Social housing Right to Manage review
Published 21 October 2026
Applies to England
Executive summary
The Right to Manage (RTM) gives local authority tenants a statutory route to take on responsibility for housing management services through a tenant management organisation (TMO). It can support resident control, local accountability and stronger engagement. However, the RTM framework has not been substantially updated since 2012 and does not reflect current regulatory requirements.
The government committed to review oversight arrangements for delegated management organisations following the Grenfell Tower Inquiry. A 2025 call for evidence found that arm’s length management organisations (ALMOs) were generally working effectively but identified more significant challenges for TMOs. These included unclear roles and responsibilities, outdated agreements, inconsistent information sharing, financial pressures and uncertainty about building safety duties.
The review of the Right to Manage ran from January to June 2026, supported by an expert steering group and broader engagement with landlords, TMOs and sector bodies. It considered how the framework could better support residents to establish and sustain TMOs, while ensuring effective oversight, clear accountability and proportionate safeguards.
The review found that RTM remains an important route for resident empowerment, but take-up has declined and existing TMOs face increasing pressures. Most TMOs are small organisations with limited staffing and volunteer capacity. Stakeholders reported that the set-up process can be complex, awareness is low, and groups often lack access to advice, training and funding.
The review also found that governance and oversight need to be clearer and more proportionate. TMOs vary significantly in size, capacity and the functions they manage. Stakeholders supported a tiered approach, with requirements linked to the scale, complexity and risk associated with the functions they take on.
Clarity of roles and responsibilities was a recurring theme. Management agreements are often outdated and do not always reflect current regulatory or building safety requirements. Responsibilities for repairs, major works, information sharing, emergency planning and building safety can be unclear. Financial transparency was also a concern, with stakeholders raising issues about opaque allowance calculations and rising compliance costs.
Through the Social Housing Bill the government will modernise the RTM framework. The reforms will enable the government to set regulations covering set-up and ongoing operation, proportionate governance with mandatory requirements for ballots and information-sharing, require agreements to be updated on a regular basis, and strengthen intervention powers where there is serious mismanagement or risk to resident safety. The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) will consult before making secondary legislation and updating statutory guidance, including on whether to extend statutory RTM to tenants of private registered providers.
Background
Local authority tenants have a statutory Right to Manage (RTM), through which they can take on responsibility for some or all of their housing management services by forming a tenant management organisation (TMO). TMOs can give residents more choice and control over housing services, but housing management also brings significant responsibilities.
To exercise the Right to Manage, a TMO must put forward a proposal setting out the services it wants to manage. It is then subject to an independent competence assessment and a ballot of affected residents before it can take on management functions, with continuation ballots held every 5 years. Housing association tenants do not have a statutory RTM, but they can use voluntary arrangements. Under any TMO agreement, the registered housing provider remains accountable to the Regulator of Social Housing (RSH).
Current estimates suggest there are around 130 active TMOs in England, managing about 40,000 homes. They vary significantly in size, from small organisations managing around 50 homes to larger TMOs managing more than 1,000 homes.
The statutory Right to Manage was first introduced through the Housing (Right to Manage) Regulations 1994, made under the Housing Act 1985, and is now set out in the Housing (Right to Manage) (England) Regulations 2012, while statutory RTM guidance sets out the detail of how TMOs are established, overseen and governed. The regulations and guidance have not been updated since the proactive consumer regulatory framework for social housing came into effect in 2024, and does not reflect the changes made by the Building Safety Act 2022.
The government response to the Grenfell Tower Inquiry, published in 2025, committed to review oversight arrangements for delegated management organisations. This followed concerns about failings by Kensington and Chelsea Tenant Management Organisation (KCTMO) and wider lessons from the Grenfell Inquiry Phase 2 report that may apply to other delegated management organisations.
Call for Evidence findings
In 2025 MHCLG conducted a call for evidence on delegated management to better understand current systems and processes, and identify areas for clarification or improvement. The call for evidence focused on TMOs and arm’s length management organisations (ALMOs), which are non-profit companies set up by local councils to manage and maintain their social housing stock.
The call for evidence received responses from 11 ALMOs and 13 local authorities with ALMOs, alongside 42 TMOs with local authority landlords, 3 TMOs with housing association landlords, 2 local authorities with TMOs, and 1 housing association with a TMO.
Arm’s length management organisations
The evidence suggested that ALMOs were working effectively, with good performance, governance and outcomes for tenants. Most managed a wide range of housing services, and ALMOs and councils were generally clear about their responsibilities.
