Food Hygiene at Primary Production Level
Published 10 November 2026
Applies to England
Foreword
Audits of local authority (LA) feed and food law enforcement functions are part of the Food Standards Agency’s (FSA’s) arrangements to improve the consistency and effectiveness of enforcement. These arrangements recognise that the enforcement of UK feed and food law relating to feed and food safety, hygiene, composition, labelling, imported food and feeding stuffs is largely the responsibility of local authorities. These local authority regulatory functions are principally delivered through Environmental Health and Trading Standards Services.
Audits assess local authorities’ conformance against the Feed and Food Law Enforcement Standard contained within the Framework Agreement on Official Feed and Food Controls by local authorities (the Framework Agreement), the Food Law Code of Practice (FLCoP) and relevant official enforcement guidance.
Local authorities may organise and deliver these services differently to meet local needs and priorities. The audit scheme protects consumers and supports public confidence by checking that local authorities provide effective feed and food law enforcement services. It also identifies and shares good practice and provides evidence to inform FSA policy.
The power to set standards, monitor and audit feed and food law enforcement authorities was conferred on the FSA by the Food Standards Act 1999 and the Official Feed and Food Controls (England) Regulations 2009. The FSA’s audits of local authorities are carried out under section 12(4) of the Act. Assimilated Regulation (EU) 2017/625 on official controls performed to ensure the verification of compliance with food and feed law, includes a requirement under Article 6(1) for competent authorities to carry out internal audits or to have external audits carried out. To fulfil this requirement, the FSA, as the central competent authority for food and feed law in England, Wales and Northern Ireland has established external audit arrangements. The audits check whether official controls for feed and food law work effectively. In developing these, the FSA has taken account of the European Commission guidance on how such audits should be conducted.
Further information on the FSA’s local authority audit scheme is available on the FSA website.
A glossary of technical terms used within the audit report can be found at Annex A.
Introduction
Background
Primary production definition
Primary production covers both products of animal origin (POAO) and foods not of animal origin (FNAO). It is a term used to describe activities, including the storage and handling of products, without substantially changing their nature, at the place of production. In the case of fishery products, the definition is extended to include transportation from the place of production to another establishment, provided the nature of the product hasn’t been substantially altered.
Primary production is defined in Article 3(17) of assimilated Regulation (EC) No. 178/2002 as: ‘the production, rearing or growing of primary products including harvesting, milking and farmed animal production before slaughter. It also includes hunting and fishing, and the harvesting of wild products.’ Primary products are defined in Article 2(1)(b) of assimilated Regulation (EC) No. 852/2004 as: ‘products of primary production including products of the soil, of stock farming, and of hunting and fishing.’ Operations that substantially alter a product or introduce new hazards, such as peeling and slicing vegetables, or bagging salad crops with the application of preserving gases, are not considered primary production activities. Annex II of assimilated Regulation (EC) No. 852/2004 applies to these operations.
Enforcement
Primary producers fall within the scope of assimilated Regulation (EC) No. 852/2004 on the hygiene of foodstuffs as identified in Annex I of that Regulation, taking into consideration relevant exemptions. These Regulations are implemented by The Food Safety and Hygiene (England) Regulations 2013.
Local authorities are responsible for conducting food hygiene controls at most primary production establishments in England, with some limited exceptions, detailed as follows:
-
Milk - The FSA’s dairy operations unit are responsible for primary production food hygiene official controls on dairy farms of all species. Local authorities retain some food hygiene enforcement responsibilities for raw drinking milk.
-
Eggs - The FSA has a Memorandum of Understanding in place with the Animal and Plant Health Agency (APHA) for the delivery of food hygiene official controls at establishments and production units with more than 350 laying Gallus gallus hens. All other egg production establishments are the responsibility of local authorities.
In two-tier authorities there should be agreement at a local level on the enforcement authority to take responsibility for each of the sectors of food hygiene at the level of primary production, having regard to the principles of the Farm Regulators Charter.
Primary production establishments are subject to routine registration requirements under the FLCoP, unless any of the relevant exemptions apply.
Exemptions
Article 1(2) of assimilated Regulation (EC) No. 852/2004 specifies that this Regulation does not apply to:
-
primary production for private domestic use
-
the domestic preparation, handling or storage of food for private domestic consumption
-
the direct supply, by the producer, of small quantities of primary products to the final consumer or to local retail establishments directly supplying the final consumer
While there is some specific guidance on what constitutes ‘small quantities’, a meaningful interpretation of what constitutes a small quantity can vary significantly from product to product. Local authorities are expected to make a professional judgement based on the product, the extent of production and the associated risk to the consumer.
Guidance
Statutory guidance relevant to primary production is issued through the Food and Feed Law Codes of Practice, with guidance contained within the associated Practice Guidance (PG).
The FSA issues annual National Enforcement Priorities (NEPs) guidance to local authorities which identifies priorities in England (and Wales) for food hygiene at primary production in certain sectors, as well as animal feed priorities. The NEPs take account of emerging risks and intelligence to identify priorities for local authorities to consider when delivering their intervention programme.
In accordance with the 2025/26 NEPs guidance, local authorities were expected to give priority to ‘effective identification, registration and inspection of food businesses producing higher-risk, fresh produce operating at the level of primary production’. Some examples are given to illustrate each category, although the guidance makes clear that these are not intended to be an exhaustive list and local authorities are advised to use their professional judgement. The examples provided are:
-
producers of soft fruits and berries, for example raspberries, blackberries, mulberries, loganberries and strawberries, for which a thorough wash post-harvest will be difficult to achieve without damaging the produce
-
producers of leafy greens and salad fruit and vegetables, normally eaten raw, for example lettuce, micro leaves, baby leaves, watercress, spinach, herbs and cucumbers, that have a short seed to harvest time, meaning that they are likely to be harvested within two weeks of last irrigation. If irrigation water is contaminated, this contamination will not have had time to dissipate in short harvest crops
-
producers of bulb and root vegetables, or vegetables with no protective skin, that are commonly consumed raw, for example salad onions, radishes and celery
The FSA’s Primary Production Food Hygiene Inspection Guidance document provides further information on various types of primary production activities and provides links to sources of additional information.
