policy designed to protect the environment from the effects of Licensed Activities and to provide for the adaptation and resilience of the railway to environmental impacts.

Land

Means any land or interest in land which is held for the purposes of, or in connection with, the provision, operation, maintenance or development of railway services or railway assets, whether or not such land is in current operational use.

Licensed Activities

Means activities authorised to be carried out by the licence holder in its capacity as an operator of railway assets under this licence.

London Transport Users’ Committee

Means the London Transport Users’ Committee and any successor to LTUC which performs the same functions.

Long-term Asset Stewardship

Relates to the planning, management and delivery of maintenance and renewals, informed by asset condition, performance and risk, with the objective of optimising whole-life value within the context of available funding.

Long-term Rail Strategy

The strategy published by the Secretary of State pursuant to [Section 15 of the Railways Bill].

Network

‘Network’ means:

  • any railway line, or combination of 2 or more railway lines
  • any installations associated with any of the track comprised in that line or those lines,

together constituting a system of track and other installations which is used for and in connection with the support, guidance and operation of trains.

ORR

The Office of Rail and Road.

Passengers’ Council

Means the Passengers’ Council and any successor or delegated body which performs the function of the PC.

Passengers’ Council Published Guidance

Any guidance on accessible travel policies inherited and published by the Passengers’ Council, as amended from time to time.

Passengers’ Council Standards

Any standards set and varied from time to time by the Passengers’ Council and consented to by ORR and the Secretary of State pursuant to [Section 46 of the Railways Bill].

PRO Regulation

Means Regulation (EC) No. 1371/2007 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 October 2007 on rail passengers’ rights and obligations.

Rail industry standards

Has the meaning set out in the standards manual established by RSSB.

Railway Group Standards

Means the Railway Group standards established by RSSB.

Railway Group Standards Code

Means the Railway Group standards code established by RSSB.

Relevant Subsidiaries

Means any Subsidiary of the licence holder, but only to the extent that its activities relate to, support, facilitate or are ancillary to the licence holder’s activities in respect of railway functions and are relevant to the discharge of the licence holder’s obligations under this licence.

Reporter

Means an individual appointed for the purposes of licence condition 3 in accordance with any criteria and procedure set out in a relevant reporting framework.

Retail code of practice

Means the code issued under section 9A of the Railways Act 1993 that will set out clear expectations for how GBR will interact with all market participants and ensure separation of decision-making where relevant. The code will be owned and managed by ORR.

RSSB

Means Rail Safety and Standards Board.

Stakeholder

Means any person:

  • who has, or in the future is likely to have, a significant relationship with the licence holder
  • who may be impacted by the activities of the licence holder
  • who has expressed in writing to the licence holder a serious and credible interest in providing, or in providing finance in connection with:
    • services relating to railways
    • a railway facility or a Network, including one which is proposed to be constructed or is in the course of construction

Subsidiary or subsidiaries

Has the meaning given by section 1159 of the Companies Act 2006.

A company is a subsidiary of another company, its holding company, if that other company:

  • holds a majority of the voting rights in it
  • is a member of it and has the right to appoint or remove a majority of its board of directors
  • is a member of it and controls alone, pursuant to an agreement with other members, a majority of the voting rights in it

A company is also a subsidiary if it is a subsidiary of a company that is itself a subsidiary of that other company.

Conditions 

1) General Provision

1.1 GBR must establish, maintain and keep up to date a list of Subsidiaries authorised, by virtue of this licence, to operate railway assets under section 7B of the Act, and must make that list available to ORR.

1.2 Where any condition of this licence requires the licence holder to comply with an obligation, the licence holder must secure that each Relevant Subsidiary, as appropriate:

  • (a) complies with that obligation as if the Relevant Subsidiary were the licence holder; or

  • (b) provides such assistance as is necessary and takes any other action to enable the licence holder to comply with that obligation.

Part A: Information Requirements

2) Information for ORR

2.1. The licence holder shall provide to ORR, on request, any information which ORR reasonably and proportionately requires for the purpose of carrying out any of ORR’s functions under [the Railways Bill] and Part 1 of the Railways Act 1993.