All ALMOs had formal agreements in place. Governance arrangements were viewed as adequate by 9 in 10 ALMOs and 6 in 10 local authorities. Lower scores were mainly due to reviews following the introduction of the consumer regulatory reforms in 2024. ALMOs described strong approaches to tenant engagement, complaints handling and staff concerns. Confidence in financial arrangements was high, with all but one ALMO reporting fit-for-purpose audit systems.
The call for evidence did not identify a need for significant reform to the current ALMO framework. Housemark analysis commissioned by the National Federation of ALMOs has found that ALMOs achieve higher than average overall satisfaction in the Tenant Satisfaction Measures.
Tenant management organisations
The evidence regarding TMOs showed more significant challenges. Most responses came from TMOs rather than councils. As such, MHCLG carried out subsequent targeted engagement with local authorities to address gaps in the call for evidence findings. This evidence was factored into the review and a summary of the findings is set out below.
Most TMOs are small organisations, with limited staffing and capacity compared with landlords. The call for evidence found that:
- 83% of respondents managed fewer than 1,000 homes
- 81% employed fewer than 20 staff
- 35% employed only 1 or 2 staff
MHCLG asked about the functions carried out by TMOs and found that all TMO respondents managed repairs and maintenance, 95% estate and grounds maintenance, and 90% tenant engagement and empowerment. Only 17% had responsibility for major works, 26% for service charge calculation and collection, and 48% for emergency planning.
Many TMOs considered the division of responsibilities between TMOs and landlords to be unclear, particularly around building safety measures, major works, emergency planning, and information sharing and reporting. Management agreements did not always reflect the current consumer regulatory framework or building safety requirements. Some respondents also described difficult relationships with their local authorities, including poor communication and information sharing practices.
Many TMOs operated under outdated management agreements. Only 12% had reviewed their agreement in the previous year, and nearly a quarter (24%) had not updated it since the TMO was established. A fifth (19%) of TMOs considered the governance arrangements set out in their agreement to be inadequate; a further 19% were unsure. Only half (52%) had discussed the consumer regulatory framework introduced in 2024 and its implications with their local authority.
The findings also suggested that governance and information-sharing arrangements were not consistently effective. Several TMOs said monitoring arrangements felt one-way: landlords asked TMOs for performance information, but did not always provide equivalent information about landlord performance, planned works, property condition, safety records or decisions affecting services managed by the TMO.
Financial arrangements emerged as a significant concern for TMOs. Half of surveyed TMOs considered arrangements for allowances, management and maintenance costs to be inadequate, while only 36% considered them adequate. Respondents raised concerns that allowance calculations were opaque, budget information was not always shared early enough, and allowances did not always reflect rising compliance costs, including building safety, fire safety, consumer regulation, data protection and health and safety. Some TMOs also reported that smaller organisations face higher overheads and cannot access the same economies of scale as local authorities.
Despite these challenges, TMOs generally demonstrated strong tenant engagement and complaints processes. Respondents described a wide range of routes for residents to raise concerns and influence local services, including board and committee meetings, resident forums, annual general meetings, estate-based staff, newsletters, surveys, drop-in sessions and community events. This evidence suggested that TMOs can support close local engagement with residents, but that clearer support, information sharing, financial transparency and oversight are needed for the model to operate effectively and safely.
Review of the Right to Manage: objectives and scope
Following the call for evidence, the government announced a review of the Right to Manage in January 2026. The review aimed to identify changes needed to primary legislation, regulations and guidance so that:
- residents can more easily take control of their housing services, with simple, accessible processes, and the right support from parent landlords
- TMOs are supported to operate effectively once established, with a shared understanding of clear, straightforward roles and responsibilities
- strong but proportionate oversight protects residents, with councils able to step in when TMOs fail and TMOs able to hold landlords to account through constructive partnership working
- TMOs are properly funded and supported by clear, up-to-date guidance, giving long term certainty and helping them respond to future changes
The review built on findings of the call for evidence on delegated management in 2025 and explored the following themes:
- support for TMOs and set up processes
- the Approved Assessor Service
- governance and accountability
- information sharing and reporting
- functions, including building safety
- financial management
This review considered the operation of the Housing (Right to Manage) (England) Regulations 2012, which set out the statutory process for local authority tenants to form a TMO and take on housing management functions. It should be read alongside the Right to Manage statutory guidance published in 2013.
Evidence gathering
The review of the Right to Manage ran from January to June 2026, supported by an expert steering group made up of TMOs, local authorities, housing associations and representative organisations. The group met nine times between March and July 2026. Steering group members are listed in Appendix 1.
The expert steering group brought together technical expertise and practical experience of using statutory and non-statutory RTM guidance. Members reviewed the existing RTM guidance, provided advice, and recommended improvements to address identified gaps in the regulatory framework. They also recommended policy measures to support greater take-up and effective operation of the Right to Manage.
