Bedford Borough Council: Best Value Inspection report
Published 15 October 2026
Applies to England
Foreword by the Best Value inspection team
The inspection team was appointed by the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government to carry out the Best Value Inspection at Bedford Borough Council in February 2026. The appointment letter set out a broad range of areas for the inspection to cover.
Our job was to assess the extent to which the Council was meeting the Best Value Duty which is the responsibility of all local authorities. This Duty does not require the Council to be perfect but it does require it to have arrangements in place to secure continuous improvement, with due regard to effectiveness, efficiency and economy.
The inspection team has used the statutory guidance on Best Value standards and intervention of May 2024 to guide our work. The themes of this guidance are leadership, culture, governance, use of resources, service delivery, partnerships and community engagement and continuous improvement[footnote 1]. These themes provide a simple and powerful framework for a local council to carry out its work.
We found Bedford Borough Council in a difficult and deteriorating position overall, notwithstanding some small improvements seen while we were on site. The Council has significant challenges across all the Best Value themes but particularly in leadership, governance, culture and use of resources. These problems have led to a fast-growing financial challenge which is now both large in scale and urgent.
No one person or group of people are alone responsible for the failings we set out in our report. However, each part of the Council leadership across political groups and officers has played a part in the Council reaching this difficult position. Unfortunately, the problems we have identified at the Council do not give the inspection team confidence that the Council can resolve its challenges on its own. We therefore recommend the Council needs external support and intervention to make the progress it needs to become sustainable.
Our recommendations will be challenging for the Council to hear but we make them because we believe they are in the interests of the local authority and local residents. As an inspection team we were struck by the pride in the borough that we felt from all the councillors, staff and partners we met in our time in Bedford. The commitment to the place was palpable in all the conversations we had with people regardless of their different roles and perspectives.
We have been privileged to meet with many committed and talented people within and beyond the Council in doing our work. We would like to thank everyone we have interviewed and all those who have provided us with evidence. Their generosity, time spent in working with us and openness in the way they engaged has been greatly appreciated by the inspection team. This report would not have been possible without their help.
Paul Najsarek - Lead Inspector
Margaret Lee OBE - Assistant Inspector
Tasnim Shawkat - Assistant Inspector
June 2026
1. Scene setter
Process and methodology
1.1 On 10 February 2026, Paul Najsarek and Margaret Lee were appointed by the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities, and Local Government as Lead and Assistant Inspector respectively for the Best Value Inspection at Bedford Borough Council. A third inspector, Tasnim Shawkat, was appointed as an Assistant Inspector on 31 March 2026.
1.2 The inspection was asked to focus specifically on the Council’s functions where the Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) has concerns, namely governance and scrutiny arrangements; section 151 of the Local Government Act 1972 and the strength of associated audit; the capacity and capability across the organisation but particularly the finance function, and whether this is sufficient to meet the Best Value Duty; service delivery; organisational culture; the adequacy of the Council’s plans; and the Council’s capacity to address the recommendations made by the Local Government Association Corporate Peer Challenge and progress review, the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy review commissioned by the Council and the external auditor’s (KPMG) update report to the Audit Committee meeting on 27 November 2025.
1.3 Given that MHCLG’s concerns relate to broad decision-making, and whether the standards expected for effective and convenient local government are being upheld, the inspectors were asked to consider decision-making in relation to those functions. This encompasses the seven themes of good practice for running an authority that meets and delivers Best Value as defined in statutory guidance, including leadership, governance, organisational culture, use of resources, partnerships and community engagement, and impact on service delivery. Inspectors were directed to report the findings of the inspection to the Secretary of State in June 2026.
1.4 During primary evidence-gathering between February and April 2026, the inspection team spent 8 days on site at Bedford Borough Hall. Inspectors conducted over 70 face-to-face or virtual interviews with a diverse range of stakeholders, including the Council’s senior political and officer leadership; members from across all political groups; the external auditor and other providers of external assurance; trade union representatives; neighbouring local authorities; and partners from health, policing, the voluntary and community sector, education, and local business, as well as commercial partners where relevant. The inspection team also met with members of the Informal Improvement and Assurance Panel and observed Improvement Panel meetings. Following her appointment in late March, Tasnim Shawkat primarily focused her enquiries on governance aspects of the Best Value Duty.
1.5 In addition to interviews, the inspection team requested and received a large number of relevant documents from the Council and observed a number of Council meetings. Inspectors received over 160 responses to a short survey open to all staff, and held two in-person staff engagement sessions to hear directly from Council colleagues. A publicly listed email address for the inspection was shared for staff, members and the public to contact.
1.6 The inspectors also met with local Members of Parliament to discuss the inspection.
1.7 In line with the terms of appointment set out by the Secretary of State, the inspection was not conducted as an investigation into individual allegations, but to come to an assessment of whether the Council is meeting its Best Value Duty. The inspection team drew on the wide range of evidence set out above to reach its findings and conclusions. Where evidence was based on interviews, the inspection team sought, wherever possible, to corroborate and triangulate accounts with other sources, including additional interviews and documentary evidence. Where differing views were expressed, the inspection team considered the weight to be given to each account, including in the context of the wider evidence base. Inspectors ultimately exercised their judgement in reaching their findings and conclusions.
1.8 Relevant individuals were also given the opportunity to comment on extracts of the report through a Maxwellisation process, to ensure factual accuracy and fairness. Inspectors carefully considered all representations received during this stage before finalising their findings.
Biographies
1.9 Paul Najsarek (Lead Inspector): Paul previously served as Best Value Lead Inspector at Warrington Borough Council, and has over thirty years of experience in leadership positions across local government and public services. He spent almost a decade as a council Chief Executive, including six years at the London Borough of Ealing, and has served in roles leading corporate and frontline services across a number of councils. He has significant experience in regulation, peer review, improvement and transformation at local and national levels, including as the interim Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman, part of the team that developed Every Child Matters, and as a national policy lead for SOLACE. Paul is the former Chair of the North Central London Integrated Care Board and currently serves as a Non Executive Director of the South East London Integrated Care Board.
1.10 Margaret Lee OBE (Assistant Inspector): Margaret was a senior local government finance leader and held the posts of Section 151 Officer and Executive Director for Corporate and Customer Services at Essex County Council for 13 years, and other senior finance positions at the Council for many years before that. She has extensive experience of Best Value inspections and interventions, including as former Finance Commissioner at Slough Borough Council and Nottingham City Council, Finance Lead on the London Borough of Croydon Improvement and Assurance Panel, and Best Value Inspector at Thurrock Council.
1.11 Tasnim Shawkat (Assistant Inspector): Tasnim currently works as the Director of Corporate Services and Governance for London Borough of Bromley, a role which includes Monitoring Officer responsibilities. From her career as a senior leader in local government, she has extensive experience of leading change, and in developing and implementing policies and strategies, including turnaround programmes and performance improvement. She has also brought her Monitoring Officer and legal expertise to the Best Value Inspection of West Midlands Fire and Rescue Authority.
The borough of Bedford
1.12 The borough of Bedford, located some 50 miles north of London in the East of England and South Midlands, has a population of approximately 195,000 residents. Its population is among the fastest growing in the country, increasing by 17.7% from 2011 to 2021, well above the average national increase of 6.6%. It also has a higher than national average increase in the number of people aged 65 and over, at 25.5% compared to 20.1% nationally.
1.13 The borough is home to a diverse population, with just over a third of residents identifying with ethnic groups other than English, Welsh, Scottish, Northern Irish or British in March 2021. This diversity is reflected in language, with over 12% of residents having a main language other than English and more than 8% of households consisting of members with different main languages. While the borough is the 94th most deprived local authority out of 153 upper-tier local authorities in England, there is considerable variation in deprivation levels across the area. Approximately 5% of people in the borough live in neighbourhoods ranked within the most deprived 10% of the country.
1.14 The borough includes three main urban areas – the county town of Bedford, Kempston, and the new community of Wixams – and a number of villages and hamlets in rural parts of the borough. It is well-connected by road and rail to London and nearby regional centres including Milton Keynes, Luton, and Cambridge, and situated in close proximity to London Luton Airport. With its central location, the borough is accessible to over 30 million people within a two hour drive. The River Great Ouse, which runs through the centre of Bedford town, is a central and attractive feature of the area.
1.15 The borough is situated in the heart of the Oxford-Cambridge growth corridor and is the focus of a number of significant major national infrastructure projects. On 9 April 2025, it was announced that Europe’s first Universal Studio theme park and resort would be built in Bedford. The Universal United Kingdom Resort will be located around three miles south of Bedford town and will have significant implications for the area and its neighbouring authorities during construction and once open in 2031. Additionally, the new East West Rail route linking Oxford, Milton Keynes, Bedford and Cambridge will run through the borough, and the proposed “New Town” of Tempsford would be situated just beyond the boundary of Bedford Borough Council.
Bedford Borough Council
1.16 Bedford Borough Council became a unitary authority in 2009, at which point it began providing district and county-level services for local citizens. At the same time, the former districts of Mid and South Bedfordshire merged to form a separate unitary authority, the neighbouring Central Bedfordshire Council. By population, in 2024 Bedford Borough Council ranked 41 out of 62 unitary authorities in England, placing it in the bottom third. The Council works with a range of partner organisations across the public, private and voluntary sectors in delivering services and responding to place based needs and challenges.
1.17 The Council has a long history of having no overall political control. In 2002, while still a district council, residents voted to replace the traditional Leader and cabinet model with a directly elected mayor. Bedford is now one of 13 councils in the country that operates under this governance model. In 2002, an Independent councillor was elected the borough’s first mayor. For 14 years, from 2009 until elections in May 2023, the mayoralty was held by a Liberal Democrat mayor, who ran a Liberal Democrat minority administration supported by coalition arrangements.
1.18 The current Mayor was elected in May 2023 and leads a Conservative administration. The Mayor is not the Conservative Group Leader; that role is held by a separate member of the Conservative Group, who is not a member of the Council’s Executive. The Council remains under no overall political control. Excluding the elected Mayor, in June 2026 the political make-up of the Council is 14 Conservative members, 13 Liberal Democrat members, 12 Labour members, 4 Green members, and 3 Independent members. The Mayor has appointed a Conservative majority cabinet, with one Independent member holding the environment portfolio. In May 2026, 3 Conservative cabinet members resigned and the number of portfolio holders was reduced from 10 to 8 including the Mayor.
1.19 The current Chief Executive and Head of Paid Service was appointed in October 2021. In recent years the Council’s senior management team has been relatively stable, with the exception of the Monitoring Officer role, which experienced considerable churn before the current role-holder was appointed in July 2025, and the Director for Children’s Services role, which saw turnover and a period of interim leadership before the current postholder was appointed permanently in July 2024.
1.20 Like many local authorities, the Council has faced increasing financial pressure in recent years arising from increased demand and cost. Areas causing the greatest concern are a growth in the number of residential and unregistered placements in children’s services along with an increase in the unit cost, increased demand and complexity for adult social care and continued demand for temporary accommodation.
1.21 In response to these issues, the Council applied for Exceptional Financial Support (EFS). In February this year, the Council was notified that the Secretary of State was minded to grant up to £20m of EFS for 2025/26 and £25m for 2026/27 (with a possible further £33m relating to an incomplete capital project). Its Medium-Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) suggests a shortfall of budget for 2027/28 as well.
1.22 Since 2023, the Council has been subject to a number of external reviews and inspections. This includes a Local Government Association (LGA) Corporate Peer Review in 2023 and progress review in 2024; a Financial Resilience and Governance Review undertaken by the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) in 2025 (the ‘CIPFA Review’); Ofsted Area SEND inspection published in February 2025; Ofsted inspection of the Council’s children’s services published in August 2025; the recent Care Quality Commission’s (CQC) assessment of the Council’s adult services published in March 2026; and an Ofsted focused children’s services visit undertaken in April 2026. These reviews and inspections have identified a range of improvement and assurance issues across different service areas as well as corporately. Children’s and adult social care services resulted in requires improvement judgements.
1.23 Since September 2025, the Council has been supported by an external Informal Improvement and Assurance Panel, which was set up in collaboration with MHCLG and the LGA. The Panel meets monthly to provide constructive challenge and support the Council on their improvement journey.
2. Executive summary and recommendations
Our findings
2.1 Bedford is a traditional authority with its roots in the reorganisation of local government in Bedfordshire in 2009. The area served by the current unitary authority was previously served by a district council and county council. Many members and officers trace their roots in public service back to this period under either the district or the county.
2.2 The Council is relatively small, and while this does not explain the current problems facing Bedford, it does somewhat constrain its ability to respond compared to a bigger authority with more advantages of scale and capacity. Notwithstanding issues of scale, the Council faces challenges largely of its own creation and it could do a much better job of resolving them than it currently does.
2.3 The mayoral model that the Council had adopted is currently combined with a minority administration in the Council. This is not necessarily a problem and other authorities manage these circumstances well. The local context and lack of political leadership evidenced during the inspection make this political situation especially difficult in Bedford.
2.4 The local political context is one of very competitive electoral politics. This background has created the conditions for low trust and highly combative politics in the Council. This political culture is evident within the ruling minority administration as well as across political groups.
2.5 The current Mayor has tended to avoid difficult decisions and conflict and lacks the leadership skills to create a positive leadership environment. Alongside the combative political culture, this has contributed to poor decision-making and lack of prioritisation. The Council has not articulated an ambition and vision for Bedford or for the organisation.
2.6 The inspection team heard evidence from a number of people about a bullying and misogynistic culture within the ruling cabinet and across political groups. Evidence was also provided of these poor behaviours between members and officers and sometimes amongst officers too.
2.7 There is low trust between members and officers, with capacity and capability challenges at officer level further damaging relationships. The inspection team heard evidence of a blame culture within the organisation and a reluctance to take responsibility for problems. This means that difficult issues are not addressed and resolved.
2.8 Officer leadership has been reasonably stable in recent years and this has allowed some limited service improvement and some positive partnership relationships to develop. However, officer capacity and capability is limited at senior level. This leads to inconsistency of delivery and in some cases deterioration of service quality. Notwithstanding the sometimes positive partnership relationships inspectors observed and heard about, partnership working is inconsistent and missing opportunities to drive positive outcomes. The Chief Executive models a collaborative leadership style but this has not prevented a siloed culture. This leadership style is not supported by all and it may not be able to deal with the urgency and scale of the issues facing the Council. These challenges over culture, capacity and capability mean the Council is not able to implement change at the pace and quality that is required.
2.9 The Council has made attempts to create plans that reflected political commitments, service needs or financial realities, but has never successfully brought together all these drivers to create a unified, cohesive prioritised plan that is owned across members and staff. The most recent attempt at this is the current Improvement Plan. However, this is more of a framework than a plan and does not give confidence that it will drive the necessary urgent and focused change in the Council this year.
2.10 The leadership described above has meant that the Council has not been able to confront its growing financial problems. This has led to a substantial amount of emergency financial support being agreed with the government. This support is one-off in nature and the Council has large gaps to fill in its medium-term financial strategy for the coming years.
2.11 The Council has a limited track record of attempting and delivering transformation and change. It has commissioned several pieces of external support and advice from the LGA and CIPFA, amongst others. The Council has not shown it has the commitment and capacity to manage the implementation of the resulting recommendations.
2.12 The Council’s formal and informal governance is not fit for purpose in making (and sticking to) evidence-based decisions and it does not promote improvement and strategic oversight.
2.13 As an inspection team we have therefore concluded that the Council is failing in its Best Value Duty – particularly in the areas of leadership, governance, culture and use of resources – and therefore needs external intervention to secure continuous improvement in the face of significant challenges. The Council needs to focus on a small number of urgent strategic priorities to use its limited capacity most effectively. As an inspection team, we would propose financial sustainability and improvement in adult and children’s services. Alongside this, it is important the Council continues to focus on its work in economic development, not least in developing its support for the Universal project.
Recommendations
2.14 As inspectors we have set out a series of recommendations that we believe will support the Council in making the improvements required and securing better outcomes for the residents of Bedford borough. Given the scale of the challenges and significant opportunities identified, including through the Universal United Kingdom Resort, it will be essential that these recommendations are considered and taken forward in a structured and prioritised way. Timely and decisive action on the most urgent issues will be critical to building the momentum and focus needed to deliver the sustained change necessary.
Leadership and culture recommendations
1) Appointment of commissioners
The Secretary of State should consider appointing commissioners to support and provide oversight of Bedford Borough Council’s improvement. The Council’s limited track record of delivering transformation and change, despite the extensive external support already available through LGA peer mentors and the LGA-supported informal Improvement Panel, means that we have no confidence that the necessary improvement will be secured without external intervention.
If appointed, commissioners should possess expertise and skills covering transformation, leadership, and financial management and include a commissioner with a political background. The Secretary of State should also consider appointing a commissioner with expertise in governance, standards of conduct and fostering positive officer/member relationships. This would provide additional support to the current Monitoring Officer in delivering the significant governance improvements required. Commissioner powers should be broadly defined, including in relation to finance and senior recruitment.
2) Improvement Plan focus
The Council should urgently significantly streamline its Improvement Plan, focusing on a small number of critical immediate priorities until the local elections: financial sustainability, children’s services, adult services and the Universal project. The focus on a small number of priorities needs to support the Council in increasing its pace of improvement, pending the development of a more comprehensive vision and plan following the local elections.
3) Cabinet collective working
The Mayor and cabinet should work collectively and cohesively to focus on the small number of agreed strategic priorities outlined above: financial sustainability, children’s services, adult services and the Universal project. This should be supported by external facilitation, until any such time as commissioners are appointed.
4) Role of the Improvement Panel
The Council’s Informal Improvement and Assurance Panel should be formalised to strengthen its oversight of the Council’s improvement in the immediate term. The Panel should include cross-party political representation and external appointments with chief executive and political experience, and should operate until such time as commissioners are appointed. If commissioners are appointed, they should review the Panel’s role on appointment.
5) Capacity and capability review
The Council should, as a matter of urgency, undertake a comprehensive review of its capacity and capability across the Council to ensure that staff and skills are aligned to its key priorities. This should support the development and implementation of the transformation programme (recommendation 20) and a sustainable MTFS (recommendation 21), as well as ensure the improvement work in children’s and adult services can continue at pace.
As such, the review should cover both corporate and service capacity. Amongst other areas, it should address the capacity of corporate functions, including finance, IT, procurement, programme and project management, transformation and strategic communication, as well as ensuring that HR arrangements address morale, capacity and workload pressures in the organisation.
If commissioners are appointed, they should review this position.
6) Post-election vision
The Mayor and Council post-election will need to develop an ambition for Bedford and set a clear vision and priorities for the place and the Council.
7) Leadership development
The Council should introduce a leadership programme (managerial and political) that drives the ways of working and behaviours needed to support transformation, and which supports the Council to articulate and own a healthy leadership culture.
8) The ‘golden triangle’
The ‘golden triangle’ of the Chief Executive, Finance Director (Section 151 Officer), and Monitoring Officer should establish a shared, transparent view of the challenges that need to be addressed in leadership, governance and culture, including the inspection findings, and develop a shared action plan. Councillors must support this plan.
9) Members-statutory officers
The Council should ensure that members understand and respect the roles and statutory responsibilities of statutory officers. The Council should establish clear, agreed ways of working between members and statutory officers.