2.2. Information required to be provided under this condition shall be provided in such form and manner and at such times as reasonably and proportionately requested by ORR. In complying with such requests, the licence holder shall have regard to any reporting framework agreed between the licence holder and ORR for the purposes of this condition. Where the licence holder considers that a request raises material practical, timing or resource implications, it shall notify ORR as soon as reasonably practicable and engage constructively with ORR regarding the arrangements for compliance.

2.3. The licence holder shall undertake appropriate assurance to ensure that any information provided under this condition is sufficiently accurate and complete for the purpose required so far as is reasonably practicable.

3) Independent Reporters

3.1. The licence holder shall, in accordance with a jointly agreed framework, appoint an independent Reporter to review, and report on, any matter as ORR may reasonably require for the purpose of carrying out ORR’s functions under Part I of the Railways Act 1993 and the Railways Bill.

3.2. The licence holder shall comply with the jointly agreed framework, as maintained and kept under review by GBR and ORR, which establishes the principles and working arrangements, including value for money and proportionality, governing the appointment and use of independent Reporters.

Part B: Passenger Experience

4) Consumer Experience

Part 1: Compliance with Passengers’ Council standards or guidance

4.1. The licence holder shall:

  • (a) comply with any Passengers’ Council Standards;

  • (b) have regard to any Passengers’ Council Published Guidance on accessible travel policies.

4.2. The Passengers’ Council Standards or Published Guidance may cover, but are not limited to:

  • (a) Delay compensation;
  • (b) Complaints handling;
  • (c) Information for passengers; and
  • (d) Accessible travel.

4.3. In relation to Published Guidance on accessible travel, the licence holder shall:

  • a) Develop, publish and comply with policy and procedures created in pursuance to the Passengers’ Council Published Guidance, unless this has been superseded by a new Passengers’ Council Standard on accessibility;
  • b) Submit any such policy and procedures and material changes to it for approval by the Passengers’ Council, and as requested by the Passengers’ Council.

Part 2: Compliance with other consumer related requirements

4.4. The Licence Holder shall:

  • a) comply with the Secretary of State’s Design Standards for Accessible Stations under s.71B of the Railways Act 1993;
  • b) comply with the Rail Passengers’ Rights, and Obligations Regulations (PRO regulations);
  • c) adopt, publish, apply and comply with the National Rail Conditions of Travel, or any successor conditions approved or otherwise required under the applicable regulatory framework;
  • d) participate in, and secure passengers’ reasonable access to, a national passenger enquiry service;
  • (e)become and thereafter remain a member of the relevant Alternative Dispute Resolution Scheme, and shall comply with its obligations, making such payments as required for the relevant ADR Scheme on the terms notified to the licence holder in writing by the Passengers’ Council;
  • (f) Secure the provision of appropriate, accurate and timely information relating to planned and actual movements of trains on the Network (including when there is disruption) to enable train operators to meet their information obligations to passengers and prospective passengers (including obligations to enable railway passengers to plan and make their journeys with a reasonable degree of assurance).

5) Liaison with Passengers’ Council and London Transport Users’ Committee

5.1. The licence holder shall engage effectively with the Passengers’ Council (PC) and London Transport Users’ Committee (LTUC) and shall respond in a timely manner to representations made by them. Where the licence holder considers that a request raises material practical, timing or resource implications, it shall notify PC and LTUC (where relevant) and ORR as soon as reasonably practicable, and engage constructively with PC, LTUC and ORR regarding the arrangements for compliance.

5.2. Appropriate representatives of the licence holder shall attend meetings with the PC and LTUC (separately or jointly), when reasonably requested to do so by the PC or LTUC, to discuss matters relevant to the passenger interest. In addition, the licence holder’s senior executives shall, on request, attend at least 1 meeting with the PC and LTUC in any calendar year to discuss matters relevant to the passenger interest.