MHCLG held meetings and site visits with several local authorities and TMOs to gather wider evidence from their different experiences. These meetings and visits focused on the themes in the review scope and gave landlords and TMOs the opportunity to make recommendations. MHCLG also met the National Federation of Tenant Management Organisations (NFTMO) and the National Housing Federation (NHF) to understand the experiences of their members.
Because the building safety regulatory framework has changed significantly, MHCLG commissioned the Adroit Consultancy to review building safety functions in relation to the Right to Manage. The findings, which informed the review and were discussed in detail at the steering group meeting on functions and building safety, are reflected below.
Key findings
Set up and support
The review highlighted a steady decline in the number of TMOs, alongside low levels of new take-up and the closure or reduction in activity of existing organisations. MHCLG examined the setup processes for new TMOs and barriers to new groups coming forward and existing groups taking on more services.
It was reported that:
- awareness of the Right to Manage is low
- the setup process can be complex and time-consuming
- groups lack the support, advice and training needed for the strengthened regulatory framework for social housing
Barriers to set up and continuation
Awareness of the Right to Manage was seen as low among residents and housing providers that did not have existing TMOs. Steering group participants suggested stronger promotion by landlords, better signposting and greater support for resident empowerment would all help to encourage new and existing TMOs.
The review identified barriers to setting up new TMOs, and to continuing or expanding existing TMOs. These included: the complexity of the RTM process; the significant time commitment; limited access to funding, advice and training; difficulties recruiting volunteers; and more complex regulatory requirements. Formal refusals of RTM proposals were described as uncommon, with groups more likely to disengage because of limited support or external pressures.
Steering group members said setting up a TMO can take much longer than statutory timescales because of the consultation, training and capacity-building needed. They suggested there was a need for more flexible timescales for set-up, whilst maintaining safeguards against unnecessary delays.
They also stressed the need for clear respective responsibilities whilst TMOs are being developed and established, so that TMOs do not inherit a backlog of unresolved service issues when they begin full operation.
Consultation
The review highlighted the importance of consultation with residents when establishing TMOs. Participants saw consultation as a way to give legitimacy to the TMO and confirm resident support. Steering group feedback showed that consultation outcomes also help clarify which management functions residents want to take on, reducing later disagreements about management agreements.
Extending RTM to private registered providers
The review considered extending statutory RTM arrangements to tenants of private registered providers. Steering group members noted that housing association tenants currently rely on voluntary arrangements, creating an uneven position compared with local authority tenants. Some stakeholders supported looking again at statutory extension, arguing that social tenants should have comparable routes to local control regardless of landlord type. However, participants also highlighted issues that would need careful consideration, including housing associations’ different legal, funding and governance models, risk appetite, regulatory accountability and experience of stock transfers. Housing association participants reported limited recent demand, but supported further engagement to explore a workable approach for residents and providers. The government has committed to holding a consultation before deciding whether to extend the statutory RTM to tenants of private registered providers.
Role of leaseholders
Participants also raised questions about leaseholder involvement under the current social housing Right to Manage. Stakeholders agreed the current position can be unclear and can lead to disputes, especially regarding non-resident leaseholders and private tenants living in leasehold properties. Some participants told us they saw this as a growing problem, especially for TMOs in central London where properties were increasingly being made available for short-term lets.
However, there was no consensus on what rights and roles these types of residents should have within TMOs. Some supported stronger rights for non-resident leaseholders, recognising that they pay service charges and have a financial interest in the property. Others favoured local discretion for TMOs to set their own rules, with some concerns that non-resident leaseholders’ interests may differ from those of resident tenants.
Approved Assessor Service
Approved Assessors are appointed by the Secretary of State to assess whether a TMO is competent to take on the management functions proposed under the statutory RTM process. Once a local authority has accepted a TMO’s proposal notice, the TMO must request the appointment of an Approved Assessor. The independent assessor then reports on whether the TMO is competent and may recommend actions for the TMO and authority if further development is needed. In recent years, there has been little demand for this service and the number of Approved Assessors has diminished.
National oversight
The steering group considered whether the Approved Assessor Service should remain centrally managed, move to local government, sit with an arm’s length body, or be delivered by another sector body.
Stakeholders felt it was important that the model for managing the Service ensured the independence of individual Assessors and consistency across the Service, in order to maintain confidence in the process. There was limited support for a local government-led model, including models using agreements between neighbouring authorities. This was because councils are one party in the RTM relationship, so a local government-led model could create real or perceived conflicts of interest and could undermine trust at the start of the relationship.
There was little support for a representative sector body leading the service because this could affect perceived independence. However, stakeholders recognised that sector bodies could support training, advice and engagement to help maximise the value delivered by the Service.
