Developing an evidence base for improving appraisal guidance

A study investigating the potential for improvements to the existing flood and coastal erosion risk management (FCERM) appraisal and guidance.

Documents

Developing an evidence base for appraisal guidance - final report (117KB) PDF

Developing an evidence base for appraisal guidance - summary (111KB) PDF

Developing an evidence base for appraisal guidance - extended summary (1.25MB) PDF

Developing an evidence base for appraisal guidance - technical report (1.5MB) PDF

Task A1 - annex and appendices (2.6MB) PDF

Task A2 - annex and appendices (3.2MB) PDF

Task B1 - annex and appendices (3MB) PDF

Task B2 - annex and appendices (2MB) PDF

Task C - annex and appendices (3.2MB) PDF

If you use assistive technology (such as a screen reader) and need a version of this document in a more accessible format, please email: defra.helpline@defra.gov.uk. Please tell us what format you need. It will help us if you say what assistive technology you use.

Details

This study investigates the potential for improvements to the existing flood and coastal erosion risk management (FCERM) appraisal and guidance. The existing appraisal guidance is:

  • limited in scope
  • no longer completely up to date
  • not always particularly user-friendly

This study identifies:

  • key areas where project appraisals do not always provide the information needed by decision-makers to determine whether a project should proceed
  • the priority that projects should take
  • common reasons why project appraisals may not give the ‘correct’ answer

It builds on these findings to recommend ways that appraisal in FCERM could be improved to help practitioners make better decisions.

The reports produced during this project will inform Defra, the Environment Agency and their advisory group. It should not be taken as indicators of any specific change in current policy.

This project ran during 2006 at a cost of £84,465.

Published 17 February 2021