5.3. The licence holder shall provide to PC and LTUC, on request, any information which PC and LTUC reasonably and proportionately require for the purpose of carrying out any of their functions [under the Railways Bill and the Greater London Authority Act 1999 respectively].

Part C: Stewardship and Governance

6) Long-term Asset Stewardship

6.1. The licence holder shall secure long-term stewardship of its Railway Assets as a whole in accordance with good practice, having regard to the Long-Term Rail Strategy and relevant circumstances, including the funding and outcomes established through the Funding Review and as may be reflected or updated through annual Business Plan updates, to deliver the safe, reliable, efficient and sustainable operation of the railway.

6.2. The licence holder shall demonstrate how the outcomes established through the funding review, and as reflected or updated through annual Business Plan updates, are consistent with the long-term asset stewardship requirements in paragraph 6.1.

6.3. The licence holder shall demonstrate to the Secretary of State and ORR how it has acted consistently with the long-term asset stewardship requirements in paragraph 6.1 where:

  • (a) those outcomes materially diverge from the outcomes determined through the Funding Review or updated in the annual Business Plan;
  • (b) those outcomes are at risk of materially diverging from those determined or updated outcomes; or
  • (c) the licence holder’s delivery of its functions otherwise indicates a systemic risk to compliance with paragraph 6.1

6.4. The licence holder shall provide that demonstration whether on its own initiative or at the reasonable request of the Secretary of State or ORR.

7) Administration of Industry Systems and Processes

7.1. The licence holder must establish, maintain and administer the cross-industry arrangements reasonably necessary to enable passengers to make seamless journeys involving more than one operator. This must include arrangements that relate to through ticketing and the accurate and prompt allocation and settlement of related passenger revenue.

7.2. The licence holder must participate in each such arrangement that applies to it as an operator and must make each arrangement available to other operators that reasonably require access, on terms that do not frustrate paragraph 7.1 or make access unreasonably difficult.

7.3. The licence holder must secure the continuity, resilience and effective functioning of the arrangements so far as necessary to secure the outcomes in paragraph 7.1 and the access required by paragraph 7.2. Subject to those requirements, the licence holder may determine the means by which an arrangement or function is provided, including by modifying, replacing, outsourcing or transferring it, but remains responsible for compliance with this Condition where a function is performed on its behalf. Nothing in this Condition permits the licence holder to act inconsistently with Condition 4 (Consumer Experience), Condition 9 (Retail Code of Practice), or any other applicable passenger-protection requirement.

8) Land Disposal

8.1. The licence holder shall develop, publish and comply with a Land Disposal Policy setting out the principles, criteria and procedures it will apply when considering the Disposal of Land.

8.2. The licence holder shall consult relevant Stakeholders, including the Secretary of State and ORR, when developing, or making material changes to, the policy.

8.3. The Land Disposal Policy shall provide for proportionate and risk-based consultation with affected Stakeholders on proposed Disposals.

8.4. The licence holder shall publish its decisions and the reasons for them, where required by the Land Disposal Policy, including how consultation responses have been considered.

8.5. Where a Stakeholder is not satisfied that a Disposal decision published by the licence holder has been made in accordance with the Land Disposal Policy, the Stakeholder may refer the decision to ORR for review under a process established by ORR. Under this process:

  • (a) ORR shall determine whether the licence holder has acted in accordance with the Land Disposal Policy.
  • (b) The licence holder shall not implement the Disposal decision until ORR’s review has concluded and shall comply with the findings presented from ORR’s review.

8.6. The obligations of this condition do not apply to Disposal decisions by GBR Subsidiaries if they have already acquired Land from GBR under the Land Disposal Policy.

9) Retail Code of Practice

9.1. The licence holder shall comply with a Retail Code of Practice issued and amended from time to time by ORR and approved by the Secretary of State, pursuant to Section 9A of the Railways Act 1993.

10) Stakeholder Engagement

10.1. The licence holder shall engage with Stakeholders, devolved governments and local leaders in a manner that is proportionate, inclusive and transparent, to support effective and well-informed decision-making and to ensure Stakeholders are appropriately engaged about matters that may materially affect them.