Participants were supportive of national oversight through central government or an existing arm’s length body. Some favoured a role for the Regulator of Social Housing, but others felt that the Approved Assessor function must be separate from the regulatory role.
Competence, quality and training
The group supported retaining competence assessments and suggested Approved Assessors could also help check management agreements before a TMO goes live, support arbitration and provide clear routes for mediation and appeal for established TMOs.
Participants also highlighted the need to refresh the pool of Approved Assessors. They suggested there was a need for new Assessors to have clearer training, accreditation, quality assurance and access to specialist advice, particularly on complex areas such as building safety, finance and governance.
Governance and accountability
The review considered how accountability for TMOs could be made clearer and more proportionate, taking into account the variable functions held by TMOs, volunteer capacity and councils’ continuing accountability to the Regulator of Social Housing. Stakeholders reported that:
- roles and responsibilities between TMOs and councils can be unclear, especially where accountability overlaps
- governance expectations can feel disproportionate where TMOs manage limited or lower-risk functions
- management agreements may be outdated or fail to reflect current regulatory and building safety requirements
- volunteer-led committees can face capacity pressures, including on renewal of Board membership, ensuring continuity through change of membership and achieving the necessary mix of skills and knowledge
Oversight arrangements
The review found mixed support for prescribing uniform governance requirements. Some participants saw value in establishing broad baseline expectations for constitutions and codes of practice for every TMO to improve consistency and oversight, while others warned against an overly prescriptive ‘one size fits all’ approach.
Tiered model
The existing modular framework allows TMOs to choose which functions they take on, ranging from a small number of lower-risk functions, such as grounds maintenance, to the full housing management service. Review participants felt that governance and compliance requirements can be disproportionate where organisations manage a limited range of lower risk functions.
Participants felt that a more flexible and proportionate approach to governance and oversight within the RTM framework would address some of the barriers to setting up a new TMO. The review considered a graduated approach which it was felt could make it easier for more tenants to establish a TMO and build their skills and confidence over time, whereby TMOs could choose to start by managing a range of lower-risk functions which would be subject to lighter-touch governance and oversight arrangements. Stronger requirements would apply for TMOs carrying out complex and higher-risk functions. It was proposed that TMOs should be able to take on additional responsibilities over time and hand back functions more easily where circumstances change, with governance and oversight adjusted accordingly. Steering Group members broadly supported this approach.
Clarifying responsibilities and agreements between the parties
The review found that councils varied in their capacity to oversee and support TMOs. Participants agreed that guidance should clarify the respective roles and responsibilities of TMOs and councils, including areas where accountability can blur, such as delivery of repairs and replacement services. Participants recommended that management agreements should be clearly distinguished from internal TMO governance documents, and agreed that both should support transparent decision-making and accountability to residents.
Review participants considered how RTM documentation and guidance can be made clearer and remain effective as statutory requirements change. The Adroit review found that management agreements were often not keeping pace with building safety legislation and regulation. Participants broadly supported requiring all TMOs to adopt an updated Modular Management Agreement (MMA), to promote consistency with current regulatory expectations while retaining operational flexibility. RTM guidance should reflect the current regulatory environment and signpost to wider relevant guidance, for example on building safety requirements and responsibilities, in a way that allows for future changes to be incorporated.
Committee renewal and continuation ballots
The review found differing views on term limits for TMO chairs and committee members. While some felt limits could encourage renewal and strengthen resident engagement, others warned they could affect stability where volunteer recruitment is difficult and term limits were not imposed in comparable roles. Steering group participants agreed any approach should reflect volunteer capacity and the diversity of TMO governance models.
Information sharing and reporting
The review considered how clearer information-sharing and reporting expectations could support effective TMO oversight, transparency and compliance, including in relation to the forthcoming extension of the coverage of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOI Act) to TMOs. Stakeholders report that:
- information sharing between councils and TMOs was inconsistent and there was uncertainty about what information should be shared, when and how
- TMOs did not always receive timely input on decisions affecting their services
- smaller TMOs often lacked specialist capacity to manage data protection and reporting requirements
- performance monitoring is inconsistent and can create burden if not applied proportionately
Clear and consistent standards
Review participants reported inconsistent and often one-way information sharing between councils and TMOs. Some TMO representatives said councils often consulted them only after decisions affecting their services had been made. Participants recommended strengthening consultation expectations, clarifying which policies need TMO input, especially on building safety, and requiring councils to show how they have considered feedback.
The review found a need for clearer minimum expectations on what information should be shared, when and how. This includes core data on property condition, tenants and arrears. Guidance should also cover data quality, how often information is shared, and secure systems compliant with the UK General Data Protection Regulation (UK GDPR). It should remain proportionate for smaller TMOs using simpler local systems.