Specific funding
The FSA provides limited funding to local authorities in England for food hygiene controls at higher-risk fresh fruit and vegetable (FFV) producers through the Feed Delivery Programme (FDP). In 2024-2025 the programme funded 124 food hygiene inspections at higher-risk FFV producers.
Funding from the FSA’s European Union (EU) exit local authority support fund was provided to local authorities during 2019/2020 to undertake risk-based inspections of fishing vessels. This funding was targeted towards larger vessels over 10 metres in length and other smaller vessels using an intelligence-led approach. While the funding has ended, the work carried out by local authorities has delivered lasting benefits. These include establishing communication channels for sharing intelligence on fishing vessels and enhancing knowledge and experience among officers operating within this sector.
Assurance schemes and earned recognition
Assurance schemes are voluntary systems which verify through regular independent inspections that farmers and growers are meeting certain standards of production. The scope of assurance schemes can cover both primary production and processing throughout the food chain including retail sale. Standards are defined by the assurance scheme criteria and members can use the scheme’s logo on their product to indicate the product has been produced to the standards of the scheme.
Red Tractor (RT) assurance is a whole chain assurance scheme which covers food safety, traceability, animal welfare and environmental protection. RT is the only FSA approved assurance scheme for high-risk fresh fruit and vegetable producers in England. It also applies to a variety of other sectors.
When an assurance scheme is approved for Earned Recognition, compliant members of that scheme can benefit from a reduced frequency of official controls on the basis that they are taking positive action to reduce risks and comply with legislative requirements, verified through a third-party certification process.
For food businesses operating at the level of primary production, the FLCoP enables local authorities to make the best use of evidence available when assessing the need for inspection. This includes consideration of membership of an approved assurance scheme.
Why we carried out the audit programme
Purpose of the local authority audit scheme
The primary purpose of audits of local authorities is to provide assurance that the delivery of official controls for feed and food is compliant with legal requirements and official guidance. Regulatory audits are also designed to verify the effective implementation of planned arrangements and to assess whether the planned arrangements are suitable to achieve the objectives of the relevant legal requirements and guidance.
The main aims of the FSA’s local authority audit scheme are to:
-
Help to protect public health by promoting effective local enforcement of feed and food law
-
Maintain and improve consumer confidence
-
Assist in the identification and dissemination of good practice to aid consistency, and the effectiveness of service delivery
-
Provide information to aid the formulation of FSA policy
-
Promote conformance with relevant central guidance or Codes of Practice
-
Provide a means to identify any issues and concerns in local authority feed and food law service delivery
-
Promote self-regulation and peer review
-
Identify and promote the principle of continuous improvement
Risk-based audit planning
The FSA’s regulatory audit planning process is based on risk prioritisation that considers national audit guidance. The topics audited are determined by conducting a planning exercise involving policy and delivery colleagues from across the FSA. The topics selected as part of annual audit programmes are risk assessed. Audit planning as well as delivery and outcomes are reported to the FSA’s Audit Risk Assurance Committee (ARAC) which provides independent scrutiny for the audit function.
Aim, objectives and scope
Key risks at primary production
Primary products form the foundation of the food chain. A lack of effective controls at primary production could have a significant impact on the safety of the food chain and public health. Inconsistent or ineffective delivery of food hygiene official controls at primary production level could result in a loss of consumer confidence, a potential risk to international trade agreements and consequent damage to the reputation of the FSA and local authorities.
Aim and objectives
The audit aims and objectives were to:
-
Seek to gain assurance that appropriate arrangements were in place for the delivery of effective official controls related to food hygiene at primary production.
-
Determine whether food hygiene official control delivery activity funded by the feed delivery programme was carried out under the NEPs.
-
Gather information on the intelligence led approach to prioritising food hygiene official control interventions at the level of primary production, including the impact of third-party assurance schemes, whether FSA approved or not.
Scope
The audit programme examined local authority delivery of official controls and other official activities relating to food hygiene at primary production. A broad range of sectors within local authority remit were included, with a focus on higher-risk fresh produce growers and fishing vessels where previous regulatory activity had been identified. Additional sectors, including honey producers and game larders, were also considered. This targeted approach aimed to maintain audit focus while managing the challenges associated with the wide variety of primary production activities and the limited availability of establishment-level data. For example, duck egg producers were initially identified as an area of interest, but they could not be reliably identified using open-source data.
Activities carried out by competent authorities in Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland were outside the scope of this audit programme, as were those delivered by the FSA, including work carried out on its behalf by third parties.
Additionally, the following primary production topic areas were excluded from the scope of the audit for various reasons including, due to recent audit coverage, the lower-risk nature of some of these activities or due to potential inclusion in future targeted audit activity as part of the ongoing audit planning process:
-
Feed
-
Combinable crops
-
Livestock including poultry
-
Agricultural crops such as carrots and potatoes
-
Sprouted seeds
-
Shellfish harvesters (including live-bivalve molluscs and marine gastropods)
Selecting local authorities
Audits were carried out at eight local authorities across England, including one shared service arrangement covering three local authorities. A list of the local authorities audited between March and July 2025 is provided in Annex B.
Local authorities were selected to ensure a mix of authority types, locations and in-scope primary producers. Those audited within the previous five years were excluded.
Audit criteria
Audit assessments were carried out against relevant legislation, the Food Law Code of Practice and centrally issued guidance including the ‘Standard’ in Chapter 2 of the Framework Agreement, the Food Law Practice Guidance and the Primary Production Food Hygiene Inspection Guidance.