10) Staff engagement
The Council should develop and implement a clear staff engagement and development plan, including promptly reaching a resolution on their ways of working and return to office policy.
Governance recommendations
11) Cross-party governance framework
The Council should urgently establish a cross-party governance framework. It should agree written protocols for cross-party engagement in the context of a directly elected mayor and no overall control. These should set out expectations for regular group leader engagement, confidentiality, dispute resolution and how political groups will work together on budget, transformation and improvement priorities.
12) Member-officer and member-member relationships and standards
The Council should seek to reset member-officer and member-member relationships and standards of conduct within the Council. It should adopt and implement a clear member–officer protocol and a member development strategy including member-member relationships following best practice. This should be supported by training and visible leadership from all group leaders, and reinforce the Nolan Principles, clarify the distinction between strategic leadership and operational management, and set expectations for respectful behaviour in public and private meetings. The Council should ensure that statutory advice is heard, recorded and properly considered in formal and informal decision-making. This work should begin as soon as possible, supported by the Standards Committee (recommendation 13).
13) Standards Committee
The Standards Committee’s work should be more proactive, moving beyond case monitoring and taking a strategic role together with the Monitoring Officer and the Head of Paid Service in improving member conduct, culture and member-officer relationships as set out above. The Code of Conduct should be strengthened to include clear expectations of respect, with the Nolan Principles placed prominently at the front of the Code.
14) Role of the Mayor’s Assistant The Council should clarify the role of the Mayor’s Assistant. The Council should revise the role description for the Mayor’s Assistant, confirming that the role is limited to strategic, policy and administrative support to the Mayor and does not extend to directing officers, operational decisions, staffing matters or finance advice to members. The Mayor should, as soon as possible, agree with the Chief Executive an operating protocol for the Mayor’s Assistant and officers in the Council.
15) Governance and improvement structures
The Council should streamline governance and improvement structures. The Council should review the number, purpose and workload of its committees and boards to ensure governance arrangements are proportionate, efficient and focused on delivery and improvement. Formal structures should be reduced where they duplicate activity or consume capacity without improving decision-making or accountability. The formal structures should be complemented or supported by informal meeting structures to resolve issues and to make sure that they actively support coherent collaboration and improvement. Informal structures should also ensure that there are effective collective forums for the Executive to meet with senior officers to discuss policy and strategy, and to support cross-party working.
16) Constitution review
The Council should undertake a fundamental review of the constitution. The Council should simplify and modernise the constitution so that it is fit for a unitary council operating a mayoral model. The Monitoring Officer should be supported by the Constitution Review Working Group to address decision-making thresholds, delegations, call in criteria and the legal status of executive members and officers in scrutiny committees as planned. Working Group members should also allow the Monitoring Officer to address issues relating to public and member question arrangements, petition signature thresholds, scrutiny and council procedure rules, in line with best practice.
17) Scrutiny
The Council should reset scrutiny and executive relations so that scrutiny operates as an effective critical friend. Scrutiny arrangements should be redesigned to support constructive, evidence-led challenge focused on outcomes for residents. This should include greater use of pre-decision scrutiny, clear call in criteria, proper officer input, transparent tracking of scrutiny recommendations and a more collaborative relationship between scrutiny and the Executive. There should be regular (six monthly) informal meetings between the executive members and scrutiny chairs to discuss work programming, tracking of recommendations and effectiveness.
18) Member development
The Council should build cross-party working into member development after the 2027 elections. If, following the 2027 elections, the Council remains under no overall control or has only a small or balanced majority, the member induction and development programme should include dedicated cross-party sessions on how members will work together in that political context. These should cover options for formal and informal arrangements, expectations of group leaders, constructive scrutiny and executive engagement, confidentiality, dispute resolution and shared behaviours needed to support decision-making in the interests of residents.
Use of resources recommendations
19) Budget process
The Council needs to develop and implement an agreed and inclusive budget process, which includes key dates and builds in scrutiny and executive processes, for all members to be aware of. It is imperative that this work is undertaken immediately and at pace.
20) Transformation programme
The Council should build a transformation programme to modernise the services that the Council provides to its residents and businesses. This should reflect the Council’s priorities and statutory requirements and enable the Council to meet its value for money duties.
A set of prioritised transformation projects, aligned with the key priorities in the streamlined Improvement Plan (recommendation 2: children’s and adult services and financial sustainability) should be developed by December 2026 for immediate input into the 2027/28 budget. Developing a full transformation programme will be a longer-term endeavour that will be supported by any commissioners appointed.
21) Savings
By December 2026, the Council should identify sufficient savings to balance the MTFS, initially for 2027/28, and then for the medium-term beyond that. These savings should be supported by robust business cases to identify risks and demonstrate deliverability. This work should include the financing of the borrowing in relation to EFS. Alternatively, the Council should identify an asset disposal programme to fund EFS requirements.
22) Efficiency review
The Council should carry out a review of the following areas to ensure efficient and effective use of resources, and maximise the opportunities for savings and efficiencies:
- IT and digital tools
- Procurement
23) Tracking previous recommendations
The Council should review all previous recommendations arising from external reviews, as well as external audit and internal audit, and build a comprehensive tracker which has ownership of actions and is reviewed regularly by an appropriate board or committee. If any recommendations are not felt to be relevant, they should be presented to this board or committee for approval to cancel. These external recommendations may be included in the transformation programme to provide one overall programme of improvement work, with appropriate governance arrangements to provide appropriate oversight.
24) CIPFA recommendations
In particular, the Council should implement the recommendations included in the CIPFA Financial Resilience and Governance Review 2025 (specifically, the Financial Recovery Plan Roadmap section included in the review at Appendix B, actions 1 to 19) as a matter of priority, to ensure the finance function and the operation of financial management across the organisation is fit for purpose and support the organisation through the next few years of intense recovery.
While the Council has started to implement some of these, and this inspection report makes a number of recommendations that overlap with those previously provided by CIPFA, it should review and complete remaining actions as soon as possible.
Service delivery recommendations
25) Performance information
The Council should use performance information (including benchmarking information) to inform its service planning process and its transformation programme (recommendation 20), to identify opportunities to reduce costs and improve value for money.
26) Cross-department working
The Council should adopt a more joined up approach to working across departments to reduce silo working and improve value for money. This will be supported by the clear vision for the Council and Bedford following the next elections.
27) Performance targets
The Council should set appropriately ambitious targets for the measures included in the Corporate Plan to ensure continuous improvement is delivered across all services.
Partnerships and community engagement recommendations
28) Universal UK Resort project
The Council should strengthen the governance of the local work on the Universal UK Resort with partners and develop a strategy for maximising the opportunities presented by the project for local residents, as an immediate priority.
29) Partnership governance
The Council should review local partnership governance in the light of a new ambition, vision and priorities for Bedford as a place following the 2027 local elections.
30) Strategic ambition and capacity
The Council should review its ambition and capacity to drive economic, social and environmental development, considering the major opportunities it has and the accompanying need for local homes and skills, following the local elections.
2.15 Of the above, the following recommendations for the Council are urgent and should begin before the local elections in May 2027: 2–5, 7–15, 19–24 and 28. Any commissioners appointed should review this position.
3. Leadership and culture
Introduction
3.1 The statutory guidance on Best Value standards and intervention sets out that effective political and officer leadership requires strong leaders who set a clear vision and priorities and model positive behaviours that shape organisational culture. Statutory officers should fulfil their duties, work collectively and have access to and influence over key decision-making. The guidance also outlines that the culture of a local authority is shaped by agreed shared values, ethics and beliefs, how decisions are made and how members and officers behave, interact and fulfil their roles. The organisation should also operate as a cohesive whole rather than in silos.
3.2 As such, strong and effective leadership and the creation of a positive culture are essential features of a successful council. Strong relationships between members, and between officers and members, are key to recognising and tackling problems and making difficult decisions. A vision, and priorities for a council and a place are needed to motivate and focus positive change. The overwhelming evidence we have seen as an inspection team is that Bedford Borough Council is not demonstrating these qualities of leadership and does not have a culture that supports continuous improvement. No one part of the officer and member leadership bears sole responsibility for the position the Council is in. Failures are evident across the leadership of political groups and officers.
Recent political history and aftermath of the 2023 elections
3.3 The individual members and officers that we have met as part of this inspection were proud of their borough and want to see it succeed. However, the borough has had a recent history of competitive elections and combative politics. Some officers and members who have worked in the borough for many years report a history of assertive political leadership and challenging relationships going back across administrations. Following the 2023 local elections in Bedford, there was an atmosphere of distrust going back to the previous Council. These elections also left Bedford with a directly elected mayor working in the context of a minority administration. There was also some distrust of officers by the Mayor and new administration following a long period of working with the previous administration.
3.4 These issues can be overcome with strong member and officer leadership and a willingness to work for the benefit of residents. Unfortunately, this type of leadership has not been consistently present in the Council. The last three years have been characterised by an inward looking, attritional and combative political culture rather than a leadership culture focused on the residents and the best interests of the borough.
Vision, priorities, and direction
3.5 During the inspection we did not find a clear vision and priorities for Bedford as a place or for the Council. The Council shows a lack of ambition. Consequently, there is no clearly understood, owned and shared direction within the administration and with officers. There have been attempts to create a plan, including a Corporate Plan, Stability Plan and the new Improvement Plan. These attempts have not articulated clear priorities and have not succeeded in gaining ownership across political and officer leaders for action.
3.6 The newly elected Mayor had a manifesto with a substantial number of commitments and a list of projects and initiatives. After the election, members and officers could have done more work to develop a shared vision, priorities and plan which delivered the manifesto, as well as other important improvements needed within the Council and borough. This did not happen with sufficient pace, rigour and engagement. This was a missed opportunity and could have also helped build trust between members and officers.
3.7 The current position 3 years on is that the Council has a Corporate Plan, adopted in November 2024, which is largely a political document without deep ownership with officers. Separately, there is a recently developed Improvement Plan (approved in January 2026) which sets out to address the weaknesses that have developed within the Council. This is also not deeply owned across members and officers. One of its main tasks is to develop a vision, priorities and principles for how the Council should work. This work is too late for it to meaningfully help the Council deal with the urgent problems it faces (see Appendix C for Improvement Plan case study). The Council elected in 2027 will need to decide how it wants to use the Improvement Plan to address medium-term challenges.
Leadership in making difficult decisions
3.8 Without a clear sense of direction the Council has been unable to build a cohesive leadership culture across the Mayor, cabinet and officers. This has been recently underlined by three resignations from the cabinet, two of whom cited problems working with the Mayor and within the cabinet. To compound this the Mayor has struggled to provide the necessary personal leadership needed and his cabinet and group have not been unified in supporting him or each other. The Mayor is passionate about delivering positive projects for the local community but has not consistently been able to make difficult decisions and has avoided conflict. These are crucial attributes for any political leader, particularly a directly elected mayor. While the Mayor does not agree with this characterisation of his leadership, and feels some difficult decisions have been taken, he has acknowledged that there are differences of views within the Conservative Group.
3.9 This context and the highly combative relationship between the main opposition and the administration have made taking decisions and sticking to them very difficult. This particularly applies to contested political decisions that would have helped the Council make more progress in addressing budget challenges. The inspection team heard a number of examples of decisions stalling because the Mayor was not supportive or some of the cabinet or wider council were opposed. There were also examples where the cabinet had considered and resolved an issue informally which was then reopened by some members of the cabinet with the Mayor. These stalled or unnecessarily strained decision processes in the Council include proposals to charge for garden waste collection, the introduction of car parking charges, changing the council tax support scheme and closing leisure provision.
3.10 There are isolated examples where good officer and member leadership have been able to make progress on issues with support from cabinet, other parties and officers. These examples are the exception.
Cross-party working
3.11 In the immediate post-election period in 2023, there were no serious attempts made to forge agreements that would enable resilient cross-party working. This has left the Council in a position of either avoiding or delaying issues where cross-party agreement would be difficult, or tackling them on a case-by-case basis. This leads to difficult and unpredictable decision-making on crucial issues and delays in implementation. The annual budget process had been particularly difficult for this reason (see Appendix C for budget process case study).
3.12 There is low trust and little respect between the Mayor, Conservative Group and Liberal Democrats that have their origins before 2023 and which have intensified from the start of the administration. This is often reflected in the public meetings of the Council which reinforce poor behaviours over the last three years. The Liberal Democrats are perceived as seeking to cause embarrassment to the Mayor and administration whenever possible and show that they have little faith in the competence of the Executive in public and private interactions. Both parties report occasions when they believe sensitive discussions have been leaked into the public domain to cause embarrassment.
3.13 The other opposition groups have been more passive in terms of their relationships with the administration. They have sometimes been open to joint working, but could have done more to foster constructive cross-party working. There is evidence that the opposition groups are able to work together.
3.14 Since 2023 there has been a monthly meeting of the Mayor and group leaders. This meeting has not been effective in building constructive cross-party working on a number of important issues facing the Council. In July 2025, there was an attempt to bring all group leaders together in a regular forum where cross-party working could be developed, specifically on the budget. This forum was not successful. The Liberal Democrats led the development of a proposed terms of reference for the forum that was unacceptable to the administration and there was a belief that the administration had leaked information from the meetings. The administration pulled out of the meetings, leaving the opposition group leaders to meet, including occasionally with the Chief Executive, Section 151 Officer and Monitoring Officer.
3.15 Overall joint working within cabinet and across groups is weak and the commitment to confronting this fact and trying to improve it is not sufficient to the task. There has been some willingness to engage on a cross-party basis during the inspection, but the inspection team has low confidence this will continue and deepen following the end of the inspection.
3.16 All of the political leaders across the Council agree that cross-party working between the administration and other political groups is not effective. When this is put to individual members, they are clear they are not the cause of the situation and point to others’ behaviour and actions as the problem. These entrenched positions make progress very difficult.
3.17 Scrutiny leadership is inconsistent in promoting cross-party working. There is some evidence of cross-party working on agenda setting and in the conduct of meetings. The culture of scrutiny can still sometimes focus on adversarial models of accountability, including political point scoring rather than appreciative inquiry, particularly in the Budget and Corporate Services Committee. There is some evidence of constructive scrutiny in the committees focused on children’s and adult services.
Member and officer relationships and roles
3.18 Overall the Mayor and the administration show low levels of trust in officer capacity and capability to deliver on member commitments and council improvement. There is still a perception that some officers were too close to the previous administration in the early months after the last local election. Members report frustrations about asking for projects to be completed or plans drawn up and experiencing delay or inaction (examples include the local plan, CIPFA action plan, the Stability Plan and procurement plan).
3.19 On the day after this Best Value Inspection was announced, local media in Bedford reported comments by the Mayor indicating concerns about “systemic mismanagement” and suggesting that the Chief Executive should reflect on her position. Whatever the origins of this report, it is not a sign of healthy officer/member relationships.
3.20 The Liberal Democrats also expressed low levels of trust in some officers, officer reports and officer advice.
3.21 It is recognised that the Chief Executive has brought a collaborative style to her role. In some contexts this has proved effective, particularly in building relationships with some partners. Not all members view this as an appropriate style given their desire for more pace in delivery and the urgency of the problems facing the Council.
3.22 The Council has a new Monitoring Officer. He is well regarded across the Council. There had been significant turnover in the role before he joined the Council.
3.23 The Director of Resources who is the Section 151 Officer has faced issues of low levels of respect for her advice and has at times been excluded from meetings with members where her formal advice would have been needed on key financial issues.
3.24 The Mayor appointed a political assistant when he took up the role. This assistant had previously been the Section 151 Officer at the Council and the former line manager of the current Section 151 Officer. This appointment had the potential to introduce tension into the Council’s governance. These tensions have played out in practice as the post holder is perceived as having significant authority with the Mayor and has a very assertive personal style. The inspection team understands that the Mayor’s Assistant provides his opinion on financial matters in the Council. While the Mayor’s Assistant considers that his contribution has been limited to providing clarity and explanation, and does not undermine the message being given by the Section 151 Officer, we consider that this goes beyond the appropriate scope of the role. Though this input is valued by the Mayor, it creates a risk, and has given rise to the perception, that there is alternative financial advice being given to the Mayor and cabinet from outside the Section 151 Officer, which is inappropriate.
3.25 Inspectors heard evidence from a range of people that there were instances of bullying behaviour and misogyny from some members, including within the cabinet. This behaviour was directed both to some other members and some officers. The Council has not had a culture where people have felt able to report these issues and therefore they have not been systematically investigated and addressed. We have also heard some evidence of bullying behaviour amongst officers. The 2025 staff survey reflects this and suggests low levels of engagement of council staff. Low staff morale was also a key point of feedback in the staff survey and engagement sessions we conducted during the inspection.
3.26 There is evidence of a blame culture across the leadership of the organisation. Councillors and officers all point to problems in other parts of the leadership of the Council. The willingness to accept personal accountability or accept problems in one’s own leadership team is low.
3.27 It is common for councils to have a collective forum where the administration and senior officers come together on a regular basis to plan the business of the council, oversee progress and spot and resolve issues. During the course of the last few years, this has either not existed or not been open to key officers and has been ineffective. There are some attempts being made to make this forum more effective currently but these are at an early stage.
3.28 The lack of strategy, planning, collective governance and priority, coupled with frustration at projects not being delivered and an assertive member culture, creates a context where members are drawn into detailed involvement in particular projects, and ask for new frequent data on delivery outside of an agreed reporting framework. This creates unhealthy overlap in member and officer roles and clouds accountability and coordination of work at officer level. Examples of this include the development of the Stability Plan and the work to review the Council’s constitution.
3.29 This is a very difficult context for senior officers to operate in and it needs strong, confident officer leadership to confront challenges and find solutions with members. The evidence is that this strong leadership is not provided on a consistent basis at senior officer level.
3.30 The current Council golden triangle of the Chief Executive, Section 151 Officer and Monitoring Officer is supportive but not yet working together as effectively as they could in addressing the challenges in working with members. They are still developing a shared view of the priority issues to be addressed and need to be more methodical in documenting, planning and implementing change.
3.31 The Council has commissioned a number of external reviews and inputs in recent years which have looked at these issues as well as other challenges in the Council. This includes a corporate peer challenge organised by the LGA and the recent setting up of an informal independent improvement and assurance panel. They have all recommended actions to improve the situation. The Council has not demonstrated a systematic approach and sustained commitment to planning and implementing these actions.
Officer capacity and capability
3.32 The lack of agreed direction and priorities for the Council creates a reactive environment for officers to work in. It is very hard to assemble a plan for delivering and ensuring the relevant skills and capacity are in place as the focus shifts between different projects as they become a concern for members. This lack of priority, capacity and capability means that the Council has struggled to make impactful change happen at the necessary pace.
3.33 Senior officers could have done more in this environment to try to create a shared set of priority projects with realistic delivery dates and clear accountability and supporting capacity to deliver. The creation of the recent Improvement Plan is a partial attempt to address this.
3.34 In practice, as members and officers have grown more frustrated about delivery, the Council has reduced officer capacity (especially in the corporate centre) which would have helped delivery. This reduction in capacity has been driven by the intensifying financial challenge facing the Council, and has in some cases diverted attention from the need to make other more difficult decisions. However, the very reduction in staff has in itself reduced capacity to deliver savings, and has in effect created a downward spiral.