10.2. To support this obligation, the licence holder shall develop, publish and comply with a policy setting out the principles and approach it will follow in engaging Stakeholders, including groups consisting of disabled people as part of its overall Stakeholder engagement approach.

10.3. The licence holder shall assure itself that its Stakeholder engagement is effective and take into consideration relevant Stakeholder groups and their respective needs.

11) Facilitating Third-party Investment

11.1. The licence holder shall develop, maintain and comply with appropriate arrangements to facilitate and support third-party investment in the railway system.

11.2. The licence holder shall publish such information as is reasonably necessary to explain its approach to third-party investment.

11.3. The licence holder shall ensure its arrangements are transparent, proportionate and accessible to persons who may be interested in investing in the railway system.

11.4. In exercising its functions under this condition, the licence holder shall have regard to the Secretary of State’s objectives for the railway, including whole-system outcomes and the delivery of value for passengers, freight users, taxpayers and the wider economy.

Part D: Industry Obligations

12) Safety and Rail Technical Standards

12.1. Except where ORR and the Secretary of State consent otherwise, the licence holder shall:

  • (a) be a member of RSSB and a party to the Constitution Agreement;
  • (b) comply with its obligations under the Constitution Agreement and the articles of association of RSSB: and
  • (c) exercise its rights under the Constitution Agreement and the articles of association of RSSB so as to ensure that RSSB acts in accordance with the Constitution Agreement.

12.2. The licence holder shall comply with:

  • (a) The Railway Group Standards Code;
  • (b) such Railway Group Standards as are applicable to its Licensed Activities;
  • (c) subject to paragraph 12.3 of this condition, such Rail Industry Standards as applicable to its Licensed Activities.

12.3. The licence holder is not required to comply with an applicable Rail Industry Standard (or part thereof) where:

  • (a) it has, following consultation with such persons as it considers are likely to be affected, identified an equally effective measure which will achieve the purpose of the standard; and
  • (b) it has adopted and is complying with that measure.

13) Insurance and Liability Arrangements

13.1. The licence holder shall establish, maintain and keep under review third-party liability insurance or equivalent financial arrangements at a level that, having regard to the nature, scale and risks of its Licensed Activities and the liabilities that may reasonably be expected to arise from them, is adequate to enable it to meet those liabilities. The licence holder shall assess and document the basis on which it considers that level to be adequate.

14) Claims Allocation and Handling

14.1. The licence holder shall, except in so far as ORR may otherwise consent, at all times be a party to and comply with such agreements or arrangements (as amended from time to time) relating to:

  • (a) the handling of claims against operators of railway assets; and
  • (b)the allocation of liabilities among operators of railway assets,

as may have been approved by ORR.

14.2 Except with the consent of ORR, the licence holder shall not, in relation to any of the agreements or arrangements described in paragraph 1 (the relevant Claims Handling Arrangements), enter into any agreement or arrangement with any other party to the relevant Claims Handling Arrangements:

  • under which the licence holder agrees not to exercise any rights which it may have under any of the relevant Claims Handling Arrangements; or
  • varying the relevant Claims Handling Arrangements

other than as provided for under the terms of the relevant Claims Handling Arrangements.

15) Environmental Matters

15.1. The licence holder shall develop and comply with an Environmental Policy or Policies (the ‘Environmental Policy’) designed to protect the environment from the effects of Licensed Activities and to provide for the adaptation and resilience of the railway to environmental impacts, including those resulting from climate change.

15.2. The licence holder shall establish operational objectives and management arrangements to give effect to the delivery of its Environmental Policy.

15.3. The licence holder shall publish, review and revise the Environmental Policy as appropriate, and shall keep ORR and the Secretary of State appropriately informed of any material changes.

15.4. In developing its Environmental Policy, the licence holder shall have due regard to any relevant guidance issued by ORR and by the Secretary of State, including the Long-Term Rail Strategy.

15.5. The licence holder shall act with regard to the Environmental Policy when carrying out its Licensed Activities, and shall use reasonable endeavours to operate its management arrangements effectively.