Audit approach
The key system controls that were assessed for food hygiene at primary production included:
-
Service planning, including the allocation of responsibilities, identification of delivery risks, and provision of appropriate resources, suitably authorised officers, guidance and training
-
Identification and registration of primary producers as food businesses, and maintenance of accurate premises databases
-
Intelligence-led prioritisation of official control interventions, including consideration of third-party assurance schemes and NEPs, selection of establishments for intervention, and the risk basis for intervention choice, including prioritisation of funded activity
-
Implementation and effectiveness of control activities, including interventions, enforcement, complaints and incident handling, and associated record management
-
Liaison arrangements between local authorities and relevant partner agencies
-
Actions taken to improve controls where monitoring identifies significant issues in the delivery of planned controls
Details of the audit methodology, design, and the evaluation and assessment framework used during the audits are set out in Annex C.
Executive summary
This report explains what we found when we assessed how effectively local authorities in England deliver risk-based food hygiene controls at primary production.
Between March and July 2025, we examined arrangements in 8 local authorities. The sample included higher-risk fresh produce growers and fishing vessels.
Key strengths
We found these strengths:
-
Well-established liaison and information-sharing arrangements across authorities and partner organisations
-
Use of multiple intelligence sources to identify and verify primary producers
-
Competent and authorised officers, supported by ongoing training and development
-
Positive engagement during visits, with constructive advice provided to businesses
-
Use of assurance scheme data and management information systems (MIS) to inform regulatory activity.
Main areas for improvement
We found these recurring issues in some local authorities:
-
Service planning did not always fully reflect the demands, responsibilities or resource requirements of primary production controls
-
Incomplete or inconsistent identification and registration of primary producers, particularly higher-risk businesses
-
Limited evidence of a structured, intelligence-led and risk-based approach to prioritising interventions across the range of primary producers
-
Inconsistent inspection frequencies and methodologies, partly due to the absence of a standardised national risk rating framework
-
Gaps in up-to-date documented intervention procedures relevant to primary production activities or their full implementation.
System-wide challenges
We also identified issues for the FSA to consider as the central competent authority:
-
A lack of nationally consistent guidance for local authorities, particularly for risk rating, inspection frequency, and interpretation of small quantity exemptions
-
Resource constraints and workforce capacity issues across local authorities linked to associated recruitment challenges for local authorities
-
Dependence on a small number of experienced officers within certain local authorities to deliver primary production work
-
The reported limited availability of training for local authority officers relating to food hygiene at primary production.
Overall, we gave Limited Assurance. Local authorities need significant improvement to show that their arrangements are effective, risk based and meet legal requirements and official guidance.
Audit findings
Service planning
Food service plans
Local authorities are required to carry out official food controls and other official activities under documented procedures, policies, plans, programmes, and strategies which they must set-up, implement and maintain. When undertaking food service planning and prioritising service activities local authorities must take account of the requirements set out in assimilated Regulation (EU) 2017/625 and have due regard to the statutory guidance contained within the FLCoP.
The Food Law Practice Guidance (PG) guidelines on the content of food service plans are structured to provide a common format, with chapter, subject headings and content guidance provided. There is flexibility for local authorities to include additional items to reflect local priorities and corporate styles which they may wish to maintain.
Effective service planning helps local authorities manage delivery, priorities and standards. The FLCoP requires that local authorities maintain an up-to-date and appropriately approved Food Service Plan to identify the demands on services, to set out how they will use their available resources to meet these demands and to ensure senior council officials are made aware of Plan contents and Service issues.
All the local authorities audited had documented their food service plans. In two local authorities these were awaiting sign-off and approval including in one local authority where there was an open engagement with the FSA’s Performance Management Team which required the Authority to develop and gain approval for a Food Service Plan. All approved plans except for one were published on the local authority website making them readily available to businesses and consumers under the PG.
The Plans detailed service demands and explained how each local authority planned to use their resources in the year ahead to deliver food hygiene controls. However, only two service plans made direct reference to primary production food businesses as part of the demands on their services. All service plans could be strengthened to provide further information on service demands at primary production level and their approach to food hygiene interventions in primary producers. All local authorities audited could strengthen their service plans by ensuring that the resources required to assess the delivery of official controls at primary producers are estimated, using an objective methodology and documented in the plan. This should also include an estimation of the resources required for undertaking associated activities including internal monitoring activities.
All local authorities reported staff resource shortfalls or vacancies within teams at the time of the audit, with associated recruitment challenges
A written agreement outlining proactive and reactive responsibilities for delivering food hygiene controls at primary producers was in place at one local authority Service, which involved working in co-ordination across the County area. It was noted that such an agreement helps to support consistency and clarity concerning the roles and responsibilities in this area of work.
All local authorities had strong and established liaison arrangements used to determine enforcement responsibility and share information and intelligence.
Officer authorisation, training and competence
Local authorities are required to ensure that officers are appropriately authorised, qualified, competent and trained to carry out food law enforcement activities. All local authorities had authorised their officers for the delivery of food hygiene at primary production and under their specified authorisation procedure where it was found to be in place. Officer authorisation documents had all been signed by senior management who were appropriately approved to do so by the delegations of the constitutional framework of each LA.
One local authority needed to develop an appropriate documented officer authorisation procedure.
An assessment of officer competency was used by all local authorities as part of the authorisation process. All local authorities were aware of the FSA’s Competency Framework which has since been updated and replaced by the FSA’s Competency Standard. Some local authorities were using the Framework for newly qualified officers, but most used their own system of competency assessment for existing officers. Local authorities reported that the Framework was not easy to use for assessing officer competency.
All local authorities had a suitable system in place to identify ongoing training needs for each officer, including primary production training. Local authorities expressed a willingness to provide the necessary primary production training when identified as a need. Due to perceived limited training opportunities, local authorities welcomed more FSA training opportunities ideally tailored to officers from different food and feed law enforcement backgrounds on primary production.
Training areas suggested included for Annex 1 of assimilated Regulation 852/2004, familiarisation training on the FSA primary production inspection guidance document, training on the practical completion of the long format primary production inspection form, access to and use of assurance scheme information and Lead Food Officer (LFO) training. These were in addition to sector specific training which would be useful for officers depending on the local authority establishment make-up. Examples included producers of leafy greens, honey producers and game larders.