3.35 The Council has a very small communication capacity which is not able to focus on strategic communication. We heard that members often preferred to develop communications themselves within their group offices. Political groups can have a need for their own communication but it is crucial that the Council overall has sufficient communication capacity to engage professionally with its residents, partners and staff.
3.36 In addition, these staffing reductions have not always been matched with either process improvements or other reductions in workload, which we would have expected to have happened. As a result, many of the officers the inspection team spoke to and who responded to the staff survey we conducted reported significant workloads which are causing stress and a loss of goodwill.
3.37 The Council does not have a track record in recent years on delivering change and transformation successfully. It had a modest programme management and transformation capacity which was lost a few years ago.
3.38 Currently the Council is trying to fill gaps in transformation, programme management, financial, management, procurement and IT, although often on an interim basis. It has also had a partial vacancy freeze and is implementing a £4.2m reduction in posts as part of the 2026/27 budget.
3.39 This is an incoherent picture that gives no confidence that a better articulation of ambition and appropriate matching of resources will happen.
Transformation and service planning
3.40 The Council has in recent years not been able to demonstrate a track record in successfully managing whole council systemic transformational change. Rather, its approach has been to have individual projects managed independently without overall planning and oversight.
3.41 In the absence of a corporate approach to change, individual directorates work in their own silos to deliver operational and financial goals. For example, inspectors heard evidence of children’s services not engaging effectively with corporate transformation work, while adult services have recently worked more effectively on building an approach to transformation. This has contributed to a mixed picture of delivery, with children’s services deteriorating from good to requires improvement in its Ofsted assessment and a challenging outcome for adult services in a recent CQC assessment. Alongside this is a positive SEND assessment from Ofsted and some evidence of service improvement in some parts of the Council.
3.42 The Council made a flawed attempt to change its approach to home working in 2025 by requiring officers to be in the office for 3 days per week. This was announced by the Mayor before the Council was ready to implement the change. It was a stand-alone initiative rather than being part of an overall change programme. The announcement was critical of staff who work from home and caused a strong reaction from staff and trade unions, which is still referred to today. At the time of writing, although the Council has set an expectation of workplace attendance of 2 days a week, it is not clear how and when this will be implemented in practice.
3.43 The Council has had an uncoordinated and overlapping approach to planning services and finance. Over time, plans have included a Corporate Plan, a Stability Plan, a standalone financial plan and now an Improvement Plan. These plans have areas of overlap as well as areas of difference but have the overall effect of an unclear picture for members and officers to deliver and oversee change.
3.44 The Council had also not developed an approach to change and transformation, which is often referred to as a target operating model. Recent work has started on this in the form of ways of working principles, but these are not yet fully owned and operating in the organisation. Given the scale of change, and the need for pace in delivery, it is essential that the Council considers how it will communicate effectively throughout what will be an unsettling period for staff and residents. This may necessitate the need for additional communications resource.
3.45 As discussed earlier, the corporate centre has been ‘hollowed out’ and there has been limited or no capacity to support transformation and change, financial delivery plans, monitoring and evaluation. This makes oversight and grip across the Council very difficult for members and officers beyond their discrete areas of responsibility.
3.46 Plans to better resource change are in early stages of planning and delivery. The early delivery is often through interim staff, so permanent arrangements will need to be confirmed and plans successfully implemented.
3.47 Given these problems already being experienced and the likelihood of further work being needed to establish a transformation / savings programme to close the financial gap in the MTFS, it is essential that the Council undertakes a thorough review of resources available. The 2026/27 budget includes a savings requirement of £4.2m relating to the establishment, which equates to approximately 120 FTE. The suggested review should be completed as a matter of urgency so that all fully understand the impact of making further cuts to an already stretched workforce, and in the context of the additional work that will be needed to support the significant transformation changes and identify the savings. It may feel counter intuitive to take on additional staff with the associated cost at a time when the scale of the budget shortfall has already been identified, but the Council may well have to invest in additional capacity on an invest-to-save basis to be able to deliver savings at pace and so reduce the financial pressure.
Oversight, performance management, accountability and risk
3.48 The lack of a clear plan with SMART objectives limits the effectiveness of the Council’s performance management and accountability arrangements. Member and senior management attention has not been consistently focused on agreed issues.
3.49 The Council Executive and scrutiny members and some senior officers were surprised by the findings of the recent Ofsted and Care Quality Commission inspections, suggesting underdeveloped systems of oversight and low collective self-awareness.
3.50 The Council leadership has also been collectively slow to detect, acknowledge and act on the growing financial challenge they face.
3.51 Data quality and timeliness limits the ability of officers and members to have up to date intelligence upon which to learn, act and make well informed decisions. The Monitoring Officer is currently leading a project to make improvements in this area as part of the Council’s Improvement Plan. Savings agreed for financial year 2026/27 included reductions to the analytics and performance team. While this has subsequently been placed on hold, this indicates a risk to the capacity needed to support delivery of the plan.
3.52 There is no consistently applied and monitored approach to team and individual performance and development across the Council. This reinforces a siloed way of working and means staff overall are not able to make a connection between their role and the wider objectives of the council. Service planning and individual performance and development reviews are inconsistently implemented which further limits opportunities for join up across services and individual accountability and learning.
3.53 A corporate risk register exists and is updated but it does not fully capture and mitigate the strategic risks facing the organisation. Risk management is not embedded in the culture of the organisation. Overall, there is an optimism bias in the delivery of key projects, including the Improvement Plan and budget proposals.
Workforce and culture
3.54 The Council has committed to creating and embedding its values in its workforce strategy and has recently produced some new ways of working principles as part of the Improvement Plan actions. The Council has previously shown no evidence of systematically trying to implement a positive culture.
3.55 In practice, the Council culture is short term, reactive, silo based, defensive, and inward looking. There is a focus on blame by leaders. It has not been able to successfully develop an effective approach to change.
3.56 We have seen that the Chief Executive is trying to develop a more collaborative approach across the corporate leadership team. This is not widely supported by councillors. There is a risk it is neither able to create effective cross council working, nor enable the Council to move at the pace it needs to in resolving its financial and service challenges.
3.57 Council staff are dedicated and committed to the borough and organisation. Substantial past and potential future staff reductions are not accompanied by new ways of working and modern support systems. This leaves remaining staff concerned about additional workloads and not feeling appreciated.
3.58 The reductions in staff numbers and posts are not carried out strategically with an eye to the challenges the organisation faces, leaving a mismatch between expectations, capacity and capability.
3.59 There have been three major projects affecting capacity in recent times: a review of home working policy; a partial vacancy freeze; and a proposal to save £4.2m from post deletion. None of these projects has been clearly explained, engaged upon or fully implemented. Decision-making has been unclear and impacts have not been fully considered.
3.60 There are important areas of the Council where capacity limits the Council’s effectiveness. These include communications, corporate services, transformation, programme management and community engagement. Some of these are being partly addressed. They will be central to achieving the performance improvements that are needed.
Self-awareness, ownership and commitment to change
3.61 The Council leadership across officers and members of all groups does not have a shared view of the problems they face. Most people are able to identify a financial challenge, although there are different perspectives of its roots and how urgent and severe it is. It was very late in the budget setting process when the Council understood and accepted that Exceptional Financial Support would be required to set a budget for 2026/27. There remain different understandings of the scale of the challenge ahead. Indeed, we were told on a number of occasions that all that was needed was for us, as the inspection team, to solve the budget problems, after which the Council’s issues would be resolved.
3.62 It was less common to hear leaders describe the broader issues which limit the Council’s effectiveness and have helped create the budget challenge. Issues of weak leadership, poor decision-making and poor planning are only partly acknowledged and articulated, and almost always blamed on other parts of the organisation.
3.63 While many we spoke to did not agree that there is a lack of will or commitment at the Council, the inspection team consider that a combination of incomplete understanding and ownership of the issues facing the Council makes the commitment to successfully tackle them inadequate to the task. This situation is further complicated by different political leaders and groups’ sensitivity to being associated with the difficult decisions.
3.64 This leadership culture, operating in the context of a directly elected mayor and a council in no overall control, means there is no centre of authority to provide leadership in addressing the Council’s problems.
3.65 This is further evidenced by the Council’s response to recent reviews and its ability to effectively use external support. The Council undertook an LGA corporate peer challenge in 2023, which was followed up in 2024. More recently, CIPFA were commissioned to review the financial position and management of the Council. There have been other reviews which considered issues relevant to the Council’s ability to deliver Best Value. In addition, Ofsted and CQC have recently reported on the Council’s performance in adult and children’s services.
3.66 With LGA support the Council set up an independent Informal Improvement and Assurance Panel to respond to these reviews. The Council was not able to agree that councillors should be involved in this panel and so it was agreed that it should remain as an informal group. There is also an independently chaired children’s services improvement board. A similar board has recently been established in adult services.
3.67 In addition, Council members and officers have had access to a range of mentoring and coaching support.
3.68 Many of the issues identified by these external reviews are still present in the Council and have become even more urgent to address. The Council has not adopted a systematic and effective way to track its response to these recommendations.
3.69 We have also heard evidence from members and officers that they do not fully support all of the findings of these various reviews, despite in some cases the reviews having been approved by the Council.
Conclusion
3.70 The leadership of the council lacks cohesion, decisiveness, focus and consistency. Leadership challenges are evident in all parts of the organisation – politically and managerially. There is a lack of clear vision, priorities and shared direction and inspectors have not seen evidence that there is a consistent and effective approach to planning and delivering change. The Council also has not demonstrated a systematic response to the findings of external reviews.
3.71 There are gaps in capacity and capability at officer and member level, alongside low accountability and a tendency to blame others. This creates a negative culture across the organisation, which hinders leadership’s ability to find the solutions to problems that would enable progress.
3.72 It is therefore the judgement of the inspection team that the Council is not meeting its Best Value Duty in the areas of leadership and culture. As a team, we also have no confidence that this position will change without external intervention.
Leadership and culture recommendations
3.73 Given these findings, we recommend:
- The Secretary of State should consider appointing commissioners to support and provide oversight of Bedford Borough Council’s improvement. The Council’s limited track record of delivering transformation and change, despite the extensive external support already available through LGA peer mentors and the LGA-supported informal Improvement Panel, means that we have no confidence that the necessary improvement will be secured without external intervention.
If appointed, commissioners should possess expertise and skills covering transformation, leadership, and financial management and include a commissioner with a political background. The Secretary of State should also consider appointing a commissioner with expertise in governance, standards of conduct and fostering positive officer/member relationships. This would provide additional support to the current Monitoring Officer in delivering the significant governance improvements required. Commissioner powers should be broadly defined, including in relation to finance and senior recruitment.
-
The Council should urgently significantly streamline its Improvement Plan, focusing on a small number of critical immediate priorities until the local elections: financial sustainability, children’s services, adult services and the Universal project. The focus on a small number of priorities needs to support the Council in increasing its pace of improvement, pending the development of a more comprehensive vision and plan following the local elections.
-
The Mayor and cabinet should work collectively and cohesively to focus on the small number of agreed strategic priorities outlined above: financial sustainability, children’s services, adult services and the Universal project. This should be supported by external facilitation, until any such time as commissioners are appointed.
-
The Council’s Informal Improvement and Assurance Panel should be formalised to strengthen its oversight of the Council’s improvement in the immediate term. The Panel should include cross-party political representation and external appointments with chief executive and political experience, and should operate until such time as commissioners are appointed. If commissioners are appointed, they should review the Panel’s role on appointment.
-
The Council should, as a matter of urgency, undertake a comprehensive review of its capacity and capability across the Council to ensure that staff and skills are aligned to its key priorities. This should support the development and implementation of the transformation programme (recommendation 20) and a sustainable MTFS (recommendation 21), as well as ensure the improvement work in children’s and adult services can continue at pace.
As such, the review should cover both corporate and service capacity. Amongst other areas, it should address the capacity of corporate functions, including finance, IT, procurement, programme and project management, transformation and strategic communication, as well as ensuring that HR arrangements address morale, capacity and workload pressures in the organisation.
If commissioners are appointed, they should review this position.
-
The Mayor and Council post-election will need to develop an ambition for Bedford and set a clear vision and priorities for the place and the Council.
-
The Council should introduce a leadership programme (managerial and political) that drives the ways of working and behaviours needed to support transformation, and which supports the Council to articulate and own a healthy leadership culture.
-
The golden triangle of the Chief Executive, Finance Director (Section 151 Officer), and Monitoring Officer should establish a shared, transparent view of the challenges that need to be addressed in leadership, governance and culture, including the inspection findings, and develop a shared action plan. Councillors must support this plan.
-
The Council should ensure that members understand and respect the roles and statutory responsibilities of statutory officers. The Council should establish clear, agreed ways of working between members and statutory officers.
-
The Council should develop and implement a clear staff engagement and development plan, including promptly reaching a resolution on their ways of working and return to office policy.
4. Governance
Introduction
4.1 The Best Value statutory guidance describes a well-run council as a council where officers and members have a clear understanding of the democratic mandate as it operates in the organisation. It includes clear and robust governance and scrutiny arrangements in place that are:
- fit for purpose
- appropriate to the governance arrangements adopted locally (in Bedford it is an executive system with a directly elected mayor)
- in accordance with statutory or sector guidance such as statutory guidance on overview and scrutiny and the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny’s governance risk and resilience framework
These arrangements should be understood by members and officers alike, reviewed regularly and accurately described in the Annual Governance Statement. The guidance identifies positive indicators of good governance as well as indicators of failure.
4.2 The Council is failing to meet some of the critical elements of the governance standards expected of a unitary council or indeed any council. This combined with weak leadership by members and senior officers of the Council means that the Council is failing to meet its Best Value Duty.
4.3 Governance arrangements are not sufficiently adapted to a directly elected mayor model, operating without overall political control. The absence of effective structured cross-party working has contributed to the failings.
4.4 Low trust between political groups, and between members and officers, has contributed to micro-management by members and weak collective accountability. Scrutiny is not operating consistently as an effective ‘critical friend’, and executive–scrutiny relationships are not constructive.
4.5 At the same time, roles, responsibilities and lines of authority are not consistently understood or applied, including the role of officers, the status of statutory advice and the boundary between political leadership and operational management. These problems are compounded by a constitution that is overly long, difficult to use and not fit for the Council’s governance model.
4.6 Taken together, these failings mean that the Council’s governance arrangements are not providing the clarity, grip or discipline needed to support timely and effective decision-making. While during the course of this inspection there have been some recent signs of improvement, these do not yet outweigh the underlying weaknesses.
Governance arrangements for a minority administration
4.7 Some within the Council see the Council’s governance model of a directly elected mayor with a minority administration as an issue and hindrance to making progress. Councils with no overall control are common and lawful. The inspection team accepts that having a directly elected Mayor for a council with no overall control poses challenges. We also know that this model can create opportunities for achieving positive outcomes for residents and services users through cross-party working on key issues. However, it requires greater political discipline, areas of agreement/s and careful governance with clear understanding of roles and responsibilities.
4.8 There has been a lack of trust and confidence between the main party groups in the current and previous administration. Following the elections and now three years on, there is no effective governance framework set up for cross-party working in the context of a minority administration. The inspection team was told that the Mayor and the group leaders meet with the Chief Executive regularly. However, no one we interviewed referred to this as an important meeting or an example of cross-party working.
4.9 It would be reasonable to expect that in a council with no overall control, there would be written protocols or terms of engagement between the administration and the opposition groups. We heard that attempts were made to enter into such agreement, but those attempts were recent and they failed, with allegations of breach of confidentiality, and no further attempts were made to rectify the situation.
4.10 As mentioned in the leadership and culture section, there is some good cross-party working on specific issues. However, the lack of formal and informal cross-party working arrangements is not delivering for residents of the borough, as evidenced throughout this report.
4.11 Both the LGA and the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny (CfGS) can provide extensive support to councils with no overall control. The Council could have obtained access to such external support to create a governance framework to facilitate cross-party working soon after the election and should have done so during the first year after the election or any time subsequently.
4.12 Members and officers should have been aware from other councils that where there is no overall control, the relationships between and within political groups will be the most important factor in the success or failure of the Council’s governance arrangements. Given the adversarial nature of the politics in this Council early on, there should have been clear focus on behaviours and organisational culture, with the statutory officers supporting, guiding and/or bringing in external support.
Governance arrangements in a unitary council
4.13 When it became a unitary authority on 1 April 2009, the Council took over county level services, including adult and children social care, environment and highways. However, the governance arrangements in the constitution and practices in the Council have not been scaled up to the level of unitary upper tier authority. For example, the threshold for key decision is £50k, which is very low for an upper tier council. This has been highlighted by officers and external assessors (CIPFA, CfGS) prior to our inspection.
4.14 However, some members still consider that given the current financial situation, the key decision threshold needs to remain low. This is understandable but ill-judged. The low threshold creates an industry around report production and governance processes which are disproportionate and inefficient, as well as ineffective in dealing with the Council’s financial situation. This level of micromanagement inevitably slows down the work of the Council at a time when they need to be working faster to deliver improvement.
4.15 There are other ways members can have oversight of executive decisions, such as through the publication of a list of delegated portfolio holder and officer decisions, the ability to review decisions once they have been taken and by undertaking impact assessments of decisions at scrutiny committees. Members could also ask the Section 151 Officer to set expenditure control and report to members on a regular basis.
4.16 The key decision threshold and other difficulties with the current arrangements and the constitution are discussed below in the section dealing with the constitution.
Trust and respect
4.17 The lack of trust between party groups and between members and officers are significant barriers to delivering good governance in this council. The lack of trust creates inefficiencies in any organisation, and particularly in Bedford Borough Council given its local context.
4.18 Immediately on being elected, councillors are legally required to sign their acceptance of office and the ‘Code of Conduct for Councillors’, which includes the Nolan Principles. These principles are the building blocks which help to establish trust and respect among members, and between them and officers, soon after the election and induction.
4.19 However, this did not happen after the election and there is still low trust amongst political groups. Members also do not have sufficient trust in and respect for officers. As a result, members focus on detail and venture into operational matters, leaving officers feeling micro-managed. The low threshold for key decision is a symptom of this lack of trust in officers and the political groups.
4.20 The difficulty with members focussing on detail is that there is no capacity or willingness to spend time on strategy, policy development and performance improvement. The lack of trust between political groups is negatively affecting decision-making, for example budget decisions.
Scrutiny
4.21 The following excerpts from the LGA publication ‘A councillor’s workbook on scrutiny’ outline how scrutiny should work:
-
For scrutiny to be effective it needs to act and be seen as a ‘critical friend,’ identifying where decisions could be improved and how to prevent mistakes being made or repeated. Scrutiny is, by its nature, political; that is, it is driven by politicians whose insights are a fundamental part of scrutiny’s work to review decisions which are themselves political and may be politically contentious. However, the focus should be on forward thinking and enabling positive outcomes, rather than apportioning blame and focusing on the negatives or political point-scoring. The challenge for you, as a scrutiny councillor, is to use your political skills and understanding of the needs of local people to shape the discussions, while not acting in a party-political manner or using the discussions to further party-political objectives.
-
Scrutiny works well when the council’s executive and officers view it in a positive light and as an opportunity to improve council performance. Scrutiny’s effectiveness will be reduced if the executive experiences it as aggressively critical, which will lead to defensive behaviour and make it difficult for scrutiny to influence change.