Participants noted that all TMOs must meet data protection requirements, but smaller organisations often lack specialist capacity. Updated guidance should clarify shared data ownership and responsibilities, reflect current legislation, and include practical examples, model agreements and minimum standards for TMOs using landlord systems or operating independently.
Information sharing requirements related to building safety responsibilities are covered in the Functions chapter below.
Performance reporting
Participants highlighted the need for effective performance monitoring, including checklists, reporting mechanisms and key performance indicators (KPIs), while avoiding unnecessary burdens that could affect service delivery. TMO representatives suggested that governance benchmarks should remain flexible and focus on engagement and capability-building rather than numerical targets alone.
Participants wanted clearer guidance on collecting, interpreting and reporting performance information without adding unnecessary burden. Participants highlighted that performance monitoring frameworks are applied inconsistently across TMO-landlord relationships, with varying approaches to reporting requirements and KPIs. Participants said it was important to distinguish regulatory requirements from local indicators, to clarify who should be collecting and reviewing Tenant Satisfaction Measures (TSMs) data, and for landlords and TMOs to work together to jointly review TSMs and carry out proportionate, risk-based verification of this and other relevant data. Guidance should also avoid duplicating regulatory requirements.
Liaison and escalation
It was reported that liaison officer arrangements were inconsistent. Some TMOs lacked a named contact or clear escalation route. Participants felt there was a need for clearer expectations and guidance on minimum competencies, regular structured meetings between TMOs and liaison officers and continuity arrangements such as a named alternative contact within the landlord to minimise the disruption of TMO staff absences and turnover. They also recognised that this could create resource pressures and wanted to see better resourcing for the liaison officer role.
Freedom of Information Act 2000
Alongside this review, the government’s response to the Grenfell Tower Inquiry Phase 2 report, published in February 2025, confirmed that we would extend the coverage of the FOI Act to TMOs. The government has now confirmed that it will proceed with the extension of the FOI Act to TMOs from April 2027, following a targeted consultation with the sector earlier this year. This extension will complement the reforms set out in this review by supporting greater transparency and access to information about housing management services and ensuring tenants have a mechanism to hold those who manage their homes to account. Further information on the consultation outcome and next steps is available: Tenant management organisations: extension of the Freedom of Information Act.
Financial management
The review considered how to strengthen financial management arrangements for TMOs. Evidence focused on allowances, which are the mechanism through which landlords provide funding to TMOs to deliver the services they manage. It also covered oversight of reserves and surpluses, and the additional support TMOs may need to manage more complex regulatory and compliance requirements. Stakeholders reported that:
- allowance calculations were often seen as opaque and difficult to scrutinise
- budget information and landlord assumptions were not always shared clearly or early enough
- allowances did not always reflect rising compliance costs or the higher costs smaller TMOs can face
- guidance on reserves, surpluses, closure and dissolution was seen as inconsistent or unclear
Allowances
The most common issue was the calculation of TMO allowances, which are based on the amount the housing provider would have otherwise spent on managing those homes. Stakeholders said the methodology is often opaque, technical and understood by only a small number of specialists. This makes it difficult for TMOs to scrutinise assumptions or challenge calculations where costs may have been missed. Several TMOs said this lack of transparency creates mistrust and disputes, particularly where allowance discussions happen late or landlords do not provide detailed cost-centre information.
There was broad support for clearer guidance, more standardised calculations and earlier, collaborative budget discussions. TMOs wanted greater transparency on budget lines, cost centres, apportionment and landlord assumptions about demand, staffing, overheads and service standards. Some landlords felt existing worksheets and open-book approaches can provide sufficient transparency when used consistently, but TMO experiences varied, suggesting a need for clearer minimum expectations on information sharing and processes.
TMO stakeholders also said allowances have not kept pace with rising compliance costs, including building safety, fire safety, data protection, consumer regulation, procurement, health and safety, and wider compliance requirements. Smaller TMOs were seen as particularly exposed because they have less capacity to absorb unexpected costs, commission advice or spread overheads across a larger stock base. Some stakeholders questioned whether the formula needs reform, while others felt the priority is regular review and updating when legal, regulatory or service requirements change.
The review also heard that TMOs can face higher costs than landlords because they cannot access the same economies of scale, corporate systems or in-house expertise. Examples included insurance, information technology systems, human resources support, professional advice, training and compliance services.
Remuneration
The review found no consensus on whether TMO board or committee members should be paid. Those in favour argued that modest remuneration could help attract skilled volunteers, recognise responsibilities and reflect practice elsewhere in housing governance. Those opposed were concerned it could undermine the volunteer ethos, create conflicts or dependency, or affect receipt of benefits.