Most of the local authorities audited relied on a small number of staff that were experienced in delivering controls at primary production. Training records for staff involved in the delivery of food hygiene controls at primary production were assessed. Local authorities had trained officers using a range of methods. Examples included:
-
use of external training providers
-
training delivered by the British Leafy Salads Association
-
in-house cascade training
-
through food/feed liaison groups
-
sharing knowledge and experience across neighbouring local authorities and
-
through formal qualifications.
One larger local authority had established an internal working group to focus on primary production matters. Training materials developed by Cornwall Port Health Authority supported inspections of fishing vessels providing practical guidance to authorised officers. In most local authorities, contractors were responsible for their own training needs. Training was mostly provided via online resources as opposed to face-to-face training.
Policies and procedures
Local authorities are required to have documented policies that set out their approach to sampling, enforcement and complaints and must perform official controls under up-to-date documented procedures that include instructions for authorised officers undertaking official controls.
All local authorities except for one had appropriate documented policies and procedures relevant to food hygiene controls at primary production level. The remaining local authority needed to either draft or update certain documented procedures to cover the full range of activities including for the authorisation of staff, dealing with complaints and internal monitoring.
All local authorities except two had a suitable system of document control in place. Most local authorities aimed to update their policies and procedures within 12 months with one local authority aiming for a review every two years. Most of the local authorities had reviewed and updated their policies and procedures within the previous 12 months of the audit. All local authorities reported that procedures are updated on an ongoing basis as required. Auditors noted that some procedures required updating in respect of legislative references and contact information. One local authority used internal working groups to oversee the updating of policies and procedures. They also held a useful master list of their policies and procedures with all documents having a timeline showing their formation and last review date.
One local authority used the Regulatory Information and Management System (RIAMS) procedures which had been adapted to reflect local arrangements. They also used flow charts as a useful aid to decision making.
In all local authorities except one, master documents, could only be amended by authorised staff. Control over editing such documents helps ensure a more consistent approach. All local authorities expressed that they discouraged the practice of staff saving documents to personal drives. Local authorities using tablets ensured the most up-to-date forms were available and previous versions removed.
Delivering food hygiene controls at primary production
Identifying and registering primary producers
All local authorities were using local information and sources of intelligence to identify food establishments including primary producers. This information was used to improve and maintain the accuracy of their Management Information System (MIS).
All local authorities had systems in place for receiving, recording and sharing information and intelligence, including in some cases through the IDB intelligence database.
Local authorities were using a range of methods to identify primary producers and to prioritise food interventions. These included:
-
Food business registration assisted by signposting on the local authorities website
-
Established liaison arrangements regionally and nationally for information and intelligence shared across teams. This included food hygiene, food standards, feed and animal welfare officers in unitary authorities and across two-tier authorities
-
Internal networking within local authorities across services, including teams leading on private water supplies and licensing
-
Assurance scheme membership information and updates
-
External listings such as the Marine Management Organisation (MMO) listings for fishing vessels
-
Local arrangements such as regular contact with Harbour Masters to identify fishing vessels
-
Social media and online platforms
-
Local press and published materials
-
Intelligence from surveys carried out during the Covid pandemic to identify seasonal workers
-
Farm gate sales, farmers markets, food festivals, events and vending machines
-
Internet searches including pick your own, fruit and vegetable box schemes and market gardens
-
Researching growers’ associations
-
Local authority MIS searches, and
-
Complaints
Where local authorities were responsible for undertaking food hygiene inspections of fishing vessels, lists of fishing vessels with home ports within each authority were being maintained and updated. Local authorities considered the MMO listings and any intelligence received. Examples were provided of where communication channels had been established with neighbouring local authorities and Harbour Masters to exchange information. This work had been aided by the FSA who provided funding and guidance.
For businesses producing higher-risk fresh produce operating at the level of primary production, some local authorities provided evidence of recent and historic work that had been carried out to identify these businesses.
All local authorities recognised the importance of maintaining up-to-date lists of primary producers to enable a risk-based approach to interventions. An online search of primary producers in each local authority area was carried out before each audit. Most establishments that were selected appeared on the premises lists held by each authority. In a few instances, further enquires were required to ensure registered establishment lists were up to date. Some food establishments consisted of food activities beyond primary production, for example manufacturers and farm shops. The full scope of business activities was not always reflected in MIS and intervention records.
Various examples were provided of ongoing work to improve the accuracy of local authority MIS such as identifying and removing duplicate establishments. In some instances, additional usage codes were being applied to easily identify specific types of primary producers using the local authority MIS. There were also examples of ongoing work to ensure appropriate inspection and usage codes for newly registered food establishments to maintain database accuracy.
In all cases local authorities had systems in place for registering food businesses including primary producers. Local authorities were either connected to the FSA’s Register a Food Business (RAFB) service or used their own registration service with documented registration procedures and instructions being in place. Examples were provided of where businesses were being signposted to a registration link and to useful advice and information on the local authority website. Often food registration forms were being uploaded by administration support teams and permissions were being restricted to specific officers to maintain control over system accuracy.
Small quantity exemptions
Local authorities had considered small quantity exemptions for primary producers largely on an ad-hoc basis. Some examples were provided of where local authorities had considered centrally issued guidance for eggs and fish. Two specific examples were provided of where local authorities had identified a threshold at a local level specifically for fresh fruit and vegetables and for producers attending farmers markets.
Some local authorities had decided to register and maintain premises details on their MIS for all primary producers within a category group, for example, honey producers and undertake interventions at these establishments. Auditors were informed that this assisted in monitoring primary producers who may develop and grow their business. This work was being balanced against potential risks and resource implications. The local authorities audited would broadly welcome further centrally issued guidance in this area to help target staff resources appropriately.
Prioritising interventions
Local authorities were considering the information received at registration when prioritising interventions at primary producers. In some cases, local authorities were requesting additional information through questionnaires or direct contact via telephone or face-to-face to prioritise interventions on a risk basis.