4.22 Though inspectors received some evidence of more constructive scrutiny functions for children’s and adult services, scrutiny in the Council is described as “almost always political” and not operating as a critical friend. We were told that there was very little appetite for pre-decision scrutiny, meaning that scrutiny tends to be reactive rather than proactive. This is a missed opportunity for influencing and shaping decisions that are being taken to the Executive. Reactive call in, although not excessive in the Council, can be frustrating for all parties and a waste of resources, especially as there are no clear criteria set out in the Council’s constitution for call in.
4.23 Some members of scrutiny committees have a different view. They felt that scrutiny committees are not political and members work well together in committees, but that their recommendations are ignored by the Executive.
4.24 However, we were also told by scrutiny committee members that they were not always aware of performance issues and the Ofsted inspection outcome was a surprise to members. Furthermore, the effectiveness of scrutiny must be questioned given the performance of the Council overall. Members said that they had warned of the financial difficulties the Council currently faces. However, it is not clear that scrutiny committees went beyond warning of issues of service and financial performance to assist in prevention in a constructive way.
4.25 There is a clear divergence between the perceptions of how scrutiny works on the part of some of the members and in parts of the organisation. Nevertheless, there is agreement in that the Executive does not address the recommendations from scrutiny committees. However, how executive members are treated in scrutiny committees is unusual, as they are allowed to present reports and answer questions but have to leave during committee discussion that follows. This is far from the collaborative approach that is best practice, and it deprives the executive members of their legal right to be present at scrutiny committees. We were told that this practice will cease and the Constitution will be amended.
4.26 Another problematic issue is the way in which scrutiny committees relate to officers at scrutiny committees. Officers are only allowed to present and may not speak again once members start to debate the issues in the report. Inspectors heard that even statutory officers have not been given the opportunity to speak at times, even if to correct the record or provide points of clarification. We were told that when officers have intervened, they have been perceived by the opposition as supporting the administration or being part of the debate which, in the opposition’s view, should be reserved for members.
4.27 This is contrary to normal governance arrangements and legal requirements, which provides that members must have regard to officers’ advice and particularly that of statutory officers, even if they do not agree with it. There is no reason for officers not to be allowed to intervene at committees during discussion or debate. As such, this represents a failure in governance processes and good practice.
4.28 Although the inspection team heard of evidence of members having some good discussion and debate at scrutiny meetings, and there are examples of good pieces of scrutiny work, our overall assessment is that scrutiny is not consistently effective as a critical friend to drive positive outcomes for residents. We agree that executive/scrutiny engagement is not consistently constructive.
4.29 For scrutiny to be effective there is a need for cross-party cooperation (particularly in councils with no overall control), a positive organisational culture with appropriate levels of support and challenge, and an executive that is open to challenge and accepts the contributions of all members. Officer input in scrutiny committee discussions is also important.
Roles and responsibilities
4.30 There is evidence that some roles and responsibilities in the Council are not clearly understood or are misapplied. As mentioned above, the role of officers at scrutiny committees is not understood, as they are not always allowed to present reports and speak to clarify facts and issues.
4.31 Similarly, the role of executive members at scrutiny committees is misunderstood. The Council’s constitution provides that once the relevant executive member has presented their report and answered questions, they have to leave the committee meeting for scrutiny members to debate the item. The effect of this is that executive members have fewer rights than members of the public attending the committee meeting. This practice which is provided for in the constitution is not lawful. Recently the Constitution Review Working Group has agreed that this provision should be removed. This will be recommended to the Council to be approved.
4.32 The roles and responsibilities of officers and members in relation to what is operational and what is policy and strategy is not understood well. As mentioned in this report, members are focussed on low threshold matters, arguably at the expense of focussing on strategic plans, outcome for residents and the performance of the organisation.
4.33 The statutory officer role is not given sufficient weight or respect. Inspectors heard that the Head of Paid Service is not able to perform her role on staffing matters without inappropriate interference by members and the Mayor’s Assistant. This suggestion is strongly denied by the Mayor’s Assistant. We find that there are reasonable grounds for believing that there is such interference given the information came from more than one source. However, we also find that the Head of Paid Service needs to be persistent in pushing back on such interference and take formal steps if necessary.
4.34 We heard that the statutory finance officer / Section 151 Officer was not given the appropriate respect and importance either, as they were excluded from informal meetings where it seemed that finance advice was being taken from the Mayor’s Assistant, who was the previous Section 151 Officer and the line manager of the current Section 151 Officer. We understand that this issue has been partially resolved in that the current Section 151 officer has pushed back and is now attending informal meetings of the Executive to give advice.
4.35 Nevertheless, the risk remains that the Mayor’s Assistant expressing opinions on the finances of the Council is taken as informal finance advice, given his previous position in the Council, which undermines good governance generally and the current Section 151 Officer in particular. The Mayor’s Assistant understands the risk of giving information or advice behind the scenes but denies undermining the Section 151 Officer. We as inspectors consider that given the context of the Mayor’s Assistant being the previous line manager of the current Section 151 Officer, the risk remains high.
4.36 In their report on financial resilience and governance of August 2025, CIPFA stressed in relation to the Council’s Stability Plan that “There is an opportunity to improve the relationship and working arrangements between members and officers and more specifically around roles and responsibilities in line with best practice. It will also require engagement and support from all members and senior officers to collaborate and work together for the wider benefit of the borough and its communities.” This was over six months before our inspection but we did not see any evidence of change in the light of the advice from CIPFA.
The role of the Mayor’s Assistant
4.37 The role of a mayor’s assistant is similar to that of political assistant, with some differences. An elected mayor may appoint one person as an assistant under Regulation 3 of the Local Authorities (Elected Mayor and Mayor’s Assistant) (England) Regulations 2002. Mayor’s assistants are employed by the council on terms and conditions agreed by the mayor, but the term of office ends when the mayor ceases to be in office. Although the decision to appoint is for the mayor and not for the council, the mayor must report to the council in writing the name of the assistant appointed and the terms and conditions of their appointment.
4.38 The purpose of this role is to provide strategic, policy and administrative support to the mayor. There can be no delegation of powers and functions to the mayor’s assistant from the executive, the council or a committee. Most importantly, no officer employed by the council can be required to work under the direction of the mayor’s assistant unless they are providing clerical or administrative support[footnote 2].
4.39 Therefore, it is clear that the role of the mayor’s assistant is not operational. They should not be involved in financial management decisions or staffing or service related matters, other than to gather information or data. Their sphere of influence is the mayor’s strategic thinking and policy development, as well as to provide administrative support.
4.40 The role of mayor’s assistant can be a risk to good governance unless the role is clearly defined and well understood by all. These roles hold a powerful position in mayoral authorities and can be a force for the good or they can lead to dysfunction at the leadership level and below.
4.41 We were told by a number of people interviewed that the Mayor’s Assistant in Bedford exercises a wide remit, going beyond advice and assistance to the Mayor into operational matters, which are strictly for officers under the Head of Paid Service to manage and control, including staffing matters. We have heard that the person in post has significant influence in operational matters as well on the roles of the Section 151 Officer and Head of Paid Service, as outlined above. This is contrary to good governance and remains a risk.
4.42 We find that there is evidence that the Mayor’s Assistant has gone beyond the remit envisaged or allowed by regulations, which is not surprising given the context of his previous role. The Mayor, in taking the decision to appoint a previous Section 151 Officer as his assistant, should have anticipated the risks associated with that decision. Having made the decision, he should have taken action to mitigate those risks.
Managerial accountability
4.43 The Council has a traditional model of senior leadership team with the Chief Executive line managing the Chief Officers, including statutory Directors for Adult and Children’s Services, as well as Chief Officers responsible for environment, planning, housing and so on. Collectively the Chief Officers have leadership roles in relation to staffing and service delivery but also to support both the executive and scrutiny functions, members, other committees as well as governance of the Council.
4.44 The 3 core statutory officers – the Head of Paid service, in this case Chief Executive, Executive Director of Resources and Section 151 Officer, and the Monitoring Officer – each has specific statutory responsibilities for which they are individually accountable. They are also required to work together as part of a ‘golden triangle’ to provide leadership of and support to staff; to ensure legal, constitutional and ethical compliance; and to ensure financial probity and sound financial management of the services and the organisation.
4.45 By working independently but also together, the three statutory officers of the golden triangle should ensure good governance across the council. These three officers have enhanced statutory and employment protection to enable them to provide challenge and ‘speak truth to power’.
4.46 Following the elections in 2023 and subsequently when the political leadership of the organisation showed signs of weakness as identified in this report, the Chief Executive should have ensured that the then statutory officers in post, including herself, took stronger and more robust action to (1) influence and advise members to enter into formal cross-party working arrangements, seeking external support if necessary, (2) set standards of conduct in relation to member and officer relationships, and (3) provide stronger challenge to establish clarity on roles and responsibilities and promote greater accountability.
4.47 These did not happen. Therefore the officer and managerial leadership, and in particular the golden triangle of statutory officers in place at that time led by the Chief Executive, have some responsibility for the missed opportunities soon after the elections and the current difficulties the Council is experiencing in terms of governance, member conduct and member and officer relations.
4.48 There has previously been a turnover of monitoring officers, but from the summer of 2025 there has been a permanent post holder who has provided some stability. This current Monitoring Officer has taken the lead in improving the constitution working with members, setting standards for member conduct and providing challenge as necessary. The inspection team were impressed with the progress the current Monitoring Officer has already made and we believe he needs to be resourced and supported with his considerable workload.
4.49 Currently the golden triangle is working well in supporting each other. However, there is a need to develop a shared understanding of governance challenges and for a clear plan of how these challenges can be mitigated or managed. The three statutory officers should also be visibly supported by the whole senior leadership team to get this work properly embedded in the work programme of the top team.
Political accountability
4.50 The inspection team considers that members in their various roles do not take accountability for the situation Bedford is in. Instead, responsibility is often attributed to others, contributing to a blame culture. All members of the Council have one or more roles in its governance, however these responsibilities can be lost in a council which is politically acrimonious or combative.
4.51 The Mayor and Conservative administration have not made serious or sustained attempts to gain consensus and engender an environment for cross-party working. We were told that there were one or two small but genuine attempts by the administration to work together on issues, which were undermined by the Liberal Democrats. Nevertheless, there is greater onus on the Conservative administration to ensure cross-party engagement to make delivery happen.
4.52 The Liberal Democrats, the second largest group, have significant experience, having been in administration from 2009 until 2023. This group has little respect for the Mayor and the Conservative administration, and has very low trust in them. They are perceived to have taken opportunities to embarrass the administration rather than work constructively in the interest of the borough and its residents, at least on some issues.
4.53 The Labour Group has been more receptive to engaging with the administration on the annual budget and on key policy issues as they emerge. However, despite holding the balance of power in the Council, they have been described as “silent”. Although the inspection team do not find the Labour Group to be “silent”, we do question whether the Labour Group understands the extent of their powerful position and the role they can play in bringing about consensus or a majority vote on key issues for the benefit of the residents, businesses and the service users in the borough.
4.54 As mentioned above, the Green Group and Independent members have been more open to working together on important policy issues and the annual budget. They could however take a stronger and more proactive role in building cross-party collaboration.
4.55 We as inspectors are alive to the fact that party politics, based on group unity, plays a key role in local authorities being effective. We accept that members do need to respect their political responsibilities and accountabilities to their party. However, they must also ensure these do not undermine their electoral accountability to the borough as a whole. The inspection team would reiterate that they found members individually to be passionate about Bedford and its residents. The judgements above are not intended to detract from their personal commitments to the borough as elected councillors.
The constitution
4.56 The Council has a model constitution which, though generally compliant with the legal requirements, has some significant defects. Although it has been reviewed annually, any changes have been incremental and a more fundamental review is needed. The constitution contains duplications, inconsistencies and inaccuracies. It is currently over 700 pages and is unwieldy and not user-friendly.
4.57 In April 2025, the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny found that the constitution in particular does not reflect the specific dynamics that apply to mayoral governance, including some incorrect descriptions of the Mayor’s power and status.
4.58 The CIPFA Review of August 2025 has also identified shortcomings in the constitution, including potential areas of conflict and lack of consistency in governance and decision-making. They highlight that the scheme of delegation is based on approval limits which are significantly lower than at comparable authorities. Examples include the value for a key decision, virement limits, debt write-off limits and processes. They recommend clear delegations and decision making, and clarity of functions, roles and responsibilities of the overview and scrutiny function and advisory panels.
4.59 The inspectors were told that external legal advice had to be sought to interpret provisions in the constitution. Taken together, these findings provide clear evidence that the constitution is not fit for purpose and requires a fundamental review.
4.60 The Council has in place a member working group looking at the review of the constitution. The inspection team observed good engagement of members with the Monitoring Officer and some changes are likely to be made to the constitution which will improve it. However, the Council needs to address areas of the constitution which are hindering good governance. Some of these priority areas for reform include provisions which members, in particular the opposition members, have decided are “no go areas”, also referred to as “red lines”. These areas are the existing rights of the public and of members (particularly those in opposition), as well as rights associated with functions relating to overview and scrutiny.
4.61 The existing rights of the public include an unlimited opportunity to ask questions, supplementary questions and statements without notice at both Council and committee meetings, and a disproportionately low threshold for petitions (30 signatures), which if achieved triggers automatic debate at the subsequent meeting of Full Council.
4.62 The existing rights of members include unlimited opportunity for members to ask questions, supplementary questions and statements without notice, either as part of a dedicated section for questions on the agenda for meetings, but also prior to debate on every item at meetings of Full Council.
4.63 The existing rights relating to overview and scrutiny committees include not having any criteria set out in the constitution for calling in any decision.
4.64 These provisions are unusual and they do not follow best practice. Inspectors were given to understand that the effect of these three elements at meetings of Full Council is that it has taken up to two hours of the Council’s time at the beginning of each meeting before getting to reports and main items. This is disproportionate. But regardless of the time taken, there needs to be a recognition that Full Council meetings are meetings in public and not public meetings. Although public engagement in Council meetings is important, that engagement needs to be proportionate to the main purpose of these meetings, which is to transact council business and to do it well and effectively, for the benefit of residents, service users and businesses.
4.65 The political and organisational environment in the Council is such that constitutional provisions, meeting rules and scrutiny practices combine to slow decision-making, reduce the quality of debate on substantive policy and financial issues, and create friction in member-member and member-officer interactions. However, some amendments have been agreed and are being agreed by the Constitution Review Working Group, for example a new scheme of delegation for the executive functions have been approved by the Mayor.
4.66 It is anticipated that a proposed new Constitution will be approved by the Council in October 2026. We believe the Monitoring Officer is having to take a phased approach and address first only those areas where he can achieve member buy-in. The Monitoring Officer is fully aware of the sensitivities and that decisions made at Full Council require cross-party support and this will be the case for any changes made to the Council’s constitution.
4.67 The Constitution Review Working Group referred to the work commissioned from the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny and said that they went beyond their terms of reference and therefore members did not support the recommendations. The inspection team understands that going beyond the terms of reference means going beyond the “red lines” or “no go areas” outlined above.
4.68 It should be noted that Centre for Governance and Scrutiny are experts on local authority governance generally and constitutions in particular. The inspectors would support the Monitoring Officer taking a robust approach to implementing the changes proposed by the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny. This should be included in the work programme of the Constitution Review Working Group.
Member development
4.69 Prior to the 2023 elections, the Council prepared a member induction plan which was approved by its General Purposes Committee in January 2023. The induction plan was as expected with some mandatory training on planning, licensing, code of conduct and data protection and a range of other non-mandatory training. The induction plan also covered scrutiny and insight into service areas. The induction plan and attendance were reviewed by the Committee in September 2023, including feedback from members. The feedback was generally positive.
4.70 The current Monitoring Officer has very recently established a Member Development Group (cross-party) which will play an active role in the development of the induction programme for 2027. They will also be developing a member development strategy which will be taken through the Group and help shape the annual member development programme.
4.71 Inspectors were told and can see that the General Purposes Committee took a very active role in considering the induction programme for 2023. It is on the agenda for the Committee later this year to ensure that members are content with the plans in place for 2027.
4.72 Following the 2027 election, if the Council remains with no overall control or balanced or with a small majority, then in addition to the usual member induction programme, it would be vital to have some briefings or training on cross-party working and options for arrangements for working together on key issues and generally.
Operation of the standards framework
4.73 The Council is compliant in having in place a Code of Conduct for members and arrangements for dealing with complaints. The Monitoring Officer is seeking to review the Code to make it stronger, as there have been a large number of complaints within parish councils that the Monitoring Officer is responsible for dealing with. These parish council complaints are not about Bedford Borough Council members.
4.74 It is noteworthy that very few of the complaints the Monitoring Officer has been dealing with relate to members of the Council. There were only two complaints from residents relating to events at a planning committee, which were considered not to merit investigation. There are no complaints against members from officers and two very recent active member-member complaints linked to cabinet member resignations in late May 2026.
4.75 This is noteworthy because inspectors heard allegations of bullying and misogyny within the Council. We also heard about a lack of respect for officers, with criticisms of officers made in public at committee meetings, and lack of respect for the Mayor. None of these issues were raised as formal complaints.
4.76 We believe that there are two probable reasons for the lack of complaints. First, that the Code of Conduct is not adequate. For example, it does not have a requirement for members to be respectful, which the Monitoring Officer intends to address. The second probable reason is that officers do not feel free to speak up and challenge, which is a wider leadership and cultural issue. It is also possible that individuals do not feel strongly enough to make a formal complaint or there are no grounds to complain. However, our interviews with some officers would suggest that this is not the case.
4.77 We were told that there are no member against member complaints because members accept the political “rough and tumble”. More recently, the Monitoring Officer has been dealing with issues raised by some officers by directly discussing those issues with members in an informal way to seek resolution.
4.78 The Nolan Principles are briefly referred to at the beginning of the Code of Conduct document and the Principles are set out in an appendix to the Code. We suggest that the Principles should be set out on the first page of the Code. This may seem a minor point to raise, but it is important in terms of the culture of the organisation and the signal it gives. The Nolan Principles apply to every member of a council and not only those in leadership positions. However, the leaders of every group on a council are expected to display these principles in their public life and to lead by example.
4.79 The Council has retained a separate standards committee even though councils are no longer required to have this. This is a positive sign that standards are taken seriously. The Council has appointed Independent Persons as required by legislation.
4.80 The Standards Committee reviews the register of gifts and hospitality on a quarterly basis. The minutes of the meetings suggest that members of the committee are engaged. They have expressed views about members needing to be cautious about accepting gifts and hospitality, with the Monitoring Officer agreeing to send reminder to all members in June 2025 and again in September 2025. The Standards Committee also receives a report with updates on complaints on a regular basis.
4.81 The Committee has a work programme of regular items and in February 2025, it included review of arrangements for dealing with allegations, which was approved in September 2025. The Committee produces an annual report for the Full Council to consider.
4.82 There are elements of the standards framework that are operating well at a micro level. The Standards Committee needs to take a macro level view and be proactive in looking into the issues raised in this report in relation to member conduct and lead on improving member conduct and relations with officers, who do not feel valued by members. This includes in relation to ensuring there is an adequate Code of Conduct in place, as well as an organisational culture that supports a complaint process that operates effectively in practice. The Standards Committee should work with the Monitoring Officer and as necessary with the Head of Paid Service in leading this work, taking their advice on board.