Training and support
Participants highlighted the need for ongoing support with financial management as part of a wider skills and capacity training offer. Stakeholders differed on who should provide it, with suggestions including landlords, central government, representative bodies, Approved Assessors, and peer support from experienced TMOs.
Several stakeholders raised concerns that TMOs may seek to take on as many functions as possible to increase their allowances, but some functions may not be financially viable because the allowances given do not reflect the true cost of delivery. Examples included service charge administration, leaseholder billing and arrears management, where responsibilities were considered to be complex and resource intensive. Review participants said TMOs need better tools to assess whether functions are affordable before transfer, including guidance on likely costs, risks and minimum systems or expertise required.
Resilience and insolvency
Financial resilience was another recurring theme. Stakeholders highlighted risks for very small TMOs with limited staffing, where a single absence or vacancy can delay or prevent a TMO delivering essential functions and services. Some favoured clearer landlord obligations to provide temporary practical support or take back some functions for a period of time, for example, where a small TMO’s staff member goes on long-term sick leave. Others preferred flexible local arrangements or felt that the focus should be on ensuring existing support provisions from the council were better understood and consistently used.
The review also identified a need for clearer insolvency arrangements, including early warning triggers, intervention routes and guidance reflecting modern insolvency law. Views differed on whether company law is sufficient or whether specific TMO procedures are needed.
Surpluses and reserves
Surpluses and reserves were another area where stakeholders wanted clearer guidance. Many said there is confusion about the distinction between a prudent reserve to manage future risks, an operational underspend, and a surplus available for reinvestment. Stakeholders wanted more consistency in how surpluses are reported, how reserves are assessed, and how historic surpluses should be treated. Some emphasised TMOs’ autonomy to spend surpluses on estate improvements, while others were concerned about large sums accumulating without clear plans in the event of closure. Strong joint planning was seen as essential to invest surpluses effectively.
Stakeholders raised concerns about what happens to TMO funds when an organisation closes or dissolves. Existing arrangements were described as inconsistent, with some respondents concerned that large sums can remain unused for long periods. Some felt constitutions provide sufficient safeguards, while others argued that they can be outdated and should not be relied on as the main protection. There was broad support for clearer guidance on closure, dissolution and remaining funds.
Leasehold charges
Mixed-tenure estates create additional financial and governance challenges. Stakeholders noted the growing number of leaseholders and non-resident leaseholders on TMO estates. This has made service charge administration, leaseholder billing, participation rights, recharging and accountability more complex. Views differed on how much influence non-resident leaseholders should have over decisions, but there was broad agreement that guidance should be clearer.
Overall, the strongest areas of consensus were that allowance calculations should be more transparent and better reflect compliance costs; TMOs need stronger support with governance and financial management; clearer guidance is needed on surpluses and reserves, closure and dissolution; and better information sharing between landlords and TMOs is essential.
Functions and building safety
The review considered how housing management functions set out in management agreements can be clearly defined, kept proportionate and updated as regulation changes. Stakeholders reported that:
- compliance requirements have increased, creating capacity pressures
- there was a lack of clarity about who holds building and fire safety duties
- repairs, major works and cyclical maintenance are categorised inconsistently across agreements
- information on works, property condition and safety records is not always shared early enough
Management functions
Participants supported retaining the current functions TMOs can manage, but said clearer definitions, stronger guidance and more easily updated management agreements are needed, particularly for smaller TMOs.
Stakeholders described a growing cumulative compliance burden over the past decade. Some TMOs had handed back functions because of these pressures and several stakeholders reported that landlords are becoming more risk averse. Councils and housing providers described this as necessary to meet regulatory duties and protect residents, while TMOs more often saw it as reducing resident control where functions had been removed or were no longer delegated.
Some participants said capacity is often a bigger issue than willingness or ability: small TMOs may understand the requirements but lack staff, specialist advice or systems to evidence compliance. Some wanted the framework to better recognise the operational realities for small resident-led organisations, while others stressed that regulatory expectations should not be lowered. Practical support from councils and landlords, including training, specialist advice, shared services, systems and compliance expertise, was seen as essential, although views differed on whether councils should have stronger support duties.
Advanced functions in a tiered model
As noted in the section on governance, review participants supported a proportionate, staged approach to the delegation of service delivery and associated functions, which can be described as a tiered model. This would allow TMOs to start with lower-risk services and take on more complex services only where they have the necessary capacity and skills, and appropriate oversight arrangements in place.
