Investigation of the Atlantic Joint Business Agreement
The CMA is investigating the Atlantic Joint Business Agreement between American Airlines, members of International Consolidated Airlines Group (British Airways, Iberia and Aer Lingus) and Finnair under Chapter I of the CA98.
Timetable
| Action | Date |
|---|---|
| Interim measures directions expire | March 2026 |
| Further investigation: information gathering, including issuance of information requests, CMA analysis and review of information gathered | September 2023 to June 2024 |
| Decision to issue second interim measures, extending remedy period under 2020 interim measure | 4 April 2022 |
| Decision to issue interim measures directions | 17 September 2020 |
| Decision not to accept commitments | 17 September 2020 |
| Consideration of representations received in response to the consultation on commitments | June to September 2020 |
| Consultation on commitments proposed by American Airlines and International Consolidated Airlines Group closed | 4 June 2020 |
| Consultation on commitments proposed by American Airlines and International Consolidated Airlines Group | 7 May 2020 to 4 June 2020 |
| Discussions with the parties under investigation on proposals for commitments | December 2019 to May 2020 |
| Decision on whether to issue a statement of objections | Winter 2019/20 |
| CMA analysis of parties’ submissions and assessment | Autumn 2019 |
| Further investigation including analysis of further information requests and submissions | April to Summer 2019 |
| Decision to proceed with the investigation | April 2019 |
| Initial investigation: information gathering, including issuance of information requests, CMA analysis and review of information gathered | October 2018 to March 2019 |
| Investigation opened | 11 October 2018 |
Change log
The following changes have been made to the case timetable since it was first published in October 2018:
| Date of change | Reason for change | Change made to timetable |
|---|---|---|
| 17 April 2023 | Additional time needed to gather and analyse additional information | Date for completing further investigation changed from March 2024 to June 2024 |
| 28 September 2023 | The CMA will assess the Atlantic Joint Business Agreement in the context of post-COVID recovery in the aviation sector | Further investigation: information gathering, including issuance of information requests, CMA analysis and review of information gathered |
| 4 April 2022 | The CMA decided to issue new interim measures directions as a result of the continued impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the sector, necessitating a longer period before it can complete its investigation | Date on which the CMA decision to issue new interim measures was issued. Date of the interim measures’ expiry amended to 2026 |
| 17 September 2020 | The CMA decided not to accept the commitments offered by American Airlines and International Consolidated Airlines Group and instead the CMA decided to issue interim measures directions | Date on which the CMA decisions not to accept the commitments and to issue interim measures were issued. Date of the interim measures’ expiry added |
| 7 May 2020 | The CMA is consulting on commitments offered by American Airlines and International Consolidated Airlines Group, which, if accepted, will mean that the CMA will not issue a Statement of Objections | Date for commitments consultation period and estimated date for CMA decision on whether to accept commitments added |
| 4 September 2019 | Additional time needed to analyse submissions | Date for CMA decision on whether to issue a statement of objections changed from summer 2019 to winter 2019 |
| 11 April 2019 | Additional time needed to gather and analyse additional information | Date for completing initial investigation and information gathering changed from March 2019 to summer 2019 |
Outcome of the 2023 slot award process
30 January 2024: In accordance with the CMA’s Interim Measures Directions issued on 4 April 2022, the CMA has approved the further use of the four available remedy slots by airlines which compete with the AJB airlines, maintaining additional competition whilst the CMA continues its investigation. Following a tender process, Virgin Atlantic Airways has been awarded a daily slot pair to operate services on the London-Boston route for four IATA Seasons commencing in IATA Summer Season 2024. Virgin Atlantic Airways will continue to operate a daily slot pair on the London-Miami route and Delta Air Lines will continue to operate a daily slot pair on each of the London-Dallas (via Atlanta) and London-Boston routes. It is anticipated that all four of the remedy slots will be operated by Virgin Atlantic Airways and Delta Air Lines until the end of IATA Winter season 2025.
Decision to issue interim measures and extending remedies until 2026
4 April 2022: Due to the continued impact of the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic on the aviation sector and the fact that material recovery is taking longer than was anticipated in 2020, the CMA wants to ensure that the remedies made available under the 2020 Interim Measures continue to be available for 2 additional years. As a result of these unprecedented circumstances, the CMA is not in a position to complete its investigation in advance of the expiry of the 2020 Interim Measures in March 2024. A tender process will take place in autumn 2023 for the remedy slots for the additional 2 years.
- (4.4.22)
- (4.4.22)
The 2022 Interim Measures issued by the CMA will expire in March 2026, by which time it is expected that the airline sector should be in a more stable position. The CMA plans to complete its investigation and, if appropriate, put in place a longer-term remedy, before the interim measures expire.
London-Boston slot awarded in 2021
22 February 2021: The CMA has approved a Slot Release Agreement which will allow a new competitor, United Airlines, to enter the London-Boston route. The CMA has made this award in accordance with the terms of Clause 3 of the CMA’s Interim Measures Directions issued on 17 September 2020 and following a tender process in Autumn 2020. In that process, United Airlines was awarded a daily slot pair for six IATA Seasons commencing in IATA Summer Season 2021. The CMA understands that United will announce its plans for servicing the route in due course (taking into account the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic and related restrictions).
Decisions not to accept commitments and to issue interim measures
21 September 2020: A Monitoring Trustee has been appointed, in accordance with clause 10 of the Interim Measures Directions. Find more information about the AJBA Monitoring Trustee or contact Justin.Menezes@mazars.co.uk.