The NEPs document for food hygiene primary production (FHPP) was being considered by three local authorities as part of their risk-based approach to prioritising interventions at FFV primary producers. Two local authorities had recently identified lists of higher-risk FFV primary producers using the NEPs but had not yet inspected these establishments or allocated a risk rating. One of these local authorities was issuing a questionnaire to assist in prioritising FFV producers for an inspection, considering information such as types and quantities of produce grown, types of customers and assurance scheme membership as part of this process.
One local authority was using feed delivery programme (FDP) funding for food hygiene inspections of higher-risk fresh produce alongside feed delivery at the time of the audit. A further three local authorities audited were using FDP funding solely for animal feed delivery work. These local authorities recognised the potential to secure future funding through this route to undertake FHPP work. Some local authorities audited had used this funding stream in previous years for FHPP work.
Auditors were informed in most cases where local authorities were responsible for inspecting FFV producers that relevant Officers had access to the portal of the FSA approved assurance scheme RT and received regular updates. Examples were provided to support this finding. However, the extent to which assurance scheme membership information including RT was used to inform a risk-based approach varied.
Auditors were informed that the use of assurance scheme information to assist in prioritising establishments for an intervention depended on the following factors:
-
All relevant officers having access to this information and sufficient knowledge to search for relevant information
-
Understanding the reasons for any change in membership status notified through updates e.g. non-payment of fees versus non-compliance
-
The ease at which assurance scheme information enables the relevant local authority to identify establishments within its area
-
Sufficient time to act on the information received and record this on the local authority MIS
-
Processes being in place to update the local authority MIS in response to updates and to ensure database accuracy
-
The confidence that officers placed in the scheme generally when using this information to determine frequency of inspection.
In some instances, local authorities effectively demonstrated how they were using this information to maintain the accuracy of the MIS and to make this information readily available on the MIS to facilitate a risk-based approach by officers. However, it was acknowledged that this process was time-consuming and required some degree of follow-up after receipt of notifications and updates. There was a need to verify information received to ensure accuracy.
Where local authorities had fishing vessels with home ports within their areas, local authorities had inspected most fishing vessels, prioritising larger vessels using EU exit funding provided by the FSA in 2019/2020 to complete official controls of fishing vessels. There were measures in place to receive and act on any intelligence received. Occasional new fishing vessel registrations were being received with inspections being carried out to facilitate trade.
Frequency of interventions
In the absence of an official FSA issued intervention rating scheme for food hygiene controls at primary producers, there was a varied approach taken by the local authorities audited. A range of methods for determining inspection frequencies at various types of primary producers including higher-risk FFV producers, game larders, honey producers and fishing vessels were used.
One local authority had not determined next inspection dates for higher-risk FFV producers having previously carried out inspections during 2018/2019. There were no local authority MIS generated next inspection dates as records were retained on a spreadsheet. A similar approach was used by one local authority for fishing vessel inspections although auditors were informed that if new intelligence was received it would be acted upon.
All local authorities except one used the FSA food hygiene intervention risk rating system to determine minimum frequencies for interventions at some or all primary producers. Despite it not strictly applying to establishments operating at the level of primary production establishments were being rated as category E establishments with three-yearly interventions. The main reason provided for using this system was the absence of an alternative system. Also, using this approach enabled the local authority MIS to generate next inspection dates and maintain digital records for primary producers.
In some instances, primary producers were overdue an intervention due to a backlog of outstanding E rated establishments and limited staff resource for delivering lower-risk interventions.
One local authority was aiming to inspect FFV producers at 4 yearly intervals in line with the FDP modelling process. Auditors were advised that use of FDP funding was further being prioritised based on risk considering whether an establishment had been inspected previously, compliance scores and membership of FSA approved assurance schemes.
Further, one local authority was using a scoring system for risk rating higher-risk FFV producers that considered assurance scheme membership and confidence in management. A four-year inspection frequency was applied to the highest risk primary production establishments, with Earned Recognition applied to those establishments determined as lower risk, assurance scheme members. Future inspection dates were being calculated using the local authority MIS.
Across all local authorities audited, auditors were informed that new intelligence received would be acted upon appropriately, based on risk. Auditors were advised that intelligence generated by other statutory inspections and incidents was considered as part of the risk-based prioritisation process. Following interventions at primary producers, various information and intelligence was considered, including confidence in management, record of compliance, membership of FSA and non-FSA approved assurance schemes. There were no Primary Authority inspection plans relating to FHPP identified within the sample of local authorities audited.
Interventions
Local authorities generally had suitable documented intervention procedures in place applicable to primary producers and all local authorities were using various inspection forms for recording interventions. In some instances, procedures and the use of appropriate forms for certain sectors required review to provide up-to-date guidance to officers.
Inspection forms that were being used included the template fresh food primary production short and long version model forms, available through the Knowledge Hub Agriculture Community for use when undertaking food hygiene inspections at FFV primary producers, in-house local authority template forms and the FSA template form for fishing vessels. The use of appropriate inspection forms helped to ensure that hazards and controls were appropriately considered, and assessments recorded during inspections.
Each audit assessed a sample of food hygiene inspection records and reports. In all cases physical inspections had been carried out by authorised officers either from food safety, food standards or feed delivery teams. In most cases, examples were provided of where inspection forms had been appropriately completed and assessments on hazards and controls had been retained. In some instances, these records provided evidence that assurance scheme membership had been considered.
There were some instances where local authorities were not fully implementing documented procedures or were unable to demonstrate that hazards and controls at primary production level had been assessed on a risk basis. For example, where primary production establishments had not been assessed as interventions had started at the processing stage or other examples where assessment records were incomplete.
In some instances, the audit notification had prompted local authorities to re-prioritise this area of work and examples were provided where work was underway to identify and inspect FFV primary producers on a risk-basis.
There were no significant issues identified arising from the sample of routine interventions that were assessed although there were examples of where officers had provided useful advice to businesses on topics such as use of irrigation water and field worker hygiene.