Effectiveness of Audit Committee
4.83 Inspectors heard mixed views of the Audit Committee, although overall perceptions were generally positive. We were told that the committee’s standout strength was a co-opted member, who was described as exceptionally knowledgeable on local government audit and finance and his questioning added real clarity. He ensures that issues are properly understood and surfaced and the committee’s challenge to both officers and auditors has been appropriate and helpful.
4.84 The Audit Committee’s terms of reference and workplan meet the legal requirements. As is usual, the Committee receives the draft Annual Governance Statement before it is signed off by the Mayor and the Chief Executive. In March 2026, the Committee received an updated local Code of Corporate Governance to reflect the role of the Statutory Officers as detailed in the new Code of Practice on Good Governance for Statutory Officers, published in June 2024.
Formal and informal governance structures
4.85 The Council has an executive model of governance (as opposed to committee model) with a directly elected mayor. The Council has the necessary legally required decision-making committees, scrutiny committees and regulatory committees. It also has a number of additional committees to discharge the decision-making functions of the Executive, for example:
- Climate Change Committee
- Community Infrastructure Levy Committee (recently agreed to be re-established)
- Housing Committee
- Rural Affairs Committee (recently agreed to be re-established)
- Finance and Improvement Committee, since March 2026
4.86 There are very limited informal governance structures, which are even more necessary in a council with no overall control. There is a monthly forum for the Mayor to meet with all group leaders, alongside the Chief Executive, though we heard limited evidence on the impact and effectiveness of this forum in helping to reach political consensus and develop a shared direction for the Council. We understand an attempt was made in summer 2025 to establish an additional cross-party forum to support the budget but it did not proceed. Instead the opposition group leaders continue to meet without the Mayor. This may be valuable for the opposition group leaders but is not a substitute if the political leadership of the Council wish to progress matters in the interest of the residents of the borough, given it is the Mayor who has the executive powers and not opposition members.
4.87 The large numbers of formal public committees require significant officer support and production of reports, processing of questions and administering the committees. These committees all follow the same procedure rules for the Council, allowing public and member questions. As suggested above, these procedure rules in the constitution need to be reviewed to follow best practice.
4.88 These rather elaborate structures for the committees with the Council’s own version of public engagement have not resulted in improvements in the Council. The weaknesses identified in external reports before this Best Value Inspection remain largely unaddressed.
4.89 In a council with no overall control, we would expect a significant number of political discussions to be had behind the scenes to build consensus on key issues. When there is such a divide between the political groups and the atmosphere is combative, it is even more important to create informal forums for group leaders to discuss matters and reach agreements wherever possible to promote the interests of the Council and to better serve the people of the borough. This is because any public meeting will create the opportunity for political points to be made, which is natural, but the focus is lost on the outcomes needed.
4.90 The Council has emergent governance arrangements for its improvement work. These arrangements include a publicly held Finance and Improvement Committee, an Informal Improvement and Assurance Panel, a Children’s Improvement Board, an Adult’s Improvement Board, executive members meetings with council officers and a supporting officer governance.
4.91 The underlying principles that should guide this governance are:
- a clear focus on shared priorities
- coherence
- motivating and driving improvement
- collaborative working across political groups and with officers
- cross departmental working
- efficient use of limited capacity and avoidance of duplication
- transparency and independent challenge
- the use of an agreed data set reported to an agreed frequency
4.92 The current arrangements have emerged incrementally, often in response to external events such as inspections and reviews. The publicly held Finance and Improvement Committee and informal Improvement Panel are not delivering what is needed of them.
4.93 These various emergent improvement governance structures in the Council have not been designed to create an overall system of oversight and improvement that fit the Council’s improvement needs or good governance principles. There is an opportunity for the Council to start to model more positive leadership collaboration and governance in this work. The Council should review the current arrangements to make sure that they actively support coherent collaboration and improvement. This includes ensuring that there are effective informal governance structures that support collective officer and cabinet discussions on improvement, as well as wider strategy and policy issues.
Conclusion
4.94 Overall, the Council’s governance arrangements are not operating in a way that is fit for purpose for a unitary council with a directly elected mayor and no overall political control. The formal governance framework for finance and improvement is overly elaborate in some respects and underdeveloped in others; it creates friction, consumes scarce capacity and does not provide the clarity, pace or accountability the Council now requires. Lack of cross-party working, low levels of trust between members and of officers, weak scrutiny and longstanding defects in the constitution have combined to produce a system that too often impedes rather than enables sound decision-making on critical issues such as budget, performance improvement and transformation.
4.95 There are some signs of more recent stabilisation, including more structured working relationships within the golden triangle of core statutory officers and the current Monitoring Officer’s efforts to strengthen constitutional and conduct arrangements. However, these steps are not yet sufficient to offset the scale of the underlying weaknesses and lack of progress. The Council’s governance problems are structural as well as behavioural, and they have materially contributed to weak grip, slow decision-making and poor collective accountability. In inspectors’ view, the Council is therefore not meeting the standards of good governance required to discharge its Best Value Duty. It needs focused intervention to simplify and strengthen its governance framework, reset member-officer relationships, establish effective cross-party ways of working and ensure that decision-making is transparent and focused on outcomes for residents.
Governance recommendations
4.96 The following recommendations are designed to address the governance weaknesses identified in this report and to support the Council in meeting its Best Value Duty:
- The Council should urgently establish a cross-party governance framework. It should agree written protocols for cross-party engagement in the context of a directly elected mayor and no overall control. These should set out expectations for regular group leader engagement, confidentiality, dispute resolution and how political groups will work together on budget, transformation and improvement priorities.
- The Council should seek to reset member-officer and member-member relationships and standards of conduct within the Council. It should adopt and implement a clear member–officer protocol and a member development strategy including member-member relationships, following best practice. This should be supported by training and visible leadership from all group leaders, and reinforce the Nolan Principles, clarify the distinction between strategic leadership and operational management, and set expectations for respectful behaviour in public and private meetings. The Council should ensure that statutory advice is heard, recorded and properly considered in formal and informal decision-making. This work should begin as soon as possible, supported by the Standards Committee.
- The Standards Committee’s work should be more proactive, moving beyond case monitoring and taking a strategic role together with the Monitoring Officer and the Head of Paid Service in improving member conduct, culture and member-officer relationships as set out above. The Code of Conduct should be strengthened to include clear expectations of respect, with the Nolan Principles placed prominently at the front of the Code.
4.97
-
The Council should clarify the role of the Mayor’s Assistant. The Council should revise the role description for the Mayor’s Assistant, confirming that the role is limited to strategic, policy and administrative support to the Mayor and does not extend to directing officers, operational decisions, staffing matters or finance advice to members. The Mayor should, as soon as possible, agree with the Chief Executive an operating protocol for the Mayor’s Assistant and officers in the Council.
- The Council should streamline governance and improvement structures. The Council should review the number, purpose and workload of its committees and boards to ensure governance arrangements are proportionate, efficient and focused on delivery and improvement. Formal structures should be reduced where they duplicate activity or consume capacity without improving decision-making or accountability. The formal structures should be complemented or supported by informal meeting structures to resolve issues and to make sure that they actively support coherent collaboration and improvement. Informal structures should also ensure that there are effective collective forums for the Executive to meet with senior officers to discuss policy and strategy, and to support cross-party working.
- The Council should undertake a fundamental review of the constitution. The Council should simplify and modernise the constitution so that it is fit for a unitary council operating a mayoral model. The Monitoring Officer should be supported by the Constitution Review Working Group to address decision-making thresholds, delegations, call in criteria and the legal status of executive members and officers in scrutiny committees as planned. Working Group members should also allow the Monitoring Officer to address issues relating to public and member question arrangements, petition signature thresholds, scrutiny and council procedure rules, in line with best practice.
- The Council should reset scrutiny and executive relations so that scrutiny operates as an effective critical friend. Scrutiny arrangements should be redesigned to support constructive, evidence-led challenge focused on outcomes for residents. This should include greater use of pre-decision scrutiny, clear call in criteria, proper officer input, transparent tracking of scrutiny recommendations and a more collaborative relationship between scrutiny and the Executive. There should be regular (six monthly) informal meetings between the executive members and scrutiny chairs to discuss work programming, tracking of recommendations and effectiveness.
- The Council should build cross-party working into member development after the 2027 elections. If, following the 2027 elections, the Council remains under no overall control or has only a small or balanced majority, the member induction and development programme should include dedicated cross-party sessions on how members will work together in that political context. These should cover options for formal and informal arrangements, expectations of group leaders, constructive scrutiny and executive engagement, confidentiality, dispute resolution and shared behaviours needed to support decision-making in the interests of residents.
5. Use of resources
Introduction
5.1 The Best Value statutory guidance states that an authority must have in place and properly deploy an effective internal control environment to safeguard the use of resources, and clear and effective processes to secure value for money. It must have appropriate financial reporting and regulation arrangements in place, in accordance with CIPFA’s Financial Management Code, to govern the strategic and operational management of its investments, funding, assets and companies. This includes ensuring it has appropriate skills and capacity in place commensurate with the complexity of its finances, using specialised expertise when needed.
5.2 The following sections examine the financial position of the Council and consider the processes in respect of financial management and budget setting. In addition, it looks at the key functions of procurement, IT and internal audit. These are all areas that support the efficient and effective use of resources and provide the appropriate framework for the delivery of local services.
Financial management and budgeting
5.3 The Council’s planned revenue expenditure for 2026/27 is £253 million, which includes £25 million of EFS funded expenditure in 2026/27 (with the possibility of a further £33 million to finance some capital work relating to a new railway station that was going to be built and may need to be written out of the balance sheet). Excluding EFS, the net budget requirement is £228 million which is funded by Council Tax (£131 million), Business Rates (£53 million) and Revenue Support Grant (£44 million)[footnote 3].
5.4 Included in the net budget is £18 million of savings and efficiencies, and £18 million of growth and pressures.
5.5 The capital programme is set for £51.5 million in 2026/27, and a further £33.5 million in 2027/28 in addition to the £59 million in the 2025/26 programme. All of these years anticipate EFS. There is also an assumption that excess capital receipts (beyond those needed for transformation work) will be used to finance EFS, with borrowing being used to fund the difference. There is no detail shown of the anticipated split of financing between capital receipts and borrowing in the February 2026 budget report. However, a budget report to Council in November 2025 suggested that after the application of grants, reserves, S106 and CIL funding, some £113 million of borrowing and £44 million of capital receipts is to be applied. Borrowing is anticipated to rise to a maximum of £227 million by March 2028 and then reducing by 2030/31.
5.6 The Treasury Management Panel has raised concerns to the Executive regarding the overall level of borrowing. A key indicator regarding borrowing levels is looking at the proportion of financing costs to net revenue streams (this is a measure under the Prudential Code). For the Council, this will rise from 5.5% to 6.5% by 2028/29[footnote 4]. This is regarded low under the CIPFA Resilience Index.
5.7 The general reserve was anticipated to be £12.7 million at March 2026. Other reserves (excluding ringfenced and capital reserves) were estimated to be £8.4m as of 31 March 2026[footnote 5], which is clearly insufficient given the projected levels of EFS needed for 2025/26 and 2026/27. The Council commissioned a Financial Resilience and Governance Review from CIPFA in 2025, which stated “… we believe the Council is already in S114 territory…”. There is no doubt a S114 declaration would have been made by now if EFS had not been approved by MHCLG for both 2025/26 and 2026/27.
5.8 Given the future forecast deficits as set out in the February 2026 budget report (£27.6 million in 2027/28, £25.7 million in 2028/29 and £32.4 million in 2029/30 in addition to the £25 million in 2026/27, with a possible further £33 million mentioned above), there are significant financial concerns for the foreseeable future. Savings will therefore need to be found well in excess of those in the current year.
5.9 When the inspection team arrived in February 2026, the Council talked of its financial position in terms of a small overspend in 2023/24, with this increasing since then and for 2025/26. The draft position suggested a substantial overspend, in the order of £16 million at that time (based on January 2026 income and expenditure analysis). Children’s services in particular was of concern, suggesting an overspend of £13 million at that time, along with overspends in adult services and temporary accommodation. This had resulted in the request for EFS funding mentioned above of £20 million for that year and an indication of further deficits over the MTFS period to 2027/28 totalling £90 million across the 3 years.
5.10 On closer examination, there has been a trend of overspending on the ‘operational services’, of which adult services, children’s services and environment make up the majority, for some time. This has been offset in the past to some extent by ‘underspends’ on the financing budgets. The following tables, based on figures provided by the Section 151 Officer, demonstrates this[footnote 6]:
| 2023/24 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Budget | Actual | Variance | |
| Adult Services | 56.8 | 61.2 | 4.4 |
| Children’s Services | 44.7 | 46.2 | 1.5 |
| Environment | 28.0 | 26.7 | -1.3 |
| Total ‘demand led’ services | 129.5 | 134.1 | 4.6 |
| Other | 29.1 | 34.3 | 5.2 |
| Total operational budget | 158.6 | 168.4 | 9.8 |
| Financing | -0.1 | -10.1 | -10.0 |
| Net Expenditure | 158.5 | 158.3 | -0.2 |
| 2024/25 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Budget | Actual | Variance | |
| Adult Services | 64.8 | 68.5 | 3.8 |
| Children’s Services | 50.2 | 47.8 | -2.3 |
| Environment | 40.4 | 45.9 | 5.5 |
| Total ‘demand led’ services | 155.4 | 162.3 | 6.9 |
| Other | 22.9 | 22.1 | -0.8 |
| Total operational budget | 178.3 | 184.3 | 6.1 |
| Financing | -8.0 | -12.5 | -4.5 |
| Net Expenditure | 170.2 | 171.8 | 1.6 |
| 2025/26 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Budget | Actual | Variance | |
| Adult Services | 72.6 | 75.8 | 3.2 |
| Children’s Services | 47.3 | 61.7 | 14.4 |
| Environment | 41.5 | 40.2 | -1.3 |
| Total ‘demand led’ services | 161.4 | 177.7 | 16.3 |
| Other | 21.9 | 22.6 | 0.7 |
| Total operational budget | 183.3 | 200.3 | 17.0 |
| Financing | -5.7 | -7.3 | -1.6 |
| Net Expenditure | 177.6 | 193.0 | 15.4 |
| Inc over 3 years | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Budget | Actual | Variance | |
| Adult Services | 15.8 | 14.6 | -1.1 |
| Children’s Services | 2.7 | 15.5 | 12.9 |
| Environment | 13.5 | 13.5 | 0.0 |
| Total ‘demand led’ services | 31.9 | 43.6 | 11.7 |
| Other | -7.2 | -11.7 | -4.5 |
| Total operational budget | 24.7 | 31.9 | 7.2 |
| Financing | -5.5 | 2.8 | 8.4 |
| Net Expenditure | 19.2 | 34.7 | 15.6 |
5.11 As indicated above, overspends on the ‘operational’ budgets have risen from £9.8 million in 2023/24 to £17.0 million in 2025/26. At the same time, underspends on the financing budgets have fallen from £10.0 million in 2023/24 to £1.6 million in 2025/26. This exposes the fragility of the budgets for these operational areas.
5.12 While the main area of overspend during this time has been children’s services, over the 3 years the spend on the demand led services of adult services, environment and children’s services have each increased by very similar amounts (£14.6 million for adult services, £13.5 million on environment and £15.5 million on children’s services). However, it should be noted that housing services transferred into the environment services during this time with a budget of £8 million, so part of the increase in this area can be attributed to that move. Overall, while the budgets for adult services and environment have more or less kept pace with this trajectory, the budget for children’s services has only increased by £2.7 million over the same period.
5.13 However, ultimately, spend for the whole Council over the period was increasing considerably faster than funding sources, leading to the budget gap now seen. Without decisive action, this situation will continue or even worsen. The external auditors have recognised this position, reporting in September 2025 that financial sustainability was a significant risk to the Council. It is clear further significant savings must be found.
5.14 Inspectors have also found that the overspend on operational areas predates the current administration. The 2022/23 accounts indicate an operational overspend of £14.9 million, mainly due to children’s services at £7 million, environment (temporary accommodation) at £2.4 million and corporate services at £4 million. This was offset by £12.6 million underspend / surplus on the financing budgets, resulting in an overall net overspend in that year of £2.3 million.
5.15 This situation should therefore be well known to the Council, and in preparing the budget for 2026/27, it attempted to find savings to close the gap. This included an ambitious efficiency programme identified by Newton Ltd on children’s services, adult services and other areas across the Council, and some diagnostic work was carried out. Savings have been identified to be delivered over time, but these come with risks given the extent of change implied and the resourcing needed to implement the programme internally.
5.16 Over the last couple of years, the Council has commissioned various organisations to help identify savings, such as PWC, Grant Thornton and CIPFA. However, to date we are not aware of these being taken forward in terms of detailed analysis to identify pragmatic solutions that help to alleviate the financial deficit.
5.17 For 2026/27, £18 million of service savings have been included in the budget, of which £8 million is classified as ‘Green’ in terms of a RAG rating for deliverability, £3.2 million as ‘Amber’ and £7.3 million as ‘Red’. The most significant of this last category are £4.2 million relating to withdrawal of vacant posts, £2 million on children’s services and £600k recouping continuing healthcare costs from the Integrated Care Board.
5.18 A recent report by the independent Improvement and Assurance Panel has raised significant concerns about the 2026/27 financial position in terms of deliverability of the savings, notably in children’s services where the pace and adoption of transformation efforts was challenged and questioned whether some actions currently rated ‘Amber’ should instead be classed as ‘Red’.
5.19 Other savings put forward were not agreed by a majority of members. For example, suggestions of charging for garden waste and changes to the Council Tax Support Scheme were dismissed without any replacement savings identified. The Council therefore had to seek EFS to close the gap.
5.20 This is not a sustainable solution. EFS must be funded either by capital receipts, or by borrowing, which increases the demands on the revenue budget through borrowing costs. A permanent and sustainable solution must be found.
5.21 Looking at the Council’s savings history, CIPFA commented that the Council had a reasonably good record of delivering savings in 2023/24 and 2024/25, with a 10% failure rate largely relating to procurement, contract management and income generation. The report also commented that over the last 10 years, the ‘low hanging fruit’ has been identified and delivered, which therefore means the way ahead is more challenging.
5.22 The scale of savings needed as set out above necessitates the introduction of a wholesale transformation programme which considers the key priorities of the Council, the performance of the services both in terms of service delivery and unit cost, and the opportunities for efficiency saving. This programme needs to be underpinned by robust processes to maximise delivery success.
5.23 Given this, it is imperative that the administration considers at the earliest opportunity how it will engage with all members across the Council to design the budget for 2027/28 which identifies sufficient savings to close the overall MTFS gap and put the Council onto a sustainable footing.
5.24 The 2025 CIPFA Review stated “…it will also require engagement and support from all members and senior officers to collaborate and work together for the wider benefit of the borough and its communities”, and “it is important that there is a better working relationship across the parties to ensure the financial wellbeing and resilience of the Council”.
5.25 It is disappointing that despite these comments from CIPFA and others before, this spirit of genuine joint working was not seen during the inspection, although many stated it was their intention to do so and now blame each other for these good intentions not working out in practice. There are various tools and facilities available to the Council to help with this process, including the use of star chambers (where a cross-party selection of members could do a deep dive into a particular area), and use of scrutiny, external facilitators or other critical friend approaches, including from other neighbouring authorities, to help examine areas in a less political environment. The Council needs to consider what help it needs, and what it needs to do differently, because the process operated in the past has not worked, and the underlying overspends have been a serious issue for an extended period.
