Water or Brine to Water Heat Pumps

1.1           Scope

Water or Brine to Water Heat Pump systems are specifically designed to transfer heat from the ground or surface water to a water-based heating system by means of a refrigeration cycle.

The liquid heat transferring medium for the heat pump may be brine or water.

In a brine to water heat pump, the heat is collected from the ground or surface water by circulating a solution of water and anti-freeze (known as ‘brine’) through a buried or submerged, closed-loop, ground heat exchanger.

In a water to water heat pump, the heat is collected from ground water (aquifer) or surface water by circulating the water through a direct, open-loop heat exchanger.

1.2           Definitions

Water or Brine to Water Heat Pumps use an electrically operated refrigeration system to transfer heat from the ground or surface water into a water-based heating system. They can be used to provide space heating in a wide range of buildings, and some products may be also able to provide cooling by reversing the refrigeration cycle within the product.

Products which are designed to be used for a water heat source without the use of an intermediate circuit, i.e. direct open-loop system, are classified as water to water heat pumps. All others are classified as brine to water heat pumps. The Energy Technology List (ETL) Scheme aims to encourage the purchase of higher efficiency water or brine to water heat pumps, which can be used to realise substantial reductions in carbon emissions.

1.3           Requirements

To be eligible for inclusion on the ETL, products shall meet the requirements as set out below.

1.3.1       Eligibility requirements

To be eligible, products shall:

• Consist of a single factory-built unit.
• Incorporate an electrically driven refrigeration system that uses a refrigerant which has a Global Warming Potential (GWP) ≤ 750.
• Be designed to use an indirect, closed-loop ground heat exchanger, indirect, closed-loop surface water heat exchanger or a direct, open-loop ground or surface water heat source.
• Be designed for, and include fittings for, permanent installation.
• Have an appropriate Conformity Assessment mark.

1.3.2       Performance requirements

Eligible products shall meet the relevant performance criteria set out in Table 1.1 below for:

• Seasonal Space Heating Energy Efficiency (η_s,h ) as defined by Commission Regulation (EU) No 813/2013.
• Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) for average climate conditions, where the product is designed to provide cooling.

Table 1.1    Performance thresholds for water or brine to water heat pumps

	Product Category	Heating mode (ηs,h)	Cooling mode (SEER)
1.	Brine to water heat pumps	≥150%	≥5.00
2.	Water to water heat pumps	≥185%	≥5.00

"≥" means "greater than or equal to"

1.3.3    Information requirements

Supplier shall report the following parameters for each model, which will be published on the ETL Product Search:

• Whether the model has ‘smart features’. Specifically, this includes the capability to provide information on whether the products are ‘smart ready’ without the replacement or addition of any hardware, which includes the following one or more options:
  1. Demand Side Response Ready
  2. Date Collection Ready, which includes:
     • Storing data on the heat pump or a remote device.
     • The ability to store data for each calendar year as a value per day, per month or per year.
     • The following real time value parameters: electricity energy consumption (kWh); heat delivered (kWh); energy efficiency performance; operating times (days, hrs); number of on/off cycles.
• The SCOP for products with an efficiency performance presented in: η_s,h
• The η_s,c for products with a performance criteria posed in: SEER. 

1.4           Measurement and Calculations

1.4.1       Energy efficiency metrics

Seasonal energy efficiency metrics are used, and should be measured for the ‘Average’ heating season, as defined in Ecodesign Commission Regulation (EU) 813/2013 and the harmonised standard BS EN 14825:2022:

Seasonal Coefficient Of Performance (SCOP) – overall coefficient of performance of a heat pump using electricity, representative of the heating season, calculated as the reference annual heating demand divided by the annual energy consumption for heating. For avoidance of doubt this efficiency metric is to be presented at medium temperature operations (Water Flow Temperature of 55 ^oC for medium & high temperature air to water heat pumps and 35 ^oC for low temperature air to water heat pumps) at Average Climatic Conditions.

Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) – ratio of the total cooling capacity to the effective power input of the unit, calculated as the reference cooling demand divided by the annual energy consumption for cooling. For avoidance of doubt this efficiency metric is to be presented at medium temperature operations, (Water Flow Temperature of 55 ^oC for medium & high temperature air to water heat pumps and 35 ^oC for low temperature air to water heat pumps) at Average Climatic Conditions.

Seasonal Space Heating Efficiency (η_s,h) – ratio between the space heating demand for reference heating season, supplied by a space heater and the annual primary energy consumption required to meet this demand. For avoidance of doubt this efficiency metric is to be presented at medium temperature operations (Water Flow Temperature of 55 ^oC for medium & high temperature air to water heat pumps and 35 ^oC for low temperature air to water heat pumps) at Average Climatic Conditions

The equation for calculating η_s,h  corresponds to section 8.2 of BS EN 14825:2022:

(1) η_s,h = SCOP/CC - F1 - F2

Seasonal Space Cooling Energy Efficiency (η_s,c) – ratio between the space cooling demand for reference cooling season supplied and annual primary energy consumption required to meet that demand, as defined by BS EN 14825: 2022.

The equation for calculating η_s,c corresponds to section 5.2 of BS EN 14825:2022:

(2) η_s,c = SEER/CC - F1 - F2

Primary energy consumption for electricity usage is obtained using Conversion Coefficient (CC), known also as Primary Energy Factor, equal to 2.5, as defined by Ecodesign Commission regulation (EU) 813/2013.