15.6. Nothing contained in this condition shall require the undertaking of any action that entails excessive cost, taking into account all relevant circumstances including the nature and scale of operations of the type carried out by the licence holder, and having regard to relevant funding determined through the funding process.

16) Emergency Access

16.1. During any emergency affecting the railway, the licence holder shall, to the extent that it is legally entitled to do so, grant to any person requesting it such permission to use any station or light maintenance depot of which the licence holder is the operator pursuant to this licence as is necessary or expedient to alleviate the effects of the emergency.

17) Changes to the Schedule

17.1. If the licence holder ceases to be the operator of any stations or depots listed in Schedule [2/3], it shall within 1 month notify ORR, the Secretary of State and the Passengers’ Council of such cessation.

17.2. If the licence holder intends to operate an additional station or light maintenance depot, it must notify ORR in advance. The station or depot shall be added to the Schedule on a date agreed with ORR or, if no date is agreed, the licence holder may add it to the Schedule after 1 month beginning with the day on which the licence holder gives notice to ORR.

Schedule 1 - Revocation

1) The Secretary of State may, after consultation with the Office of Rail and Road, at any time revoke this licence by not less than 3 months’ notice to the licence holder:

  • (a)if the licence holder agrees in writing with the Secretary of State that this licence should be revoked; or
  • (b) if a final order has been made, or a provisional order has been confirmed under section 55 of the Act, in respect of any contravention or apprehended contravention by the licence holder of any condition, and the licence holder does not comply with the order within a period of 3 months beginning with the day on which the Secretary of State gives notice to the licence holder stating that this licence will be revoked pursuant to this term if the licence holder does not so comply; provided that the Secretary of State shall not give any such notice before the expiration of the period within which an application could be made under section 57 of the Act in relation to the order in question or before any proceedings relating to any such application are finally determined; or
  • (c) if the licence holder ceases to carry on Licensed Activities for a continuous period of at least one year;
  • (d) if any person obtains control of the licence holder and:
    • (i) the Secretary of State has not approved that obtaining of control;
    • (ii) within one month of that obtaining of control coming to the notice of the Secretary of State, the Secretary of State serves notice on the licence holder stating that the Secretary of State proposes to revoke this licence in pursuance of this paragraph unless the person who has obtained control of the licence holder ceases to have control of the licence holder within the period of 3 months beginning with the day of service of the notice; and
    • (iii) that cessation of control does not take place within that period

Schedules 2 & 3 - Stations and Light maintenance depots

These Schedules relate to the requirement to list the stations and light maintenance depots that, when the licence comes into force, are operated by GBR and its subsidiaries.

Comparison with existing licences

The GBR licence will be targeted and streamlined, so it will differ in its form and contents compared to the licences that are issued today under the Railways Act 1993 and The Railway (Licensing of Railway Undertakings) Regulations 2005. A review has been undertaken of the existing types of licences to assess their relevance to GBR. These include:

  • A network licence under the Railways Act 1993. This authorises a person to be the operator of a network, and trains being used on a network for any purpose comprised in the operation of the network. You can view the current Network Rail network licence.
  • A passenger train licence under the Railways Act 1993. This authorises a person to be the operator of a train being used on a network for the purpose of carrying passengers by railway. You can view an ORR model passenger train licence.
  • A station licence under the Railways Act 1993. This authorises a person to operate 1 or more specified stations. You can view the current Network Rail station licence.
  • A light maintenance depot licence under the Railways Act 1993. This authorises a person to operate 1 or more specified light maintenance depots. You can view an ORR model light maintenance depot licence.
  • A railway undertaking passenger licence and accompanying Statement of National Regulatory Provisions under The Railway (Licensing of Railway Undertakings) Regulations 2005. This authorises a railway company to run passenger trains on the mainline network. You can view an ORR model railway undertaking passenger licence.

Table 1 sets out existing conditions included in licences today that are not proposed for the GBR licence with an accompanying rationale.