5.26 At the moment, while the Council does access a wide range of performance reporting and has multiple sets of dashboards which provide information, it is not clear how this is used in the day to day running of services and in the medium to longer term planning. The inspection team has not seen any evidence of the performance and benchmarking information being used to inform decisions or identify opportunities for savings or improving value for money. This will be essential for the future transformation work.
5.27 In her Section 25 report which accompanied the 2025/26 budget, the Section 151 Officer recommended that a resilience review should be carried out of the financial situation of the Council. This was commissioned from CIPFA in early 2025. The outcome of this work was formally agreed by the Executive in September 2025.
5.28 The findings of the CIPFA work are still relevant today and the review’s recommendations are still applicable (see Appendix B). While some of the recommendations have now been incorporated into the Council’s new Improvement Plan, others have not. Inspectors are not aware of any report to the Executive which explains why these have been excluded, despite the overall report being approved in the September Executive report. It is disappointing that the recommendations which are accepted are not being implemented with sufficient pace. The Council needs to consider what it needs to do to accelerate progress to implement the recommendations in a timely manner.
Finance function
5.29 The Council has a fairly stable finance function in terms of low turnover of staff. However, there is evidence supported by the CIPFA Review that the finance function is understaffed and workloads are very high. This has also been identified as a significant risk by external audit in their Value for Money September 2025 report to the Audit Committee.
5.30 We understand additional budget has now been provided to add capacity into the finance team, with a new structure being implemented in 2026/27. Finance posts, particularly in the technical finance team, have been hard to fill and there is a current reliance on the use of interim staff for these positions.
5.31 The inspection team did receive some feedback from budget holders which suggested that they did not always feel fully supported in managing their budgets, including in relation to training. This may in part reflect the transition to a self-service model of accessing support services, which is a common model in many local authorities now.
5.32 Some members also indicated that they had not been trained in the financial aspects of running a council. It was suggested to us that this should be made a priority, in particular for those members who are portfolio holders. Other members were complimentary about the support they received to carry out the financial responsibilities of their role.
5.33 Inspectors note that there have been 3 portfolio holders for finance and resources in the past 3 years. While changes in post holders are sometimes unavoidable, it is essential that this post holder in particular has appropriate finance training to understand the context in which the organisation works and the financial framework applicable to local government.
5.34 Regular budget management reports are produced for budget holders, the corporate leadership team and the Executive highlighting the financial position. The inspection team did not see any evidence of action being taken as a result of the information provided to manage the in-year position, nor to receive progress reports on any longer-term initiatives to manage demand across services.
Procurement
5.35 Like most authorities the Council procures considerable sums from the private sector rather than provide all services in-house. However, discussions with officers and members across the Council show that the procurement function is immature and commissioning is in its infancy. To enable the service to fully support the organisation going forward, it must:
- introduce a business partner approach with the rest of the organisation to support services going forward as they transform to more efficient ways of working and service delivery
- move to sophisticated commissioning to ensure procurement activity and expected outcomes line up with service strategies
- play a more active part in shaping the markets to support its transformation programme and new service strategies
5.36 There is no real evidence of strategic procurement that looks at models of service delivery, although the inspection team understands there is some early thinking to consider in-house provision versus external to ensure best value. However, there is insufficient in-house experience and expertise at the moment to take this thinking further.
5.37 The Council will also have to be more active in its contract management, which is currently considered to be a weakness in the Council. This is essential as the Council develops more sophisticated contracts, such as the risk and reward contracts with Newton Ltd.
5.38 A review of the capability and capacity of the function to ensure it is fit for purpose given the changing roles outlined above is therefore essential.
5.39 Most authorities are able to make significant savings through running a modern and effective procurement function linked into council priorities and performance management reporting, which identifies opportunities through comparison with others.
5.40 Inspectors understand there is good compliance to procurement regulations and have not seen any evidence to suggest otherwise.
IT and digital
5.41 An efficient IT service is essential for effective modern service delivery. The IT function at the Council is understaffed in certain key areas, including business analysis, business partners, security and compliance areas. Inspectors were informed that the servers are ‘in the cloud’ and the systems are reasonably up to date, as is individual kit. Systems are owned by the services, with systems administrators sitting in the local teams. IT users reported that system performance was on the whole satisfactory, notwithstanding some mixed feedback from Council staff on the quality of support and processes.
5.42 However, it was reported to the inspection team that there is little if any IT innovation, with the Council being reported as risk averse and change arising from IT being slow – a standard phrase being “we’ve always done it this way”. We were told that the Council does not allow the use of AI tools to help with basic tasks such as drafting letters.
5.43 Given the Council’s overall financial position and the workload pressure that many people mentioned to us, it is essential that the Council maximises its use of IT, digital and AI tools to allow it to work more efficiently and ease the workload pressure on staff. In doing this, it needs to consider how it will manage the associated change programmes to ensure risks are managed and confidence increased to ensure success.
Internal audit and risk
5.44 In its report to the Audit Committee in September 2025, the Head of Internal Audit provided an update on the audit programme and risk assessment. In summary, in terms of the 2025 audit programme, he reported that:
- “There were 47 completed audits, this equated to 83% of the Audit Plan and was slightly below the 90% target”
- “Full Assurance had been given to 7 Audits, 26 Audits received Substantial Assurance, 13 Audits received Adequate Assurance and 1 Audit had Limited Assurance”
- “He was confident that the Council’s control environment remained robust and had operated adequately across the Council during 2024/25”
5.45 In addition, the inspection team saw evidence of the implementation of recommendations arising from internal audits being completed in a timely manner. Where there was a delay, this was explained to the Audit Committee by the relevant area, demonstrating appropriate ownership of the control environment locally.
5.46 The 2025/26 audit programme was being updated following receipt of the CIPFA Review and the introduction of additional spending controls at that time. In addition, the audits of Financial Management, Resilience and Budgetary Control were being undertaken at the time of the Committee meeting “in direct response to the risks posed by the Council’s financial position.”
5.47 While helpful, both these examples could indicate that internal audit is getting involved ‘after the event’. As set out above, the financial issues and budget management issues have been prevalent for some time. The Council needs to further consider how it can use internal audit and risk functions in a more timely way to provide greater assurance and early warning of issues escalating.
Conclusion
5.48 The seriousness of the financial situation has been acknowledged by most people, but so far there is limited and insufficient evidence of action to improve. This is despite numerous external reports commissioned by the Council itself over an extended period highlighting the fragility of the Council’s finances and associated working practices.
5.49 As stated above, the build of the 2026/27 budget was problematic with very little collaboration between the political parties and some savings being voted down without any suggestion for alternatives being put forward. This left a substantial gap in funding which ultimately could only be closed with an injection of EFS of £20 million for 2025/26 and up to £25 million for 2026/27.
5.50 The inspection team understands that some limited cross-party conversations are now being undertaken which is helpful. However, the build of the 2027/28 budget will be very difficult given the scale of the problem, the history of blame between the parties, the incidence of EFS to be funded and the local government elections in May 2027.
5.51 This situation has not happened suddenly, nor has it happened solely because of external factors creating increased demand. It reflects the lack of strategic direction and focused leadership, a failure to understand the seriousness of the financial situation and take appropriate action, and a failure to understand the responsibility of all members across the whole Council to set the budget and take some difficult decisions to do so.
5.52 There is no doubt that without the EFS granted by the MHCLG in February 2026, the Council would have had to declare a Section 114 statement for 2025/26 and for 2026/27.
5.53 Given this, it is the view of the inspection team that the Council is failing in its Best Value Duty in its use of resources.
Use of Resources recommendations
5.54 Faced with this situation, we recommend that:
- The Council needs to develop and implement an agreed and inclusive budget process, which includes key dates and builds in scrutiny and executive processes, for all members to be aware of. It is imperative that this work is undertaken immediately and at pace.
- The Council should build a transformation programme to modernise the services that the Council provides to its residents and businesses. This should reflect the Council’s priorities and statutory requirements and enable the Council to meet its value for money duties.
A set of prioritised transformation projects, aligned with the key priorities in the streamlined Improvement Plan (children’s and adult services and financial sustainability) should be developed by December 2026 for immediate input into the 2027/28 budget. Developing a full transformation programme will be a longer-term endeavour that will be supported by any commissioners appointed.
-
By December 2026, the Council should identify sufficient savings to balance the MTFS, initially for 2027/28, and then for the medium-term beyond that. These savings should be supported by robust business cases to identify risks and demonstrate deliverability. This work should include the financing of the borrowing in relation to EFS. Alternatively, the Council should identify an asset disposal programme to fund EFS requirements.
-
The Council should carry out a review of IT and digital tools and procurement to ensure efficient and effective use of resources and maximise the opportunities for savings and efficiencies.
-
The Council should review all previous recommendations arising from external reviews, as well as external audit and internal audit, and build a comprehensive tracker which has ownership of actions and is reviewed regularly by an appropriate board or committee. If any recommendations are not felt to be relevant, they should be presented to this board or committee for approval to cancel. These external recommendations may be included in the transformation programme to provide one overall programme of improvement work, with appropriate governance arrangements to provide appropriate oversight.
-
In particular, the Council should implement the recommendations included in the CIPFA Financial Resilience and Governance Review 2025 (specifically, the Financial Recovery Plan Roadmap section included in the review at Appendix B, actions 1 to 19) as a matter of priority, to ensure the finance function and the operation of financial management across the organisation is fit for purpose and support the organisation through the next few years of intense recovery.
While the Council has started to implement some of these, and this inspection report makes a number of recommendations that overlap with those previously provided by CIPFA, it should review and complete remaining actions as soon as possible.
6. Service delivery
Introduction
6.1 The statutory Best Value guidance states: “Well run local services are customer and citizen focused and meeting the needs of diverse communities. They should improve outcomes for the people who use them and achieve the best balance of cost and quality (having regard to economy, efficiency and effectiveness).”
6.2 The section below considers service delivery from the point of view of the Council’s Corporate Plan dashboard, which examines performance against agreed targets. These targets are council-set, with some benchmarking and comparisons with national attainment included.
6.3 However, in addition to these measurements, there are other very significant inspections which provide further insight to the quality of service delivery. The main inspections are for children’s services and adult social care, and the outcomes of recent inspections relating to these services are set out below.
Children’s services
Ofsted Inspection - July 2025
6.4 Children’s services was downgraded to requires improvement to be good in all 5 areas when it was inspected in 2025 by Ofsted. The previous inspection in 2021 had rated the service as good.
6.5 The inspectors stated “The quality of practice and support for children and families in Bedford has declined since the last inspection of local authority children’s services (ILACS) in November 2021, when they were judged to be good in all areas. Local authority leaders have struggled to fully address significant challenges, particularly around increasing service demand, workforce and management capacity, placement sufficiency and weaknesses in performance. While they have been successful in addressing some of these challenges, in other areas sufficient progress has not been achieved.”
Focused Ofsted visit to Bedford children’s services – April 2026
6.6 This focused visit looked at arrangements for planning and achieving permanence for children in care, including long-term foster and kinship care, special guardianship, aspects of adoption and helping children return to their birth family. While the visit did highlight some areas where further development work is needed, it also identified some positive service delivery. The headline findings are:
- For children in Bedford, permanence is achieved through mostly well-considered decision-making that takes into account a wide range of available options to enable them to live in stable, lasting homes. While this decision-making is largely effective, children and their carers experience variability in the quality of planning and help across permanence pathways.
- Support for children in long-term foster care, planning for children who require adoption and helping children to move to family-based care from residential homes are strengths. Help for connected carers and special guardians is not sufficiently proactive or consistent, and direct work with children, including life-story work, is not widespread.
- Leaders have a mostly accurate understanding of strengths and areas for development in this area of practice. Since the last inspection, they have strengthened their focus on achieving permanence within families and increased the availability of suitable alternatives. This progress has contributed to more children living in, or close to, Bedford and significantly reduced the number of children who are placed in unregistered homes during their journey towards stable, secure homes.
6.7 The report identified some improvements needed in social work practice, namely the consistency and quality of help for connected carers and special guardians, the availability and quality of direct work with children, including life-story work, and the consistent application and oversight of permanence planning.
Area SEND inspection of Bedford Borough Local Area Partnership – November 2024
6.8 The inspection outcome is: “The local area partnership’s special educational needs and/or disabilities (SEND) arrangements typically lead to positive experiences and outcomes for children and young people with SEND. The local area partnership is taking action where improvements are needed. The next full area SEND inspection will be within approximately five years. Ofsted and the Care Quality Commission (CQC) ask that the local area partnership updates and publishes its strategic plan based on the recommendations set out in this report.”
Joint targeted area inspection of Bedford – February 2023
6.9 The inspection’s headline findings are that: “Children and their families benefit from a comprehensive range of universal and targeted early help services in Bedford, and the majority of children have timely early support when they need it. Partner agencies appropriately access targeted early help for families at the right time, and this is making a positive difference for most children. Children have good access to emotional well-being and mental health support, alongside effective interventions from the Adolescent Response Team (ART) and the Bedfordshire Police Education and Diversion Team. A lack of capacity by partner agencies in the Integrated Front Door (IFD) results in some children not having a timely response to meet their needs. Not all information about children and their families is requested or shared quickly enough between partner agencies. Neither individual agencies nor the Bedford Borough Safeguarding Children’s Partnership (BBSCP) have sufficient oversight of the effectiveness of early help and the IFD, given the increase in children’s contacts and the need for help and support.”
6.10 We are aware that a Children’s Improvement Board has been set up to oversee improvements in this area.
Adult social care
Bedford Borough Council: Local Authority Assessment – March 2026
6.11 Overall the service received a score of 42, 4 above the inadequate level. This equates to requires improvement judgement (score range 38 – 62). Some areas were marked as inadequate (score of 1).
6.12 The following sets out the scoring of each measure:
| Measure | Score |
|---|---|
| Assessing Needs | 1 |
| Supporting People to lead healthier lives | 2 |
| Equality in experience and outcomes | 2 |
| Care provision, integration and consistency | 2 |
| Partnerships and communities | 2 |
| Safe Pathways, systems and transitions | 2 |
| Safeguarding | 1 |
| Governance, management and sustainability | 1 |
| Learning, improvement and innovation | 2 |
6.13 The above assessments are important. Improvement plans will be monitored carefully by central government departments and improvements in the ratings will be expected. Significantly, they point to areas of lower than expected quality in service delivery and can also indicate areas of potentially unsafe practice.
6.14 As set out under the leadership and culture section, the Council’s Executive and scrutiny members and some senior officers were surprised by the findings of the recent Ofsted and Care Quality Commission inspections. This suggests underdeveloped systems of oversight and low collective self-awareness, but also a potentially slightly distant view of frontline services delivery.
Service performance assessment
6.15 Another source of intelligence about the quality of service delivery is reference to service performance monitoring.
6.16 The inspection team reviewed the Council’s Corporate Plan dashboard from Quarter 3 of 2025/2026, to help understand how well the Council is delivering key services and its approach to performance assessment. Progress is reported on a quarterly basis to the Executive, with an annual year-end report. It is accessible to the public through meeting papers.
6.17 The dashboard draws on a range of recognised national datasets across services and includes over 80 key performance indicators. In several service areas, it benchmarks local performance against national, statistical neighbour and/or regional comparators. However, this is not applied consistently.
6.18 Across service areas, targets are typically set at or slightly below national benchmarks or closely aligned with current performance. Performance broadly in line with or just under national attainment is often sufficient to achieve a ‘Green’ RAG rating rather than when stronger than peer authorities. In some cases, ‘Amber’ is used where performance is materially below comparators. Where performance is assessed as ‘Red’ this typically reflects substantial underperformance relative to targets and comparators rather than a small variance. No information on cost, unit cost or value for money is embedded within the dashboard, either through standalone metrics or as contextual information alongside service performance. Some unit costings are available through LGA Futures. This would allow greater analysis on performance from a value for money perspective, along with comparisons with statistical and regional neighbours and wider across the country.
6.19 The Council tends to perform more strongly on operational or process-based indicators, such as timeliness and compliance, than on outcome measures or outcome proxies. In some cases, outcome focused RAG indicators are rated ‘Amber’ or ‘Red’ and remain below national or statistical neighbour comparators where process measures are rated ‘Green’. This indicates that while there is evidence of operational grip in parts of the organisation, this has not yet consistently translated into improved outcomes for residents or reduced system pressures.
Service analysis
Children’s services and education
6.20 Performance against education aims present a mixed picture. Early Years Foundation Stage outcomes and Key Stage 4 attainment are broadly in line with national averages. However, Key Stage 2 attainment is weaker and significantly below benchmarks, particularly for pupils with SEND. Post 16 outcomes show a continuing area of relative weakness.
6.21 In children’s services, ‘Green’ performance relates to the process measures of review timeliness for children looked after and timeliness of Educational Health Care Plans. However, several key outcome indicators show deterioration, including increases in the rate of children subject to child protection plans, rising numbers of children looked after, weakening placement stability and low engagement of care leavers in education, employment or training. The data indicates that this decline has origins in 2024/25 and into 2025/26.
6.22 Where improvements are observed over time, with some exceptions, these often mirror national or sector wide trends rather than indicating a closing of the performance gap with comparable authorities or nationally.
Homelessness and adult social care
6.23 Three homelessness and rough sleeping indicators drawn from national H CLIC data are included within the dashboard. These are presented without national or statistical neighbour benchmarking, although these comparisons are possible using publicly available data. The number of households living in temporary accommodation is treated as contextual information and not as a performance indicator. While this reflects the demand led nature of homelessness, the Council has a degree of influence over temporary accommodation levels through its approach to prevention, supply and system flow. Treating this indicator as contextual limits visibility of the scale of pressure and the extent to which levels surpass those in comparable authorities.
6.24 There is no separate performance metric for the use of bed and breakfast (B&B) accommodation. B&B usage is included within total temporary accommodation figures. Although this figure is broken down in the accompanying commentary, this approach limits visibility of performance against statutory requirements and the most acute forms of temporary accommodation. Homelessness prevention activity is rated ‘Green’ and on track against a static target over recent years, though overall demand for homelessness services and the use of temporary accommodation has not yet shown consistent improvement.
6.25 In adult social care, direct payments uptake has shown gradual improvement but remains well below national and regional averages. The percentage of adults in contact with secondary mental health services in settled accommodation also shows a considerable reduction since May 2025.
Environment, highways and planning
6.26 Several environmental and highways indicators show evidence of recent improvement, particularly in relation to response time measures such as repair times for urgent defects. However, performance on nonurgent repairs and fly-tipping enforcement is weaker.
6.27 In planning, performance is consistently rated ‘Green’ and exceeds local targets. However, these targets are significantly below national comparators. This limits the extent to which ‘Green’ ratings reflect strong comparative performance.
Promoting health and wellbeing
6.28 The performance picture for health and wellbeing is mixed. Outcome-related indicators showing gradual deterioration or limited improvement include unplanned hospitalisation for chronic ambulatory care sensitive conditions and growing inequalities in life expectancy. Stronger performance is seen in measures such as achieving independence for short-term social care service clients and people aged 65 and over. Process focused indicators and partnership activity measures are also more likely to be rated ‘Green’, although there are weaknesses in areas such as the timeliness of adult social care assessments.