Correction factor (F1) is correction that accounts for a negative contribution to the seasonal space heating energy efficiency of heaters due to adjusted contributions of temperature controls, equal to 3% (BS EN 14825:2022).

Correction factor (F2) is correction that accounts for a negative contribution to the seasonal space heating energy efficiency of heaters due to electricity consumption of brine and water pumps, equal to 5% (BS EN 14825:2022).

Reference heating season, also called climate – a set of operating conditions describing per bin the combination of outdoor temperatures and the number of hours these temperatures occur for heating for which the unit is declared fit for purpose There are three reference heating seasons: “A” average, “C” colder and “W” warmer. UK is located in two reference zones: A and W, but for the ETL purposes “A” for average is to be used.

1.4.2       Test Requirements

No additional testing requirements beyond the measurement standard below.

1.4.3       Measurement standards

Performance data shall be determined and the η_s,h calculated, following the requirements of Commission Regulation (EU) No 813/2013, Annex III, and the procedures detailed in BS EN 14825:2022 “Air conditioners, liquid chilling packages and heat pumps, with electrically driven compressors, for space heating and cooling – Testing and rating at part load conditions and calculation of seasonal performance.”, at the specific conditions specified in Table 1.2. 

Table 1.2    Measurement conditions for water or brine to water heat pumps ​​​

	Product Category	Heating mode (ηs,h )	Cooling mode (SEER)
1.	Brine to water heat pumps	BS EN 14825: 2022, Table 14, at Average Climate Conditions. Rated capacity (kW):  Commission Regulation (EU) No 813/2013, Annex III, Table 3.	BS EN 14825:2022, Table 5, cooling tower application and cooling floor application, at Average Climatic Conditions. Rated capacity (kW):  BS EN 14511-2:2022, Table 11
2.	Water to water heat pumps	BS EN 14825: 2022, Table 14, at Average Climate Conditions. Rated capacity (kW): Commission Regulation (EU) No 813/2013, Annex III, Table 3.	BS EN 14825:2022 Table 5, cooling tower application, at Average Climatic Conditions. Rated capacity (kW):  BS EN 14511-2:2022, Table 11.

Please note that performance data obtained in accordance with the procedures and conditions laid down in BS EN 14825:2016 and BS EN 14825:2018 will be accepted as an alternative to testing in accordance with BS EN 14825:2022 until further notice.

The seasonal coefficient of performance (SCOP) shall be determined according to the calculation methods in BS EN 14825:2022.

Where results are determined by calculation then this should be on the basis of design and/or extrapolation. In this case, details of such calculations and/or extrapolations, and of tests to verify the accuracy of the calculations undertaken (including details of the mathematical model for calculating performance of such combinations, and of measurements taken to verify this model) shall be made available. Tests undertaken to verify the accuracy of the calculations shall be carried out in accordance with the test procedures described above.

1.4.4       Rounding 

For the avoidance of doubt test data should be presented to zero decimal places for percentage points in η_s,h values and to two decimal places for SEER indicators. As an example, a brine to water heat pump with a heating mode performance η_s,h of 149.4% and a SEER value of 4.994 would be deemed to be a fail.

1.5           Verification for ETL Listing

There are five main ways that applicants can demonstrate their product’s performance:

• In-house testing – Self-certified
• In-house testing – Self-tested and verified or cross-checked by an independent body
• Witnessed testing
• Independent testing
• Representative testing (see clause 1.5.1)

Further information regarding the first three routes can be found in the ETL Testing Framework.

1.5.1       Representative Testing

Where applications are being made for a range of products that are variants of the same basic design, test data may be submitted for a representative model, provided that all variants, i.e. models, share following characteristic features:

• Use the same refrigerant
• Have the same compressor type (i.e. manufacturer, line of models), which should imply:
  • same method of compression (e.g. reciprocating or scroll) and
  • same type of enclosure (e.g. hermetic or semi-hermetic)
• Are powered using same configuration of inverters.

The representative models may be selected by dividing the range of products into groups of models with similar design characteristics. The performance of each model shall be predicted using a validated mathematical model. At least one model in each group shall be tested for validation purposes. A report documenting performed model calculations, showing all significant calculation steps, shall be submitted with the application.

It should be noted that:

• If a manufacturer voluntarily removes the representative model from the ETL then other products linked with that representative model may or may not be permitted to remain on the ETL.
• If any product submitted under these representative model rules is later found not to meet the performance criteria when independently tested, then all products based on the same representative model will be removed from the ETL.

1.6           Conformity testing

Products listed on the ETL may be subject to the scheme’s conformity testing programme in order to ensure listed models continue to meet the ETL requirements.

1.7           Review

1.7.1       Indicative review date

The next technical review is scheduled for 2025-26.

1.7.2       Illustrative future direction of the requirements 

Future changes to the Specification may include:

• An increase of the performance thresholds for SEER and/or η_s,h
• Updating the product eligibility and functionality requirements as per market demand and any UK or EU regulatory changes. 
• The possibility of ‘smart features’ becoming an eligibility requirement for listed water or brine to water heat pumps.
• The possibility of updating the product eligibility requirements to encompass the embodied and lifetime carbon of heat pumps. Introducing a maximum value (measured in tonnes/ CO₂) for the lifetime carbon of a heat pump.