Table 1: Conditions in Network Rail’s licences and ORR model licences not proposed for inclusion in the GBR licence

Model licence condition Licence types Rationale for not including in the GBR licence
Core duties including network management duty Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant as GBR’s core duties and functions will be established in legislation, which will make them enduring and legally binding.
Structure of the licence holder Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant, as legislation will require that the Secretary of State designates a public company wholly owned by the State to be designated as GBR. The corporate structure should be decided by GBR as the directing mind and in agreements between GBR and the Secretary of State.
Sufficient resources Network Rail’s network licence As a public body, the funding for GBR will be agreed by the Secretary of State and the Scottish Ministers through the agreed funding process, in line with statutory requirements.
Managing change Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant given evolving role of ORR, which will have a new statutory monitoring and advisory role across the scope of GBR’s Business Plan.
General network, route business and system operator network management responsibilities Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant given evolving role of ORR, which will have a new statutory monitoring and advisory role across the scope of GBR’s Business Plan including network management responsibilities.
Regulatory Accounts Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant as this information can be obtained through GBR’s consolidated information for ORR condition.
Periodic and annual returns Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant as this information can be obtained through GBR’s consolidated information for ORR condition.
Information on stakeholder dealings Network Rail’s network licence No longer necessary as the essence now captured in GBR’s new general stakeholder engagement condition.
Financial ring-fence Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant as GBR will be a public body, controls on what GBR can or cannot do are a matter for the Secretary of State. Overall permitted business will be established through existing controls including Managing Public Money (MPM), with the option for additional requirements to be established in GBR’s Articles of Association (AoA) or the Framework Agreement (FA) if required.
Interests in railway vehicles Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant as GBR will be a public body, controls on what GBR can or cannot do is a matter for the Secretary of State. Overall permitted business will be established through existing controls including Managing Public Money (MPM), with the option for additional requirements to be established in GBR’s Articles of Association (AoA) or the Framework Agreement (FA) if required.
Cross-subsidy Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant as GBR will be a public body, controls on what GBR can or cannot do are principally a matter for the Secretary of State. Cross-subsidy between different GBR activities can be achieved through alternative mechanisms and protections in law.
Regulatory undertakings Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant, as GBR corporate structure and design should be decided by GBR as the directing mind and in agreements between GBR and the Secretary of State.
Restricted use of protected information Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant, GBR will be under legal requirements on the handling of restricted information. GBR will also have a consolidated information for ORR condition, which includes a reporting framework that is expected to take into consideration GBR’s legal requirements on the use of protected information.
Corporate governance Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant, as GBR corporate structure should be decided by GBR as the directing mind and in agreements between GBR and the Secretary of State. Alternative mechanisms are considered more suitable for establishing corporate governance arrangements.
Incentive schemes Network Rail’s network licence No longer relevant as incentives should be agreed between GBR and the Secretary of State. Alternative mechanisms are considered more suitable for establishing corporate governance arrangements
Payment of fees All The Railways Bill introduces a power for ORR to fund itself through a statutory levy on GBR so a licence condition would be redundant.
Change of control All ORR currently uses the licensing regime to ensure operators are ‘fit and proper’ to operate railway assets. Change of company control may have implications for the ability of the licence holder to meet important legal and regulatory requirements. The Railways Bill ensures GBR will be fit and proper and any change of control would be agreed via legislation not the licence.
Non-discrimination Station, Light Maintenance Depot, network GBR will be subject to public law principles, which includes requirements to act reasonably and without bias, and will be subject to competition law. The Railways Bill establishes a new legal regime for access to GBR’s infrastructure that differs significantly from current arrangements. GBR access decisions will be made under a new framework and by reference to GBR’s statutory duties and its Access and Use Policy. The access regime for non-GBR infrastructure and service facilities is not expected to change.
Co-operation with Transport for London (TfL) Station Not required as GBR will have a statutory duty to cooperate with TFL. GBR will also be under a general stakeholder engagement condition through its licence.
Station asset information Station only GBR has a new long-term asset stewardship condition, which will be capable of capturing information on GBR’s station(s) assets.
Rail Delivery Group (RDG) Passenger and freight This condition will not be relevant given the expectation that GBR will in future perform functions currently carried out by RDG.