Conclusion
6.29 Taken together, the evidence from the Corporate Plan dashboard suggests that the Council demonstrates some operational grip over processes and compliance, but this is not consistently translating into improved outcomes for citizens or reduced system pressures. While the Council does not hold all the levers to drive improvement, it plays a critical role as a local place leader. The choice of targets, and sometimes inconsistent use of comparators, contribute to a performance picture that lacks ambition and can present performance more positively than comparative evidence would suggest.
6.30 Significantly, the two areas of children’s services and adult services have both been subject to significant external review. In both cases, these have been rated as requires improvement, necessitating improvement boards to be established and comprehensive programmes to be put in place.
6.31 It is inspectors’ view that the lack of vision outlined in the leadership and culture section has a bearing on a lack of ambition in the Council for service delivery improvement beyond the statutory areas subject to the Ofsted and CQC inspections. This translates into targets that are generally not stretching, a tendency for silo working and lack of innovation in delivery of outcomes. Overall, the inspection team are not convinced that the Council can demonstrate consistent continuous improvement in their service delivery.
Service delivery recommendations
6.32 In this context, we recommend that:
- The Council should use performance information (including benchmarking information) to inform its service planning process and its transformation programme, to identify opportunities to reduce costs and improve value for money.
- The Council should adopt a more joined up approach to working across departments to reduce silo working and improve value for money. This will be supported by the clear vision for the Council and Bedford following the next elections.
- The Council should set appropriately ambitious targets for the measures included in the Corporate Plan to ensure continuous improvement is delivered across all services.
7. Partnerships and community engagement
Introduction
7.1 The Best Value statutory guidance sets out on the theme of partnerships and community engagement that authorities should have a clear understanding of and focus on the benefits that can be gained through partnership working. There should be appropriate governance structures in place to oversee these arrangements.
Consultations and engagement should be fair, open and inclusive.
7.2 Working in partnership is critical for a local authority in joining up services for residents and developing the place it serves socially, environmentally and economically. Engaging local residents and partners is necessary to properly understand and respond to local needs and to help people understand and contribute to changes taking place locally.
7.3 Bedford Borough Council has established some positive relationships with its partners and community. However, these relationships are not driven by a clear vision and ambition for the Borough and do not consistently deliver continuous improvement. Governance, data and oversight mechanisms need to be strengthened. The Council needs to bolster its approach in order to make the most of the opportunities offered by the major developments in the area.
7.4 The Council carries out consultation when it is required to do so, but not consistently to high standards.
Vision and approach
7.5 Partnerships with public, private, voluntary and community groups are crucial for effective approaches to economic growth, environmental sustainability, service outcomes and effective use of resources.
7.6 Bedford participates in all the normal relationships for a local authority. Both members and officers play a role in these different relationships. Inspectors heard particularly that the role of the Chief Executive is sometimes welcomed as a constructive collaborator. Many partners appreciated the Mayor’s openness to partnership working.
7.7 The Council has not developed a co-produced and shared vision and strategic direction for the local area, which can help build a cohesive, long term and purposeful partnership environment. This limits the effectiveness of partnership working and means that while individual partner relationships may make progress, there is a lack of collective effort on agreed priorities. This lack of vision also means there is a risk the Council is not able to spot and grasp opportunities for the borough and is instead left reacting to events. The inspection team also heard evidence that the Council was not always responsive to partner approaches with ideas for joint work.
7.8 Although partners often felt the Council was visible in partnership working, the Council is often not seen as a driving force to achieve outcomes in partnerships. We heard evidence that the Council had often not fully developed its approach to partnerships and did not always offer leadership when it was needed.
7.9 We were impressed by the quality of local organisations who worked with the Council. This provides opportunities which the Council is not currently making the best of.
Universal United Kingdom Resort
7.10 The Universal UK Resort project to bring a theme park and resort to Bedford is a major national project, as well as being a hugely significant opportunity for Bedford and its surrounding areas. There are major opportunities for job creation and business growth, as well as a requirement for new transport infrastructure and housing.
7.11 The Council has played a positive role in attracting the Universal investment in the borough and they are currently playing a constructive role working with Universal and the government as the project develops. Universal has invested a significant sum in ensuring the Council planning service has the capacity to support the work that will be needed from them in the coming years in a timely way. The government is also strongly committed and will support the project with an investment of £1.3 billion on regional and local community infrastructure.
7.12 While the resort project itself will move forward with increasing intensity, we have not seen evidence that the Council is well-placed to offer strategic leadership to ensure the Universal project is delivered with maximum benefit and mitigated disruption for residents.
7.13 The pace and scale of the development would be difficult for any authority to manage. Given the Council’s limited capacity, the inspection team is concerned that the pace and volume of the permits and licences that are needed for the project will be difficult for the Council to cope with. Similarly, the Council will be confronted with very significant decisions to make on the associated new homes and infrastructure that will be needed to accompany the resort. This will need a very significant step change in ambition and decision-taking by members.
7.14 The Council needs to develop a strategy for ensuring the project brings maximum benefit locally, as well as strengthening its convening role with local stakeholders to support skills development and community engagement and communication.
Partnership governance and performance
7.15 The Council hosts or participates in the normal statutory governance, including with the NHS and the police. Where partnership is not statutory, there is less evidence of coherent governance. As discussed above, the Council has an opportunity to bring all partners together to develop collective partnership work on shared priorities. This could offer a more consistent basis for relationships with partners such as the voluntary sector, Further Education, Higher Education and business sectors.
7.16 Inspectors found evidence of varying degrees of performance management and impact in different areas of partnership working. Data support and oversight mechanisms need to be strengthened in some partnerships.
7.17 The partnership with the police and public health partnerships have shown positive results, but other areas have not delivered continuous improvement.
7.18 Inspectors heard evidence that the concerning educational attainment gap between young people from different backgrounds had begun to be addressed as a result of an initiative for the local charity sector.
7.19 Recent Ofsted and CQC assessments of children’s and adult social care suggest there is significant work to do to develop performance and oversight systems across the partnerships in these service areas.
7.20 The inspection team found that economic development partnership working was also underdeveloped and lacking strategic intent. While some good work has happened to support Bedford town centre, this was not guided by a clear vision, and there is still significant work to do to make sustainable improvement in the town centre for businesses and residents.
7.21 The Council runs and participates in a number of shared services with neighbouring authorities. With the exception of the public health partnership, inspectors heard evidence that continuous improvement in these services was not systematic and reliable.
Capacity and capability
7.22 The inspection team heard from a wide range of stakeholders that the lack of Council capacity and capability to support and drive partnership working was limiting effectiveness. There were often either single officers or small corporate coordinating teams supporting partnership working, including in work with the voluntary sector, health, communications and community engagement areas.
7.23 We also heard that the Council’s financial position has impacted the length and predictability of voluntary sector funding.
7.24 Many people commented positively to inspectors about the Council’s response to a recent emergency in Cleat Hill, where the Council positively responded and coordinated with partners.
Community engagement
7.25 The Council carries out the consultation it is required to do as part of its normal business, for instance consultations on service change and budget proposals. The voluntary sector is often positive about the Council’s openness in involving them in consultation activity. There have also been less positive consultation processes – notably the consultation on garden waste charges, where after the consultation had concluded, the Mayor reportedly told the local press in Bedford he had not intended to introduce the changes.
7.26 The Council has developed what it calls a community engagement strategy. The focus of this is on standards of professional practice in community engagement.
7.27 There is limited coordination of consultation and engagement activity across the Council and efforts to make consultation accessible were inconsistent. Departments lead their own approach with varying degrees of priority and innovation in methods. Like other corporate issues, there is limited capacity within the corporate core of the Council to bring together a unified strategic approach to engagement.
7.28 The formal public governance of the Council, like full Council and the Executive, do offer residents opportunities to ask questions of Council members.
7.29 Equality is not a central focus for the administration but the Council uses its formal consultation processes to help inform the equality impact assessments it has a duty to undertake.
7.30 The Council last undertook an open resident survey across its services in 2023. The inspection team did not find a clear strategic approach to resident surveys and driving resident satisfaction. We also did not find a systematic approach to learning from resident feedback across surveys, complaints, member casework and FOI requests.
7.31 Looking ahead, the Council will need to develop a strategic approach to community engagement and strengthen the connection between community engagement and strategic communication. Closing the budget gaps in the medium-term, as well as transforming services and managing the major changes to Bedford as a place, will need strong resident engagement in the future vision for the Council and the borough. Without this, it will be much harder to sustain public support for and involvement in these significant changes.
Conclusion
7.32 The Council works to sustain cordial relationships with its partners and community but does not provide sufficient leadership, vision and drive to achieve continuous improvement in its partnership working. It also risks not making the most of the significant opportunities presented by major local economic and transport projects.
Partnerships and community engagement recommendations
7.33 Inspectors therefore recommend that:
- The Council should strengthen the governance of the local work on the Universal UK Resort with partners, and develop a strategy for maximising the opportunities presented by the project for local residents, as an immediate priority.
- The Council should review local partnership governance in the light of a new ambition, vision and priorities for Bedford as a place following the 2027 local elections.
- The Council should review its ambition and capacity to drive economic, social and environmental development, considering the major opportunities it has and the accompanying need for local homes and skills, following the local elections.
8. Conclusion: Delivering Best Value and continuous improvement
8.1 During the course of the inspection we met many members, officers and partners with pride in Bedford and strong commitment to the place. We heard that relationships with partners were often cordial.
8.2 The Best Value Duty does not require perfection from a local authority, but it does require a sense of direction and drive that motivates continuous improvement in service quality, financial management and quality of the local place.
8.3 In Bedford, we did not find the vision and ambition for the Council or the place that is needed to drive this improvement consistently, even though we found isolated pockets of improvement.
8.4 Fundamentally there is a problem of leadership. Neither the Mayor, cabinet, political groups or most senior officers could find the will, understanding and commitment to confront problems and tackle them. This was partly caused by a desire to avoid accountability for decisions and change, which further resulted in a search for blame rather than solutions.
8.5 The Council does not have the effective governance arrangements across both cabinet and officers and across parties which are routine in other authorities. A previous attempt to develop an additional cross-party forum focused on the 2026/27 budget was not successful and cabinet/officer governance was still developing at the time of the inspection.
8.6 Officer capacity and capability is stretched and is being further eroded by finance driven reductions. Staff morale and engagement is low.
8.7 The Council has not chosen to systematically manage and implement the recommendations of several external reviews. It has only recently written an improvement plan which still needs much further development. There is a weak track record of successful transformation and change in recent years.
8.8 The problems set out above are now expressing themselves in a significant deterioration of the financial position of the Council.
8.9 As an inspection team we judge that the Council is failing to meet its Best Value Duty across all themes of the duty, but particularly in leadership, governance, culture and use of resources. We have no confidence that the Council will be able to address this without external intervention.
8.10 Strong leadership, positive culture, clear governance and aligned finances and priorities are essential for continuous improvement. The lack of these qualities, together with the evidence of deterioration in service and financial performance, means that we judge the Council is not achieving its duty of continuous improvement.
8.11 The Council has an urgent need to identify a small number of priorities to address its rapidly escalating problems with its limited capacity. Over the next year, tackling the large financial gap and improving services for vulnerable adults and children are crucial.
8.12 Beyond that period, and after the 2027 elections, it is essential the Council sets out its clear vision and priorities which take into account the financial position. This will provide the backbone for future service planning and delivery.
Appendix A: Recent external reviews and inspections
In recent years, the Council has been subject to a number of external reviews and inspections which the inspection team has reviewed, including:
- LGA Corporate Peer Challenge, undertaken October to November 2023 - LGA Corporate Peer Challenge Final Report
- LGA Corporate Peer Challenge Progress Review, undertaken October 2024 - LGA Corporate Peer Challenge Final Report 2024
- CIPFA Financial Resilience and Governance Review, August 2025 - D459056801771181.pdf
Appendix B: CIPFA Financial Resilience and Governance Review recommendations
The following recommendations and actions for Bedford Borough Council come from CIPFA’s Financial Resilience and Governance Review of the Council from August 2025. We have included them here given the ongoing relevance of many of these recommendations to the Council. Some of these recommendations overlap with those made in this inspection report.
In particular, we recommend that the Council implements actions 1 to 19 from the Financial Recovery Plan Roadmap section of the Review (Chapter 7):
1. Early engagement with MHCLG setting out the urgent financial challenges and share proposals for recovery and exploring opportunities for support.
2. Following the budget holder briefing in April, put in place a regular forum to communicate and engage with all budget holders it must reset and align its behaviours, culture and practices to a new way of working. Only then can the organisation achieve its north star in relation to financial sustainability.
3. Develop an outline recovery plan to form the basis for a more detailed plan that sets out how the Council will achieve financial sustainability in 2025-26. This should include (as a minimum):
- refresh and reset a spending control panel to stop any discretionary expenditure
- developing a plan for significant shorter-term cost reductions and income generation
4. Review aged debt and initiate recovery and write-off processes to clear down the debt and maximum recovery. If there is limited in-house capacity and expertise, it would be advisable to bring external specialist support. Assess the extent to which third party support and intervention could accelerate a positive financial impact on the outstanding debt portfolio.
- reviewing capital commitments to reduce impact on revenue budget – stop, delay, mothball. This could be facilitated as a key set of early actions through the newly established Strategy Asset Group
- identifying those assets that are no longer cost effective to maintain or can help mitigate the costs of additional borrowing by providing more of an immediate delivery focus to the pipeline of asset sales
- acceleration of the work being commissioned by Adult Social Services with a clear brief on purpose and outcomes
- revisit the improvement plan prepared for Children Services and identify opportunities for taking some of the recommendations forward that would better support the emerging demand and cost pressures
- undertake a comprehensive review of the reserves position (focused on committed service and unspent grant reserves) and ensure that the reserves are aligned with the Council’s strategic risk register
5. Ensure that senior management issue regular communications to promote the importance of robust and sound financial management alongside clear boundaries for staff to work within to ensure that levels of empowerment are increased but commensurate with increased levels of financial accountability.
6. Publishing guidance on when business cases should be created with clear support and training to be provided by the Finance team to develop a programme focused on improving the commercial culture. Business cases to include full modelling and sensitivity analysis to ensure they are fit for purpose.
7. Undertake a full review of the capacity and capability of the finance team but also other corporate functions to assess the capacity to deliver change and emerging priorities and focusing on the development of a permanent team, progression and succession arrangements.
8. Introduce a more structured approach to developing and implementing savings plans integrated with finance monitoring and with continual cashflow monitoring if appropriate. Delivery of savings should be included to the corporate risk register.
9. Establish appropriate governance arrangements to ensure the continued support and commitment of elected members, especially at the interconnect point of decision making required around the future delivery of services and the hard choices that will inevitably need to be made.
10.Reaffirm the working arrangements, roles and responsibilities and relations between members and officers.
11. Enhance the finance support provided to adults, children and environment (Housing) services to support robust analysis.
12. Ensure that a clear and deliverable debt recovery plan is created as early as possible to drive forward the work required to deliver tangible (cashable) returns for the Council in-year and beyond.
13. A comprehensive and integrated reset of the Capital Strategy needs to be developed which considers all aspects of the capital programme, financing arrangements and lifecycle revenue implications within the challenging financial environment.
14.Conduct a short review of the control environment, such that there is a well understood view of the programme of changes required within the Council’s control environment. Ensuring at the same time that the financial regulations are brought in line with good financial prudence and practice and that all staff (including budget managers) are made aware of the revised processes along with the implications of not following them.
15. As part of the Council looking at its asset base more strategically and within the scope of the Strategic Asset Group, review the existing portfolio and align with the stability plan and the medium-term financial plan.
16.Commence the Agresso replacement project integrated, but in parallel with the priority commitment to financial sustainability. Ensure that a programme of improvements to budget ownership and key system integration fixes is maintained and effectively communicated. As these changes become known to the point of deployment, the roles and responsibilities of Finance and budget holders needs to be recalibrated to ensure that lines of demarcation are clear.
17. Deploy the CIPFA Finance Competency Model in Finance (and extend to budget managers) to assess the financial awareness and relative maturity of financial matters including financial literacy and understanding. This work needs to be done in parallel with any other work being undertaken by Finance in upskilling budget managers on the new system and ensuring there are clear lines of demarcation between Finance and other (service-based) roles.
18.Improve support for budget holders to improve financial ownership and management of budgets across the organisation enabling more value adding support from finance business partners. Noting that this needs to be in conjunction with better resourcing and development of the FBP community.
19. Going forward, further work is needed in the short term to build a more robust 2026-27 to 2029-30 MTFP, specifically underpinned by improved demand modelling, a more nuanced approach to funding gap.
20. Undertake a comprehensive review of procurement to consider data and transparency, systems, overall operating model, Standing Orders and financial regulations etc. alongside the scope to enhance contract management capabilities.
21. Overall, across services there is a relatively good understanding of cost benchmarks and comparators. However, this varies and there is scope to create a stronger basis to drive key lines of enquiry to support and challenge service costs.
The CIPFA Review also includes Financial Management and Sustainability recommendations:
- going forward, further work is needed in the short term to build a more robust 2026-27 to 2029-30 MTFP, specifically underpinned by improved demand modelling in particularly for Adults, Children and Housing services including using the worst case predictions for identifying the budget gap
- clear and council wide income and debt strategy supporting by robust income management and concessions policy and procedures.
- review and benchmark the Council Tax Support scheme with near neighbours and comparator authorities and align with corporate plan priorities
- robust specification for the external review of Adult social care and clear, actionable deliverables
- core services such as Finance, legal and procurement have been adversely affected by prior savings as and should be reset to be able to provide the right level of support to the organisation
- budget management and budget holder training
- review of current procurement and contract management support and training, refresher training
- greater engagement and oversight during development of savings proposals, tracking and reporting and aligned with budget monitoring and reporting
- review of approval limits, decision thresholds, scheme of delegations
- update constitution and decision making arrangements including role and purpose of scrutiny and oversight functions, number of committees, panels and respective compositions following the review under way by the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny
- review the decision and timetable for upgrade/replacement of finance systems to better align with council requirements
- digital and technology strategy to better align systems, to support better information and decision making
- review of system based controls and processes to better manage procure to pay processes and compliance
- review and risk assess all agreed saving proposals for deliverability covering both value and timeframe. Identify mitigations for any slippage or non- delivery
- review and update the Council Tax Support scheme to ensure that it continues to support the most vulnerable residents
- conduct a short review of the control environment, ensuring at the same time that the financial regulations are brought in line with good financial prudence and practice and that all staff (including budget managers) are made aware of the revised processes along with the implications of not following them
Commercial Investment and Debt recommendations:
- review the asset and investment portfolio to identify those assets which are no longer supporting the corporate priorities or are expensive to maintain should be considered for disposal to fund the capital investment programme and reduce the requirement for external borrowing
- review the assets and estates management service to ensure that it is outcome focused and is fully aligned with the emerging priorities and financial resilience
- ensure that a clear and deliverable debt recovery plan is created as early as possible to drive forward the work required to deliver tangible (cashable) returns for the Council in-year and beyond into 2025-26
- assess the extent to which third party support and intervention could accelerate a positive financial impact on the outstanding debt portfolio
- explore the opportunities for refinancing the external debt portfolio to reduce costs and provide more certainty over the longer term financial planning period
Capital Programme recommendations:
- as part of a wider recovery plan and in light of the proposals regarding the development and funding of Wixams train station, review capital commitments to reduce impact on revenue budget – stop, delay, mothball. This could be facilitated as a key set of early actions and aligned with the stability plan and most recent MTFS
- capital projects to proceed once all funding is in place and maximise external contributions
- focus on transformation and service redesign programmes
- review current loan portfolio with a view to switching short term borrowing to longer term borrowing to support improve cashflow and budget planning and management.