Reality visits
Auditors accompanied local authority authorised officers on announced reality visits to a sample of registered primary producers as part of the audit programme. The purpose of these on-site verification visits was to provide assurance that official controls were being carried out under planned arrangements and that these arrangements are being applied effectively. The businesses visited were of varying size and scale of operations and included four producers of higher-risk fruit and vegetables and a honey producer.
The businesses visited included RT scheme members for fresh produce as well as non-members, and members of other assurance schemes and trade associations that resulted in business audits and provided access to specialist advice. Examples included British Retail Consortium (BRC), Linking Environment and Farming (LEAF), Sedex Members Ethical Trade Audit (SMETA) and the Bee Farmers Association. Some businesses were also subject to multiple customer audits such as by supermarkets they supplied.
The primary producers were often operating alongside other food operations including manufacturing operations where primary products were being further processed on site, caterers using fresh produce and retail sales through farm shops or farmers’ markets.
Auditors were able to verify that the business details and the scope of operations generally corresponded to establishment records. In most cases accompanying authorised officers had completed the last food hygiene at primary production inspection. These officers were able to demonstrate a clear understanding of the business operations including hazards and controls that were in place. Positive relationships with the food business representatives were observed with business advice and information provided on relevant topic areas.
In one instance, the local authority was advised to further consider the hazards associated with food hygiene production and consider FSA approved assurance scheme membership when determining inspection frequencies.
Complaints, enforcement and incidents
The programme of audits considered any food hygiene complaints, incidents and enforcement that occurred in primary production establishments in the three years before each audit. Very few complaints and incidents were noted within scope, and no formal enforcement actions were taken by local authorities audited for primary production establishments within the time-period stated. In two local authorities, where complaints or incidents had been received, audit findings confirmed that these were appropriately investigated and managed.
All local authorities except one had suitable documented procedures in place which provided officers with guidance for investigating food complaints and food alerts/incidents.
All local authorities had a published Enforcement Policy which included criteria for use of enforcement options applicable to primary production work if necessary. There were no examples of formal enforcement activity at primary production level.
Internal monitoring and performance review
Internal monitoring and corrective action
Local authorities are required to carry out appropriate quantitative and qualitative internal monitoring (control verification) to verify conformance with legal obligations, official guidance and their own policies and procedures across the full range of service activities including those relating to primary production. All internal monitoring should be recorded and records kept for at least two years under ‘The Standard’ within ‘The Framework Agreement on Official Feed and Food Controls by local authorities’. Such monitoring helps to ensure the effectiveness and consistency of the official controls being delivered.
All local authorities audited provided evidence of their arrangements for undertaking internal monitoring. In relation to FHPP activities, activities were mostly focused on monitoring numbers of interventions. Examples of qualitative monitoring included record checks, one to one meetings and accompanied visits. Some local authorities included a wide range of interventions including primary production whilst others restricted it to higher-risk food hygiene and food standards inspections. All local authorities were found to be taking corrective actions where necessary in response to internal monitoring activities.
Reviewing performance and service delivery
Undertaking formal reviews assessing delivery performance against the previous year’s service plan helps local authorities identify areas for service improvement or service development. All local authorities were reviewing service delivery at least once per year with reviews being reported to senior management and sometimes to Cabinet members. Reviews included outputs across various service delivery areas with variances detailed where appropriate. One local authority specifically identified the need to review interventions and processes for primary production operations. In the service plan reviews undertaken by the remaining local authorities, there was no direct reference to primary production, although primary producers were often included in quantitative monitoring figures with some variances and corresponding actions identified.
Conclusions
Overview
The audit programme provided limited assurance that the sample of local authorities had effective and appropriate arrangements for the delivery of food hygiene controls at primary producers at the time of the audit. Overall, while there are examples of effective practices across the sample of local authorities, the audit programme highlights the need for improvements to ensure a consistent, risk-based approach to food hygiene controls at primary production level.
Each local authority provided a time-bound action plan for the improvements we identified. Annex E summarises the recommendations contained within individual audit reports.
Examples of strengths and good practice that were identified, each with corresponding benefits to service delivery, are listed below.
A summary of areas for local authority improvement and observations for the FSA are also listed below.
Strengths, good practice and Service Delivery Benefits
Internal and External Liason Arrangements
Active, effective internal and external liaison arrangements, collaboration, and communication channels to share information and intelligence on primary producers, assist in identifying primary producers and prioritising food hygiene interventions at primary production level.
Primary Production Delivery Arrangements
Formalising primary production delivery arrangements across a county within a Memorandum of Understanding ensures clarity on delivery arrangements.
Use of MIS Codes
Use of MIS codes to allow easy identification of different types of primary producers, supports proactive and reactive work.
Joint Visits
Joint visits (including inter-authority) to share knowledge in new and more complex work areas benefit officer competency and contingency arrangements.
Establishing Working Groups
Establishing working groups within an authority to support key processes and specialist areas for example, MIS management. These groups serve as effective forums for resolving issues and sharing good practice.
Undertaking Proactive Work
Undertaking proactive work to identify higher-risk primary producers using the links contained within the NEP guidance, helps identify higher-risk primary producers.
Up-to-date Information
Effective use of up-to-date information relating to assurance scheme membership to maintain the accuracy of the MIS and to facilitate a risk-based approach ensures best use of available resources.
Using Questionnaires
Use of a questionnaire to collect relevant information from primary producers such as quantities produced and third-party assurance scheme membership to prioritise primary producers for inspection, supports a risk-based approach.
Using Model Forms
Use of model forms, including those on higher-risk fresh fruit and vegetable producers available through the Agriculture Knowledge Hub page, helps identify relevant hazards and promotes consistency.
Using Food Standards Scotland (FSS) Risk Assessment Tools
Use of available Food Standards Scotland (FSS) risk assessment tools on irrigation water assessment and field worker hygiene, supports a risk-based approach.
Using Feed Delivery Programme Funding
Use of feed delivery programme funding to support food hygiene inspections at primary producers, provides additional resources.