Some councils and housing providers felt higher-risk functions should bring stronger governance, monitoring and competence requirements. Those stakeholders also favoured mandatory reassessment for competency by an Approved Assessor for safety-critical repairs, contractors or major works, while some TMO stakeholders warned that requirements should remain proportionate and not discourage volunteers or make small TMOs unviable.
Building safety
Building safety was one of the strongest themes in this part of the review, reflecting changes introduced through the Building Safety Act 2022 and related reforms. These created new legal duties for landlords and, in some circumstances, TMOs. Stakeholders said it is unclear who is responsible for building safety duties when management functions are delegated, and that management agreements are often not specific enough.
Views differed on how far building safety functions should be delegated. Some councils and housing providers argued that higher-risk responsibilities should largely remain with landlords because they retain ultimate regulatory accountability. Some TMO representatives felt TMOs should continue to take on some building safety-related functions where responsibilities are clear, competence is demonstrated and support is available. There was broad agreement that safety standards should not be reduced.
Duty holders
Adroit’s analysis found that a TMO’s building and fire safety duties depend on its agreement, functions and building type. Duty holders or ‘responsible persons’ are the people or organisations legally responsible for meeting specific safety duties. TMOs may have responsibilities as a responsible person under fire safety legislation or, for higher-risk buildings, as an Accountable Person under the Building Safety Act. The review found uncertainty over duty-holder roles where TMOs manage repairs, major works or buildings. Management agreements often do not align statutory roles with contractual responsibilities or new regulatory requirements.
Repairs and major works
The review heard widespread concern that repairs and major works categories are not clear enough. Terms such as day-to-day repairs, major repairs, major works, cyclical repairs and planned maintenance are used inconsistently. Adroit also found significant variation between agreements, with responsibilities depending on whether works were routine repairs, construction work or notifiable building work constituting major works. Building safety activities such as fire alarms, fire doors and fire stopping were often not clearly categorised.
The review found wide variation in the thresholds used by TMOs and providers to determine who was responsible for building safety-related works. Some stakeholders supported financial thresholds to reduce disputes, while others felt they do not adequately capture risk or complexity. Stakeholders suggested updating RTM guidance to reflect legal changes, explicitly include building safety works, and provide clearer examples of cyclical maintenance, safety checks, shared-area repairs and major works.
The review also identified a need for clearer signposting to building safety legislation that may apply to TMO repairs and major works. Detailed guidance is already available from MHCLG, the Building Safety Regulator and the Health and Safety Executive (HSE). However, users of the RTM framework would benefit from clearer explanations of when and how those requirements apply to TMOs.
Information sharing
Information sharing and monitoring were also recurring issues regarding building safety. TMOs said they are not always told about landlord works, property condition information, repair records, certificates, surveys or planned investment early enough to plan effectively. Some landlords felt existing arrangements were sufficient, but many TMOs said information is often late or missing. Shared IT systems were generally viewed positively, although smaller TMOs warned they can be disproportionate. Stakeholders also wanted clearer guidance on contractor competence and assurance, especially for safety-critical work.
Overall, the key conclusions of the review were that responsibilities and duty holders need clearer definition in management agreements; repairs, major works and cyclical maintenance definitions should be updated; a tiered model could better align functions with risk and competence; and stronger information sharing and specialist advice are needed.
Review conclusions
The Right to Manage remains an important route for resident control and empowerment, but the current framework needs to be modernised so it remains viable, safe and effective. Evidence gathered through the review showed that take-up has declined, existing TMOs face a range of increasing pressures, and the current regulations and guidance have not kept pace with regulatory changes. The review findings point to the need for action on several aspects of the RTM framework:
Support residents to establish and sustain TMOs
Evidence showed that low awareness, complex processes, limited access to advice and training, and increasing regulatory requirements can make it difficult for residents to establish new TMOs or expand existing ones. Formal refusals of Right to Manage proposals were described as uncommon, but groups could disengage because of limited support, the time commitment involved, or wider capacity pressures.
This points to the need to raise awareness and ensure processes for taking up the Right to Manage are as clear and straightforward as possible, for better support during set-up, and more flexible arrangements that allow organisations to take on functions that match their capacity and capability.
Proportionate governance and oversight
The evidence showed that TMOs vary significantly in size, staffing and the functions they manage. Most are small organisations, and many rely heavily on volunteers. Stakeholders supported stronger governance and oversight where TMOs manage higher-risk or more complex functions but warned that a single set of requirements could place unnecessary burdens on smaller TMOs or those managing lower-risk services.
The review concluded that the framework should therefore support a more graduated approach, with tailored oversight and governance expectations linked to the scale, complexity and risk of the functions being managed.
Greater clarity of roles and responsibilities
The review found that responsibilities between TMOs and landlords are not always clear, particularly where accountability overlaps on repairs, major works, and building safety. Management agreements are often outdated and may not reflect current consumer regulation or building safety requirements.