- regular update to MRP calculation and MTFP modelling
Governance and Culture recommendations:
- demonstrate that the Council is committed to delivering the changes required. The Council will need to further enhance the importance of securing financial sustainability into a revised corporate plan
- ensure that senior management issue regular communications to promote the importance of robust and sound financial management alongside clear boundaries for staff to work within to ensure that levels of empowerment are increased but commensurate with increased levels of financial accountability
- establish appropriate governance arrangements to ensure the continued support and commitment of elected members, especially at the interconnect point of decision making required around the future delivery of services and the hard choices that will inevitably need to be made
- building on the recently agreed stability plan, establish how the Council will maintain financial sustainability in 2025-26 and beyond. This should integrate finance, change activity, and include:
- reviewing the next level of detail on the 2025-26 savings plans to gain the assurance that the savings are deliverable
- progress on delivery of savings is included within the monthly budget monitoring process and reporting
- a strengthened spending control panel with senior leadership and ownership
- build additional expertise in project management and change management to support the senior management team and the wider organisation to deliver meaningful and sustainable change initiatives, ensuring at the same time that the organisation avoids change overload and in the longer term, change fatigue
There are a number of recommendations to improve the effectiveness of the finance function:
- Undertake a full review of the capacity and capability of the finance team but also other corporate functions to assess the capacity to deliver change especially taking forward some of the recommendations of this review focusing on the specialist areas of local government finance. The structure needs to be reviewed alongside a full review of the capacity and capability of the Finance team to support the emerging priorities and responses. The review should include a focus on development of a permanent team, progression and succession arrangements.
- There is a clear requirement for support for the S151 to bolster corporate capacity and support the transition to a balanced MTFP. Careful thought to be given to the Finance manager roles to ensure that they have the experience and autonomy to take forward the change agenda within Finance and across the organisation as a whole.
- Deploy the CIPFA Finance Competency Model in Finance (and extend to budget managers) to assess the financial awareness and relative maturity of financial matters including financial literacy and understanding. This work needs to be done in parallel with any other work being undertaken by Finance in upskilling budget managers on the Agresso system and ensuring there are clear lines of demarcation between Finance and other (service-based) roles.
- Improve support for budget holders to improve financial ownership and management of budgets across the organisation enabling more value adding support from finance business partners. Noting that this needs to be in conjunction with better resourcing and development of the FBP community.
- Publish guidance on when business cases should be created with clear support and training to be provided by the Finance team to develop a programme focused on improving the commercial culture. This will ensure that tolerances for error are managed out of the process prior to business cases being formally submitted for review and approval. Also consider a retrospective review of existing business cases including full modelling and sensitivity analysis to ensure they are fit for purpose. It is also recommended that enabling functions are improved. Key requirements are:
- A comprehensive review of procurement to consider data and transparency, systems, overall operating model, Standing Orders and financial regulations etc. alongside the scope to enhance contract management capabilities. We understand that this is already being considered and support the need for this review.
- Undertake a review of procurement to pay systems and the associated controls.
- Review of the billing and collection activities to focus on increasing pay first options, active debt recovery and a more efficient and timely write-off process.
Appendix C: Case studies
Case study 1: The Improvement Plan
1.1. Inspectors examined the Council’s corporate Improvement Plan in detail, given that it is the Council’s primary mechanism for responding to external challenge and delivering the transformation programme needed to drive improvement. Inspectors also received papers for and attended Informal Improvement and Assurance Panel meetings and interviewed members of the panel.
1.2. This case study highlights issues with the Council’s current approach to delivering the improvements required. It is particularly relevant to the Best Value themes of leadership, culture, governance, and continuous improvement.
Development
1.3. In October 2025, the Council began developing a corporate Improvement Plan following a period of external challenge. The plan was intended to bring together a number of improvement work strands into a single framework for addressing identified weaknesses across governance, finance, performance and service delivery. Its ambition was to set the vision, priorities and direction for the Council and its improvement journey. It was approved by the Executive in January 2026. At the point of approval, a central tracker was also established to help monitor delivery.
1.4. The Improvement Plan partially incorporates and ultimately supersedes the Council’s previous Stability Plan, which had been approved in April 2025 and had a more specific focus on financial stability. Inspectors found that some interviewees were unclear about the relationship between the Stability Plan and the Improvement Plan and whether both were still in effect.
1.5. Some of the external recommendations the Improvement Plan is seeking to address date back to CIPFA’s Review (2025) and the LGA Corporate Peer Review in 2023. While the Council’s Improvement Plan reflects many of the key issues raised through these reviews, the inspection team is not confident that it provides a complete, clearly articulated and systematic response to all outstanding external recommendations.
1.6. Inspectors were told that external consultants played a significant role in the formation of the Improvement Plan. This included work by CIPFA and short-term support brought in with relevant transformation expertise. While this external input was intended to strengthen the Plan, inspectors heard that there was at times limited engagement with and from some senior officers during its development. We also heard that the plan did not secure buy-in across parties as it was produced. This limits its political and organisational ownership and poses risks to its stability.
Current operation and governance
1.7. The Improvement Plan is intended to operate as a living document and remains subject to ongoing development. It contains over 100 actions structured around four aims with identified outcomes. However, given the scale of activity captured, actions are not clearly prioritised.
1.8. The Improvement Plan does not yet fully articulate how the scale of savings required to address the Council’s budget gap will be delivered. The Council continues to operate and report against a partially overlapping Savings/Efficiency Plan, which has a separate savings dashboard. This contributes to a complex and confusing landscape. Given that one of Council’s key priorities must be to secure a more sustainable financial footing, it is inspectors’ view that this omission is a serious weakness of the Improvement Plan.
1.9. The governance and oversight arrangements for the Improvement Plan are extensive. These include monthly executive Improvement Plan boards (previously fortnightly), monthly independent Informal Improvement and Assurance Panels (officer only), and a recently established publicly held Finance and Improvement Committee, as well as weekly officer corporate leadership team meetings. The plan will also be subject to consideration of audit and oversight and scrutiny committees. While officers described efforts to reduce duplication where possible, inspectors did not see a clear articulation of how these different forums relate to each other, all add value, or where ultimate ownership for delivery sits. Besides the public Finance and Improvement Committee meetings, there is not a robust cross-party formal or informal forum to steer progress and support shared ownership and collaboration across the Council.
1.10. Inspectors were told that the breadth of governance arrangements increases demands on officer capacity and can pull limited resources away from delivery. We also heard of difficulties in meeting overly ambitious delivery timescales and saw evidence of over-optimism in the Council’s assumptions about the pace and ease of delivery, despite acknowledged constraints. We were also told that many deadlines were unrealistic but did not have support across the organisation to be changed, which limits the usefulness of RAG ratings.
1.11. More broadly, capacity constraints within the corporate centre limit the Council’s ability to deliver at pace. In particular, there are capacity gaps in transformation and programme management, for which the Council has begun to consider longer-term resourcing. In at least one instance, a workstream included in the Improvement Plan has also been subject to proposed staffing reductions, creating additional delivery risks.
1.12. Inspectors heard mixed views on the level of current officer and member buy-in for the plan. We heard that levels of engagement and investment vary across directorates and the plan’s different aims. Interviewees linked this to wider capacity constraints within the organisation; the way in which different elements of the Plan had been developed externally; and the lateness into the administration of actions like developing Council priorities and ways of working principles. Outside of the senior team, the staff we spoke to generally did not feel there was a strong link between the priorities in the Improvement Plan and their day-to-day work.
1.13. It is our view as inspectors that the current Improvement Plan:
- is only partially complete and operates more as a framework than a fully developed delivery plan, with many actions still requiring robust, costed business cases, clearer outcomes and SMART objectives
- contains too many priorities in the context of where the Council is in the election cycle, while lacking a clear strategic hierarchy, particularly given resourcing constraints
- does not have the necessary emphasis on transformation as the primary lever for achieving financial sustainability, and therefore will not drive the savings necessary to close the budget gap
- is not being considered strategically in relation to staff reductions, and does not have the strong corporate core necessary to help drive ownership and delivery across the Council
- is hindered by siloed working across the organisation and duplication in plans
- suffers from overly complex governance arrangements that distract from rather than support delivery
- would need to build significantly stronger cross-party and officer buy-in across the organisation to be fully owned to the extent needed to support genuine cultural and organisation change
1.14. Given these factors, delivery against the plan will continue to be challenging. This case study illustrates wider weaknesses with the Council’s approach to improvement, including the pace at which change is delivered, the absence of clear and enforceable prioritisation and the difficulties the Council has faced in translating plans and recommendations into collective, focused action. This all limits the ability of Improvement Plan in its current form to act as a mechanism for securing improvement.
Case study 2: Acquisition of Debenhams site
2.1. During the inspection, inspectors were frequently told about the Council’s acquisition of the former Debenhams site in Bedford. This case study primarily speaks to the Council’s use of resources, but also highlights issues in governance, strategic leadership and the clarity of planning associated with major capital decisions.
Background
2.2. The Debenhams site in Bedford town centre was closed in May 2021, as part of nationwide closures. The site, comprising 75,377 square feet of accommodation over 5 levels, was unsold from 2021 until the current cabinet’s decision in principle to purchase the site in December 2023. The sale was finalised in May 2024.
2.3. The site is located in a prominent position on Bedford’s high street, and in close proximity to other Council owned premises. This includes Bedford Corn Exchange, the Harpur Suite and Bedford Central Library. These properties are located within the wider Mayes Yard development regeneration scheme.
2.4. The Council first started developing plans for the Mayes Yard regeneration project in 2021, under the previous Liberal Democrat administration. This was included as a key development and regeneration project in the Council’s emerging Local Plan 2040. Development was proposed to serve a mix of uses, creating an extended cultural quarter in this part of the town, including residential, hotel, retail and leisure. While the Local Plan 2040 was withdrawn from examination in October 2025, the Mayes Yard development has continued to form a key Council ambition to redevelop and revitalise Bedford town centre.
Decision-making and governance
2.5. In late 2023, officers advised members in favour of the purchase of the Debenhams site, producing a report with recommendations and a business case for the current Mayor on the potential acquisition. This advice positioned the Mayes Yard area as a key development site as part of proposals for the re-vitalisation of Bedford town centre to be driven by Bedford Borough Council. The Debenhams site was highlighted as an important asset in the wider Mayes Yard development. The purchase was positioned as bringing local economy, community and urban development benefits, with potential for positive financial and broader community impact. Potential investment was linked to the priorities set out in the then emerging (and subsequently withdrawn) Local Plan 2040.
2.6. It was also acknowledged that any benefits may be realised over the longer term and that the purchase would carry inherent risks, though these were often positioned in the context of the significant benefits anticipated. It is inspectors’ view that the accompanying business case could have gone further in articulating the range and scale of these risks, particularly given that the property had remained vacant since 2021 and had not been acquired by private developers during that period.
2.7. The Executive decided in December 2023 to proceed with the purchase. The total cost for purchasing the property was £1.88m, which came from the Council’s capital spend.
2.8. Inspectors heard views across political groups that there was a lack of clear overarching strategy at the point the site was purchased, in the context of the Council’s increasingly difficult financial context.
Current and future use
2.9. The site was unused from its purchase until May 2025. Since then, the ground floor of the site has been used as the What’s On Bedford Borough hub. This comprises a new visitor information centre, a gift shop and the box office for Council events. The box office relocated there from another site nearby.
2.10. Some members have spoken passionately about the potential of the site, which occupies a prominent location in Bedford town centre and has been positioned as part of wider planned regeneration efforts in the town centre. The Debenhams site is anticipated as the first step of further regeneration plans, and the building’s end use is linked to the wider Mayes Yard regeneration project.
2.11. In June 2025, the Council commenced the formal procurement process for the selection of a development partner for Mayes Yard. The indicative construction budget for the regeneration project was set in excess of £120 million. A development partner was very recently announced in May 2026.
2.12. A subsequent potential purchase to support the Mayes Yard development, of Lloyds Bank on Bedford high street, was agreed at Executive in October 2024. The potential acquisition was subject to a call in procedure. This was on the basis that the price agreed to be paid was significantly above the ‘fair value’ professional valuation and that there were no details of a business case to determine if the decision was a good investment or not for taxpayers. Though the call in was not upheld, a formal decision of the Executive was taken to stop the purchase.
2.13. Since the purchase of the Debenhams site, the Council has incurred ongoing annual maintenance and holding costs. As of July 2025, these amounted to £551,299.
2.14. Capital costs were paid through the Regeneration and Development Budget. The Council also incurs costs through business rates (net cost of £55,715 for 2024/25) and to run the What’s On in Bedford Borough hub. As a result of the period of inaction, and limited use of the property now, it is likely that the building may have lost value since the Council’s initial purchase.
2.15. The site does not currently generate any income for the Council as such, and the rest of the building is not in a lettable condition. There is consequential income generation in connection with the use of the What’s On in Bedford Borough hub.
2.16. The Council has developed internal options for interim use pending the progression of the Mayes Yard regeneration. However, these options are not currently being progressed due to the level of further investment required.
2.17. The purchase has been subject to consideration at the Budget and Corporate Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee. In September 2025, the Committee recommended that the Executive review the value for money associated with the Debenhams building and necessary running costs.
2.18. The purchase of the Debenhams site has remained a point of political disagreement between the administration and opposition groups.
2.19. It appears that there was not a clear timetable or plan at the point the site was purchased, or thereafter, setting out future development options and a clear interim use until such time as the Mayes Yard site was developed. The purchase of the Debenhams site aligned with commendably ambitious regeneration aims, but illustrates wider issues identified by inspectors in relation to value for money, the handling of risk and commercial considerations and the clarity of strategic decision-making and planning. These disciplines will only become more vital given the financial gap the Council must now close.
Case study 3: 2026/27 budget process
3.1. Inspectors reviewed the Council’s approach to setting its 2026/27 budget, given the financial situation facing the Council and the challenges it experienced in passing the budget, which succeeded on its second attempt. This case study reflects themes of leadership, culture, and use of resources at Bedford Borough Council.
Process
3.2. Inspectors heard that budget discussions for 2026/27 began relatively late in the financial cycle, despite the scale of the financial challenge facing the Council. We were also told that the budget process has not materially changed in recent years to reflect this. We understand that the budget approach remained largely incremental and focused on piecemeal savings on a department-by-department basis. We saw limited evidence that it was directed by an overarching strategic vision or rooted in a transformational approach commensurate to delivering the scale of savings required.
3.3. Inspectors heard from some interviewees that the budget process was driven by a top-down approach, with departments issued with savings targets to deliver. While this provided clarity on the required scale of savings at a departmental level, some officers told us they felt it was not accompanied by sufficient enabling central financial or corporate support. We understand that finance capacity within the Council was overstretched during the budget cycle. This was exacerbated by both unhelpful team structures and ongoing challenges in recruiting permanently to vacant posts in key technical finance roles.
3.4. There is mixed evidence on the extent to which there was a shared understanding across the administration, and more widely among members, on the scale and ongoing nature of the financial challenge and the degree of change that would be required to address it. Inspectors also heard that the decision to apply for EFS was taken late into the process, indicating that the full implications of the Council’s financial position were not fully acknowledged earlier in the process.
3.5. In July 2025, the Council established a cross-party group focused on supporting budget decisions. However, by September 2025, the administration had stopped attending.
3.6. Potential savings proposals were agreed in principle by the Executive in October 2025 and subsequently progressed to public consultation in line with statutory requirements. However, we heard that late planning and lack of cross-party collaboration prior to this reduced the time available for political engagement and detailed consideration of alternative options.
3.7. A number of potential savings options that could have contributed to reducing the financial gap were not taken forward, or were initially progressed and then overturned without consideration of alternatives. This includes proposals to charge for garden waste collection, which were agreed in principle and consulted on but ultimately not adopted, and consideration of changes to the Council Tax Support Scheme. Evidence suggests that these decisions were, at least in part, not made or overturned as the result of disagreements in the Conservative Group and administration and/or across political groups. Proposed savings for green waste collections amounted to £850, 000 for 2026/27.
3.8. In the absence of effective cross-party forums, the Council was unable to build the level of shared understanding and ownership required to support difficult budget decisions. The budget was unable to secure the necessary numbers and was voted down at its first attempt on 4 February 2026. On 18 February, it was voted through on its second attempt.
Strategic impact
3.9. Inspectors heard evidence across interviews that the budget process did not always support robust consideration of the impact of savings decisions on services, risks and trade-offs, to support effective financial decision-making.
3.10. The 2026/27 budget relies on £4.2 million of savings to be delivered through staffing reductions. Inspectors saw limited evidence demonstrating the strength of the evidence base underpinning this figure, or that the Council yet has a clear understanding of the strategy, risks and service impacts of these reductions. As set out in this report, it will be imperative that the Council’s remaining resources are clearly aligned to the Council’s priorities.
3.11. The Council is also relying on significant savings being identified and delivered with the support of Newton consultants in children’s and adult services. These savings form a key part of budget proposals, although inspectors note that they will not in isolation close the budget gap, and there will need to be capacity and capability in the organisation to continue this work after the period of external support ends.
3.12. Overall, inspectors consider that the Council’s previous approach to the budget process creates risks to the stability and credibility of the budget and heightens concerns for the 2027/28 budget. This case study illustrates:
- slowness in the Council to respond to the current financial context, as shown through continuation of existing budget processes and the timing of the EFS application
- a lack of transformation approach, with activity focused on incremental change rather than fundamental transformation
- the impact of ineffective cross-party working, including a lack of shared understanding of the Council’s financial position
- limited follow-through in taking difficult decisions
- a lack of confidence in a clearly articulated and deliverable strategy to deliver the savings needed (for example, the basis of the £4.2m identified in staff reductions)
3.13. We understand that the Council is seeking to implement a revised budget process for 2027/28. Inspectors did not hear evidence that the Council has yet established effective, robust processes and forums for members across parties to convene to make progress on budget agreement and negotiations. This will be imperative to securing the buy-in needed to pass a sound budget.
Appendix D: List of abbreviations
CfGS – Centre for Governance and Scrutiny
CIPFA – Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy
CQC – Care Quality Commission
EFS – Exceptional Financial Support
ILACS – Inspection of Local Authority Children’s Services
LGA – Local Government Association
MHCLG – Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
MTFS – Medium-Term Financial Strategy
Ofsted – Office for Standards in Education, Children’s Services and Skills
RAG – Red, Amber, Green
SEND – Special Educational Needs and Disabilities
S114 – Section 114 notice
-
Best value standards and intervention: a statutory guide for best value authorities ↩
-
Source: General Fund Revenue Budget 2026/27 report to Council 4 February 2026 ↩
-
Source: Capital Strategy - Capital Prudential Indicators, Council report 18 February 2026 ↩
-
Source: 4 February 2026 Budget report ↩
-
It should be noted that the 2025/26 figures are included as draft outturn figures. ↩