Section 9(3) of the Human Rights Act 1998 Review: terms of reference
Published 16 November 2026
Government review of section 9(3) of the Human Rights Act 1998 terms of reference
The terms of reference for the review contain information on:
- Context
- Objectives and scope of the review
- Timelines
- Structure and engagement
Context
The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) has committed to reviewing the operation of section 9(3) of the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA).
Section 9(3) HRA sets out a general prohibition on the award of HRA damages for judicial acts done in good faith, with two specific exceptions. The first relates to breaches of Article 5 (right to liberty and security) of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).
The second relates to breaches of Article 6 of the ECHR (right to a fair trial) and was added via a Remedial Order[footnote 1] in 2020 to implement the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) judgment in Hammerton v United Kingdom[footnote 2].
In May 2026, the Government laid before Parliament a draft Remedial Order to address the ECtHR judgment in SW v United Kingdom[footnote 3]. The draft Remedial Order creates a third exception to the general rule in section 9(3) HRA by amending section 9(3) to make damages available in relation to judicial acts done in good faith that breach the requirements of procedural fairness under Article 8 of the ECHR (right to respect for private and family life).
In November 2025, the Joint Committee on Human Rights (JCHR), in their initial scrutiny report of the Remedial Order[footnote 4], expressed concerns that it was too narrowly drafted to prevent future breaches of Article 13 of the ECHR (right to an effective remedy) where judicial acts infringe on ECHR rights. They recommended amending the Order, either by introducing broader principled exceptions to section 9(3) HRA or removing the provision entirely.
Whilst the Government has not taken forward the recommendation made by the JCHR to introduce broader principled exceptions to section 9(3), or to remove the provision in its entirety, we have committed to reviewing the operation of section 9(3) HRA.
Objectives and scope of the review
The objectives of the review are to assess the impact and effectiveness of section 9(3) HRA and determine whether it remains fit for purpose.
This will include an evaluation of the intended purpose of section 9(3) HRA, its operation in practice and whether it meets that intended purpose.
The review will inform how to proceed in relation to section 9(3) HRA.
The scope of the review will focus solely on the operation of section 9(3) HRA and not the HRA more broadly.
Timelines
The review will commence on 16 November 2026 with the launch of a call for evidence, which will run for a period of eight weeks.
HM Government will conclude the review by writing to the JCHR setting out what action it plans to take in relation to section 9(3) HRA in Spring 2027.
Structure and engagement
This is an internal government review, conducted by a small team of MoJ officials, with oversight from the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Sentencing, Human Rights and Technology, The Rt Hon Jake Richards MP.
The review is expected to conduct evidence-based research during the process, including:
- targeted engagement with the JCHR (via its secretariat), the Judiciary, civil society organisations and academics; and
- a call for evidence, to invite the views of experts and interested parties on the operation of section 9(3) HRA.
-
Hammerton v United Kingdom, Application no. 6287/10, 17 March 2016 ↩
-
SW v United Kingdom, Application no. 87/18, 22 June 2021 ↩
-
Proposal for a Remedial Order to amend the Human Rights Act 1998: Judicial Immunity ↩