17 September 2020: Having considered representations received in response to the May 2020 commitments consultation and as a result of the uncertainty created by the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic on the aviation sector, the CMA has decided that it would not be appropriate to accept the commitments offered by American Airlines and International Consolidated Airlines Group.
The CMA will not be able to complete its investigation before the expiry of various agreements currently in place pursuant to the Commission’s 2010 commitments. This means that an ‘enforcement gap’ (meaning a situation whereby there are no remedies in place to address the competition issues related to the AJBA) would have arisen if action was not taken urgently on an interim basis. Such an enforcement gap would significantly negatively impact the public interest (i.e. the interests of protecting competition and, by extension, consumers). Accordingly, the CMA has decided to issue interim measures directions.
The interim measures which have been imposed effectively extend the terms of the 2010 Commitments for an additional 3 years until March 2024. Airlines currently operating slots on London to Boston, Dallas and Miami routes pursuant to the 2010 commitments will continue to operate these slots for an additional year, until March 2022.
A tender process will take place in March 2022 for these slots for the remaining two years. A tender process will be undertaken this autumn in relation to a second slot on the London to Boston route.
- (17.9.20)
- (17.9.20)
- (17.9.20)
- Press release: CMA acts to protect competition on UK-US airline routes (17.9.20)
The interim measures issued by the CMA expire in March 2024, by which time it is expected that the airline sector should be in a more stable position. The CMA plans to complete its investigation and, if appropriate, put in place a longer-term remedy, before the interim measures expire.
Consultation on commitments
7 May 2020: The CMA has published a notice of intention to accept the commitments offered by International Consolidated Airlines Group and American Airlines and invited representations from interested third parties. The CMA is seeking views on the proposed package, but this comes at a time when the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic is having a major impact on the aviation sector. In the CMA’s discussions with airlines, they have emphasised the importance of certainty about the future availability of slots, due to the imminent expiry of the 2010 commitments. The CMA is therefore proceeding to market test the proposed package but is also giving additional time for responses if required.
- (7.5.20)
- Press release: CMA consults on BA and American Airlines commitments (7.5.20)
Interim measures application dismissed
30 January 2020: On 4 October 2019, Virgin Atlantic Airways Limited submitted an application to the CMA requesting that the CMA exercise its power to issue an interim measures direction to American Airlines Inc.
The CMA’s final decision not to impose the requested measures was issued to Virgin Atlantic Airways Limited on 10 January 2020. This decision does not have a bearing on the outcome of the CMA’s investigation into the AJBA, which remains ongoing. In the circumstances of this case and in the light of the continuing investigation, the CMA does not intend to publish a summary of its decision at this time.
Case information
On 11 October 2018, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) launched a competition investigation into the Atlantic Joint Business Agreement. In line with the approach of the European Commission when it first investigated the agreement during 2009 to 2010, the investigation is being conducted under the rules on agreements restrictive of competition under the Chapter I prohibition in the Competition Act 1998.
Five airlines are currently signed up to the Atlantic Joint Business Agreement: American Airlines, Aer Lingus, British Airways, Iberia, and Finnair.
Following an investigation under EU competition law, in 2010 the European Commission accepted commitments from the parties in relation to 6 routes to address potential competition concerns: London-Dallas, London-Boston, London-Miami, London-Chicago, London-New York and Madrid-Miami. These included a commitment to make landing and take-off slots available to competitors at either London Heathrow airport or London Gatwick airport. These commitments were binding for 10 years. See the Commission’s Commitments Decision (PDF, 223KB) for more information.
On expiry of the parties’ commitments, in 2020, the European Commission may have re-assessed the agreement, but there was no requirement for it to do so. As 5 of the 6 routes subject to commitments are from the UK, and to prepare for the time when the European Commission will no longer have responsibility for competition in the UK, the CMA decided to review afresh the competitive impact of the agreement in anticipation of the expiry of the commitments.
No assumption should be made that the Atlantic Joint Business Agreement infringes competition law.
Further detail of the CMA’s procedures in Competition Act 1998 cases is available in our guidance.
Notes
-
Parties under investigation: American Airlines Group Inc; International Consolidated Airlines Group SA (including Aer Lingus Limited, British Airways plc and Iberia Líneas Aéreas de España SA); and Finnair OYJ. Aer Lingus is a signatory to the agreement but is not yet operating any services as part of the Atlantic Joint Business Agreement as this is subject to the United Stated Department of Transportation extending Anti-Trust Immunity (currently under review).
-
The CMA is liaising with the United States Department of Transportation in relation to the investigation.
Contacts
- Assistant Project Director: Eren Kilich (020 3738 6887, Eren.Kilich@cma.gov.uk)
- Project Director: April Carr (020 3738 6204, April.Carr@cma.gov.uk)
- Senior Responsible Officer: Ann Pope (020 3738 6786, Ann.Pope@cma.gov.uk)
Last updated 17 April 2024 + show all updates
-
Timetable and change log updated
-
Outcome of the 2023 slot award process published.
-
Timetable and change log updated
-
Decision to issue interim measures and extending remedies until 2026, including appendix, published.
-
The CMA has approved a Slot Release Agreement which will allow a new competitor, United Airlines, to enter the London-Boston route.
-
A Monitoring Trustee has been appointed, in accordance with clause 10 of the Interim Measures Directions.
-
Decisions not to accept commitments and to issue interim measures and timetable updates published.
-
Notice of intention to accept binding commitments and press release published.
-
Interim measures application dismissed.
-
Additional party included under scope of the investigation.
-
Timetable updated with dates for the later stages of the investigation.
-
Updated timetable for the investigation.
-
First published.