Areas for local authority improvement
Service Planning Consideration
Ensuring that service planning considers food hygiene delivery at primary production level and the resources that are required ensures a risk-based approach to service delivery and the allocation of resources.
Identifying Primary Producers
Identifying primary producers within the local authority area of responsibility and maintaining an up-to-date list of registered primary producers supports a risk-based approach to the delivery of official controls.
Prioritising Primary Producers
Prioritising primary producers based on risk, considering all available information and intelligence, supports a risk-based approach to delivery official controls.
Interventions
Delivering interventions on a risk-basis ensures a targeted risk-based approach to the delivery of official controls.
Documented Procedure
Developing a documented procedure to support food hygiene inspections at primary production level and ensuring implementation provides guidance to authorised officers and ensures consistency of approach.
Audit opinion
Based on the findings from the sample of local authorities assessed, the audit programme has assigned an overall Limited Assurance audit opinion. A full list of audit opinion definitions is contained in Annex F.
Findings for the FSA
Policy/Guidance
Areas for FSA Improvement:
The absence of a standardised risk rating scheme for determining frequencies for food interventions at primary producers was resulting in inconsistencies in the approaches taken by different local authorities.
Areas for FSA Consideration:
- Local authorities were not always considering the demands of this work and associated resource implications as part of their service planning arrangements.
- There was limited guidance available on the small quantity exemptions applicable to different types of primary production establishments which was resulting in inconsistent interpretations by different local authorities.
- In some instances, businesses producing higher-risk fresh produce operating at the level of primary production were not being identified, registered or prioritised for an intervention under the NEPs guidance document.
Training
Areas for FSA Consideration: Local authorities audited would generally find additional food hygiene at primary production training opportunities useful.
Competency Assessment
Areas for FSA Consideration: Authorities raised concerns regarding the complexity and work involved in applying the FSA’s Competency Framework. The revised FSA Competency Standard has been made available to local authorities since these audits were completed.
Annex A: Glossary
Animal and Plant Health Agency (APHA)
An executive agency, sponsored by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, the Welsh Government and The Scottish Government that works to safeguard animal and plant health.
Assurance Scheme
A formal system that sets standards and uses independent checks or audits to provide confidence that agreed standards are being met.
Audit
Audit means a systematic and independent examination to determine whether activities and related results comply with planned arrangements and whether these arrangements are implemented effectively and are suitable to achieve objectives.
Audit and Risk Assurance Committee (ARAC)
The Audit and Risk Assurance Committee (ARAC) is a Committee of the FSA Board and is responsible for reviewing, in a non-executive capacity, the comprehensiveness and reliability of assurances on governance, risk management and the control environment.
Authorised officer
Means a person (whether, or not an officer of the enforcement authority) who is authorised by the competent authority, either generally or specially, to act for matters arising under food law.
British Retail Consortium
A trade association for retail businesses in the UK.
Competent Authority
Has the meaning as defined in article 3(3) of Regulation (EU) 2017/625 to mean the competent authority responsible for the performance of official controls and of other official activities, under that Regulation and the rules referred to in article 1(2).
Earned Recognition
Food and feed business operators who demonstrably maintain high standards of food and feed safety by taking appropriate steps to comply with the law may have these standards recognised by the competent authority when determining the frequency of their official controls and therefore earn recognition.
Enforcement Authority
Has the meaning as defined by regulation 2(1) of The Food Safety and Hygiene (England) Regulations 2013 to mean the authority which is responsible for executing and enforcing the Hygiene Regulations.
Establishment
Has the meaning as defined by article 2(1)(c) of Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 to mean any unit of a food business.
Feed Delivery Programme
Programme designed to ensure local authorities deliver official controls for animal feed in an efficient and consistent manner.
Food Alert
Communication from the FSA to a competent authority concerning a food hazard or other food incident, where specific actions/responses are required to be carried out by the competent authority.
Food Business
Has the meaning as defined by article 3(2) of Regulation (EC) No 178/2002 to mean any undertaking, whether for profit or not and whether public or private, carrying out any of the activities related to any stage of production, processing, and distribution of food.
Food Business Operator (FBO)
Has the meaning as defined by article 3(3) of Regulation (EC) No 178/2002 to mean the natural or legal persons responsible for ensuring that the requirements of food law are met within the food business under their control.
Food Hygiene
The measures and conditions necessary to control hazards and to ensure fitness for human consumption of a foodstuff, taking into account its intended use as set out in Regulation (EC) No 852/2004.
Food Law Code of Practice (England) (FLCoP)
This Code is issued as statutory guidance to local authorities on the enforcement of food legislation.
Food Law Practice Guidance (England) (FLPG)
The Practice Guidance is non-statutory, complements the statutory code of practice, and provides general advice on the approach to enforcement of the law where its intention might be unclear.
Food Standards
The legal requirements covering the safety, labelling, composition and traceability of food.
Food Standards Agency (FSA)
An independent, non-ministerial department, working across England, Wales and Northern Ireland, whose objectives are to protect public health from risks arising from the consumption of food and to protect the interests of consumers in relation to food.
Food Standards Scotland (FSS)
A public sector food body for Scotland whose objectives are: to protect the public from risks to health which may arise in connection with the consumption of food; to improve the extent to which members of the public have diets which are conducive to good health; and to protect the other interests of consumers in relation to food.
Hazard
Has the meaning as defined by article 3(14) of Regulation (EC) No 178/2002 to mean a biological, chemical, or physical agent in, or condition of, food or feed with the potential to cause an adverse health effect.
Higher Risk Fruit and Vegetables
Fruit and vegetables most likely to be contaminated with microbiological risks because post-harvest washing will damage the produce or they have no protective skin and may be eaten raw.
Intelligence
Information that has been evaluated to assess its relevance and reliability, and has been verified where possible.
Intervention
Interventions include official controls and other interventions such as education, advice and coaching, information and intelligence gathering (including sampling where the analysis is not to be carried out by an Official Laboratory).