Impact assessment

The impact assessment supporting the Railways Bill covers the provision that allows a single railway licence for GBR which is included in the Railways Bill.

When responding to the consultation, please comment on the potential costs and benefits of the proposals, including equality impacts, administrative burdens or potential risks - giving supporting evidence wherever possible.

How to respond

See the Ways to respond section of the consultation page on GOV.UK to find out how you can respond to this consultation.

The consultation period began on 12 November 2026 and will run until 21 January 2027. Please ensure that your response reaches us before the closing date.

Full list of questions

These questions are listed here to give you an overview of what we are asking.

The consultation response form may include more questions, for example questions about who you are.

See the Ways to respond section of the consultation page on GOV.UK to find out how you can respond to this consultation.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed scope of the licence allows GBR the flexibility to make strategic decisions, whilst providing a clear framework for ORR’s independent enforcement role? Explain your answer.

Question:

In your view, are there any aspects of the proposed licence that could have impacts for particular groups? Explain your answer.

If any, what measures could address these impacts for groups within the scope of this licence, including through measures that promote equality of opportunity?

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed information conditions strike the right balance between enabling effective regulatory oversight and allowing GBR the flexibility to deliver its responsibilities? Explain your answer.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed consumer experience condition provides an appropriate framework for protecting passengers’ interests while ensuring GBR remains responsible for leading improvements in the passenger experience? Explain your answer.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed condition on liaison with the passenger watchdogs sets the appropriate expectation for GBR to engage with the watchdogs and respond to issues they may raise? Explain your answer.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed long-term asset stewardship condition provides an appropriate framework to enable effective stewardship of GBR’s railway assets? Explain your answer.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed condition on supporting seamless passenger travel appropriately defines the scope of ORR regulation through the licence in relation to GBR’s responsibilities for providing services that facilitate the provision and use of railway services by operators? Explain your answer.

Question:

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed approach to GBR’s land disposal provides an appropriate framework for GBR’s decision making? Explain your answer.

Question:

In your view, does the proposed stakeholder engagement condition provide an appropriate framework for GBR’s engagement with its stakeholders? Explain your answer.

Question:

In your view, does the proposed third-party investment condition provide an appropriate level of transparency, assurance and flexibility to support investment in the railway? Explain your answer.

Question:

In your view, does the proposed condition on insurance provide adequate reassurance to other parties operating on GBR’s network about how third-party liabilities will be covered by GBR? Explain your answer.

Question:

In your view, does the proposed environmental matters condition provide an appropriate framework for GBR to identify and respond to environmental priorities and exercise its wider stewardship role across the railway? Explain your answer.

Freedom of information

Information provided in response to this consultation, including personal information, may be subject to publication or disclosure in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA) or the Environmental Information Regulations 2004.

If you want information that you provide to be treated as confidential, please be aware that, under the FOIA, there is a statutory code of practice with which public authorities must comply and which deals, amongst other things, with obligations of confidence.

In view of this it would be helpful if you could explain to us why you regard the information you have provided as confidential. If we receive a request for disclosure of the information, we will take full account of your explanation, but we cannot give an assurance that confidentiality can be maintained in all circumstances.

An automatic confidentiality disclaimer generated by your IT system will not, of itself, be regarded as binding on the department.

What will happen next

We will publish a summary of responses and the government response on the homepage for this consultation. Paper copies will be available on request.

If you have questions about this consultation, please contact:

GBRLicenceTeam@dft.gov.uk

Data protection

Your personal data collected through this consultation is processed in line with our online forms, surveys and consultations privacy notice.

You can find more about how your personal data is used along with your rights within this privacy notice.

Artificial intelligence

Artificial intelligence (AI) may be used to analyse responses to this consultation. Where the consultation asks for directly identifiable information, such as your name or contact details, these will be removed before processing with AI tools.