The review concluded that there is a need to update regulations, statutory guidance and the Modular Management Agreement, to provide greater clarity and consistency; and that all Management Agreements should be updated within a specified time frame, and then at regular intervals thereafter. Mandatory terms on ballot arrangements, information sharing, and co-operation with regulatory standards will be implied in existing agreements.
Improved transparency and accountability
The review found that performance monitoring and information sharing arrangements are inconsistent. TMOs do not always receive timely information on decisions affecting their services, works, property condition or safety records. Stakeholders also reported uncertainty about what information should be shared, when it should be shared, and how landlord and TMO engagement should work in practice.
Clearer expectations are needed on performance reporting, liaison arrangements, escalation routes and information sharing. This is important for effective oversight, transparency, service delivery and building safety. The detail of changes should be considered through consultation and could be delivered through changes to the regulations, Modular Management Agreement, and/or guidance.
Financial transparency and resilience
Stakeholders raised widespread concerns about financial arrangements. Allowance calculations can be opaque and difficult to scrutinise, budget information is not always shared clearly or early enough, and allowances do not always reflect rising compliance costs or the higher costs faced by smaller TMOs. The evidence also identified the need for clearer guidance on reserves, surpluses, closure, dissolution and financial resilience.
This points to the need for financial arrangements to be more transparent, sustainable and easier to understand. TMOs should have better information about how allowances are calculated, clearer routes to discuss costs and risks before functions transfer, and more consistent guidance on reserves and closure arrangements. These issues should be considered further through consultation and could be addressed through updated guidance.
Stronger safeguards against mismanagement
Landlords and some residents told us that stronger mechanisms are needed where there is serious mismanagement, governance failure or risk to residents. Stakeholders recognised the importance of preserving resident control but reported that landlords need clearer and more effective routes to intervene where serious problems arise and proportionate local action has not resolved them.
The evidence demonstrated the case for stronger safeguards for residents where serious failures occur. This supports the case for amendments creating a court-backed intervention route, allowing action such as removing officers, transferring functions or ending agreements where this is necessary and proportionate.
Knowledge gap within existing TMOs
The review highlighted a lack of knowledge and understanding among existing TMOs following significant changes in recent years to regulatory requirements and statutory legal duties. Many TMO board members are volunteers and may not have updated their knowledge to reflect recent reforms.
The review concluded that bespoke, role-specific training could help residents build the skills and confidence to take up the Right to Manage, whilst for existing TMOs, it identified a need for targeted training and support to help strengthen Board members’ skills and knowledge, for example with respect to regulatory and building safety requirements.
Next steps
The government is reforming the statutory Right to Manage following the review. The reforms will make it easier for residents to take control of housing services and will improve support, oversight and accountability.
The government has brought forward amendments to the Social Housing Bill to update the Right to Manage framework. The amendments will:
- give regulation-making powers allowing the government to make regulations on both the set-up and ongoing operation of TMOs
- enable the introduction of proportionate governance through a tiered governance model so oversight matches the scale, complexity and risk of the functions a TMO manages
- require managements agreements to be updated on a regular basis, helping to ensure they stay up to date with legal, regulatory and safety requirements
- introduce mandatory requirements, which will be implied into existing agreements, for ballot arrangements, information-sharing, and co-operate with meeting regulatory standards
- strengthen intervention powers, creating a court-backed route for serious mismanagement or risks to resident safety, including removing officers, transferring functions or ending agreements where necessary and proportionate
The government will consult before making secondary legislation and updating statutory guidance. The consultation will also consider whether to extend the statutory Right to Manage to tenants of private registered providers.
To address the identified knowledge and skills gaps within the TMO sector, the government will provide funding for a targeted training package through the NFTMO. This dedicated training programme will be for existing TMO board members, many of whom are volunteers and may not have up to date knowledge on recent changes in social housing regulation, governance expectations, and building and fire safety requirements. The aim is for the training programme to reach at least one board member in each TMO.
Appendix 1: Expert steering group members
Trade and representative bodies
- National Federation of Tenant Management Organisations
- Association of Directors of Housing (ADoH)
- Confederation of Co-operative Housing (CCH)
- National Housing Federation
- Association of Retained Council Housing (ARCH)
TMOs
- Bushbury Hill
- Blenheim Gardens
- New Barracks
- Pembroke Estate Management Board
- D’Eynsford
- Glebe Court
Landlords
- London Borough of Southwark
- London Borough of Lambeth
- London Borough of Islington
- A large housing association
- Plymouth Community Homes
- Birmingham City Council
- City of Wolverhampton Council