Lead Food Officer
The authorised lead food officer(s), appointed by the competent authority for food, who demonstrates the relevant competencies.
Linking Environment and Farming
An organisation that promotes sustainable food and farming.
Local Authority (LA)
Has the meaning as defined in section 270 of the Local Government Act 1972 to mean a county council, a district council, a London borough council, or a parish council.
Management Information System (MIS)
A computerised system which collects, stores, processes and delivers information.
Marine Management Organisation (MMO)
An executive non-departmental body of the Department for Environmental, Food and Rural Affairs that licenses and regulates marine activities in the seas.
Memorandum of Understanding
A written agreement on the exchange of information between two or more parties.
National Enforcement Priorities (NEPs)
The NEPs for animal feed and food hygiene at the level of primary production assist Competent Authorities and businesses in maintaining standards and safeguarding public health.
Primary Authority
Has the meaning as defined in and set out in section 25 of the Regulatory Enforcement and Sanctions Act 2008 to mean for a regulated person, a qualifying regulator for the exercise of the partnership functions for that person as nominated by the Secretary of State, or for a regulated group, a qualifying regulator for the exercise of the partnership functions for the members of the group as nominated by the Secretary of State.
Primary Production (Food)
The production, rearing or growing of primary products including harvesting, milking, and farmed animal production before slaughter. It also includes hunting and fishing and harvesting of wild products as defined in article 3(17) of Regulation (EC) No 178/2002.
Red Tractor
An FSA approved assurance scheme. Standards cover animal welfare, food safety and environmental protection.
Sedex Members Ethical Trade Audit
An audit methodology that evaluates an organisation’s ethical, social and environmental practices in its supply chain.
Service Plan
A document produced by a local authority setting out their plans on providing and delivering a food service to the local community.
Annex B: Local authorities audited
The FSA is grateful for the co-operation and assistance provided by the following local authorities who took part in this audit programme:
-
Northumberland County Council
-
Herefordshire Council
-
Swale Borough Council *
-
Maidstone Borough Council *
-
Tunbridge Wells Borough Council *
-
Lincolnshire County Council
-
Mid Devon District Council
-
East Riding of Yorkshire Council
(*Operate a shared food safety service through Mid Kent Environmental Health Services)
Annex C: Audit method
The audits were carried out using a variety of approaches and methodologies:
1) Examination of local authority plans, policies and procedures. This included service plans, evidence of their approval, monitoring, and any review of performance. Relevant policies and procedures providing guidance to officers were reviewed.
2) Use of structured audit protocols and checklists. A range of local authority records including selected interventions were reviewed.
3) Review of information from the local authority food premises database. This included establishment records and risk profiles.
4) Discussions with key personnel. This typically included discussions with the LFO and Heads of Service.
5) A reality visit. Auditors accompanied authorised officers to selected primary producers.
Annex D: Audit team
-
Tracy Hardy, Head of Regulatory Audit
-
Alison Dugan, Senior Regulatory Auditor (Audit programme lead)
-
Jamie McMeeking, Senior Regulatory Auditor (Audit programme lead)
-
Allan Riley, Senior Regulatory Auditor
Food Standards Agency - Regulatory Compliance Division
Annex E: Recommendations raised by audit criteria
Food Service Delivery Plan
Requirement:
- Draw up, document and implement a service delivery plan in conformance with Regulation (EU) 2017/625, the Food Law Code of Practice and Practice Guidance.
- The Authority should:
- i) Set out within its Food Service Delivery Plan how it intends to deliver and resource all official control activity in its areas including for food hygiene at primary production
- ii) Carry out a documented performance review at least once per year considering all service delivery areas. Submit the Plan and performance review for approval to the relevant member forum or relevant senior officer
- iii) Address any variance in meeting the outcome of the previous service delivery plan.
[Regulation (EU) 2017/625, Article 12] [FLCoP Chapter 2, 2.4.3] [FLPG Chapter 2, 2.6.1] [The Standard 3.1, 3.2, 3.3]
Total number of Services:
- 1 (17%)
Documented Policies and Procedures
Requirement:
- The Authority shall ensure that documented policies and procedures are drawn up in conformance with Regulation (EU) 2017/625, the Food Law Code of Practice and Practice Guidance.
- The Authority:
- (i) Ensure documented policies and procedures for carrying out official food controls and related activities for food hygiene at primary production are in place.
- (ii) Ensure that all documented policies and procedures are reviewed and updated at regular intervals, and whenever there are changes to legislation or centrally issued guidance.
- (iii) Ensure that an appropriate control system is in place for documented policies and procedures.
[Regulation (EU) 2017/625, Article 12] [FLCoP Chapter 2, 2.4.1] [FLPG Chapter 2, 2.4] [The Standard 4.1, 4.2]
Total number of Services:
- 1 (17%)
- 2 (33%)
Delivery of Official Controls at Primary Producers
Requirement:
- The Authority shall ensure that they perform official controls at primary producers on a risk basis under documented procedures, using available information and intelligence, in conformance with Regulation (EU) 2017/625, the Food Law Code of Practice and Practice Guidance.
[Regulation (EU) 2017/625, Article 9 &12] [FLCoP, Chapter 2 and 4, 2.4.1, 4.2 and 4.4.3] [Practice Guidance, Chapter 4]
Total number of Services: 4 (67%)
Annex F: Audit opinion definitions
Substantial
The system for delivering official controls demonstrates effective implementation of planned arrangements suitable to achieve the objectives of legal requirements and guidance.
Moderate
The system for delivering official controls requires some improvement to fully demonstrate effective implementation of planned arrangements suitable to achieve the objectives of legal requirements and guidance.
Limited
The system for delivering official controls requires significant improvement to fully demonstrate effective implementation of planned arrangements suitable to achieve the objectives of legal requirements and guidance.
Unsatisfactory
The system for delivering official controls requires substantial improvement to fully demonstrate effective implementation of planned arrangements suitable to achieve the objectives of legal requirements and guidance.